Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Ġgantija - World's Oldest Man Made Structures
Unexplained Mysteries Discussion Forums > Unexplained Mysteries > Ancient Mysteries & Alternative History
Pages: 1, 2
The Sandman
QUOTE
Ġgantija
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


Ggantija templeĠgantija (also Ggantia) IPA: [gænti:ə] is a megalithic temple complex on the Mediterranean island of Gozo (part of Malta), constructed by the Sicani tribe from the Italian island of Sicily, when the people first inhabited Malta.[1] The two temples of Ġgantija on the island of Gozo are notable for their gigantic Neolithic structures, which were erected during the Neolithic Age (c. 3600-2500 BC). At more than 5500 years old, the Ġgantija temples are the world's oldest free-standing structures (Even older than the Pyramids of Egypt and the Stonehenge) and the world's oldest religious structures.[citation needed] The temples were possibly the site of an Earth Mother Goddess Fertility Cult, with numerous figurines and statues found on site believed to be connected with that cult.

In the Maltese language, Ġgantija means "belonging to the giants". According to local Gozitan legend, the temples were built by the giants who resided in Gozo during ancient times. It is said that the temples themselves were used by the giants as watchtowers.


Its quite distressing to learn that these ancient structures which are even more ancient than the Pyramids and the Stonehenge are not taken seriously by the archaeological community in a manner they do with the Pyramids and the stonehenge!!!

linked-image
linked-image

[above pictures are from wikipedia.org]

I feel that lots more stone has been used up in building these huge temples than for the stonehenge!

the following pictures are ©1998-2008 / Malta (Vista) www. maltavista.net
linked-image
linked-image
linked-image

The three images above are from www. maltavista.net - please visit the site to see more photos since i cant link too many images in here.

You folks tell me, why are these oldest strutures ignored so much??
GrayTone
Here's a nice site about the temples there on Malta

It really is a quite impressive place.
Герой Советского Союза
Its not that its been ignored, its just that the site has been fully excavated.
Sag!ttarius
QUOTE
You folks tell me, why are these oldest strutures ignored so much??



I got the same feeling. Somehow suggesting new alternative history theories that don't fit current dogmatic Smithsonian/Darwinian consensus amounts to heresy. Too bad, I just love reading Hancock, Steiger, Cremo, Bauval, West, Dunn, David et all. There's a lot more going on that is hidden/discarded that we are led to believe.
questionmark
Very simple... they are being ignored by the general public because neither Daniken nor Sitchin or any other quack has claimed that it was build by extraterrestrials. Archeologists are all but ignoring that site.

Cradle of Fish
QUOTE (Sag!ttarius @ Jun 13 2008, 07:43 PM) *
I got the same feeling. Somehow suggesting new alternative history theories that don't fit current dogmatic Smithsonian/Darwinian consensus amounts to heresy. Too bad, I just love reading Hancock, Steiger, Cremo, Bauval, West, Dunn, David et all. There's a lot more going on that is hidden/discarded that we are led to believe.


So what you're saying is aliens built it and they dont want us to know about it?

Maybe it's just an ancient stone building built by stacking stones, and the reason we don't hear about it is because it's nowhere near on the scale of the pyramids or stonehenge.
The Sandman
QUOTE (Cradle of Fish @ Jun 14 2008, 07:03 AM) *
So what you're saying is aliens built it and they dont want us to know about it?

Maybe it's just an ancient stone building built by stacking stones, and the reason we don't hear about it is because it's nowhere near on the scale of the pyramids or stonehenge.


But it is older than the Pyraminds and the stonehenge!! That should make it primary!
Eieam Wun
...what is it with ancient man using these megalithic stones throughout the ancient world...most be compensating like buying a big car, LOL.

The whynsos to get her be patient and anything is possible
OldTimeRadio
But how can these be the world's oldest human-built structures when there are ruins in Turkey which are twice as old? I speak, of course, of Gobekli Tepe, which is nearly 12,000 years old (9,500 BC).
questionmark
QUOTE (OldTimeRadio @ Jun 14 2008, 05:47 PM) *
But how can these be the world's oldest human-built structures when there are ruins in Turkey which are twice as old? I speak, of course, of Gobekli Tepe, which is nearly 12,000 years old (9,500 BC).


Which are largely unknown because the afore mentioned quacks have not put it on their list of extraterrestrial monuments.

Qoais
Tarxien Temple (Tar-sheen)

linked-image

A German couple have been researching this site for a number of years. It's believed that more of the complex has fallen into the ocean.
The Sandman
QUOTE
The two temples of Ġgantija on the island of Gozo are notable for their gigantic Neolithic structures, which were erected during the Neolithic Age (c. 3600-2500 BC). At more than 5500 years old, the Ġgantija temples are the world's oldest free-standing structures (Even older than the Pyramids of Egypt and the Stonehenge) and the world's oldest religious structures.[citation needed] The temples were possibly the site of an Earth Mother Goddess Fertility Cult, with numerous figurines and statues found on site believed to be connected with that cult.


QUOTE
The Tarxien Temples (IPA: [ˈtarʃiɛn]) are an archaeological complex in Tarxien, Malta. They date back to approximately 2800 BC.[/b] The site was accepted as a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 1980 along with the other Megalithic temples on the island of Malta.


and thanks to oldtimeradio, i stand corrected

QUOTE
Göbekli Tepe (Turkish for "Hill with a Belly") is a hilltop sanctuary built on the highest point of an elongated mountain ridge about 15km northeast of the town of Şanlıurfa (Urfa) in southeast Turkey. The site, currently undergoing excavation by German and Turkish archaeologists, was erected by hunter-gatherers in the 10th millennium BC (ca 11,500 years ago), before the advent of sedentism. [b]It is currently considered the oldest known shrine or temple complex in the world, and the planet's oldest known example of monumental architecture. Together with the site of Nevalı Çori, it has revolutionised the understanding of the Eurasian Neolithic.
Rosewin
Is there any other links to verify the age of Ggantija? The ones that represent Malta tourism or the govt of Malta that I have seen make me suspicious. Basically any government that can stand to gain tourist dollars might stretch the numbers. National Geographic had nothing on them. According to legend they were built by 'giants'. Nephilim eh?
questionmark
QUOTE (Clovis @ Jun 15 2008, 12:00 AM) *
Is there any other links to verify the age of Ggantija? The ones that represent Malta tourism or the govt of Malta that I have seen make me suspicious. Basically any government that can stand to gain tourist dollars might stretch the numbers. National Geographic had nothing on them. According to legend they were built by 'giants'. Nephilim eh?


http://www.art-and-archaeology.com/malta/ggantija.html

http://www.sacred-destinations.com/malta/g...ija-temples.htm

and if you don't trust any of these you may find:

Encyclopedia of Sacred Places (Paperback)
by Norbert C. Brockman (Author)
Oxford University Press, USA (February 25, 1999)
# ISBN-10: 0195127390
# ISBN-13: 978-0195127393

in your local library.

Rosewin
Aye, I saw those two sites but thank you. The first stated on source claimed it was that old so is that the only source or is there others...not much to find online though I do not think so. The second is clearly a site based on tourism revenue.
questionmark
QUOTE (Clovis @ Jun 15 2008, 12:00 AM) *
Is there any other links to verify the age of Ggantija? The ones that represent Malta tourism or the govt of Malta that I have seen make me suspicious. Basically any government that can stand to gain tourist dollars might stretch the numbers. National Geographic had nothing on them. According to legend they were built by 'giants'. Nephilim eh?


Sure there are, try some university papers:

http://www.sanandrea.edu.mt/Senior/CyberFa...tijaTemple.html
http://www3.niu.edu/anthro/pdf/kolb/kolb05a.pdf
OldTimeRadio
It seems currently in favor to describe the builders of Gobekli Tepe as "hunters-gatherers."

But I'd submit that any culture which could construct such a magnificent complex had long-since passed out of the "hunter-gather" phase.

And "hunter-gatherer" itself is a neat little potted phrase made up decades ago by anthropologists to "explain" a pre-historic period about which we actually know next to nothing.
The Sandman
question - why isnt there much on Gobekli Tepe ?? why is it not in the news? why arent archaeologists coverging on Gobekli Tepe and doing further investigation??

beacuse no psuedo archaeologists cared for it since it didnt provide any mysteries.

I wonder....that society/man kind is more prone to believe psuedo-what-ever-ians than the accredited/experienced/proffessional views.
Magnatude
I have a feeling that it all has to do with dates and theories already being "committed", and this just ends up putting a wrench in a lot of theories about what we assumed about mankind back that far. I feel mankind was much more advanced than the time-line indicates in most archaeological circles. But, thats just me nattering away, not like I'm a professional (maybe a professional natterer)
Eieam Wun
QUOTE (Magnatude @ Jun 15 2008, 01:30 AM) *
I have a feeling that it all has to do with dates and theories already being "committed", and this just ends up putting a wrench in a lot of theories about what we assumed about mankind back that far. I feel mankind was much more advanced than the time-line indicates in most archaeological circles. But, thats just me nattering away, not like I'm a professional (maybe a professional natterer)


I don't know if they were much more advanced, but just as capable of doing the same as most later cultures the only difference I believe is they were not as aggressively pushing for a full blown society, just aspects of it.

the whynsos ...indeed I'm a father on the day of fathers day so uh...yea! grin2.gif
OldTimeRadio
QUOTE (Da Verminator @ Jun 15 2008, 05:53 AM) *
question - why isnt there much on Gobekli Tepe ?? why is it not in the news?


But very nearly everything I know about Gobelki Tepe (admittedly not enough!) has come from the news.
crystal sage
linked-image
http://users.aber.ac.uk/jpg/malta/arch.html
It so would be a beautiful place to visit....


Yes anyone who could build something like this is further along on the evolutionary trail.


http://www.carnaval.com/goddess/malta_temples2.htm

QUOTE
linked-image

It appears that the site was first in use around 3600 BC when some natural cavities were used as a repository for the bones of the dead. As the cavities filled up, newThe Hypogeum on Malta chambers were cut progressively deeper into the rock.

An underground area of more than 500 square meters devoted to worship and burial - the bones of over 7000 people have been found. The system of caves, passages and cubicles cut into the stone is similar to the interiors of megalithic temples.

Hal Saflieni Hypogeum is an enormous subterranean structure excavated with cyclopean rigging to lift huge blocks of coralline limestone around the year


linked-image
crystal sage
laugh.gif cool.gif wink2.gif UFO gossip related to Malta???


yes.gif Too late!!!

http://www.ufoarea.com/aas_malta.html
http://www.ufocasebook.com/malta1947.html

http://www.maltavista.net/en/list/photo/1034.html
linked-image

QUOTE
http://www.conspiracyarchive.com/UFOs/tunnels.html
An opening in the wall opposite the entrance to this cave leads to a passage narrow and torturous, the entrance to the real caves. This passage ends on a pathway which extends along the side of a vast cleft in the earth, a pathway along the edge of a veritable chasm, a pathway which leads ever downward to the long underground tunnels and series of caves which are reputed to allow one to traverse the entire length of the island and even further.

Legend has it that these passageways at one time connected with the underground crypts from which the Catacombs of Rome were created. This may very well be true; for the reader must remember that the Mediterranean Sea was created after neolithic times by earthquakes and the shifting of the earth's crust. Therefore, while the ancient tunnels may have existed, they might have been closed by cataclysms of this type, with the knowledge of them coming down to us only in legends.

The tunnels under the "Hypogeum" have been sealed off ever since a school teacher took 30 students into the caves and disappeared, guide and all. It was stated that the walls caved in on them. Search parties were never able to locate any trace of these people.

It has been asserted that for weeks the wailing and screaming of children was heard underground in different parts of the island, but no one could locate the source of the sound. If the walls caved in, why the cave-in could not be found and excavated to free the children remains a mystery.

How the children could live to scream for weeks later is another involved puzzle. At any rate, the underground entrance to the caves in Malta has been sealed off, and nobody is allowed to investigate the site.


QUOTE
MALTA – Cone Head Race Alien Sapien

http://www.nationalufocenter.com/artman/pu...article_226.php
Italian writer Adriano Forgione has investigated a cone head or dolichocephaly race on the Mediterraen island of Malta. The cone head or elongated skulls found in Maltese temple-tombs are similar to those found in Peru and studied by Dr. Von Tschudi. The"oldest city in the Americas," is "a massive 4,600-year-old urban center called Caral" in Peru (L.A. Times, 27 April 2001). Maltese cone head skulls are dated from 4100 B.C.-2500 B.C., that is several hundred years later.
http://www.biped.info/articles/missingrace.html
http://www.gizapyramid.com/adriano_forgione.htm


QUOTE
Another race
http://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/esp_maltaskulls_1.htm
Even the other skulls we examined presented strange anomalies. Some were more natural and harmonic than the cranium that mostly gained our attention, but they still presented a pronounced natural dolichocephalous and we could assume, without fear of refutation, that it is distinctive of an actual race, different to the native populations of Malta and Gozo. This consideration was confirmed by the Maltese archeologists themselves, Anthony Buonanno and Mark Anthony Mifsud, who said:

"They are another race although C-14 or DNA exams haven't yet been performed. Perhaps these individuals originated from Sicily".
linked-image
We shall discuss this detail further on. Meanwhile, it's worth the while to emphasize that one of these skulls showed unequivocal signs of surgical intervention in the occipital area. The outlines of three small holes, made in the occipital bone called inion, had time to cicatrize, therefore the patient survived the operation although such intervention surely would have undermined his motorial faculties. But there is more. A fair part of the 7000 skeletons dug out of the Hal Saflienti hypogeum and examined by Themistocles Zammit in 1921, present artificially performed deformations.




he origins
The skulls we examined are dated 2500 B.C. (but may be even older) a date in which Malta's megalithic history ends, initiating a period of historical darkness and absence of population that will last about 300 years, until the arrival of the Phoenicians. These will begin to make Malta their Mediterranean outpost. The Phoenicians will also erect temples to the Mother Goddess in Malta, calling her Astarte, the snake-faced Goddess. Again we find the representation of a Goddess who is associated with the snake and healing powers, almost as if the Phoenicians wanted to continue an interrupted tradition. But it's the date of 2500 B.C. that presents a fundamental key of interpretation for understanding who these long-headed individuals were and to use it we must move from Malta to nearby Egypt.

Professor Walter B. Emery (1903-1971), the famous Egyptologist, author of "Archaic Egypt", who excavated at Saqqara in the 30's, indeed discovered the remains of individuals who lived in pre-dynastic epoch. These presented a dolichocephalous skull, larger than that of the local ethnic group, fair hair and a taller, heavier build. Emery declared that this stock wasn't indigenous to Egypt but had performed an important sacerdotal and governmental role in this country. This race kept its distance from the common people, blending only with the aristocratic classes and the scholar associated them with the Shemsu Hor, the "disciples of Horus".
Anukis
I am from Malta, and i have to say that they are quite a site. I always wondered why there weren't as appreciated as other archaeological sites around the world, considering those are some of the oldest man-made structures ever discovered so far.

There is also another site called Hagar Qim.

Source

linked-image

QUOTE
The layout of the building is quite complex, perhaps the most complex of any of the temples, and the design is very sophisticated. Its most dramatic feature was the use of exceptionally tall stone uprights, which would have been highly visible for miles around. As you approach the site, you are immediately impressed by the building’s façade of carefully dressed megalithic blocks. The tallest ones were at the corners and had been notched to accommodate two horizontal courses running between them—in short, looking very similar to the model found at Tarxien. The pillars and lintels that make up the trilithon doorway have been compared to those of the Lion Gate at Mycenae built some two thousand years later. To either side was a low stone bench that runs the whole length of the façade. In front is a block with a V perforation—a feature that is found at some other sites and is generally thought to be for tethering animals.


linked-image

QUOTE
It would appear that the original plan was for a ‘standard’ four or five-apse temple (Spaces 1-6) but instead of a terminal apse or niche there is another doorway at the rear of the building. It would appear that at some point the decision was taken to add more rooms (10-13) to the south and the external wall was substantially rebuilt to accommodate them. As was the case at other temples, such as Tarxien, one of the apses (6) was remodelled to provide access.



linked-image

QUOTE
The main doorway led to a small court (1) with apses on either side. However, each of these apses are screened off by thin megalithic slabs. Access is through carved porthole in the central stone. To the left was an elaborately carved pedestal altar with reliefs of potted plants on all four sides and a slab with pitted and spiral decoration. Five statues were found here, including the so-called ‘Venus of Hagar Qim,’ in the 1830’s along with another four in the adjacent Apse 2. Apart from the figures, little was found in either of the rather plainly finished outer apses.


linked-image

QUOTE
Further along, Apse 5 is characterized by fairly uniform megalithic architecture with a line of orthostats of uniform height supporting a number of courses of corbeled masonry. Inside the room is a curved setting of smaller upright slabs set just inside the wall. David Trump offers the opinion that it was some sort of animal pen but this cannot be proven. In the wall is small aperture known as an ‘oracle hole’ that connects the room to a small shrine (16) on the exterior of the building. In this case, however, the hole is positioned so that the light of the rising sun shines into the apse on the day of the summer solstice.


linked-image

linked-image

The goddess that they used to worship was the goddess of fertility, in Maltese ''Il- mara il- hoxna'', which literally means the fat lady. Probably thats why they depicted her as fat, which meant abundance and fertility.

linked-image
crystal sage
linked-image

How beautiful is this?


QUOTE
Down the centuries, the Maltese have developed a clever system of underground tunnels, called galleries, to extract the water for human consumption.

Salt rise

About 97m (320ft) beneath the surface of the island lie the Ta' Kandja galleries. Reached by a lift, the tunnels stretch out for several kilometres like the spokes of a wheel, all half-filled with water that is pumped up to the surface and then to homes and farms around the island.

The water in the tunnels is fresh. But just 10m below, it is salty. And thanks to climate change the brackish water is rising.

linked-image
crystal sage
...On the 'ruts'

QUOTE
http://www.sott.net/signs/forum/viewtopic.php?id=2299
Officials dont even deny that there is maze of tunnels streching all over this tiny island.
There is even a legend (I still regard it as urban myth but I wouldnt be surprised at all if this was true) that there is one tunnel which links Malta with Sicily.
British Colonial forces seem to have explored this maze of tunnels the best but as far as explanation for the public goes only their existance is acknowledged. yet we know very little of its origin and possible purpose.
I have been living on this beautiful island for almost 10 years now and one of the first things I noticed ( consciously I have became aware of it only after some time) is extraordinary energy this rocky Island vibrates with.

There is evidence of ancient civilizations all over the place and few megalithic temples that still stand are still very impressive.
Also there are so called "cart ruts" which could be everything but cart ruts, some of them continuing on the sea bed.
Again there is no any data on culture that has produced these material objects and we can just speculate their real purpose. ( Cassiopeian explanation for Cart Ruts is quite close to what I have always guessed)

Talking back about the maze of tunnels it is very strange that one of the first thing that British government did was to seal the most of these tunnels.
End then there is an incident that took place shortly before WWII. Again I thought this was another urban myth until I found out there was even National Geographic ( issue 1940 if I am not mistaken) coverage of this story. also recently I talked to my friends grandparents who are native islanders and who still remeber the whole story:

Hypogeum is underground temple situated centraly in the island , official explanation is that this is a neolitic human sacrifice site as multitude of human bones was found here. The place is really astonishing with spiral shaped underground dome and extrourdinary accoustic properties. To me it looks as if some sound magic was preformed here many years ago.
Anyways, this place is connected to above mentione maze of tunnels and after the incident British Governor ordered 99 percent of coridors at this site to be sealed with concrete blocks. The place is open to the public but admission is controled and restricted to small groups. The level of supervision imposed on the visits to this place is something I have never seen at any archeological site.
QUOTE
"The enigmatic cart ruts are too obvious in the Maltese rocky landscape to be ignored in any work, however concise, on Maltese archeology even though they are still not easy to locate in the chronological sequence. according to the traditional view, they should be placed in prehistory, more precisely in the Bronze Age, the main argument being that some specimens are cut by "Punic" tombs and, therefore, should be prior to that period. The validity of this argument is, in my view, highly questionable particularly since for Temi Zammit, its originator, 'Punic' could mean anything from the 7th century BC to the 3rd century AD, especially as far as tombs are concerned.

"In my search and study of ancient quarries over the last fifteen years, I found cart ruts very frequently, almost invariably, associated with them. The best example is, perhaps, the Buskett group which lies next to the largest and most important of Malta's ancient quarries. For this reason I cannot refrain from believing that they were intended for the transportation of construction blocks from the quarry face to the road in ancient (i.e., not prehistoric) times.

"This view is supported by a good number of parallels abroad (for instance in Sicily, southern France and Greece) as well as by their concentration in several areas around Melite which must have required a constant supply of ashlar masonry for its buildings. "


"More emigrants from Sicily came to the island around 3200 BC. An astonishing number of megalithic temples were constructed between BC. The still extant temples, some thirty in number, exhibit a highly developed plan and superstructure

...This population possibly followed warlike immigrants from western Greece...

The strange 'cart-ruts' belong to the same period."

QUOTE
http://www.sott.net/signs/forum/viewtopic.php?id=2299


Now, the problem with this cart rut theory is the following: When you look at these furrows impressed in the ground, most of them parallel as they should be, the natural thing is to think of them as ruts. But, apparently, close examination - according to Von Danniken - shows that they CANNOT have been ruts in the ordinary sense of the word. The reason is that the tracks of the two parallel furrows are not only DIFFERENT FROM RUT TO RUT! but also vary in the course of a single stretch!

They run through valleys, over hills, and sometimes exist in several "pairs" side by side which then unite into single two track stretches, followed by sudden curves. They also run off straight into the Mediterranean. Others end abruptly at cliff edges.

They are from 65 to 123 cm wide. The furrows themselves are frequently over 70 cm DEEP! At one place, on rut runs in a curve over a hill and cuts 72 cm into the limestone ground. If a cart ever ran in these ruts, it could not have taken a curve because of the great depth of the ruts! Either the axle would have vanished in the deep imprint or the axle must have been at least 72 cm high which would have given the wheel a diameter of 1.5 cm. But that presents the problem that such a large wheel could NOT have taken such a tight curve! It would get stuck or break.





As noted, in many places, the ruts run straight into the waters of the Mediterranean. It was assumed until recently that the ruts would end underwater a few meters from the coast, which would suggest that they had originated when the sea level of the Mediterranean was lower. However, divers have discovered that the ruts continue in the stone to great depths below sea level.



Cart-Ruts : non-Maltese examples
http://www.geocities.com/athens/agora/5685/forcar.html

Cart Ruts
http://www.legendarytimes.com/index.php?me...d=10&cat=18

linked-image


linked-image


http://www.travelexplorations.com/the-cart...ideo-clip..html



http://video.google.com.au/videosearch?q=c...a=N&tab=wv#
Siara

I don't think this qualifies as the world's oldest free-standing structure. Not that it isn't absolutely fascinating and worthy of more study. But what about, for example, Göbekli Tepe in Turkey?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%B6bekli_Tepe

I think sometimes ancient Grecian settlements get neglected because we are already aware of the massive influence that the Greek/Anatolian cultures had on civilization.

I don't think that there's a cover up in the archaeological community about the influence of space aliens on ancient civilizations. What would the motive be for covering things up?
OldTimeRadio

Only two or three years back there were press reports of a city and temple discovered in the Western Sahara that were an estimated 15,000 years old (13,000 BC). Those reports vanished after a couple of days. No denials, just no nothing.
The Puzzler
QUOTE (OldTimeRadio @ Jun 16 2008, 09:39 AM) *
Only two or three years back there were press reports of a city and temple discovered in the Western Sahara that were an estimated 15,000 years old (13,000 BC). Those reports vanished after a couple of days. No denials, just no nothing.

WHERE? Where? where is this city and temple you speak of???

Good one Verm!! This is such a fascinating place, great topic, I was thinking of starting one ,yself but had too much other stuff going but all my other research led me to here. Malta, amzing structures, the top pic that Crystal Sage linked is my favourite, the inside of the Hypogeum at Hal Saflieni. The bones of more than 6000 people were found here, dating to between 3500 and 3000BC.
I only 'discovered' it a few weeks ago in a book from the library called Atlas of Mysterious Places. Why, indeed don't we hear much about it, I thought I was pretty knowlegable about this sort of thing and up pops Malta and it's mysterious Earth Mother Goddess cult.
Crystal Sage also showed another picture of the oracle sleeping - this was a way of telling the future through dreams and making predictions and readings. The great thing is this is also the practice done in Cumae, Southern Italy which the Etruscans practised and they became one of the most religious cultures ever. Chalcas the seer, who read livers but is said to foretell the fall of Troy in the Trojan War came from, it all links up. The Etruscans had Apollo running this temple and then of course, we see Apollo also at the Greek Oracle at Delphi, who funny enough foretells the future in the same states.

As for the cart tracks, they are just an incredible part of an already amazing past.
Harte
Problem is, these are not at all the "Oldest Man Made Structures."

Note:
QUOTE
Construction of the Jericho site apparently began before the invention of agriculture, with the construction of stone structures beginning earlier than 9000 BCE, which is known as the Natufian culture. There is speculation these were of a spiritual nature, rather than dwellings or fortifications. However archaeologists claim that Jericho is the "oldest city in the world," though there is now competition from the Urfa Culture in southern Turkey. Neverheless, such monumental construction reflects social organization and central authority as well as agricultural surpluses. though there are doubts that the fortification completely date to the 8000 BCE. The wall was built of large Cyclopean stones which supported a mudbrick wall above it. Discovered and excavated by Kathleen Kenyon in her Trench I, the Neolithic tower was built and destroyed in Pre-Pottery Neolithic A, which Kenyon dated to 8000-7000 BCE. The 8m diameter tower stands 8m tall and was connected on the inside of a 4m thick wall.


Source

Also
QUOTE
Definition: Catal Hoyuk is an Early Neolithic site in Turkey (6300-5500 BC), and so far the oldest civilization on earth. Çatalhöyük, as it is spelled in Turkish, represents a village of 300 mud brick and plaster residences, based on a farming economy--in fact, the first farming community we've found to date. Its most striking and famous features are the shrines dedicated to what has been called the "Mother Goddess."


Source

I should add that, last I read, many megalithic structures around Malta could not be dated due to the absence of any contextual materials. So it is possible that the Maltese megalithic structures could be much older (some of them.)

Harte
crystal sage
QUOTE (Harte @ Jun , 02:27 AM)
Problem is, these are not at all the "Oldest Man Made Structures."

Note:


Source

Also


Source

I should add that, last I read, many megalithic structures around Malta could not be dated due to the absence of any contextual materials. So it is possible that the Maltese megalithic structures could be much older (some of them.)

Harte

http://www.d.umn.edu/cla/faculty/troufs/an...cdentistry.html
or evidence of 9000 year old dental surgery

linked-image




http://www.pureinsight.org/pi/index.php?news=1899
A 100,000-year-old Metal Vase
linked-image

The metal was composed of an alloy of zinc and a considerable portion of silver. On the sides were six flower bouquets inlaid with pure silver, and around the lower part was a vine or wreath also inlaid with silver.

cool.gif There definately had to be some nice home to place this piece of art 100,000 years ago.. and some set up to make this item...Zinc requiring some 1000 c 's of heat...
cormac mac airt
Hi crystal sage,

I am new here, but wanted to point out a few things. The first is that the picture you posted of teeth is kind of misleading, as regards the 9000 year old dentistry reference. The caption underneath the original suggests Classical Mayan period which is during the first millenium AD. I realize the original site mentions the 9000 year old time frame further down the page, it's just not in relation to your picture.

Also, as regards the 100,000 year old Metal Vase. What dating technique was used to determine that? The Carbon 14 dating method didn't come along until nearly 100 years after it was found.

cormac
Qoais
The bit about the metal vase notwithstanding, how can science contradict itself all the time, and still expect people to believe all of orthodox science?

From Wikipedia:
QUOTE
Classically, the Iron Age is taken to begin in the 12th century BC in the ancient Near East, ancient Persia, ancient India (with the post-Rigvedic Vedic civilization), and ancient Greece (with the Greek Dark Ages). In other regions of Europe, it started much later. The Iron Age began in the 8th century BC in Central Europe and the 6th century BC in Northern Europe. Iron use, in smelting and forging for tools, appears in West Africa by 1200 BC, making it one of the first places for the birth of the Iron Age.[1][2][3]

The Iron Age is divided into two subsections, Iron I and Iron II. Iron I (1200-1000) illustrates both continuity and discontinuity with the previous Late Bronze Age. There is no definitive cultural break between the thirteenth and twelfth century throughout the entire region, although certain new features in the hill country, Transjordan and coastal region may suggest the appearance of the Aramaean and Sea People groups. There is evidence, however, that shows strong continuity with Bronze Age culture, although as one moves later into Iron I the culture begins to diverge more significantly from that of the late second millennium.

The Iron Age is usually said to end in the Mediterranean with the onset of historical tradition during Hellenism and the Roman Empire, in India with the onset of Buddhism and Jainism, in China with the onset of Confucianism, and in Northern Europe with the early Middle Ages.


So if an iron pot is found in 300 million year old coal, who is correct? The people who gave us the dates of the ages ie: bronze age, iron age etc., or the dudes who are experts in determining the age of the coal?

Rosewin
There is also the Venus of Dolni Vestonice and other figurines all found in the same vicinity of each other which are considered the oldest figurines found in the world. They date from 29,000-25,000 BCE. Most likely they will find things much older. I am most curious, even though it is a tragedy, but on what is under all the Arctic and Antarctic ice if anything.

QUOTE (Qoais @ Jun 18 2008, 02:14 AM) *
The bit about the metal vase notwithstanding, how can science contradict itself all the time, and still expect people to believe all of orthodox science?

From Wikipedia:


So if an iron pot is found in 300 million year old coal, who is correct? The people who gave us the dates of the ages ie: bronze age, iron age etc., or the dudes who are experts in determining the age of the coal?


There is only consensus and minority views. It depends on what you choose to believe if any. We might never know who is correct. Some even fault carbon dating methods as being accurate. I am somewhat of a skeptic there is just no way we can positively know from what year something really is IMHO.
cormac mac airt
QUOTE
So if an iron pot is found in 300 million year old coal, who is correct? The people who gave us the dates of the ages ie: bronze age, iron age etc., or the dudes who are experts in determining the age of the coal?


Putting aside the question of how anyone determined the coal was 300 million years old in the 19th/early 20th century, a few points should be made.

1. Iron rusts.

2. It takes a tremendous amount of pressure to turn prehistoric plant vegetation into coal.

3. It takes a tremendous amount of time as well.

4. It would require suspending disbelief to think that any object made of iron would not only NOT rust, but would remain perfectly intact for 300 million years.

In the 19th and early 20th century, there weren't any real experts on the AGE of coal. Finding it was easier to determine.

cormac
Qoais
I'm not a metal expert for sure, but if any metal is kept dry and air tight, I don't think it rusts. But would the pot withstand the pressure? And it must have been wet at one time if it was within rotting plant vegetation so it WOULD rust.

But back to the question as to what our sciences are still teaching these days, I find these contradictions in every field I've looked into. So if there are contradictory theories, how is one to know which is correct? I've been jumped on in this forum about this, but it just points up my beef, that something has to be done to verify the truth in these fields, and I'm glad to see there are a lot of modern scientists daring to challenge the previous concepts in their fields of expertise.
cormac mac airt
Keep in mind Qoais that coal is compressed vegetation. Not exactly dry and air tight, originally. Also, the site said that the pot allegedly left a mold of itself in the coal, meaning that everything was compressed including the vegetation inside the pot. Yet the pot was intact. NOT POSSIBLE.

Personal note: Six people in the last 4 generations of my family were miners.

Science is to a large extent self adjusting. When a new discovery or theory comes around that better explains the unknown, then the old gets thrown out. Yes, there are some who will want to stick to the outdated thoughts, but those are not the majority. Science, just like other things, is not perfect.

It should also be said that those who wish to ignore all of science in favor of what they want to be true do themselves and everyone else a great diservice. Not saying that is you, but I have run into my share of such people.

cormac
1.618
Regarding the sites in Malta, Graham Hancock did write quite extensively about them in one of his books. I think it was underworld.
He seemed to think that a lot of Malta's history was kept out of the public eye because it does not tally with established archaeological theory.
crystal sage
QUOTE (cormac mac airt @ Jun , 04:42 PM)
Hi crystal sage,

I am new here, but wanted to point out a few things. The first is that the picture you posted of teeth is kind of misleading, as regards the 9000 year old dentistry reference. The caption underneath the original suggests Classical Mayan period which is during the first millenium AD. I realize the original site mentions the 9000 year old time frame further down the page, it's just not in relation to your picture.

Also, as regards the 100,000 year old Metal Vase. What dating technique was used to determine that? The Carbon 14 dating method didn't come along until nearly 100 years after it was found.

cormac
There has been a bit written about it..


http://www.wired.com/science/discoveries/news/2006/04/70599

QUOTE
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/20...eeth_drill.html
Human teeth excavated from an archaeological site in Pakistan show that dentistry was thriving as recently as 9,000 years ago.



linked-image
Luca Bondioli / Pigorini Museum via AP
This image, released by Nature, shows a drilled molar crown from a Neolithic graveyard in Pakistan. A hole about a tenth of an inch (2.6 millimeters) wide was drilled in the center of the crown. The hole shows smoothing, indicating it was drilled well before the death of the individual.
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/12168308/

cool.gif linked-image
BELL FOUND INSIDE OF COAL
http://www.wvancientartifacts.com/thepangaeawvmystery.html
artifacts found in coal...
QUOTE
Iron Pot Found in Coal in 1912
linked-image
Oklahoma, mines is said to contain coal that formed about 312 million years ago. This would predate the dinosaurs by about 87 million years (according to the widely accepted evolutionary theory). Most people are not aware that many human artifacts have reportedly been found in coal. One such find occurred in 1912 at the Municipal Electric Plant in Thomas, Oklahoma. Frank Kennard was breaking a piece of coal to throw it into the furnace. As he broke it this iron pot fell from the center of the coal.
http://creationtruthministries.org/answers.html


Hammer Found in Rock in 1936
linked-image

Impossible Stuff Found In Coal And Rock
http://perdurabo10.tripod.com/warehouseb/id30.html

http://www.virtuescience.com/salzburg-cube.html
linked-image
http://www.book-of-thoth.com/thebook/index.php/Wolfsegg_Iron

OldTimeRadio
QUOTE (weareallsuckers @ Jun 17 2008, 04:21 PM) *
WHERE? Where? where is this city and temple you speak of???


"Western Sahara" is as close as the news articles came.
Герой Советского Союза
Report from Reuters-

http://www.reuters.com/newsArticle.jhtml?t...storyID=6021742

RABAT (Reuters) - The remains of a prehistoric town believed to date back 15,000 years and belong to an ancient Berber civilization have been
discovered in Western Sahara, Moroccan state media said on Thursday.
A team of Moroccan scientists stumbled across the sand-covered ruins of the town Arghilas deep in the desert of the Morocco-administered territory.
The remains of a place of worship, houses and a necropolis, as well as columns and rock engravings depicting animals, were found at the site near the town of Aousserd in northeastern Western Sahara.
The isolated area is known to be rich in prehistoric rock engravings but experts said the discovery could be significant if proven that the ruins were of Berber origin as this civilization is believed to date back only some 9,000 years.
"It appears that scientists have come up with the 15,000-years estimate judging by the style of the engravings and the theme of the drawings," Mustapha Ouachi, a Rabat-based Berber historian, told Reuters.
Berbers are the original inhabitants of North Africa before Arabs came to spread Islam in the seventh century.
The population of Western Sahara, seized by Morocco in 1975 when former colonial power Spain pulled out, are mostly of Berber and Arab descent.


i managed to find this news report, although it is no longer available on the reuters website.
crystal sage
QUOTE (Геро
@ Jun , 01:04 AM)
Report from Reuters-

http://www.reuters.com/newsArticle.jhtml?t...storyID=

RABAT (Reuters) - The remains of a prehistoric town believed to date back 15,000 years and belong to an ancient Berber civilization have been
discovered in Western Sahara, Moroccan state media said on Thursday.
A team of Moroccan scientists stumbled across the sand-covered ruins of the town Arghilas deep in the desert of the Morocco-administered territory.
The remains of a place of worship, houses and a necropolis, as well as columns and rock engravings depicting animals, were found at the site near the town of Aousserd in northeastern Western Sahara.
The isolated area is known to be rich in prehistoric rock engravings but experts said the discovery could be significant if proven that the ruins were of Berber origin as this civilization is believed to date back only some 9,000 years.
"It appears that scientists have come up with the 15,000-years estimate judging by the style of the engravings and the theme of the drawings," Mustapha Ouachi, a Rabat-based Berber historian, told Reuters.
Berbers are the original inhabitants of North Africa before Arabs came to spread Islam in the seventh century.
The population of Western Sahara, seized by Morocco in 1975 when former colonial power Spain pulled out, are mostly of Berber and Arab descent.


i managed to find this news report, although it is no longer available on the reuters website.



yes I remember... http://www.unexplained-mysteries.com/forum...showtopic=20595


also a mention of them....
QUOTE
http://www.unexplained-mysteries.com/forum...howtopic=118101

the great Garamantian Empire. This civilization held power in the Sahara for over 1000 years. Recent archaeological work has revealed that the desert civilization known to the Romans as the Garamantes constructed almost a thousand miles of underground tunnels and shafts in order to mine long-buried fossil water. These remarkable people are the ancestors of the present-day Tuareg, the famed "Blue Men of the desert "- because their robes are frequently dyed indigo blue.

http://www.the153club.org/herodo.html

http://www.encyclopedia.com/doc/1G1-166944397.html
The Garamantes masters of the Sahara: the Garamantes of Libya have been dismissed by everyone from the Romans to 20th-century scholars as irrelevant desert pastoralists and nomads. But now, new research has revealed that they had a sophisticated civilisation and represented one of the most powerful kingdoms in North Africa.(LIBYAN ARCHAEOLOGY)


http://www.geocities.com/Tokyo/Bay/7051/anwrite.htm
The Proto-Saharans or Ku****es
EgyptSearch Forums: The Nubian Kametian Sumerian Dravidian World View
Olmecs and Dravidians Ku****es, since the ancestors of ..... As a result the ancient Proto-Saharans share the same name for boat:. Dravidian (Tamil) Kalan ...
www.egyptsearch.com/forums/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic;f=8;t=005738 - 218k - Cached - Similar pages
Journal of Black Studies
proto-Saharans migrated. first into Nubia and then into. Kemet. The Proto-Saharan. origin. of the Kemites. explains. the fact that the. Ku****es ...
jbs.sagepub.com/cgi/reprint/25/2/170.pdf - Similar pages
The Black Greeks — (by Prof. Clyde Winters) | Rasta Livewire
The Libyans were Proto-Saharans, as were the original Thracians. Some Thracians were descendants of the Ku****e and Egyptian troops established at Trace, ...
www.africaresource.com/.../sesostris-the-great-the-egyptian-hercules/the-black-greeks-by-prof-clyde-winters/ - 40k - Cached - Similar pages
AFRICAN BY NATURE® - GLOSSARY OF TERMS
... Kemites explain the fact that the Ku****es (Cu****e) were known for maintaining the most ..... U; Unite: 1. To bring together so as to form a whole. 2. ...
africanbynature.com/glossary.html - 146k - Cached - Similar pages
[PDF]
LETIN D'INFORMATIONS
File Format: PDF/Adobe Acrobat - View as HTML
University. RARIES. J STUDIES ...... Tokharians who lived in Central Asia and the Ku****es of ... Amun, a common god of the ProtoSaharans suggest that ...
www.meroiticnewsletter.org/MeroNews23.pdf - Similar pages
crystal sage
http://africascience.blogspot.com/2007/07/...ntified-is.html
Egypt's Oldest Known Art Identified, Is 15,000 Years Old
linked-image
questionmark
QUOTE (mr nobody @ Jun 18 2008, 01:33 PM) *
Regarding the sites in Malta, Graham Hancock did write quite extensively about them in one of his books. I think it was underworld.
He seemed to think that a lot of Malta's history was kept out of the public eye because it does not tally with established archaeological theory.


All the contrary...it tallies quite well.

Harte
What a load of happy crappy.

There has never, ever, been any "artifact" found "embedded in coal." There have only been artifacts presented to the public and claimed to have been found embedded in coal.

Funny how it never strikes some people as odd that none of these "coal-embedded" "proofs" are ever shown even partially embedded in coal.

Sites linked to here with this ridiculous "evidence" have in common one thing - they all wish to dismiss archaeology as either controlled by conspiracy or completely and overwhelmingly incorrect in every inter-related dating ever determined by science.

Most such sites are doing one or the other (or both) in order to discredit science itself in a last-ditch attempt to promote "creationism" (or it's evil twin "intelligent" design.)

Most of the claims made at the sites C.S. (and others) link to here have been completely debunked in the past, right here at Unexplained Mysteries, yet we still have to look at this so-called "evidence?"

I note the following at one of the linked sites:

QUOTE
In addition, American archaeologists discovered prehistoric copper mines at Isle Royale in northern Michigan. Even the Indian natives whose ancestors had lived in the region for centuries didn't know the existence of the mines. The mine sites present evidence that prehistoric mining activities produced several thousand tons of copper, but archeologists did not find any trace of long-term habitation near the mines.

That is complete rubbish. HERE is a paper written by a State Archaeologist that worked in that area of Michigan for decades, along with a quote from the paper:
QUOTE
Now we turn to the second major theme in the copper culture myth, that of the dogma of the missing copper. Where did all the copper go? This theme is formulated on a calculus of mythic arithmetic, a prehistoric numbers game! The mythic calculations involve the numbers and depths of copper extraction pits, the numbers and weights of stone hammers, the percentage volume of copper per mining pit, the numbers of miners, and the years of mining duration. Ultimately, the mix of these numbers yields the alleged total amount of extracted prehistoric copper, that being in the range of 1 to 1.5 billion pounds. It's difficult to attribute this branch of mathematics to any one individual, but if there's credit to be given, it should be given first to Drier and Du Temple (Drier and Du Temple 1961) and then to a Chicago-area writer named Henrietta Mertz, who lays out her numerology proposals in a book entitled Atlantis: Dwelling Place of the Gods (Mertz 1967). In contrast, I propose that none of these numbers, save those related to the weight of the hammers, are actually knowable in an empirical sense. We'll start then on our firmest ground, the weights of the hammers.

The link posted above can be found at Doug's Archaeology Site. I already told you all, several times, to go read the material there. The fact that CS has not done so says as much about her as it does about the paucity of her so-called "evidence."

It is known that American natives used copper. It is also known that some of this copper came from the site mentioned in Michigan. Maybe most of you are unaware that there remains at that site pure copper available at the surface.

Duh.

Also there was this:
QUOTE
The strangest discovery has to be the Lion coal mine in Utah. In 1953, miners unexpectedly discovered a tunnel in the mine that had never recorded. The coal in that tunnel was oxidized and had lost its commercial value — proof that previous mining had been done in this area. In August 1953, two scholars from the Department of Engineering and the Department of Ancient Anthropology at the University of Utah investigated the mine, declaring that the local Indians had never used coal. Both the Isle Royale copper mine and the Lion coal mine present evidence that prehistoric miners developed technology to extract and transport coal to distant places


Boy, I'd like to see this "ancient coal mine." I'd also like to see the "ancient copper mines."
Wouldn't you?

Too bad, then, because the editors at that site also say:

QUOTE
[PI editors have not been able to find independent evidence confirming the existence of these two mines.].


IOW, these mines don't even exist!

Please.

Harte
cormac mac airt
Hello Harte,

Long time, no see. Got to hand it to you, you definitely know how to come out swinging. laugh.gif

I tend to agree with you, but what kills me is this. Why do people always seem to reference websites, etc., that make claims of objects "found" in West Virginia. Mostly in the 1800's/early 1900's. Does no one realize how scarcely populated West Virginia was back then. Especially the western and southern parts of the state. Also, there was no real dating method to coal back then, other than the deeper it was found the older it was assumed to be.

Also, like you said, showing something was found in coal and claiming it was found in coal are two entirely different things.

Sorry, but the claims dealing with West Virginia are a pet peeve of mine. As I stated before, many of my family are miners. Guess where. Southern West Virginia. My own grandfather and great uncle used to tell stories of how gullible people where when someone told them they "found" something out of place in a coal mine. It used to be a running joke amongst the miners back home.

cormac
Harte
QUOTE (cormac mac airt @ Jun 18 2008, 01:45 PM) *
Hello Harte,

Long time, no see. Got to hand it to you, you definitely know how to come out swinging. laugh.gif

I tend to agree with you, but what kills me is this. Why do people always seem to reference websites, etc., that make claims of objects "found" in West Virginia. Mostly in the 1800's/early 1900's. Does no one realize how scarcely populated West Virginia was back then. Especially the western and southern parts of the state. Also, there was no real dating method to coal back then, other than the deeper it was found the older it was assumed to be.

Also, like you said, showing something was found in coal and claiming it was found in coal are two entirely different things.

Sorry, but the claims dealing with West Virginia are a pet peeve of mine. As I stated before, many of my family are miners. Guess where. Southern West Virginia. My own grandfather and great uncle used to tell stories of how gullible people where when someone told them they "found" something out of place in a coal mine. It used to be a running joke amongst the miners back home.

cormac


Mac,

Same old arguments, aren't they?

I'll say that at least here at U-M people (for the most part) tend to have a somewhat longer memory of what's been shown to pure hogwash than is exhibited over at ATS.

Believe me, nobody is more surprised than I that the above would be true. Two years ago, if you had told me that such would be the case, I would have never believed it.

It's astonishing how reason has collapsed at ATS and how far this site has come over the same period.

Anyway, welcome to Unexplained Mysteries and I'm glad to have you here!

Harte
crystal sage
QUOTE
What a load of happy crappy.

There has never, ever, been any \"artifact\" found \"embedded in coal.\" There have only been artifacts presented to the public and claimed to have been found embedded in coal.

Funny how it never strikes some people as odd that none of these \"coal-embedded\" \"proofs\" are ever shown even partially embedded in coal.

Sites linked to here with this ridiculous \"evidence\" have in common one thing - they all wish to dismiss archaeology as either controlled by conspiracy or completely and overwhelmingly incorrect in every inter-related dating ever determined by science.

Most such sites are doing one or the other (or both) in order to discredit science itself in a last-ditch attempt to promote \"creationism\" (or it\'s evil twin \"intelligent\" design.)

Most of the claims made at the sites C.S. (and others) link to here have been completely debunked in the past, right here at Unexplained Mysteries, yet we still have to look at this so-called \"evidence?\"

I note the following at one of the linked sites:


That is complete rubbish. HERE is a paper written by a State Archaeologist that worked in that area of Michigan for decades, along with a quote from the paper:

The link posted above can be found at Doug\'s Archaeology Site. I already told you all, several times, to go read the material there. The fact that CS has not done so says as much about her as it does about the paucity of her so-called \"evidence.\"

It is known that American natives used copper. It is also known that some of this copper came from the site mentioned in Michigan. Maybe most of you are unaware that there remains at that site pure copper available at the surface.

Duh.

Also there was this:


Boy, I\'d like to see this \"ancient coal mine.\" I\'d also like to see the \"ancient copper mines.\"
Wouldn\'t you?

Too bad, then, because the editors at that site also say:



IOW, these mines don\'t even exist!

Please.

Harte


It goes back to the early 70\'s when an edition of National Geographic t actually had their usual standard of high quality photos
of a shoe... jewelery and other surprising objects actually still wedged in coal.... the article suggested that perhaps there were previous civilizations on earth millions of years ago..

I remember being absolutely astounded... and it certainly made the \'Pliocene\' .. \'Golden Torc\' stories by Julian May of time travelers seem all the more realistic...( worth a read...) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saga_of_Pliocene_Exile

Who knows... that National Geographic article could have inspired Julian May\'s imagination to write the series!!!!

Does anyone have old copies of National Geographic?

Been hunting the internet for copies of these photos ever since.. happy.gif

on Mining...

QUOTE
A Short History of Copper Mining

copper mining in the upper peninsula of mi

Copper was first mined in this area by an ancient vanished race between 5,000 and 1,200 bc. These miners left no burial grounds, dwellings, pottery, clay tablets or cave drawings. What was left behind was thousands of copper producing pits and more thousands of crude hammering stones with which the pits had been worked. The ancients apparently worked the copper bearing rock by alternately using fire and cold water, to break the copper ore into smaller pieces from which they could extract the metal with hand held hammering stones or stone hatchets. With this copper, they made tools.

Scientists and engineers estimate that it would have required 10,000 men 1,000 years to develop the extensive operations carried on throughout the region. It is estimated that 1.5 billion pounds of copper were mined by these unknown people.
http://www.exploringthenorth.com/cophistory/cophist.html

QUOTE
http://www.tc.umn.edu/~bakk0029/Old_Copper/OC_Sec_3.HTML

1975
Taxonomic and Associational Considerations of Copper Technology During The Archaic Tradition. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis.

This source provides the first detailed information on four site related to the Old Copper complex. Pickerel Lake (aka \"Sarberg\"), collected 1968-71, is located in Quetico Park, southwest Ontario. Copper artifacts were found along a beach and rocky shore ky campers, along with corner notched lithic points. There were indications of copper manufacture. Steinbring examines that possibility that this site, which strongly resembles the McCollum site, may represent the last vestiges of the Old Copper complex. Tulabi Falls, Whiteshell Provincial Park, Manitoba, was excavated in 1972. The site contained 4 copper artifacts, rich faunal remains and no signs of copper manufacture. Whitemouth Falls on the Winnipeg River in Manitoba produced 1 copper artifact. The site is deeply stratified, with a middle stratum radiocarbon date of 4860 + 150 suggesting that the earliest strata may be 7000 years old. Houska Point on the Rainey Lake in Ranier, Minnesota was excavated in 1970-71. The stratigraphy was significantly disturbed. The site produced approximately 600 copper artifacts, all characterized as fragile. Two gracile socketed forms were found in ceramic strata, and a possible socket fragment in a pre-ceramic strata. Trim bits and nuggets eroding from adjacent shoreline indicated copper manufacture on the site. (See Rapp 1984 regarding raw material source of the copper here.) Steinbring 1975 is cross-listed und er Section I with notes on other contents.


In the old days they didn\'t seem very particular about keeping archaeological sites.. findings...or records in a very scientific manner... ( cool.gif they probably didn\'t have television series.. such as \'Bones\' NCIS ... etc.. as basic guidelines for preserving these site... LOL... look at the series...Relic Hunter... it\'s all about making a quick buck... or grabbing a relic...before some other collector gets it... no concern over protecting the sites...

Can you imagine how many secret wealthy collectors there are of ancient artifacts????

How many are long forgotten in storage rooms of universities... museums??? or have simply been thrown out... lost during renovations..

As to new archeological sites... I know as a fact .. some farmers.. hide evidence.. or quickly cement over any potential archaeological sites.. as the outcome would be that various authorities..take over their land for further investigations with very little compensation to the farmers... landowners... They would much rather either keep it... or find someone...who knows someone willing to buy it for a good price....
I was horrified when I found out... eg by various aquaintances in Europe... as according to them... if you look hard enough .. dig deep enough... there is evidence of ancient man ... almost every where!!!! They say too that quite often.. these sites ..do get covered up anyway for various political..religious..etc reasons..or get \'lost\'.. note what has happened in New Zealand...
QUOTE
http://www.kilts.co.nz/mitancient.htm
View ancient sites near Hamilton

Revisit Ancient Celtic / Viking New Zealand (?).

Investigate the controversial subject of anomalies in New Zealand . New Zealand has a deliberately suppressed pre-Maori, pre-Taupo eruption history. Authorities have jealously hidden our pre-history. Evidence that contradicts conventional historical attitudes which are essentially that NZ has no pre-Maori human history is deliberately hidden, ignored or destroyed.

Maori secrecy aided by DOC and our National Archivists confound, obstruct and generally set about to prevent investigation. Maori spiritualist values, tapu, secret folk lore and general obstructions under the guise of cultural sensitivity are used to prevent investigations on land and in national archives.


http://www.lauralee.com/index.cgi?search=%...ger%20jewell%22

OldTimeRadio
QUOTE (Harte @ Jun 18 2008, 06:59 PM) *
There has never, ever, been any "artifact" found "embedded in coal." There have only been artifacts presented to the public and claimed to have been found embedded in coal.


Chances are that you are correct. But I simply cannot share your cast-in-concrete Certainty.

The Puzzler
QUOTE (Геро
@ Jun 19 2008, 01:04 AM) *
Report from Reuters-

http://www.reuters.com/newsArticle.jhtml?t...storyID=6021742

RABAT (Reuters) - The remains of a prehistoric town believed to date back 15,000 years and belong to an ancient Berber civilization have been
discovered in Western Sahara, Moroccan state media said on Thursday.
A team of Moroccan scientists stumbled across the sand-covered ruins of the town Arghilas deep in the desert of the Morocco-administered territory.
The remains of a place of worship, houses and a necropolis, as well as columns and rock engravings depicting animals, were found at the site near the town of Aousserd in northeastern Western Sahara.
The isolated area is known to be rich in prehistoric rock engravings but experts said the discovery could be significant if proven that the ruins were of Berber origin as this civilization is believed to date back only some 9,000 years.
"It appears that scientists have come up with the 15,000-years estimate judging by the style of the engravings and the theme of the drawings," Mustapha Ouachi, a Rabat-based Berber historian, told Reuters.
Berbers are the original inhabitants of North Africa before Arabs came to spread Islam in the seventh century.
The population of Western Sahara, seized by Morocco in 1975 when former colonial power Spain pulled out, are mostly of Berber and Arab descent.


i managed to find this news report, although it is no longer available on the reuters website.

Well thank you very much. The only place I could find is Lixus.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.