747400, on 01 December 2012 - 10:50 AM, said:
just picking up on a remark here, if no one minds me interloping;
Not at all on my behalf.
747400, on 01 December 2012 - 10:50 AM, said:
that assumes that they (any ET race that might be exploring round this way) knows that this Planet is inhabited by a, sometimes, intelligent species,
Yes indeed, considering our forays into extrasolar planets, and the magnificent success we are experiencing in it's infancy, I do not understand why the planets lighting, radio signals, orbital debris and probes from activities by NASA and the ESA would not indicate such powerfully.
747400, on 01 December 2012 - 10:50 AM, said:
and that they'd then want to communicate with them.
Yes you have a point, but is curious enough to hide here for 60+ years one wonders what the draw card is if not intelligence. I really doubt rocky earth like planets are incredibly rare seeming as we have found some ourselves.
747400, on 01 December 2012 - 10:50 AM, said:
isn't it a basic scientific principle not to interfere with the subject that you're researching, and to do it discreetly?
No. Instead of thinking of Star Treks Prime directive, or us trying to capture animal habits such as predation or general behaviour, which the purpose of is not to disturb the animal so we have an accurate record of it's natural behaviours, but think more of Columbus and Cook. There was no stealth or such involved in first contact with intelligent species in our history. And all our efforts, like SETI are actively trying to make contact with advanced species. The Voyager probes had those classy Golden Records on them. When it comes to observing instinctual species one must hide, or we disturb the natural process and we do not learn. With intelligent species, we can just go up and ask, and perhaps even compare our evolutionary records.
I think cultures would be much more of a stumbling block. We canot agree across seas. Christians, Muslims, Republicans, Cats and Dog's living together.
747400, on 01 December 2012 - 10:50 AM, said:
And that's assuming that they specifically wanted tio study us; what if they didn't even know for sure if there was (sometimes) intelligent life, and they just sent out a signal, or sent out probes, speculatively?
If an advance species I honestly do not know how they could be flying blind. If we can not only see, but photograph this much:
And OK, the planet is 8 times the size of Jupiter, however, this is an image, a photo, not an artists impression, not an extrapolation, not wobble. This is the real deal. How much further away are images like this:
Maybe next week, maybe never. But we are following this path, would it not make sense for others to consider this path? It does seem a viable option?
And if not wanting to study us, the other popular option is settle the planet, in which case we might not get too much of a say in anything. I refuse the "ant analogy" I do not believe intelligence is seen in the respect by another intelligent species, no matter how supposedly advanced.
Edited by psyche101, 03 December 2012 - 01:03 AM.