Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Magic - an analysis
Unexplained Mysteries Discussion Forums > Unexplained Mysteries > Spirituality vs Skepticism
Pages: 1, 2
eqgumby
QUOTE(momentarylapseofreason @ Sep 21 2007, 03:59 PM) *
I know what you mean-been there-done that-biblical apologetics etc.

I can't have faith in something that's not solid

If my husband is wonderful to me but I "suspect" he may be a pedophile-possibly too many "hints" -then I will divorce him-see what I mean ? Can't live like this

I don't ignore all the good-but the whole thing has to be right if I'm going to dedicate my life to it not alone believe it
A good marriage is not perfect but it better be 80% great but if murder,rape,beastiality are part of that equation I'm OUT and we are talking about a perfect GOD for KFC's sake !

Mind has to be able to digest it-if I force it-it's mental rape to me
How can I live a lie and force myself to believe ?

Understood, but then again, nothing is perfect, and we all have secrets or a "dark side". I would bet that there are things that if you knew them about your husband (things he thinks, or dreams, or whatever) that you would run screaming. I think that's true of nearly all people to some degree.

Look at Mother Theresa. She was an icon before she passed away, to millions! Now we discover that in her deepest heart, she felt there was no God at times (most of the time it seems). Yet she still held to the basic IDEALS of Christianity, and helped thousands, and inspired so many people.

No religion, or any organization, is without flaw, as are humans. There is no true utopia. Someone HAS to clean out the crapper, and sometimes you may get the shovel.

Are you dedicated to anything? Because I have yet to find anything that is completely (or wholly) right. Sometimes you NEED to overlook the bad. Hell, America was founded by murderers and rapists. Europe is chock full of villains that were leaders. Ireland is a hotbed of terrorists and religious zealots. The man that WROTE the Declaration of Independence owned slaves, and had affairs with them!

This isn't to derail the thread, just to point out that nothing is perfect.
How the hell did I get here on an analysis of magic thread? ohmy.gif wacko.gif
Devol
Who the Hell puts raisins in their omelets, PA? What kind of sicko are you?!? w00t.gif
Paranoid Android
I personally don't like them, but omelet's are a remarkably versatile food. See THIS SITE for just a small number of recipes. Of interest - The Raisin-nut Omelet Recipe grin2.gif

Sorry, back on topic unsure.gif *shifty eyes*

questionmark
Many years ago I heard a speech on magic by a very wise guy whose main thesis was that magic is religion practiced for the wrong reasons.

There are many people every day praying to hurt others, trying to gain profit and so on. There are even "Christian" cults that claim they will make you rich if you practice their type of Christianity. All that is not religion, it is magic.

So, I would say that the this preaching rant sweep should have started right at his congregation.

Tommy2007
QUOTE(GIDEON MAGE @ Sep 16 2007, 09:29 PM) *
There is no difference between magic and religion.



Correct, both are nonsense. Here's religion once again causing problems....
momentarylapseofreason
QUOTE(eqgumby @ Sep 22 2007, 03:48 AM) *
Understood, but then again, nothing is perfect, and we all have secrets or a "dark side". I would bet that there are things that if you knew them about your husband (things he thinks, or dreams, or whatever) that you would run screaming. I think that's true of nearly all people to some degree.

Look at Mother Theresa. She was an icon before she passed away, to millions! Now we discover that in her deepest heart, she felt there was no God at times (most of the time it seems). Yet she still held to the basic IDEALS of Christianity, and helped thousands, and inspired so many people.

No religion, or any organization, is without flaw, as are humans. There is no true utopia. Someone HAS to clean out the crapper, and sometimes you may get the shovel.

Are you dedicated to anything? Because I have yet to find anything that is completely (or wholly) right. Sometimes you NEED to overlook the bad. Hell, America was founded by murderers and rapists. Europe is chock full of villains that were leaders. Ireland is a hotbed of terrorists and religious zealots. The man that WROTE the Declaration of Independence owned slaves, and had affairs with them!

This isn't to derail the thread, just to point out that nothing is perfect.
How the hell did I get here on an analysis of magic thread? ohmy.gif wacko.gif



I know alot more about my husband that he doesn't know-that I know.

I don't want to embarass him because he is very kind and loving. He was raised strict catholic and he is ashamed very easily and I feel kind of bad for him so I pretend I don't know. In fact I think his strict religious upbringing is related to this dark side. Too me it's not so dark but to him it is because he was TOLD IT IS.

I am understanding and can live with it. Let's just say that.

He is not harming anyone and he is a man that is often too nice to people and can easily be taken advantage of.

He fascinates me because he is very kind and self-confident without being arrogant at all.

I've never met a person that doesn't like him.

I got rid of my "dark side"- it took lots of work. What is considered dark is defined differently to different people.

Life is not perfect BUT GOD IS
Repoman
QUOTE(Paranoid Android @ Sep 16 2007, 12:31 PM) *
I wonder how some of our church members would react when evangelizing
Things like this always give me the creeps. I mean a deep-down, cold feeling in the pit of my stomach. To think there are millions of people in America that worship a god they believe slaughtered every baby on the planet by drowning them in a flood and it is just a normal figure of speech to them to talk about "evangelizing". It honestly makes the hairs on the back of my neck stand up.


QUOTE(Paranoid Android @ Sep 16 2007, 12:31 PM) *
~PA's note - in this sermon, our pastor came to the realisation that playing computer games involving demons and magic was wrong, and took his copy of Diablo II, which until this point he loved playing, and took a pair of scissors to it, cutting the CD/DVD up for everyone in the congregation to see
What a creepy story. This is scarier than Hostel or Cabin Fever or 28 Days Later! It is scarier because it is true! There actually are TENS OF MILLIONS of otherwise intelligent people in America that go to sermons to be preached at by morons like this nutjob that thinks video games are "EVIL" and they willingly follow a god that slaughters ahumanity on a somewhat regular basis and they want to CONVERT the rest of the people.

THIS IS SCARY SH*T!!!

At least they are supposed to be peaceful....

Paranoid Android
QUOTE(Repoman @ Sep 25 2007, 01:48 AM) *
What a creepy story. This is scarier than Hostel or Cabin Fever or 28 Days Later! It is scarier because it is true! There actually are TENS OF MILLIONS of otherwise intelligent people in America that go to sermons to be preached at by morons like this nutjob that thinks video games are "EVIL" and they willingly follow a god that slaughters ahumanity on a somewhat regular basis and they want to CONVERT the rest of the people.

THIS IS SCARY SH*T!!!

At least they are supposed to be peaceful....
I wouldn't go that far, repoman. I would not call my assistant pastor a "nutjob" at all. He's probably one of the most intelligent men I've ever met. His knowledge of the Bible is parallel to none. I don't agree with his interpretation of magic as it relates to modern-day video games and movies, but he is quite within his right to hold that belief and it doesn't make him a "nutjob" or a "moron" for doing so. I respect my pastor greatly, even though we don't always agree with each other, which means I guess I'm giving respect to a moronic nutjob.

Repoman
QUOTE(Paranoid Android @ Sep 24 2007, 12:10 PM) *
I wouldn't go that far, repoman. I would not call my assistant pastor a "nutjob" at all. He's probably one of the most intelligent men I've ever met. His knowledge of the Bible is parallel to none. I don't agree with his interpretation of magic as it relates to modern-day video games and movies, but he is quite within his right to hold that belief and it doesn't make him a "nutjob" or a "moron" for doing so. I respect my pastor greatly, even though we don't always agree with each other, which means I guess I'm giving respect to a moronic nutjob.


I tend to sling labels - but I sling them in a context that comes off the wrong way to other people.
In my mind, I assign a label (like "moron") to a person but only in the context of a specific behaviour.
In regards to your assigned indocrination engineer, I was using the moron label in reference to his actions of cutting up the CD-ROM in front of the assembled group of indoctrination subjects.

I usually write train of thought and in my mind, I attach the moron label to a previous event and I understand my internal context. I recognize this context may not be the default context when my train of thought post is read later.


What I was actually trying to convey was that the act of cutting up a CD-ROM while squealing about how it is EVIL is moronic.
I do not believe that your indoctrination engineer is a moron.
John A Spera
QUOTE(momentarylapseofreason @ Sep 24 2007, 09:40 AM) *
I got rid of my "dark side"- it took lots of work. What is considered dark is defined differently to different people.

Life is not perfect BUT GOD IS


I am fond of anyone who is not fearful of doing "dark side" work. In my view much of what we consdider dark is a matter of perception. The human is biased towards good experiences. The other kind are never seen as blessed and the energies we create around "bad" experiences go unloved and unappreciated.

The more a person realized that all is perfect, the more they can understand the mind of God.

John

Tangerine Sheri
QUOTE(John A Spera @ Sep 24 2007, 09:48 AM) *
I am fond of anyone who is not fearful of doing "dark side" work. In my view much of what we consdider dark is a matter of perception. The human is biased towards good experiences. The other kind are never seen as blessed and the energies we create around "bad" experiences go unloved and unappreciated.

The more a person realized that all is perfect, the more they can understand the mind of God.

John




I agree John, the imperfection is the perfection and we are all of it the up, the down ,the good,the bad, the beautiful,the ugly and its in this wisdom we create the experiences we call 'the perfection"....the error is one sets a standard on what perfection must be and in that misses that all of life is the perfection....

we as a humanity have erected models, labled them (god) deeming this is the prefection... and in this man has lost his way. and dosen't know it.......
Paranoid Android
QUOTE(Repoman @ Sep 25 2007, 02:37 AM) *
I tend to sling labels - but I sling them in a context that comes off the wrong way to other people.
In my mind, I assign a label (like "moron") to a person but only in the context of a specific behaviour.
In regards to your assigned indocrination engineer, I was using the moron label in reference to his actions of cutting up the CD-ROM in front of the assembled group of indoctrination subjects.

I usually write train of thought and in my mind, I attach the moron label to a previous event and I understand my internal context. I recognize this context may not be the default context when my train of thought post is read later.
What I was actually trying to convey was that the act of cutting up a CD-ROM while squealing about how it is EVIL is moronic.
I do not believe that your indoctrination engineer is a moron.
My "assigned indoctrination engineer"???? laugh.gif laugh.gif laugh.gif That would be funny, if I didn't think you were so serious. You don't have a high opinion of churches, do you.
eqgumby
QUOTE(Repoman @ Sep 24 2007, 10:48 AM) *
Things like this always give me the creeps. I mean a deep-down, cold feeling in the pit of my stomach. To think there are millions of people in America that worship a god they believe slaughtered every baby on the planet by drowning them in a flood and it is just a normal figure of speech to them to talk about "evangelizing". It honestly makes the hairs on the back of my neck stand up.
What a creepy story. This is scarier than Hostel or Cabin Fever or 28 Days Later! It is scarier because it is true! There actually are TENS OF MILLIONS of otherwise intelligent people in America that go to sermons to be preached at by morons like this nutjob that thinks video games are "EVIL" and they willingly follow a god that slaughters ahumanity on a somewhat regular basis and they want to CONVERT the rest of the people.

THIS IS SCARY SH*T!!!

At least they are supposed to be peaceful....

Toting the party line I see.
What's REALLY scary, is that people get this paranoid and panicked over religion. A little education goes a long way, as does being calm and methodical rather than panicky and reactionary. This, by the way, is true of both sides of this coin. That's right. The goobers that burn the Harry Potter books are just as scary as the dingbats that scream and panic when a religous group preaches morality. "How dare you try to legislate away my right to be a pedophile!", is as scary as "Harry Potter is in league with the Devil!"

Try some reason folks. It's yummy! thumbsup.gif
Repoman
QUOTE(eqgumby @ Sep 25 2007, 11:21 AM) *
What's REALLY scary, is that people get this paranoid and panicked over religion.

Are you saying that there aren't millions of people in America that worship a god they believe slaughtered every baby on the planet by drowning them in a flood and talk about "evangelizing"?

I can understand why you don't find that frightening - you are one of the worshippers of that particular god out of many gods.

What I can't understand is how you fail to understand why some of us get disgusted and creeped out by this.

And there are probably a million christian "soldiers" for every pedophile that publicly screams for his right to be a pedophile as you used in your counter-example.
Repoman
QUOTE(Paranoid Android @ Sep 24 2007, 10:03 PM) *
My "assigned indoctrination engineer"???? laugh.gif laugh.gif laugh.gif That would be funny, if I didn't think you were so serious. You don't have a high opinion of churches, do you.

No. They anger me because they are self-serving business interests. Churches exist to make people frightened. After frightening the people, they offer services to soothe the people. They then ask for money from the people. They use that money to make more churches and hire more clergy so that they can frighten more people.

But negative reinforcement doesn't work without positive reinforcement so they also offer eternal bliss and an afterlife.

So now you have the ultimate carrot-and-stick.

What is truly mind-blowing is that almost every intelligent and well-informed christian out there KNOWS that the old testament was a re-telling of ancient egyption, sumerian and perisan astrological mythology and the new testament wasn't even written during the time the events were said to have taken place. Furthermore, the church has rewritten several sections of it and threw out some books entirely. They know all this yet they still claim it to be the the word of god.

What makes anyone think that their religion just happens to be the one true religion? Gee, I guess you got lucky for being born here instead of Nepal! But then the Nepalese are feeling mighty lucky to have been born there for the exact same reason!

What is going on in your minds that allows you to think this way?

Do I think it is scary? HELL YES.
Why? Because intelligent people that have allowed themselves to be wholly absorbed by the financial machine that is modern religion can probable be made to do anything if given enough time.

And I don't want those jesus freak zombies showing up on my doorstep with a bible in one hand and a gun in the other.
Tangerine Sheri
QUOTE(eqgumby @ Sep 25 2007, 08:21 AM) *
Toting the party line I see.
What's REALLY scary, is that people get this paranoid and panicked over religion. A little education goes a long way, as does being calm and methodical rather than panicky and reactionary. This, by the way, is true of both sides of this coin. That's right. The goobers that burn the Harry Potter books are just as scary as the dingbats that scream and panic when a religous group preaches morality. "How dare you try to legislate away my right to be a pedophile!", is as scary as "Harry Potter is in league with the Devil!"

Try some reason folks. It's yummy! thumbsup.gif


eggy, alot of folks take the beleifs of the bible very seriously, many really feel this is god's word and and implement the ideas in a way that cause harm and this is somethng to be very concerned about IMO.....i am very pleased to know that their are those that look to history and research and look at sceince and make informed decisions and thats the point of these discussions to encourge one to really question, the lack of questioning has permeated humanity for along time....so it is a good thing religion is thinking and for me that is what i care about.......it seems that the US is the slowest to come to this understanding...IMO...
eqgumby
QUOTE(Repoman @ Sep 25 2007, 01:13 PM) *
Are you saying that there aren't millions of people in America that worship a god they believe slaughtered every baby on the planet by drowning them in a flood and talk about "evangelizing"?

I can understand why you don't find that frightening - you are one of the worshippers of that particular god out of many gods.

What I can't understand is how you fail to understand why some of us get disgusted and creeped out by this.

And there are probably a million christian "soldiers" for every pedophile that publicly screams for his right to be a pedophile as you used in your counter-example.

Ah yes, yet again another hater, simply assigning me belief a in God YOU dislike/fear/whatever.

Reason my friend, reason. Don't try to rationalize faith, it just can't be done. These folks faith (all religions that rely on faith) are like the relationship between you and your spouse/significant-other in many ways. There has to be FAITH, as intangible as it may seem. What do YOU have faith in, and is it morally superior to "God", "Allah", "Pick-a-Pagan-Deity"? The point is, it's not meant to be taken literally. It's an object lesson, and wailing about "God" being a murderer of babies, is just lip service. You want to bash religion, bash molesting Priests and the hierarchy that protects them, or the "Reverends" with the shiney gold watches and Mercedes Benz limos. That's who you need to poke at.
Repoman
QUOTE(eqgumby @ Sep 25 2007, 03:17 PM) *
You want to bash religion, bash molesting Priests and the hierarchy that protects them, or the "Reverends" with the shiney gold watches and Mercedes Benz limos. That's who you need to poke at.
If a person willingly worships the god that supposedly drowned every baby on earth then they are a morally bankrupt jackal.

If a person claims to worship that god but really doesn't believe in all the bible crap then they are a miserable hypocrite.

If it weren't for the miserable hypocrites that claim to follow whatever god happened to be popular at the time and place they were born then there would be no place for molesting priests and millionaire preachers.



eqgumby
QUOTE(Repoman @ Sep 25 2007, 02:34 PM) *
If a person willingly worships the god that supposedly drowned every baby on earth then they are a morally bankrupt jackal.

That's an unnecessary personal attack on anyone that worships a God who's holy book includes a global flood.
QUOTE(Repoman @ Sep 25 2007, 02:34 PM) *
If a person claims to worship that god but really doesn't believe in all the bible crap then they are a miserable hypocrite.

Also unnecessary as this is an attack on "Deists", as well as anyone that believes in God but is not a "literalist" when it comes to interpreting the bible (and that is darn near EVERYONE that claims Christianity as their faith).
QUOTE(Repoman @ Sep 25 2007, 02:34 PM) *
If it weren't for the miserable hypocrites that claim to follow whatever god happened to be popular at the time and place they were born then there would be no place for molesting priests and millionaire preachers.

Almost can agree with this one. But I think condemning people for choosing to live rather than deny a state sponsored religion is a little hypocritical too.

Exactly how high is your horse anyway? wink2.gif
momentarylapseofreason
Faith to me is like putting all your eggs into one basket.

And I NEVER do that.

I have 100% faith in NOTHING. Not even in myself for I am always changing (my clothes).



ANYTHING CAN AND DOES HAPPEN.

eqgumby
QUOTE(momentarylapseofreason @ Sep 25 2007, 03:57 PM) *
Faith to me is like putting all your eggs into one basket.

And I NEVER do that.

I have 100% faith in NOTHING. Not even in myself for I am always changing (my clothes).
ANYTHING CAN AND DOES HAPPEN.

Which is fine. However, those who are faithful (as they can be) to their religion, have a different opinion.
Beckys_Mom
QUOTE(Repoman @ Sep 25 2007, 08:34 PM) *
If a person claims to worship that god but really doesn't believe in all the bible crap then they are a miserable hypocrite.

Yea and YOU would know a lot about that wouldn't you? huh.gif

I mean you must know something we don't? Like...ohh I dunno...a law that states - You MUST only follow a God that is linked to a bible...you cannot separate the 2, its not right..if you do this, you are a miserable hypocrite!!

Ironically at the same time of you calling people names...you have the idea that God don't exist at all...so where does it leave you?? a leg to stand on to judge others, calling them names for how they WISH to follow God?? for if they don't believe in the bible crap (as you so like to put it)...then ohh noo it so can't be done..that makes them miserable and hypocrites... ohmy.gif

It's like going to a fast food joint, and asking for a burger with no dressing...goodness me ..it's unheard of...or a cake without the icing..lol

It's 4am, do you know where your wit is? huh.gif

You seriously have no idea what faith is...but you act as though there are rules to how someone should worship God....BRAVO..you just made yourself look ever so..........bright! LOL laugh.gif

Devol
QUOTE(Repoman @ Sep 25 2007, 02:23 PM) *
What is truly mind-blowing is that almost every intelligent and well-informed christian out there KNOWS that the old testament was a re-telling of ancient egyption, sumerian and perisan astrological mythology and the new testament wasn't even written during the time the events were said to have taken place. Furthermore, the church has rewritten several sections of it and threw out some books entirely. They know all this yet they still claim it to be the the word of god.

I doubt Genesis was written during the time those events were said to have taken place either, but it's what some people believe.

But let's recap...these people know all this, and they still claim it to be the word of God? Sorry, perhaps they don't know. Maybe, just maybe, they look at all the ideas you just presented and view them as garbage, just as you view the Bible as garbage. You seem to have a hard time understanding exactly what "belief" means.

Let's try this...we'll argue from the other side of the fence...
Atheists know that a greater power exists all around them, yet they still claim that Divinity doesn't exist. Or haven't you been outside lately? Ever seen a birth? Ever look at nature? These miracles of life were just coincidences? Happy accidents?



QUOTE(Beckys_Mom @ Sep 25 2007, 06:12 PM) *
Yea and YOU would know a lot about that wouldn't you? huh.gif

I mean you must know something we don't? Like...ohh I dunno...a law that states - You MUST only follow a God that is linked to a bible...you cannot separate the 2, its not right..if you do this, you are a miserable hypocrite!!

Ironically at the same time of you calling people names...you have the idea that God don't exist at all...so where does it leave you?? a leg to stand on to judge others, calling them names for how they WISH to follow God?? for if they don't believe in the bible crap (as you so like to put it)...then ohh noo it so can't be done..that makes them miserable and hypocrites... ohmy.gif

It's like going to a fast food joint, and asking for a burger with no dressing...goodness me ..it's unheard of...or a cake without the icing..lol

It's 4am, do you know where your wit is? huh.gif

You seriously have no idea what faith is...but you act as though there are rules to how someone should worship God....BRAVO..you just made yourself look ever so..........bright! LOL laugh.gif

Cheers for that, hun! w00t.gif
Darkwind
I thought we were talking about magic on this thread? As usual it turns into a debate about Abrahamic religions.

What people don't understand about magic and spells is they are for the most part ritualized prayer to the Universe, whatever deities you follow or even yourself in the case of ceremonial magic. Druidic magic is done with words for the most part. Druid spells are set up like a poem with dance. Magic is manipulating the fundamental forces in the Universe to effect an outcome for your's or someone else's benefit. Prayer is a request for your god to do it for you.
Devol
QUOTE(Darkwind @ Sep 25 2007, 09:09 PM) *
I thought we were talking about magic on this thread? As usual it turns into a debate about Abrahamic religions.

What people don't understand about magic and spells is they are for the most part ritualized prayer to the Universe, whatever deities you follow or even yourself in the case of ceremonial magic. Druidic magic is done with words for the most part. Druid spells are set up like a poem with dance. Magic is manipulating the fundamental forces in the Universe to effect an outcome for your's or someone else's benefit. Prayer is a request for your god to do it for you.

Sorry, DW! It's all PA's fault! He brought up raisins in omelets and I lost my concentration.

Well, in this day and age of automobiles and Ebay, we've gotten a bit lazy! Some would rather sit on the couch, or at the computer, and let God worry about the details. tongue.gif

I've been reading some of Silver Ravenwolf's stuff, but I'm mainly looking for Earth based practices. Any suggestions?
Repoman
QUOTE(Beckys_Mom @ Sep 25 2007, 06:12 PM) *
You MUST only follow a God that is linked to a bible...you cannot separate the 2, its not right..if you do this, you are a miserable hypocrite!!
I was referring to people that claimed to follow a religion but failed to follow that religion's scripture. In my haste I said "follow a god" rather than "follow a religion" and "bible" instead of "holy texts". OK? Hopefully you are a strong enough person to re-interpret my post based on this new information.

QUOTE(Beckys_Mom @ Sep 25 2007, 06:12 PM) *
Ironically at the same time of you calling people names...you have the idea that God don't exist at all...so where does it leave you??
First off, what you are describing is not an example of irony - even in its most butchered usage. Secondly, if the name fits then you are stuck with it. If you claim to be a Southern Baptist but don't believe the bible is true then you are a hypocrite. If you willingly follow a god that murdered millions of babies because he didn't like their parent's behaviour then you are exactly the type of person that allowed the Nazis to take over Germany - a religious fascist - willing to smile at the most horrific of acts as long as your god said it was cool. Those sorts of people make me sick. I'm sorry that you seem to support such people. I cannot. Thirdly, I believe in a creator. Where does that leave me?


QUOTE(Beckys_Mom @ Sep 25 2007, 06:12 PM) *
It's 4am, do you know where your wit is?
I wasn't trying to be witty.

QUOTE(Beckys_Mom @ Sep 25 2007, 06:12 PM) *
You seriously have no idea what faith is...but you act as though there are rules to how someone should worship God....
Nice try. But your attempt to appeal to the wounded masses will only inspire comaraderie from the most pathetic and feeble of readers. I understand faith. Faith isn't limited to deities. I remember the sense of wonder I felt as a stupid, ignorant child while anticipating the yearly visit from Santa Claus. I can see how the same sort of faith could work for some god or another.

And I never said there were any rules for how a person "worships god". Just as there are no rules for how much I can despise hypocrites. Worship however you want. Worship whatever you want. But if you claim to follow a religion but don't believe in its scripture then you are a hypocrite. And if you willingly worship a murderous god then I would never welcome you in my house and I have avoided friendships with such people all my life because I am NOT a hypocrite and I will NOT sit down with someone that truly believes the stories in the bible (FOR EXAMPLE <===) and isn't repulsed and disgusted by such a "god" and chooses, instead to willingly worship that thing.

Am I attacking anyone? No. I am explaining to you my general feelings about a topic of discussion.

I am basically saying hypocrisy is bad and offered up as an example of hypocrisy a person that tells the world that they follow a religion but secretly don't actually believe in the religion's holy scripture. You have weighed in against this. And that is fine too. A lot of people support hypocrisy.

I am also saying I don't understand why a person would willingly worship a god that has done such evil things. You respond by hissing and saying I lack the common human emotion/concept of "faith".


QUOTE(Beckys_Mom @ Sep 25 2007, 06:12 PM) *
BRAVO..you just made yourself look ever so..........bright! LOL laugh.gif

Nice having this discussion with you. You have raised some excellent points.
Repoman
QUOTE(eqgumby @ Sep 25 2007, 04:04 PM) *
That's an unnecessary personal attack on anyone that worships a God who's holy book includes a global flood.

It's actually an unnecessary insult to jackals and I retract it. But the morally bankrupt part I do not retract. Morals are subjective. There is no unit of conversion from one person's interpretation of another person's morals to another. When I call someone morally bankrupt - that is just how I interpret them. It is certainly not worse than a christian telling me I am going to hell if I don't repent. And I do honestly believe that a person that would willingly follow such a murdering god is morally bankrupt. That is not an insult - that is my interpretation of an unquantifiable trait.

QUOTE(eqgumby @ Sep 25 2007, 04:04 PM) *
Also unnecessary as this is an attack on "Deists", as well as anyone that believes in God but is not a "literalist" when it comes to interpreting the bible (and that is darn near EVERYONE that claims Christianity as their faith).
You are right by pointing this out. I actually alluded to this on another post. I said I was wrong there and I'll say it again here. What I meant to say was that people who claimed to follow a "religion" but didn't believe their own "scripture" were hypocrites. I sincerely apologize to the deists.
eqgumby
QUOTE(Repoman @ Sep 26 2007, 01:11 PM) *
It's actually an unnecessary insult to jackals and I retract it. But the morally bankrupt part I do not retract. Morals are subjective. There is no unit of conversion from one person's interpretation of another person's morals to another. When I call someone morally bankrupt - that is just how I interpret them. It is certainly not worse than a christian telling me I am going to hell if I don't repent. And I do honestly believe that a person that would willingly follow such a murdering god is morally bankrupt. That is not an insult - that is my interpretation of an unquantifiable trait.

You are right by pointing this out. I actually alluded to this on another post. I said I was wrong there and I'll say it again here. What I meant to say was that people who claimed to follow a "religion" but didn't believe their own "scripture" were hypocrites. I sincerely apologize to the deists.

I'm bordering on agreeing with you. Cut it out or I'll have to change my beliefs at random to confuse you! wacko.gif

I still think the folks that ramble and whine about a "murdering God" are just sheep that run to evilbible.com so they can feel trendy and anti-establishment, maybe in an attempt to piss off their parents. I don't feel any real conviction there, just an "emo" kind of anime trash-talk. Sorry.
momentarylapseofreason
Here chew on this sammich. It tastes magical.

MAGICAL THINKING

In psychology and cognitive science, magical thinking is non-scientific causal reasoning (e.g. superstition).[citation needed]James George Frazer and Bronislaw K. Malinowski said that magic is more like science than religion, and that societies with magical beliefs often had separate religious beliefs and practices.[citation needed]

Like science, magic is concerned with causal relations, but unlike science, it does not distinguish correlation from causation. For example, a man who has won a bowling competition in a given shirt may then believe this shirt is lucky. He will continue to wear the shirt to bowling competitions, and though he continues to win some and lose some, he will chalk up every win to his lucky shirt.

However, Sir Arthur C. Clarke has proposed the now widely accepted postulate that "any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic" (see Clarke's three laws), highlighting that the difference between science and magic may be one of methodology rather than one of effect.


According to Frazer,[1] magical thinking depends on two laws: the law of similarity (an effect resembles its cause), and the law of contagion (things which were once in physical contact maintain a connection even after physical contact has been broken). These two laws govern the operation of what Frazer called "sympathetic magic", the idea that the manipulation of effigies or similar symbols or tokens can cause changes to occur in the thing the symbol represented. Typical examples of sympathetic magic include the use of voodoo dolls, and the fetishization of cargo cults. Others have described these two laws as examples of "analogical reasoning" (rather than logical reasoning).

*See Source for further reading
Odd Christian
i agree that there should be a distinction made between fantasy magic and real magick. the main objection to fantasy magic, is that it could lead to people dabbling in the real thing.
from a christian perspective, we are to rely on GOD for all things, according to HIS will, because HE is above us, knows more, sees more, understands more. because of this, when we want something and use magick to obtain it, when HE has told us no because HE knows that it would have a bad affect either on our own lives, or the lives of somone else, then we are rebelling against HIM.

depending on the magick system being used, the person participating is calling on and relying on the power of a spiritual entity aside from GOD, thus we fall into not only rebellion, but also idolatry, as most systems are religious in nature.

i once read a simplified definition of magick- doing something in the physical, which affects the spiritual, which then effects the physical. based on this simple definition, yes prayer could be considered magick.

the difference here is that we are asking GOD to provide or do something for us by HIS power, as opposed to using rituals to cause our own wills to be accomplished through another spiritual agency through that spirits power.
in all the systems i have looked at, they ALL have protective rites to keep the powers being called on from harming the person/s performing the ritual, whith the exception of wicca, their circle is designed to keep the power in, not to keep anything out.
draconic chronicler
QUOTE(Paranoid Android @ Sep 17 2007, 10:53 AM) *
No, I don't believe this is possible. But then again, nobody else does, either. It's fiction. Not even witches or warlocks or druids believe you can throw a fireball from thin air. I know what point you are trying to make, but my discussion is concerned with beliefs that people actually hold, as opposed to those Eddings fans who happen to like a good novel (btw, I love David Eddings, among other fantasy-writers).

It was months ago, so unfortunately I can't give you a detailed synopsis. In general though, we spoke at length on the matter - there were 4 main issues that i think we discussed, but I couldn't say what the overall response of it was:

~ The nature of magic. It was my contention that "magic" was subtle, not as obvious as Diablo demons and firebolts and lighting strikes. My pastor disagreed and said that in the Bible that's exactly what magic was like - pointing to the priests advising Pharaoh as an example (these priests were able to do many of the same magic tricks that Moses was able to do with the power of God, except that God proved his power by doing it better and more decisively (eg, both turned their staffs into snakes, but Aaron's staff ate the other snakes). It is true that the Bible doesn't give us detail as to whether Pharaoh's advisers were really magicians, or just illusionists, so I'll give him the points for this one.

But then I countered by saying that Simon Magus could do many of the miracles that the apostles (and Jesus, while he was alive) could perform. But there were some things he couldn't do, and Simon attempted to "buy" this information from Peter, as if it was a trick to be peddled. Many consider Simon Magus to be a simple illusionist, but like the priests of Pharaoh, there is no biblical indication either way. But the fact that Simon tried to buy the trick as if it were an illusion is a big give-away. Points to me.

So far we're even.

For the rest, we discussed matters of how magic is portrayed in the popular media. He argued that according to the Bible magic is wrong. According to the Bible rape is wrong. But we are happy to watch a movie that extols the virtues of magic, yet we would recoil at the concept of a movie which revolved around rape. I spoke about the nature of theatre and how "entertainment" wasn't the sole purpose of any movie (though often times it is). That then led to what circumstances would be acceptable to see a piece of theatre involving magic.

Really, it seemed to be a stalemate. i believe I "won" the debate. He believes he "won". In the end, we both agreed to disagree, and agreed that whatever our points of view, they were not part of "essential doctrine" (that is, they did not impact on our eternal salvation). We thus agreed to leave it at that, and moved on our separate ways. As long as we both agreed that practicing it was wrong, and that we should be careful when exposing children to ideas of magic, even if it was in the context of a cartoon or a children's program. But I never disagreed with that - heck, when I was young, my parents sat me down and made sure taht I knew Road-Runner wasn't real, and that what happened to Wyle E. Coyote wasn't real and couldn't happen to us in real life. that's just common sense, if you ask me. If you don't teach kids that a cartoon is only a cartoon and not real, then who knows what ideas can slip into their heads.

As I said...... a stalemate.

~ regards, PA


Hmmm, I wonder what your pastor has to say about Moses turning the rod into a whale because according to Christians concordances this is what a Tannin is and that is the word used in the Bible. In the old KJV version this word is usually translated to "dragon", except in this one place because a serpent to a staff sounds so much better. Or if he ever looked at a medieval bible that illustrates at least two chapters with God riding on the back of a dragon, because it says so in Pslams and II Samual, just like all of the fantasy stories and games he seems to be condemning. You ought to give him my book when its out, and he can see that even Yahweh Himself is a fire breathing, flood causing, child (and virgin) devouring, Cannanite storm dragon as the archaeological record conclusively proves.

There is more magic and dragons, and fireballs in the Holy Bible than in all the works of Tolkien. In fact it is the most detailed and complete biography of one of the true Creators's "dragon" assistants ever put to paper.
Repoman
QUOTE(eqgumby @ Sep 26 2007, 05:49 PM) *
I still think the folks that ramble and whine about a "murdering God" are just sheep that run to evilbible.com so they can feel trendy and anti-establishment, maybe in an attempt to piss off their parents. I don't feel any real conviction there, just an "emo" kind of anime trash-talk. Sorry.

It's all good. I've never been to any anti- websites. I had the bible read to me when I was a kid. I remember the pictures of the drowning people and the burning cities and the dead first-borns and I knew then I would never worship such a god.

I give people I encounter the benefit of the doubt. Instead of worshipping a god that would do such things, maybe they are just hypocrites.

When you remove the religion from spirituality I have no problem with anyone.

Ritual is fine, but a willingness to "fight" for the "image" of your religion is one of the most dangerous things mankind has ever done to itself.


Repoman
QUOTE(draconic chronicler @ Sep 27 2007, 08:53 AM) *
Or if he ever looked at a medieval bible that illustrates at least two chapters with God riding on the back of a dragon, because it says so in Pslams and II Samual, just like all of the fantasy stories and games he seems to be condemning. You ought to give him my book when its out, and he can see that even Yahweh Himself is a fire breathing, flood causing, child (and virgin) devouring, Cannanite storm dragon as the archaeological record conclusively proves.

There is more magic and dragons, and fireballs in the Holy Bible than in all the works of Tolkien. In fact it is the most detailed and complete biography of one of the true Creators's "dragon" assistants ever put to paper.

These are some of the things they all know but pretend to not know. They simply ignore it grin2.gif

They are so ridiculous that they are cute. Wow - a warm, happy feeling just came over me. It must be all the folks praying for my soul after reading this. Thanks guys!

Snaps and props!

Beckys_Mom
QUOTE(Repoman @ Sep 26 2007, 06:59 PM) *
I was referring to people that claimed to follow a religion but failed to follow that religion's scripture. In my haste I said "follow a god" rather than "follow a religion" and "bible" instead of "holy texts". OK?

No not OK...if you are going to sit on your backside and throw out judgment at anyone that follow God or any God...at least be CLEAR about it...unlike your previous statement about people who 'Follow God' <---dude, when you do that, ANYONE that follows God will automatically think you MUST mean them.... ohmy.gif ...think before you post...ohh sure you come back and correct it now...but throw in some attitude because I pulled you on it..how sweet!! huh.gif

QUOTE
Secondly, if the name fits then you are stuck with it.

No it doesn't fit sweetheart...it's a tad rich a non believer can sit on his rear end and judge others on how they choose to follow God..then come back and say -- Ohh dear I meant to say RELIGION IE a Baptist <---yup pull the other one mate, it plays jingle bells!!..I call it back pedaling hmm.gif

QUOTE
If you claim to be a Southern Baptist but don't believe the bible is true then you are a hypocrite.

This makes sense YES...if you had of written this BEFORE...I wouldn't have bothered to pull you on it....good job I don't follow a religious group eh?

QUOTE
If you willingly follow a god that murdered millions of babies because he didn't like their parent's behavior then you are exactly the type of person that allowed the Nazis to take over Germany - a religious fascist - willing to smile at the most horrific of acts as long as your god said it was cool. Those sorts of people make me sick

AHA now I am beginning to see where you are coming from on this lol....See here is something that might shock you..............But I follow God..the same God in heaven right?? but I dont agree with the bible on how this bible portrays God...I couldn't bring myself to follow such a evil dictator like the one from the bible...all the carnage he has left according to that book is too much...heck Stephen King wouldn't make up a character remotely as rotten as the God from the bible... blink.gif so no thanks...I prefer to Follow God in my own way without a religion or a manual telling me how I should follow God and lead my life....

QUOTE
I'm sorry that you seem to support such people. I cannot. Thirdly, I believe in a creator. Where does that leave me?

Thing is...I DON'T support such people, I am dead against it....I have good morals and I don't see the need to believe thats how God really was....not a mission...and If others want to follow it...fine...I take not much to do with them...I don't agree with this whole - Ah but yea but, no but, yea but.but but but......he is our creator, so therefore he giveth so he taketh <---nuts to that...what God writes a commandment telling you that killing another is wrong...but left out the small print at the bottom that should read - Do as I say, don't do as I do..I am an all loving God..but if you do not follow me..you will burn in a fiery pit, were you can choke and scream in agony for all eternity ....BUT HE LOVES YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! blink.gif all loving right?? uhuh I don't think so

Listen up..I only quoted your post, for one simple reason...you said ANYONE that FOLLOWS God <-- that includes me...so I figured....for if you had of put up religion and gave your example of the baptist...I would have skipped over the entire post.....for i do follow God..I just dont stick a christian label on and follow a book that tells me how to!!...LOL No...I was given a brain to USE IT...so I make up my own mind how I feel better in following God in my own way....a number of christian used to sit and b*tch at me for claiming to follow God...but Not believe in the bible....it's like them saying - Ohh BM you can't follow God UNLESS you pick up a bible and repent <---I say get out of my face and bugger off...bunch of dictators the lot of them

EDIT ..Why do you think a lot of people would frown at a murderous God from the bible?? ....The same reason as to WHY people frown and look down on a dirty good for nothing murderer in real life.....but there are some people that b**** non stop complaining that someone that doesn't agree with the carnage that this God from the bible has done...well they MUST be anti christs of some sort LMAO...I say this...then if thats what you think of people that look down and frown at a murderous God...then they must think its OK to kill the innocent...shame on them!!
eqgumby
QUOTE(Repoman @ Sep 27 2007, 12:18 PM) *
These are some of the things they all know but pretend to not know. They simply ignore it grin2.gif

They are so ridiculous that they are cute. Wow - a warm, happy feeling just came over me. It must be all the folks praying for my soul after reading this. Thanks guys!

Snaps and props!

I just offered a burnt offering of a he-ram and some burnt grain in your name. I'll be splashing some bull blood on the alter later and popping a few beers too. Got ya covered Bro' ! thumbsup.gif
Repoman
QUOTE(eqgumby @ Sep 27 2007, 04:28 PM) *
I just offered a burnt offering of a he-ram and some burnt grain in your name. I'll be splashing some bull blood on the alter later and popping a few beers too. Got ya covered Bro' ! thumbsup.gif

Much appreciated! It's dangerous to be an infidel without some believer homies to cover my backside.



mmmmmmmmmmm, heeeeeeee raaaaaaammmmmmmmmmmm grrgaggrllllllllllllllll.........
Repoman
QUOTE(Beckys_Mom @ Sep 27 2007, 02:49 PM) *
Listen up..I only quoted your post, for one simple reason...you said ANYONE that FOLLOWS God <-- that includes me...so I figured....for if you had of put up religion and gave your example of the baptist...I would have skipped over the entire post.....for i do follow God..I just dont stick a christian label on and follow a book that tells me how to!!...LOL No...I was given a brain to USE IT...so I make up my own mind how I feel better in following God in my own way....a number of christian used to sit and b*tch at me for claiming to follow God...but Not believe in the bible....it's like them saying - Ohh BM you can't follow God UNLESS you pick up a bible and repent <---I say get out of my face and bugger off...bunch of dictators the lot of them

I have explained my error twice previously on this thread and apologized completely and openly to deists.

If you want to keep pulling on me you should feel free.
Eventually I will need a cigarette.
eqgumby
QUOTE(Repoman @ Sep 28 2007, 06:30 AM) *
Much appreciated! It's dangerous to be an infidel without some believer homies to cover my backside.
mmmmmmmmmmm, heeeeeeee raaaaaaammmmmmmmmmmm grrgaggrllllllllllllllll.........

laugh.gif
Actually I was just BBQ'ing some kabobs...if you need a believer, I'm sure you can ask BM or Iams or someone to get your soul right. All I can guarantee from my burnt offerings is a good steak and a full belly! thumbsup.gif
Beckys_Mom
QUOTE(Repoman @ Sep 28 2007, 12:34 PM) *
I have explained my error twice previously on this thread and apologized completely and openly to deists.

If you want to keep pulling on me you should feel free.
Eventually I will need a cigarette.

So it's ok for you to explain your side but not ok for anyone else

Next time you wanna post up stupid assumptions...alllow yourself to think 1st...and at least pay attention
Repoman
QUOTE(Beckys_Mom @ Sep 30 2007, 02:29 PM) *
So it's ok for you to explain your side but not ok for anyone else

Next time you wanna post up stupid assumptions...alllow yourself to think 1st...and at least pay attention

Thank you sir, may I have another!
Beckys_Mom
QUOTE(Repoman @ Oct 1 2007, 02:32 PM) *
Thank you sir, may I have another!

Well miss sunshine...I would offer you another, but it would go way over your little head... happy.gif
Repoman
QUOTE(Beckys_Mom @ Oct 1 2007, 10:34 AM) *
Well miss sunshine...I would offer you another, but it would go way over your little head... happy.gif

Is that you in your avatar? You sort of look like a girl. LOL!
Devol
QUOTE(Beckys_Mom @ Oct 1 2007, 10:34 AM) *
Well miss sunshine...I would offer you another, but it would go way over your little head... happy.gif



QUOTE(Repoman @ Oct 1 2007, 03:08 PM) *
Is that you in your avatar? You sort of look like a girl. LOL!


Alright, you two! No need for personal attacks. It's not as if we've gone way off topic or anything, but I think this thread may be that much closer to being locked for the bickering.

PA, kudos to you for your efforts to educate those around you! Someday we'll all know everything, but until then...

Good luck to you all! Take care!
Beckys_Mom
QUOTE(Repoman @ Oct 1 2007, 08:08 PM) *
Is that you in your avatar? You sort of look like a girl. LOL!

I take it you aren't a fan of the BLADE movies?? lmao...the chick in my avatar is Jessica Biel from - Blade Trinity..and a lot of guys thinks she is a hottie...but you are different..you cant tell if she is a male or female LMAO laugh.gif thanks I needed a laugh
Repoman
QUOTE(Beckys_Mom @ Oct 1 2007, 07:38 PM) *
I take it you aren't a fan of the BLADE movies?? lmao...the chick in my avatar is Jessica Biel from - Blade Trinity..and a lot of guys thinks she is a hottie...but you are different..you cant tell if she is a male or female LMAO laugh.gif thanks I needed a laugh

Ahh, Jessica Biel. I loved that episode of MTV Punk'd where she got punked.
Anyways, she is not a hottie. Her high cheekbones and stuff look too masculine.
Drew Barrymore is a hottie.

Please stay on topic or I will snap my fingers and this thread will be LOCKED.
Devol
QUOTE(Repoman @ Oct 1 2007, 09:43 PM) *
Please stay on topic or I will snap my fingers and this thread will be LOCKED.

Quite condescending, aren't you, Repo? But that's already been proven by nearly every word you've posted. I'll look forward to the day you're banned!
Paranoid Android
Right, I was hoping this whole argument would blow over once the issue raised had been dealt with. It obviously has not. Keep things on topic, please. No more insults or attacks against each other, or this really will be closed and warnings/suspensions issued to the relevant parties.
Repoman
QUOTE(DeVoL @ Oct 2 2007, 05:41 AM) *
Quite condescending, aren't you, Repo? But that's already been proven by nearly every word you've posted. I'll look forward to the day you're banned!

Please stay on topic and avoid the name-calling and anti-christian glee in another's future punishment. It is quite unseemly.

Anyways, back to the topic of Magic.

I don't think that any "play" magic is wrong. This includes, books, video games, cartoons, etc.
But I can see how "real" magic would be frowned upon by the church and declared heretical. By attempting to use real magic, you are trying to circumvent the limits god placed on humans and that would be a direct challenge to god.

Note that I do not follow any religion and am just trying to put myself in the shoes of a religious follower.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.