TheMacGuffin, on 19 July 2012 - 11:53 PM, said:
I can't claim to be an expert on 1947 teletype machines. In her original version in 1973-74, Lydia Sleppy just made it sound like someone had tapped into it, and only many years later did she mention the FBI. At this late date, in the absence of any records at all except this story she was telling for years, there's no way to know.
Kal Korff was the one who talked about the ringing bell and the switch, although from what I have heard about him, I'm surprised that he could even tie his shoes or get out of his own way. I mean, literally. Some people thought he was a CIA guy, but I have real questions about whether he could even walk and breathe at the time, much less walk and chew gum.
I rarely say such things about anyone, but in Korff's case, well, that's just what I've heard. I'm not sure that he knew what he was talking about at all, on any subject. I don't think he could have hit his plate with a fork or found his way to the restroom.
What was that story about how he just flipped out completely and started pretending that he was an Israeli agent or something? He was running around Europe insisting that everyone call him Captain Korff or Captain Crunch or some damn thing?
Well maybe, Korff did oust Mier, but I am not sure how hard that would have been to be perfectly honest. Whilst I am not an expert in the teletype machines of the era, I am proficient in communications installations, and Korff's sends/receive argument makes good sense. Still like that with many things today, even your email still uses a different part of your mail server to send and receive emails. And I think if his argument could have been challenged, it certainly would have been by now.
More than just the machine, Sleppy's account changes three times, and claims Johnny McBoyle gave her instructions and was present, yet he completely denies any such thing ever happening. With Karls comment earlier about Merel, Sleppy places her as being out of time in the same affidavit.
I just do not see Lydia Sleppy as strong evidence for the ET argument on the Roswell case.