Simbi Laveau, on 08 September 2012 - 08:25 AM, said:
Part of it may also be guilt ?,catholic guilt ,Jewish guilt ,they are the worst ,so they keep part of their faith ,to keep from feeling as if they are betraying their devout Irish mum .
I cannot speak for all Christian witches.
A Christian witch, that is just who I am, have always been one even before the label which is not as important as the path itself. I just considered myself a Christian who was attracted to magic, mainly low magic and mental techniques. I know an older faithful Catholic lady who
used to do the egg thing to cure the evil eye, who still massages people to get rid of negative energy, who knows about a scant few herbs, who whistles to bring the wind on hot days, and sings to the moon to watch over her newborn grandsons.
She stopped using the egg because she felt it was too much magic but she doesn't realize what she still does is all part of her path of a CathoWitch. No label is really needed.
For myself, I used to feel guilt, but that is only because Western Christianity in general, but not in all cases, but in general it assumes a dominant narrative of a dichotomy between Christianity and witchcraft. Not all Christians throughout history have felt like this so comparing our culture to that of others I can see other narratives exist, even within our own culture, and my own narrative sees that dichotomy as a false one. The borders are breaking not just in this domain but also between black and white, rich and poor, male and females, to name a few examples. There is no one right way to be black, white, rich, poor, male, female, Christian, or witch.
Here are a couple of examples I have come across that reveal this false dichotomy did not always exist.
The stone of Niederdollendorf: Christ in glory or Woden?
Quote
The average Frank probably lived in a mental world in which that image could represent either of those ideas, or both. The missionary and the historian who reads the missionary writings tend to assume that Christian and pagan are two diametrically opposed systems of belief.
Any tinge of something which does not look like what the twentieth century regards as Christian will be denounced as 'paganism'. Yet Christianity in the fifth- or sixth-century Roman Empire had resonances that were very different from modern Christianity.
Most Franks probably accepted Christianity initially as a welcome addition to the already complex mythology and ritual of their ancestors; they would naturally adapt their iconography to suit the new cult, and interpret Mediterranean Christian iconography in their own way.
—The Franks by Edward James pg 144-45
Edwin + Æthelburh
Quote
Some of the Saxons saw Christ as yet another god that could give them victory on the battlefield and so some of the conversions of Saxon kings had to do with their allegiance to Christ at particular military "crises" and Christian conversions.
—Chris Snyder, Marymount University
Military Channel, Barbarians II: Saxons
So why would I let any group tell me what to believe? A single denomination that I grew up in? Listen to Christians in general in Modern America when Christians existed before throughout the ages who for me are better examples in deciding my own path? Why listen to Pagans who choose to think just like those Christians on this issue?
For those who still do not understand the postmodern approach and will ask well what about "Thou shall not suffer a witch to live"? Well open up a Bible go to Exodus 22, where one instance of that appears, and read all the other rules next to that. If a man steals an ox he should return five oxes, if a man sleeps with a maid (virgin) he has to marry her, and all the other laws meant for a tribe that existed in one moment of history. Not even Christians follow all those rules, they were written for Jews of that era, so why would I let that dictate my own narrative? Why would I let ignorant Christians who do not even understand this, or Pagans who agree with them, tell me what to do and choose?
Oh but what about Revelation 9 where sorcerers won't go into heaven some will still say? They will keep asking because in their mind the dichotomy is strong, true, and all that exists. Look up the original Greek word used which is
pharmakeia aka pharmaceutical more or less. That means poison so according to that poisoners will not go to heaven. This is another example of specific terms that we understand in a general way but failing to understand the specific context it actually is in.
In the end the choice for me was one of the individual vs the collective. Which do I put importance in? What I believe and am attracted to in my heart of hearts or what the collective agree is right? In many instances of witch persecutions it is always this theme, the individual vs the collective.
Edited by Chasingtherabbit, 08 September 2012 - 04:54 PM.