Professor Buzzkill, on 16 October 2012 - 11:57 PM, said:
I think the aquatic ape theory makes the most sense as it explains a number of things which are a mystery in our evolution. It explains why we are hairless
Or it would if we were vaguely fish shaped like whales and dolphins. Mammals that are not fish shaped (even those who spend a ton of time in the water) tend to have hair.
Professor Buzzkill, on 16 October 2012 - 11:57 PM, said:
why babies instinctively hold their breath underwater (unlike all land mammals)
That's just untrue. A common cost effective way of ridding a bunch of dogs or cats of fleas is dipping. Basically, you mix a batch of poisonous water and make like John the Baptist. I've seen it many times on both dogs and cats and never once saw one come out of the water coughing or dying from a lungful of poison.
Professor Buzzkill, on 16 October 2012 - 11:57 PM, said:
and why we walk upright as drowning is a very good why of ensuring that those who do not stand upright do not pass on their genes.
If floods were frequent enough and of long enough duration for the difference to have any effect on reproductive viability, the world would be crawling with bipedal deer, dogs, and horses. It makes no sense that such an evolutionary pressure would affect only us.