Saru, on 23 December 2009 - 05:01 PM, said:
There's no concrete plans to hold a debates tournament however its possible that the debates board will return at some point in the future. The problem with the debates is that they are a lot of work to set up and the last time we held them there was only limited interest, most people prefer the open and less formal style discussions we have on the forums.
I think if it is advertised(on the main page, a sticky on every forumn, as welcome message in chat,etc.) and possibly if there are rewards for example "Debate Champion" as a title bar(like where you have Moderator) people will do it.
The problem with Formal Debates is in my opinion there usually isn't a point. Usually I can just debate/discuss in the thread itself. In a Formal Debate I would have to do a lot more research, spend more time, and gather sources. There is no way to officially 'win' and an opponent would be unlikely to admit defeat so you spend all the time and effort just for yourself because other members don't usually go into Formal Debates to read about Aliens they go into the Aliens forum to read about Aliens. It's just not very fun.
A tournament gives a clear victor, brings attention to the debate itself, and generally gives members a reason to debate formally rather then just debate within a topic. I you or other moderators choose the debate topics, say the most popular of each forum section then people would jump at it...general Believer versus Skeptic would work for most of the paranormal.
However that is a mess of moderator work to deal with I would imagine.
Edited by Cadetak, 31 December 2009 - 07:55 AM.