Jump to content




Welcome to Unexplained Mysteries! Please sign in or create an account to start posting and to access a host of extra features.


- - - - -

[Merged] Stand Your Ground


  • Please log in to reply
23 replies to this topic

#1    questionmark

questionmark

    Cinicus Magnus

  • Member
  • 35,611 posts
  • Joined:26 Jun 2007
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Greece and Des Moines, IA

  • In a flat world there is an explanation to everything.

Posted 08 April 2012 - 01:38 PM

www.washingtonpost.com said:

When Billy Kuch knocked on the wrong door, he had a cigarette in one hand and a shirt in the other. The homeowner, Gregory Stewart, stepped outside, stood his ground, fired a round from his semiautomatic into Kuch's chest, and in the eyes of the state of Florida, committed no crime.

Three years after that shooting, in a Land O' Lakes subdivision called Stagecoach Village, Kuch is alive but damaged by his injuries and the shock of being shot at point-blank range.Stewart is free but lying low, still sought out by neighbors and others who want him to account for his actions.

Posted Image Read more...
  

Guess the NRA is happy now :innocent:

A skeptic is a well informed believer and a pessimist a well informed optimist
The most dangerous views of the world are from those who have never seen it. ~ Alexander v. Humboldt
If you want to bulls**t me please do it so that it takes me more than a minute to find out

about me

#2    libstaK

libstaK

    Nosce Te Ipsum

  • 6,895 posts
  • Joined:06 Feb 2011
  • Gender:Female
  • Location:Melbourne, Australia

  • Hello Reality and all that is True
    When Oxymoron was defined it was just for you

Posted 08 April 2012 - 01:50 PM

There is absolutely no detail in that article that explains why Kuch was on that doorstep ... what exactly is that article proving? It lists no sources, verifiable numbers or even accounts of injustice - just a vague reference to an incidence in which Kuch was shot but not why it was not justified or what actually happened?

"I warn you, whoever you are, oh you who wish to probe the arcanes of nature, if you do not find within yourself that which you seek, neither shall you find it outside.
If you ignore the excellencies of your own house, how do you intend to find other excellencies?
In you is hidden the treasure of treasures, Oh man, know thyself and you shall know the Universe and the Gods."

Inscription - Temple of Delphi

#3    and then

and then

    Abyssus Abyssum Invocat

  • Member
  • 13,953 posts
  • Joined:15 Dec 2011
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Land's End

  • Because what came before never seems enough...

Posted 08 April 2012 - 02:02 PM

The truth is that of the millions of legal gun owners in the US only a very tiny fraction ever discharge a firearm in such circumstances.  Much more a problem is the accidental death rate by people handling firearms without proper training.
I agree that the SYG laws need to be revisited.  I'm not sure how they can be made more clear, yet still provide the protection originally envisioned.  It may be that they just have to be scrapped altogether.  We cannot have a law that creates the impression that if you just feel threatened you can kill another person.

  We've cast the world, we've set the stage,
  for what could be, the darkest age...

#4    rashore

rashore

    Telekinetic

  • 7,021 posts
  • Joined:26 Feb 2010
  • Gender:Female

Posted 08 April 2012 - 02:33 PM

View PostlibstaK, on 08 April 2012 - 01:50 PM, said:

There is absolutely no detail in that article that explains why Kuch was on that doorstep ... what exactly is that article proving? It lists no sources, verifiable numbers or even accounts of injustice - just a vague reference to an incidence in which Kuch was shot but not why it was not justified or what actually happened?

Sorry LibstaK, you must not have been able to access pages 2 and 3 of the article covering that. Here's the text for you...

‘Could happen to anyone’

Billy Kuch was a troubled kid. As an adolescent, he had bipolar disorder diagnosed and he’d been arrested a couple of times for driving under the influence. He drank too much, and he knew it.
So when he was out at a party that August night on Golden Eagle Drive near the intersection of Gun Smoke Drive, he decided he was too blitzed to drive home. He left the party to lock his keys inside his car so he couldn’t get behind the wheel later that night.
Kuch, then 23, stumbled back toward the party but forgot which beige stucco house was hosting the bash. He knocked on the wrong door, the one belonging to Gregory Stewart, a 32-year-old homeowner who did not appreciate having his wife and baby disturbed by a drunk kid after 4 in the morning. Kuch went away and texted his sister that he was totally confused about what was going on.
Then Kuch found what he thought was the party house and tried the door. But he’d landed at Stewart’s place, again.
This time, after Kuch turned the doorknob, Stewart told his wife to call 911. Then he grabbed his Smith & Wesson semiautomatic and went into his front yard.
Stewart said he kept asking Kuch to leave, but Kuch, thinking the guys at the party were playing a joke on him, stayed.
“Don’t make me shoot you,” warned the 6-foot-1 Stewart, according to police records. “I don’t want to shoot you.”
Kuch, who stands 5-foot-9, raised his hands, asked for a light and lurched toward the homeowner. Stewart fired.
Stewart broke down in tears when police arrived. “I could have given him a light,” he said. But he said he had felt threatened.
Police asked Stewart why he hadn’t just waited inside until officers arrived.
“I don’t know,” replied Stewart. His unwanted visitor, he said, was unarmed.
“If I had a crazy drunk guy at my door,” said Jeanann Kuch, Billy’s mother, “I’d have locked my door and called 911.”
Kuch spent five weeks in a coma. He woke with no recollection of the incident.
Before the shooting, Kuch had supported the Stand Your Ground law, his parents said. Stewart’s view of the law is not known. He did not return repeated calls, and no court ever asked, because Stewart was never brought before a judge.
Stewart was arrested that night, but Assistant State Attorney Manny Garcia concluded that his actions were “justified.”


#5    libstaK

libstaK

    Nosce Te Ipsum

  • 6,895 posts
  • Joined:06 Feb 2011
  • Gender:Female
  • Location:Melbourne, Australia

  • Hello Reality and all that is True
    When Oxymoron was defined it was just for you

Posted 08 April 2012 - 02:42 PM

View Postrashore, on 08 April 2012 - 02:33 PM, said:

Sorry LibstaK, you must not have been able to access pages 2 and 3 of the article covering that. Here's the text for you...

'Could happen to anyone'

Billy Kuch was a troubled kid. As an adolescent, he had bipolar disorder diagnosed and he'd been arrested a couple of times for driving under the influence. He drank too much, and he knew it.
So when he was out at a party that August night on Golden Eagle Drive near the intersection of Gun Smoke Drive, he decided he was too blitzed to drive home. He left the party to lock his keys inside his car so he couldn't get behind the wheel later that night.
Kuch, then 23, stumbled back toward the party but forgot which beige stucco house was hosting the bash. He knocked on the wrong door, the one belonging to Gregory Stewart, a 32-year-old homeowner who did not appreciate having his wife and baby disturbed by a drunk kid after 4 in the morning. Kuch went away and texted his sister that he was totally confused about what was going on.
Then Kuch found what he thought was the party house and tried the door. But he'd landed at Stewart's place, again.
This time, after Kuch turned the doorknob, Stewart told his wife to call 911. Then he grabbed his Smith & Wesson semiautomatic and went into his front yard.
Stewart said he kept asking Kuch to leave, but Kuch, thinking the guys at the party were playing a joke on him, stayed.
"Don't make me shoot you," warned the 6-foot-1 Stewart, according to police records. "I don't want to shoot you."
Kuch, who stands 5-foot-9, raised his hands, asked for a light and lurched toward the homeowner. Stewart fired.
Stewart broke down in tears when police arrived. "I could have given him a light," he said. But he said he had felt threatened.
Police asked Stewart why he hadn't just waited inside until officers arrived.
"I don't know," replied Stewart. His unwanted visitor, he said, was unarmed.
"If I had a crazy drunk guy at my door," said Jeanann Kuch, Billy's mother, "I'd have locked my door and called 911."
Kuch spent five weeks in a coma. He woke with no recollection of the incident.
Before the shooting, Kuch had supported the Stand Your Ground law, his parents said. Stewart's view of the law is not known. He did not return repeated calls, and no court ever asked, because Stewart was never brought before a judge.
Stewart was arrested that night, but Assistant State Attorney Manny Garcia concluded that his actions were "justified."
Ah, you know it's late here - the problem might be that I just didn't notice a page 2 and 3 - thanks for the details.  So Stewart felt genuinely threatened/adrenaline coursing through his veins, a wife and child to worry about should the Kuch turn out to be up to no good.  But then when it was done he broke down in tears and told the cops "I could have just given him a light".

I would hate to be in his shoes then or any day since by the sounds of it.  I don't think the stand your ground law was tested appropriately in that case, it should have been, both parties are available to state their case - amnesia from Kuch notwithstanding, the phone records and all the party goers would be evidence he was looking for the right address for a party.

The whole SYG business is really messy but should be tested in the courts in every practical instance.

"I warn you, whoever you are, oh you who wish to probe the arcanes of nature, if you do not find within yourself that which you seek, neither shall you find it outside.
If you ignore the excellencies of your own house, how do you intend to find other excellencies?
In you is hidden the treasure of treasures, Oh man, know thyself and you shall know the Universe and the Gods."

Inscription - Temple of Delphi

#6    rashore

rashore

    Telekinetic

  • 7,021 posts
  • Joined:26 Feb 2010
  • Gender:Female

Posted 08 April 2012 - 03:06 PM

View PostlibstaK, on 08 April 2012 - 02:42 PM, said:

Ah, you know it's late here - the problem might be that I just didn't notice a page 2 and 3 - thanks for the details.  So Stewart felt genuinely threatened/adrenaline coursing through his veins, a wife and child to worry about should the Kuch turn out to be up to no good.  But then when it was done he broke down in tears and told the cops "I could have just given him a light".

I would hate to be in his shoes then or any day since by the sounds of it.  I don't think the stand your ground law was tested appropriately in that case, it should have been, both parties are available to state their case - amnesia from Kuch notwithstanding, the phone records and all the party goers would be evidence he was looking for the right address for a party.

The whole SYG business is really messy but should be tested in the courts in every practical instance.

I had problems getting the pages to load, I thought maybe you had the same problem.. it's all good :)

I'm not sure how I feel about SYG.. I think it's good to have some sort of clear legal CMA for when one is attacked. But I think there a handful of cases like this one where it wasn't justified. It is indeed a mess :(


#7    susieice

susieice

    December's Child

  • Member
  • 11,087 posts
  • Joined:10 Jun 2009
  • Gender:Female
  • Location:Pennsylvania

  • "Some say the world will end in fire, some say in ice."
    .....Robert Frost

Posted 08 April 2012 - 05:16 PM

After reading stories about the SYG law and it's application, I don't think I want a bar, a sporting event or anything else that could cause a fight to break out anywhere near where I live. It seems as if open gunfare is acceptable now and not even investigated anymore. I do agree with libstaK in that I wouldn't want to live with myself knowing that I killed someone on the spur of a moment that may not have really deserved it.

"The universe is full of magical things, patiently waiting for our wits to sharpen."  Eden Phillpotts

Opponere draconem est prehendere vitam

"I'm sure the universe is full of intelligent life. It's just been too intelligent to come here." Arthur C. Clarke

#8    conspiracybeliever

conspiracybeliever

    Telekinetic

  • Banned
  • 7,078 posts
  • Joined:10 Jul 2008
  • Gender:Not Selected

Posted 08 April 2012 - 05:51 PM

WE don't need any more laws. That is not the problem. We need a system that does what it is designed to do. The way it is now it does just the opposite and laws like this do nothing but create more crime. When we have to have laws like this it means people do not trust our system to do what it is supposed to do. If we are going to have laws like this we may as well just do away with the legal system. It's a waste of money. And the way it is presently working it is a waste of money and lives.


#9    Babe Ruth

Babe Ruth

    Non-Corporeal Being

  • Member
  • 8,519 posts
  • Joined:23 Dec 2011
  • Gender:Not Selected
  • Location:27North 80West

Posted 08 April 2012 - 06:01 PM

There was a similar incident in the next county about a year ago.

Young man celebrating his 21st birthday and drunk at 2am, knocks on the wrong door in a little neighbor he was not familiar with.  Looking for the home of his friends who he had been with.

The people that got woke up did not understand what was going on, but were scared.  Maybe they called 911.  Eventually the door is opened and the drunk youngster comes charging in.  Shot inside the house as I recall, fatally.


#10    Rafterman

Rafterman

    Telekinetic

  • Member
  • 6,769 posts
  • Joined:27 Sep 2010
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Upstate

Posted 09 April 2012 - 10:37 PM

View PostBabe Ruth, on 08 April 2012 - 06:01 PM, said:

There was a similar incident in the next county about a year ago.

Young man celebrating his 21st birthday and drunk at 2am, knocks on the wrong door in a little neighbor he was not familiar with.  Looking for the home of his friends who he had been with.

The people that got woke up did not understand what was going on, but were scared.  Maybe they called 911.  Eventually the door is opened and the drunk youngster comes charging in.  Shot inside the house as I recall, fatally.


Do you have a link?

That actually happened about 20 years ago in LA and was even a plot on the show Homicide Life on the Street in the early 90s.

But since it's a story that's rife for "urban legendry", I'd like to see actual proof that it happened again recently.

As to the OP, if the homicides are in fact justified, then so be it.  A legal shoot is a good shoot in my mind.  People have a right to defend themselves.

"You can't have freedom of religion without having freedom from the religious beliefs of other people."

#11    Sir Wearer of Hats

Sir Wearer of Hats

    SCIENCE!

  • Member
  • 10,767 posts
  • Joined:08 Nov 2008
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Queensland, Australia.

Posted 09 April 2012 - 10:42 PM

I think that "Stand Your Ground" should be a judicial decision, so you shoot someone you go to court and have to prove you were justified in shooting them, if you're successful nothing will be recorded against your name.

I must not fear. Fear is the Mind-Killer. It is the little death that brings total obliteration. I will face my fear.
I will permit it to pass over me and to move through me. And when it is gone I will turn the inner eye to see it's path.
When the fear is gone, there will be nothing.
Only I will remain.

#12    questionmark

questionmark

    Cinicus Magnus

  • Member
  • 35,611 posts
  • Joined:26 Jun 2007
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Greece and Des Moines, IA

  • In a flat world there is an explanation to everything.

Posted 09 April 2012 - 10:52 PM

View PostWearer of Hats, on 09 April 2012 - 10:42 PM, said:

I think that "Stand Your Ground" should be a judicial decision, so you shoot someone you go to court and have to prove you were justified in shooting them, if you're successful nothing will be recorded against your name.

Any Homicide/Manslaughter should go to court and there decided whether justified or not.

A skeptic is a well informed believer and a pessimist a well informed optimist
The most dangerous views of the world are from those who have never seen it. ~ Alexander v. Humboldt
If you want to bulls**t me please do it so that it takes me more than a minute to find out

about me

#13    conspiracybeliever

conspiracybeliever

    Telekinetic

  • Banned
  • 7,078 posts
  • Joined:10 Jul 2008
  • Gender:Not Selected

Posted 09 April 2012 - 11:52 PM

I can't even believe the same people on these boards talking about crime in black neighborhoods are ok with this. Do they actually think white people are going to be smarter with guns than black people? All this is going to do is create more neighborhoods just like those. More and more people are going to be paranoid and carrying guns, ready to shoot for any reason. Do you think all white people who own guns now are smart because I have news for you!Just tell them it's legal and you will see very quickly your perfect neighborhoods turning into that black neighborhoods you're always ranting about.


#14    Rafterman

Rafterman

    Telekinetic

  • Member
  • 6,769 posts
  • Joined:27 Sep 2010
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Upstate

Posted 10 April 2012 - 12:34 PM

View Postconspiracybeliever, on 09 April 2012 - 11:52 PM, said:

I can't even believe the same people on these boards talking about crime in black neighborhoods are ok with this. Do they actually think white people are going to be smarter with guns than black people? All this is going to do is create more neighborhoods just like those. More and more people are going to be paranoid and carrying guns, ready to shoot for any reason. Do you think all white people who own guns now are smart because I have news for you!Just tell them it's legal and you will see very quickly your perfect neighborhoods turning into that black neighborhoods you're always ranting about.

And yours is always the argument that is put out there - "it'll be just like the old west!" But yet the numbers in states where these types of laws and concealed carry in general have been enacted don't support your position.

Your profile says you live in Vermont - I'm assuming you know that Vermont has the most liberal firearms laws in the United States.  No permits are required for purchase or carry and that it's perfectly legal to walk around with pistol in full view Billy the Kid style - talk about the Old West.

Are the bodies piling up?

"You can't have freedom of religion without having freedom from the religious beliefs of other people."

#15    Babe Ruth

Babe Ruth

    Non-Corporeal Being

  • Member
  • 8,519 posts
  • Joined:23 Dec 2011
  • Gender:Not Selected
  • Location:27North 80West

Posted 10 April 2012 - 12:45 PM

View PostRafterman, on 09 April 2012 - 10:37 PM, said:

Do you have a link?

That actually happened about 20 years ago in LA and was even a plot on the show Homicide Life on the Street in the early 90s.

But since it's a story that's rife for "urban legendry", I'd like to see actual proof that it happened again recently.

As to the OP, if the homicides are in fact justified, then so be it.  A legal shoot is a good shoot in my mind.  People have a right to defend themselves.

No, I don't have a link.  It might be a year now since it happened, in the next county north from where I live.

I agree with Wearer Of Hats however, and Questionmark--any homicide should be taken to some sort of formal inquest or judicial proceeding.

I'm all for this SYG statute, but whether or not any given case meets the standard required should be closely and openly examined. The failure to do so in this Martin case is what has caused all the problem.





0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users