Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Theresa Neumann
Unexplained Mysteries Discussion Forums > Unexplained Mysteries > Spirituality, Religion and Beliefs
Regency
I have been reading about Theresa Neumann in a book I have. She was a Bavarian peasant girl who was said to suffer Christ's Passion every lent for the last 32 years of her life. She had marks on her back from the scourging, bleeding punctures marked her forehead and her hands, feet and side gushed blood as though they had been torn by nails and a world.

What I found interesting was that they say that apart from communion wafter and wine, no food had been seen to pass her lips for 35 years. Doctors once kept her under surveillance for several weeks, night and day, but in the end said that nothing had passed her lips but the wafer and wine.

She was said to have remind in good health, though photographs of her show her to be a ghost like image. Doctors noted that her excreta, which had diminished since 1926, ceased altogether after 1930 and her intestinal tract simply withered away. She continued to have visions until her death in 1962.

This seems totally impossible to me.

Reg

Edit: Wiki doesn't mention the intestines withering away, but more or less the other stuff seems to tally.

Click to view attachment
Lotus Flower
Perhaps she survived as her "food" was Manna. (the miraculous food which sustained the Israelites in the wilderness. Any Spiritual or Divine nourishment).

It sure is a mystery though, especially as in your posting you quoted that her intestinal tract had withered away and yet she continued to live blink.gif

Some people thought that her stigmata was faked, personally, I consider that someone miraculous was going on especially regarding the extra pieces you quoted Regency. I mean, think about it, she lived for not just a few weeks or months after this intestinal tract bit but for YEARS.

Thanks for the info Regency thumbsup.gif
SunDogDayze
I tried a search on her, just to get a little more info, but the sites I found seem to insinuate that the whole thing was faked. Here is an excerpt from one of them:

QUOTE
During her thirty-five years fast, doctors kept Theresa under strict surveillance and subjected her to long periods of medical scrutiny. They testified that to the best of their knowledge nothing was ingested other than the wafer and wine of the Holy Communion, and that her excreta ceased completely after 1930, her intestinal tract having withered away. By 1951 Theresa's phenomenon had diminished, and in the last five years of her life although she continued to have visions and ecstasies she faded into obscurity, dying of malnutrition in 1962.

There is considerable doubt that all the phenomena reported actually occurred. Theresa's abstinence from food for example was never rigorously controlled to the satisfaction of the Church authorities and the medical men called in to advise on the case. Many of the phenomena resembled closely that which have been observed to occur in other paranormal but non-religious contexts, and the blood observed on the stigmata was never seen to flow from them, but only appeared on the wounds after Theresa had escaped observation beneath the bedclothes. Further, when a sample of the blood was subjected to analysis it proved to be of menstrual origin.


Of course, I don't understand how she would have been able to produce menstrual blood every Friday, especially considering that she was malnourished. When women are malnourished, they can sometimes go for years without a menstrual cycle at all. I don't know what the truth is about her, but I find it hard to believe that someone would bleed openly for 32 years, eat only wafers and a tablespoon of water a day, and live for more than a few weeks.
Lotus Flower
QUOTE (SunDogDayze @ Nov 5 2007, 08:47 PM) *
I tried a search on her, just to get a little more info, but the sites I found seem to insinuate that the whole thing was faked. Here is an excerpt from one of them:



Of course, I don't understand how she would have been able to produce menstrual blood every Friday, especially considering that she was malnourished. When women are malnourished, they can sometimes go for years without a menstrual cycle at all. I don't know what the truth is about her, but I find it hard to believe that someone would bleed openly for 32 years, eat only wafers and a tablespoon of water a day, and live for more than a few weeks.

Yes I agree, a real mystery!

Mind you, that still doesn't explain the bit about the phenomenon diminishing by 1951, I mean that is still many years after it started. Truly baffling!
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.