45 replies to this topic

[ancient astronaut]

people usually make outlandish claims for personal gain, in this case book sales.

[coldethyl]

If she suffers from PTSD she probably really believes in what she saw.  I don't believe it but I'm sure she does.  Most people don't just convert from Catholicism to spiritualism that time in their life for no reason.  
If she makes the families feel better with her book, good for her.

[the L]

How come that people have instinct to believe in the first place?
Why would one when see something wierd have instinct to believe in something?
Beliefs have own reason for existing otherwise it shouldnt be here.

Im not saying that I belive her but I would realy like to hear more from her.

[Junior Chubb]

the L, on 06 July 2012 - 10:31 PM, said:

Im not saying that I belive her but I would realy like to hear more from her.

Buy the book...

http://www.amazon.co...41620987&sr=8-1

Its a bit pricey though (I would go for the Kindle version ).

Edited by Junior Chubb, 07 July 2012 - 12:32 AM.

[nyuk]

It would be comforting for  family members who lost a loved one if it could be proven beyond doubt to be true

[Rafterman]

So this Ex-FBI Agent shouldn't be believed.

But Ex-FBI Agents spouting insane 9/11 Truther crap should be swallowed hook line and sinker - even if they're selling books or videos.

Got it!  

[docyabut2]

Maybe she was just trying to sell a book but I  have to believe her, only for the fact that my mom`s friend told her of a experience her young grand daughter  ten years old had in walking along the rail road tracks with her little brother and a man tired to attack her and she said this angel came and scare the man away, does one believe a child ?

[Rafterman]

docyabut2, on 08 July 2012 - 11:25 PM, said:

Maybe she was just trying to sell a book but I  have to believe her, only for the fact that my mom`s friend told her of a experience her young grand daughter  ten years old had in walking along the rail road tracks with her little brother and a man tired to attack her and she said this angel came and scare the man away, does one believe a child ?

That would be a negatory.

[Sheetz]

coldethyl, on 06 July 2012 - 07:50 PM, said:

If she suffers from PTSD she probably really believes in what she saw.  I don't believe it but I'm sure she does.  Most people don't just convert from Catholicism to spiritualism that time in their life for no reason.  
If she makes the families feel better with her book, good for her.

I can get onboard with that....I think there will only be good from it if she were to donate ALL proceeds from the sale of that book to those respective family funds that were invariably setup.  or to some other like cause.  If she keeps one red cent from it, then I have to believe she was in it for the money only.  story made up entirely for gain.  People who HONESTLY believe something like this happened and then write about it usually aren't in it for gain.  The money would be pointless in regard to the story they are trying to put across.  make sense??

[Sheetz]

Junior Chubb, on 07 July 2012 - 12:31 AM, said:

Buy the book...

http://www.amazon.co...41620987&sr=8-1

Its a bit pricey though (I would go for the Kindle version ).

whoaaaaaa hold the phone. she is asking 140 pounds ($218.00 US) for this 188 page paperback book??????  what the heck is it printed on, angel wings?  again, if she donates the proceeds, then she can charge whatever she wants and her story is then more believable.  sheesh, I am instantly suspect on pricing alone, that's disrespectful capitolizing on this tragedy.

Edited by Sheetz, 11 July 2012 - 05:15 PM.

[Junior Chubb]

Sheetz, on 11 July 2012 - 05:09 PM, said:

whoaaaaaa hold the phone. she is asking 140 pounds ($218.00 US) for this 188 page paperback book??????  what the heck is it printed on, angel wings?  again, if she donates the proceeds, then she can charge whatever she wants and her story is then more believable.  sheesh, I am instantly suspect on pricing alone, that's disrespectful capitolizing on this tragedy.

Isn't human nature a wonderful thing...

[moonshadow60]

Sheetz; it's $12 American on Amazon, not that I would buy it. I might read it, if it's at the library, but even then...

[coldethyl]

moonshadow60, on 13 August 2012 - 05:37 PM, said:

Sheetz; it's $12 American on Amazon, not that I would buy it. I might read it, if it's at the library, but even then...

I'd read it if it was at the library or someone lent it to me.  Or if i found it really cheap used.

[Sheetz]

moonshadow60, on 13 August 2012 - 05:37 PM, said:

Sheetz; it's $12 American on Amazon, not that I would buy it. I might read it, if it's at the library, but even then...

It is now....but when I posted it wasn't. In fact I went back several times to check before I posted for the very reason I was going to get my facts checked. It was that price back then....a typo on amazon? maybe..probably...as now it clearly says what you stated. But whoa, it wasn't on my first post.  That sounds better....

[Mikami]

Hmmmmm I wonder how you can hijcak a plane...