Trenberth's cv lists: "Nobel Laureate (shared) for Nobel Peace Prize 2007 (as part of IPCC)
That doesn't sound like an untruth to me in that he was part of the team.
so now even Cornelius to his credit is saying Mann and Trenberth were not awarded the Nobel Prize.
can you bring yourself to agree with myself, BFB, cornelius, the ipcc and the Nobel Committee?
its time for you to present some evidence or accept they are telling "untruths".
science is about pursuit of truth, not pursuit of prizes.
Little Fish, on 13 November 2012 - 08:08 PM, said:
you refute your own contention in that you persistently refuse to accept the fact that Trenberth and Mann were caught lying.
its clearly important to you.
I saw Trenberth's and Mann's cvs. Neither says they received the Nobel Prize. Both say they were part of IPCC at the time and that IPCC received it. So that doesn't sound like a lie to me and if you don't think think warming is happening, why are you going after this side issue? The world will judge these men by their work, not by the rantings of the denialists.
Edited by Doug1o29, 14 November 2012 - 04:53 PM.
If I have seen farther than other men, it is because I stood on the shoulders of giants. --Bernard de Chartres
The beginning of knowledge is the realization that one doesn't and cannot know everything.
Science is the father of knowledge, but opinion breeds ignorance. --Hippocrates
Ignorance is not an opinion. --Adam Scott
I saw Trenberth's and Mann's cvs. Neither says they received the Nobel Prize.
Trenberth claims to be a "Nobel Laureate" on his CV. http://www.cgd.ucar....enberth-cv.html
it amounts to the same false claim, no amount of arguing semantics and tweezering of words will dilute this untruth. he is not a Nobel Laureate, shared or otherwise.
Mann claims to have been awarded the Nobel Prize in his submission to a law court, no amount of "well he doesn't claim it on his cv" negates this untruth.
and if you don't think think warming is happening, why are you going after this side issue? The world will judge these men by their work, not by the rantings of the denialists.
the topic of discussion is "Mann caught lying again", no amount of "why don't you talk about.." can change the topic title. the forum rules (3J) state we stay on topic. what you are doing here is a tactic known as "attempting to derail".