FurthurBB, on 31 December 2009 - 03:00 AM, said:
It really makes me laugh to think that some people believe we ever entered a war for another country.
Screw the other countries. We go to war to advance our own interests.
KennyB, on 31 December 2009 - 06:45 AM, said:
The U.S. knew where those ships were from the time they left Japan. They had plenty of time to get the captial ships lit off and ready. The carriers were already at sea. 12 submarines were setting in their pens, loaded and ready to go. They had a few B-17s and had more coming in. They had hundreds of P-40s on the ground, ready to go. They had plenty of time to get those ships out to sea. Ships have never won a battle against land-based bombers. Yamamoto knew that. If he came on, he would have lost his entire fleet before he even got in range to launch his planes. He would probably have gone to the Philipeens and attacked Manila, that would have put us at war. But we would be in much better shape because we wouldn't have lost any ships at Pearl. That's what that traitor Roosevelt should have done. He just gave them the fleet at Pearle. He could have brought all the capital ships we had in the Atlantic thru the Panama Canal and threw them against the Japs, too. We could have defeated them in short order. Never had to use the A-bombs. We could have fire bombed them till there wasn't a stick of wood in the islands. Japan would never have attacked us with all that firepower facing them.
They would have had to withdraw from China and Korea and make peace with us so we'd raise the embargo. KennyB
Wow, your understanding of the Japanese psyche in general and of the Japanese warrior specifically, is truly outstanding.
KennyB, on 31 December 2009 - 06:56 AM, said:
They would back away if they didn't think they had the edge. At Pearle, they didn't make another sortie because they didn't know where the carriers were. They would have backed off if we had sent that whole fleet from Pearle at them, especially with those land-based planes. If they didn't we'd have sunk them all. KennyB
Of course they would have! The Japanese
always shied away from a lost cause. They never charged machine gun nests with swords drawn. They even displayed this logical approach to combat magnificently at The Great Marianas Turkey Shoot.
Kenny, you are guilty of ethnocentrism.
Edited by aquatus1, 31 December 2009 - 05:15 PM.