QUOTE (oslove @ Jun 29 2008, 03:32 PM)

The trouble with reincarnation is that you don't get to know who you are a reincarnate of.
The Christian doctrine is a more soothing belief in resurrection of the dead and ultimate happy life forever and ever.
On the other hand, you say you get reincarnated until you get it right; then what?
I don't mind being reincarnated again and again, that is the next best thing to indefinite duration of life.
That is why if I were a Buddhist I would take the care to make sure that I don't get to Nirvana, but always leave something still wanting in me to do karma for, and thus I get to come back by reincarantion or rebirth again and again.
The downside here is that Buddhism does not guarantee you will get to know which person your present identity is a reincarnation or rebirth of.
But if you are smart you can claim that you are a rencarnate or rebirth of Aristotle or Buddha or Confucius or Howard Hughes, etc., and who is wiser to challenge your claim to being this or that -- you can always answer that you are adopting a changed comportment for the sake of doing better karma.
About hell, since it's been in Western civilization since time immemorial and also in several other civilizations, that is always some minor worry however you claim to be a non-believer in hell.
So, better to just be good, it's no big deal anyway; you observe government law don't you, so it is just a little bit more to be a morally correct person.
oslove
Remember this Oslove:
Just because an idea is comforting doesn't bring any more truth to it. Just because the concept of living in eternal paradise seems more soothing and appealing doesn't give it any more merit then reincarnation. Past lives aren't remembered in order to give oneself a clean slate for experience and learning. How would you like to be reincarnated in the 1700's as an African American slave when you were a wealthy Caucasian in a previous life? Not pleasant, hm? That would be why we don't naturally remember our past lives. We can access these memories through past life regression which, although it's accuracy is debatable, gives us a look into possible past lives.
I have a question for you Oslove, what happens once we get to heaven? Do we just sit there all hunky-dory for the rest of time? Sounds rather boring if you ask me. And we wouldn't be able to do the activities we do now, seeing as we'd have thousands, if not millions or billions, of people from all stretches of time and countries. People from 15th century England wouldn't be able to handle the technology of present day, or even future, Japan. It's just not practical, I believe.
Hell has most certainly not been in Western civilization since the beginning of time. Yes, the Europeans believed in hell, but certainly not to the degree as we see it now. Plus, the United States was NOT founded as a Christian nation, as we can see in the treaty with Tripoli, which was written in 1796 by George Washington himself, and signed by John Adams a year later.
"As the Government of the United States of America is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion; as it has in itself no character of enmity against the laws, religion, or tranquility, of Musselmen; and as the said States never have entered into any war or act of hostility against any Mehomitan nation, it is declared by the parties that no pretext arising from religious opinions shall ever produce an interruption of the harmony existing between the two countries."Hm, well, we can see that "hell" has no application whatsoever in our government of our nation from it's conception. It most certainly has not been a focal point of the western civilizations, even before the US. Yes, earlier religions had spiritual worlds and underworlds, but there is NO other religion that has a hell like the Abrahamic religions where sinners are punished in never-ending flames for all eternity. Show me one other example and I'll be impressed.