bleedingelite on Mar 17 2008, 01:28 PM, said:
I mostly agree, except your short essay here is obviously skewed to the skeptics' point of view. Yes, things would go more smoothly if the people claiming to have psychic abilities would consider the possibility that they don't have powers. Well, theoretically. I don't know what the skeptics would do if that happened. Some might smile smugly to themselves and move on, some might see that as a point of weakness and keep attacking.
But for it to work out into a state of equilibrium, the skeptics would also have to concede that they're possibly wrong, and that some of these people might possibly have psychic powers. And, again, one of the two above possibilities might occur and still nothing might be solved.
And I will say THIS again: the people posting on these boards don't owe you crap. It's YOU challenging THEM. They're not coming on here saying "I can prove I have psychic powers," they're coming on here and making message boards called "psi-balls: what are they and what are they used for?" and the skeptics are coming into these topics and turning them into big debates on reality and pseudo science. If YOU want the proof, make a topic stating that you want proof.
In other words, maybe what would REALLY benefit this forum would be if people would stop sabotaging topics with "you're making it up; there is no such thing as _____" posts. Because within a couple of pages the original topic is completely lost and it turns into another circular debate that solves absolutely nothing.
Of course it is in favor of the skeptics point of view. But, the whole outcome was to point out that we are all flawed
in our ways of expressing certain points on these subjects.
People come on here making factual claims, and then not backing them up with factual evidence. It's not that hard
to see the flaw in that. It's one thing to believe in these abilities! But, when a person goes into I can manipulate this
levitate that, (Amazing claims in general!) thats a whole different level from just belief.
By the way! This is an open forum, if people make amazing claims they should expect to be on the recieving end
of a good deal of skepticism. No one is sabotaging a topic on here.
Regards,
Tom