psyche101, on 11 January 2013 - 05:02 AM, said:
Are they not already testing it? I was under the impression they were. Too early for results I admit, but I would like to see more than the claim that a doughnut shape reduces power requirements in the thousands. You must admit, it is quite a claim. If early trials manage to achieve anything, I will be suitably impressed, but I just find this sort of news tends to be released a little prematurely - as was seen recently with the Neutrino claim.
From what I understand, this drive needs to be capable of resolving planets, it's a massive undertaking to go from Jupiter to a voyager probe and still be able to fly through a planet without anyone noticing. As I say, we hear grandiose claims often, and thank you for the latest news on this, and I hope you are correct and trials are at least partially successful, but I doubt we will have FTL anytime soon or that this first delve into this type of construction is likely to be successful. I imagine quite some R&D involved with such an extraordinary undertaking.
The theoretical paper by Dr. White scarcely amounts to the premature release of anything. It was based on a modification of M. Alcubierre's work, which has published in a peer reviewed journal nearly 20 years ago.
If you care to read Dr, White's paper carefully, you will find an explanation for why a toroidal warp coil is anticipated to be more efficient than a flat ring.
I don't perceive how the warping of space in the direction of travel amounts to flying through a planet. If they wanted to fly to Alpha Centauri, they wouldn't aim at Saturn, obviously. Besides this, it is discussed that a ship using such a drive would probably move to the edge of our solar system by conventional means, then use its warp drive to reach its destination, then resume conventional propulsion within another solar system.
Dr. White proposes a relatively simple test of the principle of warping space, by doing so to a tiny degree. He is not proposing to build a warp drive equiped space vessel at this time, and would be the first to admit that a great deal of research and development stand between us now and the creation of such a device.