26 replies to this topic

[Rafterman]

If that guy is the UK's leading dinosaur expert, perhaps they should send a few over the US for a refresher course.

[Ranyhyn]

While I'm not a nessie believer, I won't discount that it could  be possible, though there would have to be more than just one such creature in that lake, or else it'd have died out a long time ago (if there are any at all, which as I said I kinda doubt)

Eye witnesses are unreliable. They might be right, but they're unreliable. I guess time will tell ... or not.

[fatalcharm]

Well I'm not sure about the Loch Ness Monster, I have never really had a fasination with it so never looked into it.

However, years and years ago people believed that the stories and sightings of the giant squid were fake, and the stories were just ledgends but now we know that the giant squid does exist.

We humans know more about space than we know about our oceans. There would still be many undiscovered species in our oceans that would resemble sea monsters.

[skookum]

Do I believe in something we haven't seen yet in these Lakes such as Loch Ness, and Lake Champlain.  Definitely.  Do I believe it is a Dinosaur? No way.  Other interesting things have been observed at the lakes such as echo location.  No lake creature is known to echo locate so there is something unusual down there.

[vitruvian12]

SoundWaveFX, on 28 August 2011 - 01:13 AM, said:

Well I'm not sure about the Loch Ness Monster, I have never really had a fasination with it so never looked into it.

However, years and years ago people believed that the stories and sightings of the giant squid were fake, and the stories were just ledgends but now we know that the giant squid does exist.

We humans know more about space than we know about our oceans. There would still be many undiscovered species in our oceans that would resemble sea monsters.

Thats not true about the giant squid.  Evidence for its existence was there.  It always seems to get brought up as a reason to believe in cryptids.  Do a search and see what was known about it.  All that was missing was a recorded sighting.  And Loch Ness is not the ocean, its a confined volume of water with little to offer a large life form like nessie.

[bulldogzrep]

Has anyone read Roy Mackal's book: "Monsters of loch ness" ?

[Rat Girl]

I watched a show about 6 years ago where they, from what I can remember, did a proper investigation into loch ness, sent people down there, basically monitored the entire lake for anything odd, over a course of days, and found nothing.
The show had to conclude there was nothing odd down there.

Now, this was a long time ago so I might have some of the specifics wrong, but I definitely remember them saying that they were as certain as it were possible to be with our modern technology that nothing odd was down there.

[Reason101]

I have stood on the shores of Loch Ness and it is an unusual body of water with an interesting cast of light and atmosphere ,even on a summer day in the hight of tourist season..I saw a few strange dark shapes in the water myself and even managed to get excited for a moment or two..but they were ripples and a log..nothing more .I can easily see why in lower light on autumn and winter days..with maybe some mist around ,anyone might see anything out there .I will say this though..it's worth a visit..go ,wander around the shops in Fort Augustus while you are there..buy a toy Nessie..why not..and enjoy the strange atmospher and magnificent scenery...and if Nessie is in there..I hope some of the business owners who are making a good living from it remember to throw in the odd salmon ;-)

[Still Waters]

Reason101, on 17 October 2011 - 09:54 AM, said:

I have stood on the shores of Loch Ness and it is an unusual body of water with an interesting cast of light and atmosphere ,even on a summer day in the hight of tourist season..I saw a few strange dark shapes in the water myself and even managed to get excited for a moment or two..but they were ripples and a log..nothing more .I can easily see why in lower light on autumn and winter days..with maybe some mist around ,anyone might see anything out there .I will say this though..it's worth a visit..go ,wander around the shops in Fort Augustus while you are there..buy a toy Nessie..why not..and enjoy the strange atmospher and magnificent scenery...and if Nessie is in there..I hope some of the business owners who are making a good living from it remember to throw in the odd salmon ;-)

Interesting you should post this. I uploaded some pics in the gallery recently I took of Loch Ness. For anyone interested if you click on the green icon under my seahorse avatar pic, you'll see them. There's 12 pics in total  

[Mike G]

Still Waters, on 17 October 2011 - 10:10 AM, said:

Interesting you should post this. I uploaded some pics in the gallery recently I took of Loch Ness.

Synchronicity?

[psyche101]

Sorry
We cannot find the page you are looking for.
The page may have been moved, updated or deleted.

UPDATE [added August 1st 2011]: The Telegraph have apologised, and have removed the offending article. Various versions based on the Telegraph’s piece are still out there of course.





I see Darren Naish's name being splashed, that is the Dinosaurid fellow. He is not stranger to speculation, but in any case, Clobhair-cean seems to have cleared this all up page previous. Naish never said this, the Journo did.

Edited by psyche101, 18 October 2011 - 01:09 AM.

[Still Waters]

psyche101, on 18 October 2011 - 01:07 AM, said:

Sorry
We cannot find the page you are looking for.
The page may have been moved, updated or deleted.

UPDATE [added August 1st 2011]: The Telegraph have apologised, and have removed the offending article. Various versions based on the Telegraph’s piece are still out there of course.

I see Darren Naish's name being splashed, that is the Dinosaurid fellow. He is not stranger to speculation, but in any case, Clobhair-cean seems to have cleared this all up page previous. Naish never said this, the Journo did.

Thank you for this update.

*Thread closed*