Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Church will get you rich....
Unexplained Mysteries Discussion Forums > Unexplained Mysteries > Spirituality vs Skepticism
Jack-A-Roe
So anyway I was watching a program called Religion and Ethics today and I saw a few interesting stories this was one of them.
Apparently they are preaching about get rich through worship and a few of them seem to think it is working.
Now obviously it is working for their pastors cause they are all tithing to him but I wanted to see what you all think about this.
From PBS- program Religion and Ethics newsweekly
QUOTE
BOB ABERNETHY, anchor: There's an interpretation of Jesus' teachings that seems to be spreading fast, especially in many African-American churches, especially among the young. Critics call it the prosperity gospel and say Jesus never promised his followers that they would become wealthy. Proponents say they're just preaching what the Bible says. Deborah Potter has our story.

DEBORAH POTTER: It's Sunday morning at the Crenshaw Christian Center in Los Angeles, and the Reverend Frederick K.C. Price is preaching about abundance.

FREDERICK K.C. PRICE Reverend FREDERICK K.C. PRICE (Pastor, Crenshaw Christian Center, Los Angeles, during sermon): When you read that Jesus says I came that you might have life and have it more abundantly, what does "abundantly" say to you as an individual person? What?

CONGREGATION: A whole lot of stuff!

Rev. PRICE: A whole lot of stuff. Talk to me brother. A whole lot of stuff.

POTTER: Price, who leads a 10,000-member congregation, preaches that Christians who act as the Bible tells them, who are "doers of the Word," will prosper, and not just in the next life but in the here-and-now.

Rev. PRICE: God gives us power to get wealth. Does that sound like he wants you to be on welfare? That's in the Bible! He gives you power or the ability to get wealth. Notice what it doesn't say. It doesn't say God will make you wealthy. It says he'll give you the power to get it.

POTTER: The pastor points to his own wealth, including his luxury home and cars, as living proof that the message is true.

FREDERICK K.C. PRICE Rev. PRICE: I am one of the very few ministers that are very open, very, very open, because I don't have anything to hide. And I do it —I tell my people here all the time, "I'm only doing it so that you can see that there's somebody the same color that you are, breathing the same contaminated air, paying the same outrageous prices for everything else, and I'm prospering because of the Book."
questionmark
QUOTE(Jack-A-Roe @ Aug 19 2007, 07:33 PM) *
So anyway I was watching a program called Religion and Ethics today and I saw a few interesting stories this was one of them.
Apparently they are preaching about get rich through worship and a few of them seem to think it is working.
Now obviously it is working for their pastors cause they are all tithing to him but I wanted to see what you all think about this.
From PBS- program Religion and Ethics newsweekly


What is their congregation's name? The church of the Holy Capitalius?

Jack-A-Roe
QUOTE(questionmark @ Aug 19 2007, 12:36 PM) *
What is their congregation's name? The church of the Holy Capitalius?

grin2.gif apparently they are known part of something called the word of faith ministries,
heres a link to the story
http://www.pbs.org/wnet/religionandethics/...51/feature.html
I love the fact that the minister's last name is Price (cha ching) and one of the other ministers in the organization's last name is Dollar. I wonder if they changed their last names hehehe or if it was just coincidental.
questionmark
QUOTE(Jack-A-Roe @ Aug 19 2007, 07:44 PM) *
grin2.gif apparently they are known part of something called the word of faith ministries,
heres a link to the story
http://www.pbs.org/wnet/religionandethics/...51/feature.html
I love the fact that the minister's last name is Price (cha ching) and one of the other ministers in the organization's last name is Dollar. I wonder if they changed their last names hehehe or if it was just coincidental.


I once listened to a speech of a pretty wise guy who said that Magic was religion practiced for the wrong reasons. The reason to practice religion is to be and the reason to practice magic is to have. Guess he was wiser than I thought at the time.
Kane S. Latrans
I am aghast that you would even put out the idea that organized religion (some not so organized as well) would use its “influence” and ability to manipulate its followers to make money, to preach greed and wanton desire for material things would never happen. I am shocked and dismayed by the idea that you could even suggest that a church would have its followers call on their deity to “show me the money” aghast I say…

Ok maybe aghast to strong a word.

Sorry the sarcasm just slipped out, won’t happen again (in this minute).

My question is how this can be a process that is supported by the Christian Bible. I wonder what version of the bible this congregation uses. I wonder, is the cover is green?
I wonder how long until the religion of litigation smacks down hard on the “Pastor”.


sbradj
The bible tells us if we live accordingly to his word, he will supply our every need, as so much that we cant contain it all, as we have received so shall we give, share with others...


I dont believe anywhere in the bible God tells us to seek after him and he'll give us great pleasures of this world.
GetBornAgain
QUOTE(sbradj @ Aug 19 2007, 01:30 PM) *
The bible tells us if we live accordingly to his word, he will supply our every need, as so much that we cant contain it all, as we have received so shall we give, share with others...
I dont believe anywhere in the bible God tells us to seek after him and he'll give us great pleasures of this world.


Keyword is need. Nobody needs to own a 2 million dollar home or drive a mercedes. I think the congregation mentioned in the article is on the wrong track. IMO religion should be somewhat of an escape from the material world.
sbradj
QUOTE(GetBornAgain @ Aug 19 2007, 01:43 PM) *
Keyword is need. Nobody needs to own a 2 million dollar home or drive a mercedes. I think the congregation mentioned in the article is on the wrong track. IMO religion should be somewhat of an escape from the material world.

exactly I fully agree with your post!
Llucid
welcome to the wonderful world of prosperity preaching. it's spreading like wildfire and driving me up the wall.

i think it's important to note that many of these 'prosperity preachers' are very tight-lipped about their income and financial holdings, including many of the 'household names' from the Trinity Broadcasting Network(TBN). a wonderful website to visit to see what ministries are teaching a comprised message and which aren't open about their finances, please visit http://www.ministrywatch.com/
Paranoid Android
There is a passage in Malachi that does seem to advocate a "prosperity doctrine" (the teaching that following God will lead to wealth). However, I think this passage is very much misunderstood and is based on the complete Literalist approach to the Bible in that whatever is said in any part of the Bible, regardless of who wrote it, when, or why, it has the same applicable meaning to today's society. I'll try and give a fuller discussion on the passage in question when I get home from uni, but I've got class in 15 minutes and don't really have a Bible handy right now grin2.gif

~ Regards, PA
MissMelsWell
I keep running across these "prosperity" ya-hoo's... it makes me physically ill to be honest. It goes against everything I believe.I can't say more than that without getting very angry.
Lotus Flower
QUOTE(Paranoid Android @ Aug 20 2007, 03:11 AM) *
There is a passage in Malachi that does seem to advocate a "prosperity doctrine" (the teaching that following God will lead to wealth). However, I think this passage is very much misunderstood and is based on the complete Literalist approach to the Bible in that whatever is said in any part of the Bible, regardless of who wrote it, when, or why, it has the same applicable meaning to today's society. I'll try and give a fuller discussion on the passage in question when I get home from uni, but I've got class in 15 minutes and don't really have a Bible handy right now grin2.gif

~ Regards, PA

That Prosperity Doctrine, I suspect, probably refers to being rich in spirit as opposed to being materially rich. Following God will lead to wealth of the spirit etc.

Having said that, the vast majority of people are given the means to work, which is just as well or the planet would come to a standstill laugh.gif

Mind you, I do think that the preaching is taking it all out of context.
Jor-el
QUOTE(Jack-A-Roe @ Aug 19 2007, 05:33 PM) *
So anyway I was watching a program called Religion and Ethics today and I saw a few interesting stories this was one of them.
Apparently they are preaching about get rich through worship and a few of them seem to think it is working.
Now obviously it is working for their pastors cause they are all tithing to him but I wanted to see what you all think about this.
From PBS- program Religion and Ethics newsweekly


The prosperity movement as it is commonly called was started by Kenneth E. Hagin and a few others in the 50's but really took off in the 70's. A few others like Kenneth Copeland and Fred Price are also partly respnsible for this type of teaching.

These evangelists started what is known as the "Word of Faith" movement and even though there are many positive aspects regarding these ministries, they started a chain of events that lead to what we are discussing on this thread.

While they do not take the word of the bible out of context, they certainly do take its spirit out of context, there are some allegations that these evangelists are actually reintroducing Gnosticism back into the church in a disguised form.

Some of his books on the subject are well known...

The Midas touch: a balanced approach to biblical prosperity
Biblical Keys to Financial Prosperity
Obedience in Finances

He is the founder of Rhema Bible Church, a church I used to go to in South Africa and I used to love going there. I wasn't a member but I learned alot of good things in that church...
Beckys_Mom
QUOTE(MissMelsWell @ Aug 20 2007, 08:56 AM) *
I keep running across these "prosperity" ya-hoo's... it makes me physically ill to be honest. It goes against everything I believe.I can't say more than that without getting very angry.

eh? wacko.gif
Jor-el
QUOTE(Beckys_Mom @ Aug 20 2007, 06:28 PM) *
eh? wacko.gif


Hi BM, Long time... happy.gif

She probably means christians that are part of what we call the "prosperity movement"...
MissMelsWell
QUOTE(Jor-el @ Aug 20 2007, 10:45 AM) *
Hi BM, Long time... happy.gif

She probably means christians that are part of what we call the "prosperity movement"...


It's not even the people who are involved with these churches... it's the clergy/ministers I have a problem with.
momentarylapseofreason
I would think the bible means by "prosper"-spiritual prosperity and your "basic" needs like food and shelter will be taken care of - ????????? Not material riches.
Jesus hated greed and obsession with materialism.
momentarylapseofreason
Just another thing I can get very p'd off about.

I'd be p'd off as a christian just as much if not more.
randomhit10
there are many false teachers who use the word for personal gain...i am sure there will be a special place for them in the end...saved or not, i believe that God will not be mocked or caught on a technicality...if you know the truth, then there is no salvation when you knowingly go against it...anyway, that's what i believe.

randomhit10
darkmoonlady
Almost all fundamentalists preach this kind of thing. If you give to god, you get perks, and the more money you have the better you can serve god in giving back. On the surface it sounds like a pyramid scheme, and it kind of is. Bring in more faithful to the church, have fun, give money and the money comes back to you because you have faith. Lets face it most of the large churches in this country and others are out to make money, they are corporations. Whatever spiritual quota exists they worry more about the bottom line than souls.
Jor-el
QUOTE(darkmoonlady @ Aug 20 2007, 08:57 PM) *
Almost all fundamentalists preach this kind of thing. If you give to god, you get perks, and the more money you have the better you can serve god in giving back. On the surface it sounds like a pyramid scheme, and it kind of is. Bring in more faithful to the church, have fun, give money and the money comes back to you because you have faith. Lets face it most of the large churches in this country and others are out to make money, they are corporations. Whatever spiritual quota exists they worry more about the bottom line than souls.


While not necessarily true, I can see that it is a point of view seen by many... don't confuse the Prosperity movement with Fundamentalist christianity, or rather born again christianity, the two do not go hand in hand...

Lets put it this way, many born again christians may adhere to this idea but it is not an idea that pervades the church, it is rejected by many more churches than it is accepted by, even the large congregation churches...
Mr Walker
The funny thing is that in my experience, the more of gods bounty you return to him, the more he gives back to you. If you start off with the premise that everything you possess is actually the lord's and you are just his steward, it helps.

Giving a tithe and free will offerings ,in a true spirit of giving, seems to bring back both spiritual and financial rewards greater than those you give away. Plus, no matter how much a miser has, he is rarely happy, while those who share their wealth quite often are.

The bible does tell us to use our talents wisely, including making wise use of our finances. If we are capable, we should make enough to look after ourselves and our families, plus some surplus to share with those less fortunate. I am a teacher with a single income family. While not rich, we have never lacked for food or shelter (except the time our house burned down.) Even then, within 24 hours we had offers of houses, caravans and other places in which to stay, as long as we needed, and actually had our own rental home again within a week.

We give a lot away to mongolian villagers, asian kids, children close by who need food and education, and even quite a bit for animal welfare( mostly due to my wife's love of animals) In return we recieve not only a wonderful standard of living, but many physical, emotional and spiritual blessings.
MissMelsWell
QUOTE(Mr Walker @ Aug 20 2007, 07:43 PM) *
The funny thing is that in my experience, the more of gods bounty you return to him, the more he gives back to you. If you start off with the premise that everything you possess is actually the lord's and you are just his steward, it helps.

Giving a tithe and free will offerings ,in a true spirit of giving, seems to bring back both spiritual and financial rewards greater than those you give away. Plus, no matter how much a miser has, he is rarely happy, while those who share their wealth quite often are.

The bible does tell us to use our talents wisely, including making wise use of our finances. If we are capable, we should make enough to look after ourselves and our families, plus some surplus to share with those less fortunate. I am a teacher with a single income family. While not rich, we have never lacked for food or shelter (except the time our house burned down.) Even then, within 24 hours we had offers of houses, caravans and other places in which to stay, as long as we needed, and actually had our own rental home again within a week.

We give a lot away to mongolian villagers, asian kids, children close by who need food and education, and even quite a bit for animal welfare( mostly due to my wife's love of animals) In return we recieve not only a wonderful standard of living, but many physical, emotional and spiritual blessings.


Hat's off Walker.

wub.gif
Jor-el
QUOTE(Mr Walker @ Aug 21 2007, 03:43 AM) *
The funny thing is that in my experience, the more of gods bounty you return to him, the more he gives back to you. If you start off with the premise that everything you possess is actually the lord's and you are just his steward, it helps.

Giving a tithe and free will offerings ,in a true spirit of giving, seems to bring back both spiritual and financial rewards greater than those you give away. Plus, no matter how much a miser has, he is rarely happy, while those who share their wealth quite often are.

The bible does tell us to use our talents wisely, including making wise use of our finances. If we are capable, we should make enough to look after ourselves and our families, plus some surplus to share with those less fortunate. I am a teacher with a single income family. While not rich, we have never lacked for food or shelter (except the time our house burned down.) Even then, within 24 hours we had offers of houses, caravans and other places in which to stay, as long as we needed, and actually had our own rental home again within a week.

We give a lot away to mongolian villagers, asian kids, children close by who need food and education, and even quite a bit for animal welfare( mostly due to my wife's love of animals) In return we recieve not only a wonderful standard of living, but many physical, emotional and spiritual blessings.


That is exactly right, Mr. Walker... your post essentially embodies how christians should see their finances and it is according to biblical principle, just as long as the reason you are giving is not because you expect alot more, like a financial investment... that is essentially how the prosperity movement sees this issue and it goes against the spirit if not the word of the scriptures...

One should give out of love not out of self interest... this is quite differnt to: "I'll give you a nice present as long as I get an even better one..."
Nachtmahr
That's just weird.
Nachtmahr
Then again a perfect example of this is Benny Hin.
Jor-el
QUOTE(Nachtmahr @ Aug 22 2007, 07:39 PM) *
Then again a perfect example of this is Benny Hin.


At one time I was fascinated by Benny Hinns teaching and those of Kenneth E. Hagin as well but I think this was a fad that came and went, there is no real "meat" in that type of theology.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.