Being somewhat knowledgeable on the subject, I have decided to compile a compendium on the mothman experience to help those who are unfamiliar with the story/and or concepts contained therein.
In many ways this thread was born out of my frustration spending many hours correcting people in every mothman thread that arises….not so because of ignorance or stupidity on behalf of the original poster…more so because I think in many ways the movie really took people down the wrong path.
The first place to start, would be to put mothman in context of the original research.
The book ‘The Mothman Prophecies’ is a UFO text, written by a renowned Ufologist; John Keel. In his previous work Operation Trojan Horse, he was attempting to use collected data throughout history to find a pattern that could be unite the paranormal in a unified theory; much like Einstein’s quest to find a unified theory to bridge the gap between Gravity and Quantum mechanics. Similarly he noted that in the field of the ‘paranormal’ several camps existed…
UFO enthusiasts focussed on anything that would lead them to an Extra-terrestrial answer, Ghost hunters were taught to believe that black shadows and psychics were sign-posters of a spirit world, and Cryptozoologists were busy trying to find links to seemingly ethereal creatures in terrestrial pursuits.
Patrick Harpur Wrote:
QUOTE
It is often said that visions and apparitions are experienced according to the culture in which they appear. To draw a religious parallel, it is a truism to say no Buddhist has ever had a vision of Christ, and no Christian ever had a vision of Buddha.
To summarise how Keel felt about the different camps I will use an analogy:
A blind man arrives into New York from Bulgaria with his young son, and having heard of the wonder of the New York cityscape he asks his son to describe it to him. “Well father”, the son says “the New York skyline is tall, has lots of windows, and has a large spire on top”.
Of course, the son is describing a single building; of course we know that the description of a single building does not fit over the entire cityscape of New York city.
Keel believed that Ufologists were so busy searching for evidence of Extra-terrestrial spacecraft that a lot of evidence that pointed them in another direction was completely overlooked, similarly with the other two camps. Keels analysis of NICAP was scathing, particularly the mindframe; individuals who thought themselves urban heroes of truth who tore into UFO investigations with very little to guide them apart from their own sense of self satisfaction.
“Aliens are real, and I am going to prove it any way I can”.
Of course if we examine a true to life experiment, a researcher or scientist must remain impartial to their findings and NOT have their mind made up already before they even begin. Evidence, for this very reason can sometimes be tailored to suit the researcher’s pre-conception and is not always an accurate description of the truth.
Back to Mothman.
Come 1966 West Virginia and the Ohio Valley is in the grip of a UFO flap that is drawing many researchers and Ufologists from right around the United States. It wasn’t until November 15 of that year that the first Mothman sighting was made by Mr. and Mrs. Roger Scarberry and Mr. and Mrs. Steve Mallette, who were driving through the local TNT area looking for friends.
From the book:
QUOTE
They all looked into the blackness and saw two bright red circles. They were about two inches in diameter and six inches apart. Roger slammed on his brakes.
"What is it?" Mary Mallette, a strikingly attractive brunette, cried from the back seat.
The lights bobbed away from the building and the startled foursome saw they were attached to some huge animal.
"It was shaped like a man, but bigger," Roger said later. "Maybe six and a half or seven feet tall And it had big wings folded against its back." "But it was those eyes that got us," Linda declared. "It
had two big eyes like automobile reflectors." "They were hypnotic," Roger continued. "For a minute we could only stare at it. I couldn't take my eyes off it."
“It was grayish in color and walked on sturdy manlike legs. It turned slowly and shuffled toward the door of the generator plant which was ajar and hanging off its hinges”. (Mothman Prophecies chapter 6)
"What is it?" Mary Mallette, a strikingly attractive brunette, cried from the back seat.
The lights bobbed away from the building and the startled foursome saw they were attached to some huge animal.
"It was shaped like a man, but bigger," Roger said later. "Maybe six and a half or seven feet tall And it had big wings folded against its back." "But it was those eyes that got us," Linda declared. "It
had two big eyes like automobile reflectors." "They were hypnotic," Roger continued. "For a minute we could only stare at it. I couldn't take my eyes off it."
“It was grayish in color and walked on sturdy manlike legs. It turned slowly and shuffled toward the door of the generator plant which was ajar and hanging off its hinges”. (Mothman Prophecies chapter 6)
The original building can be found here:
http://www.mothmanmuseum.com/MothmanLives/...dedonation.html
Over the next 12 months there would be 100 sightings of the creature, but Keel was far more fascinated by the link between the witnesses and the strange events that soon followed.
Connie Carpenter, an important Mothman Witness was almost abducted by three men dressed in Black who tried to pull her into their car. She was so traumatised by the events she locked herself away for a considerable time. Soon letters written in childish scribble would be left at her front door telling her to ‘Keep Quiet’ or they will ‘Get you girl’.
QUOTE
According to her story, Connie, a shy, sensitive eighteen-year-old, was driving home from church at 10:30 A.M. on Sunday, November 27, 1966, when, as she passed the deserted greens of the Mason County Golf Course outside of New Haven, West Virginia, she suddenly saw a huge gray figure. It was shaped like a man, she said, but was much larger. It was at least seven feet tall and very broad. The thing that attracted her attention was not its size but its eyes. It had, she said, large, round, fiercely glowing red eyes that focused on her with hypnotic effect "It's a wonder I didn't run off the road and have a wreck," she commented later.
As she slowed, her eyes fixed on the apparition, a pair of wings unfolded from its back. They seemed to have a span of about ten feet. It was definitely not an ordinary bird but a man-shaped thing which rose slowly off the ground, straight up like a helicopter, silently. Its wings did not flap in flight. It headed straight toward Connie's car, its horrible eyes fixed to her face, then it swooped low over her head as she shoved the accelerator to the floorboards in utter hysteria.
Over one hundred people would see this bizarre creature that winter.
Connie's conjunctivitis lasted over two weeks, apparently caused by those glowing red eyes. At the tune of my first visit to Point Pleasant in 1966 I did not relate the winged weirdo to flying saucers. Later events not only proved that a relationship existed, but that relationship also is a vital clue to the whole mystery. (Mothman Prophecies Chapter 2)
As she slowed, her eyes fixed on the apparition, a pair of wings unfolded from its back. They seemed to have a span of about ten feet. It was definitely not an ordinary bird but a man-shaped thing which rose slowly off the ground, straight up like a helicopter, silently. Its wings did not flap in flight. It headed straight toward Connie's car, its horrible eyes fixed to her face, then it swooped low over her head as she shoved the accelerator to the floorboards in utter hysteria.
Over one hundred people would see this bizarre creature that winter.
Connie's conjunctivitis lasted over two weeks, apparently caused by those glowing red eyes. At the tune of my first visit to Point Pleasant in 1966 I did not relate the winged weirdo to flying saucers. Later events not only proved that a relationship existed, but that relationship also is a vital clue to the whole mystery. (Mothman Prophecies Chapter 2)
Sometimes mothman appeared to the same individual twice:
Connie Carpenter and Shelia Cain would both see it twice.
Mr & Mrs Scarberry (the original Mothman sighting) were plagued for months afterwards by mysterious circumstances:
QUOTE
Roger and Linda Scarberry were living in a house trailer at the time of their Mothman sighting. In the week that followed they were suddenly plagued by strange sounds around the trailer late at night. Beeps and loud garbled noises like a speeded-up phonograph record. They could not locate the source of the sounds outside or inside the trailer. Worried and frightened, they finally moved out of the trailer and settled in the basement apartment in the home of Linda's parents, Parke and Mabel McDaniel.
The same men who tried to abduct Connie Carpenter were also seen by Mr Scarberry:
QUOTE
One night Roger Scarberry, Steve Mallette, and myself were driving around the TNT area when we came upon a large black Cadillac parked in the shadows. I slammed on the brakes, got out of our car, and walked over to the other vehicle. A well-dressed, distinguished-looking man was sitting behind the wheel holding a microphone in his hand. I tried to engage him in a conversation but he would only grunt. Obviously he wanted to be left alone. I never saw him again.
Many witnesses were also plagued by Phantom Photographers; individuals who loiter around witnesses houses, snap a photograph, and quickly run off into the ether. The Scarberry’s fell victim to such people.
MOTHMAN AND UFOs
Mothman was just one strange aspect in a myriad of unexplained occurrences that plagued the east coast of the United States in 1966 – 1967. Hence, Mothman’s arrival in November ‘66 was far from a sign-post for the strangeness that was going on in Point Pleasant. Mary Hyre (Editor of the local Newspaper across the river in Ohio) was being swamped by UFO reports, some of them daily.
QUOTE
In March 1966, a shapely housewife, whom I will call Mrs. Kelly because she asked that her name be withheld, was waiting in her car for her children near the Point Pleasant school when she saw an unbelievable apparition low in the sky. It looked like a glistening metal disk and was hovering directly above the school playground. A doorlike aperture was open at its rim and there was a man standing outside. He was not standing in the doorway, he was standing outside the object in midair! He wore a silvery skin-tight costume and had very long silvery hair. He was looking down into the school yard intently. She watched him for a long moment until her children bounded up to the car. When she looked again, the man and object were gone.
In fact, West Virginia in general had been for the past few decades beforehand quite active, the Flatwoods Monster and Braxton Monster followed a massive UFO flap in 1952.
Keel in the Mothman Prophecies book, delved into the strange world of the UFO witness.
Witnesses to the Mount Misery UFO flap were being harassed in their homes by mysterious Census takers probing them deeply about the number of children in the family, and particularly dietary concerns.
Edward Christiansen and his family of seven were driving along the Garden State parkway when they observed a Green, white and red object plummet from the sky directly in front of them. Thinking they had just witnessed a plane crash they pulled over to the side of the road and watched awe-struck as a sphere came up above the treeline and passed directly over their heads. For several months afterwards, their house was plagued with the same electronic beeping that troubled the Scarberry’s, mysterious photographers were taking their pictures, and a strange man visited their home to ask the family some questions about their personal lives.
QUOTE
They had just moved into the new house, some distance from the place where they had lived at the time of their November UFO sighting. Neither their address nor phone number was listed in the then-current phone book. They entered their house by the back door. The front door was still heavily bolted and locked, the way they had left it when they had gone to Florida.
At 5:30 P.M. there was a knock on the front door. Mrs. Arline Christiansen was in the kitchen preparing dinner.
"Check and see who that is," she told her seventeen-year-old daughter, Connie. "If it's a salesman, don't answer."
Connie took a peek and reported back, "It's the strangest-looking man I've ever seen."
..
"Does Edward Christiansen live here?" he asked. Arline admitted he did. "I'm from the Missing Heirs Bureau," the man continued. "Mr. Christiansen may have inherited a great deal of money. May I come in?"
..
Arline and Connie were most fascinated by a strange feature on his leg. When he sat down they could see a long thick green wire attached to the inside of his leg. It came up out of his socks and disappeared under his trousers. At one point it seemed to be indented into his leg and was covered by a large brown spot.
..
When Tiny had seated himself, Mrs. Christiansen told him they were about to eat and asked him if he wanted to join them. He replied that he was on a diet but that he would like a glass of water in about ten minutes. He seemed to wheeze, they all noted, like a man with asthma, and he appeared to have difficulty breathing.
..
According to Connie, Tiny's face gradually grew redder and redder as he talked and after a few minutes he turned to her and asked: "May I have that glass of water now?" She fetched the water for him and he took out a large yellow capsule which he gulped down. He returned to normal after taking it.
At 5:30 P.M. there was a knock on the front door. Mrs. Arline Christiansen was in the kitchen preparing dinner.
"Check and see who that is," she told her seventeen-year-old daughter, Connie. "If it's a salesman, don't answer."
Connie took a peek and reported back, "It's the strangest-looking man I've ever seen."
..
"Does Edward Christiansen live here?" he asked. Arline admitted he did. "I'm from the Missing Heirs Bureau," the man continued. "Mr. Christiansen may have inherited a great deal of money. May I come in?"
..
Arline and Connie were most fascinated by a strange feature on his leg. When he sat down they could see a long thick green wire attached to the inside of his leg. It came up out of his socks and disappeared under his trousers. At one point it seemed to be indented into his leg and was covered by a large brown spot.
..
When Tiny had seated himself, Mrs. Christiansen told him they were about to eat and asked him if he wanted to join them. He replied that he was on a diet but that he would like a glass of water in about ten minutes. He seemed to wheeze, they all noted, like a man with asthma, and he appeared to have difficulty breathing.
..
According to Connie, Tiny's face gradually grew redder and redder as he talked and after a few minutes he turned to her and asked: "May I have that glass of water now?" She fetched the water for him and he took out a large yellow capsule which he gulped down. He returned to normal after taking it.
Tiny would make another appearance at a Diner in New Jersey before completely disappearing into the ether.
Keel was quick to draw the distinction between these visitors, and those associated with the Mothman witnesses.
Back in the Ohio Valley, the Kelly family were being plagued nightly by a number of UFO’s that would pass through the Valley at the back of their property.
QUOTE
The light traveled on to the ravine that passed behind North Park Road, then it dipped down and moved low along the bottom of the ravine. Betty Kelly, thirteen, looked out the kitchen window of the Kelly house and screamed.
"Ma ... it's back!"
The glowing thing was appearing nightly behind the Kelly home. It seemed to settle in their backyard at times and the glow faded slightly so they could see a definite object. They even thought they saw a triangular doorway in it and what appeared to be frosted glass windows. Their neighbours had all been watching, too, but had wisely avoided publicity. They didn't want their street to become another Camp Conley Road or TNT area.
"Ma ... it's back!"
The glowing thing was appearing nightly behind the Kelly home. It seemed to settle in their backyard at times and the glow faded slightly so they could see a definite object. They even thought they saw a triangular doorway in it and what appeared to be frosted glass windows. Their neighbours had all been watching, too, but had wisely avoided publicity. They didn't want their street to become another Camp Conley Road or TNT area.
As you can see, Mothman was simply ONE of the strange occurrences taking place in Point Pleasant and the Ohio Valley during the 1966 – 1967 period.
Compared to the thousands of UFO sightings reported to the media and the authorities, Mothman’s 100 sightings paled in comparison.
INDRID COLD
The movie paints Indrid Cold to be a very different individual to the one that befriended Woodrow Derenberger in November 1966. Colds appearance came three weeks before the first mothman sighting, but was very late considering the number of UFO reports in the region over 12 months beforehand.
The movie seems to paint Cold as an ethereal entity that seemingly is the Mothman itself. However the real (supposedly of course) Indrid Cold first identified himself to Woodrow as an extra-terrestrial entity from the planet Lanulos. His opening line has become something of a legend in the Mothman community:
QUOTE
We mean you no harm. I come from a country much less powerful than yours.
Cold’s contact with Woody would escalate over the coming months, until eventually Cold took Derenberger on a grand tour of the Planet Lanulos, that Woody described as a place similar to Earth where the inhabitants walked around naked.
Derenberger would go on to write a book called “Visitors from lanulos”….a book that I have been desperately been trying to get a copy of. I recently saw a first edition copy on sale for over $1600.
Eventually, like all high profile UFO contactees, Derenberger would eventually divorce his wife, move away to escape ridicule, and become completely obsessed with his encounters for the rest of his life.
Keels interpretation of Cold was surreal, and labelled the alien visitor as nothing more than a participant in a cosmic game being played by these ‘non people’. Derenberger fell for it, much the same way ‘Tiny’ confused the Christiansen family, and much like the phantom photographers and MIB agents plagued Connie Carpenter and the Scarberry family for no apparent reason.
These ‘non people’ would go on with their games right up until December 1967 when it all came to a dramatic conclusion:
THE PROPHECY
Many people get confused and label Mothmans appearance as an ‘omen of doom’, however even Keel himself insists that it may very well be coincidence. The ‘prophecy’ didn’t come from the appearance of a red-eyed Cryptid, but from a group of UFO contactees with whom Keel kept in constant contact.
These contactees would supposedly predict the assassination of Robert Kennedy, and on the 26th July 1967 messages from entities who called themselves Apol and Ashtar predicted the end of the world after the Popes assassination.
The prophecies continued right up until several of the contactees passed on to Keel information about a large Electro-magnetic discharge that would affect the Entire eastern United States:
QUOTE
I had a definite date for the big December "EM effect." It was scheduled for December 15. By this time Mr. Apol had assumed a definite personality. He was as real to me as Cold was to Derenberger, although I would never meet him. I studied his psychology, his quick temper, his mischievous sense of humor.
Of course we would come to know that on December 15 1967 the Silver Bridge would collapse in Point Pleasant West Virginia.
Keel notes in the book:
QUOTE
"John," Mary [Hyre] began hesitantly, "do you think this had anything to do with UFOs and the 'Bird'?"
"There's no answer to that, Mary”
"There's no answer to that, Mary”
Mothman sightings continued in Point Pleasant for a few months afterwards and all of the sightings of Mothman on the bridge at the time of the collapse were completely unsubstantiated.
I hope this thread has enlightened some individuals on the subject a lot more. I will post more information as more comes to hand.
Thoughts, Discussions anyone?

