QUOTE (Atheist God @ Jul 8 2008, 06:07 PM)

Then why keep replying? No one is making you post here.
True.
But that doesn't explain why you wish to belabor an issue which you cannot substantiate. No one's making you do that either...it's just interesting to me when someone draws an absolute conclusion about something for which there is no experience base to go on.
We simply don't know what we'd find if we ever did encounter an alien species or their artifacts.
Your points are well taken, and I'm sure alot of people probably feel that way.
We have alot of advanced theoretical concepts.
We might find substantiation for them...the missing link through an alien craft...if there was one.
On the other hand, we might find something that appeared to be magic.
That's what I've said, clearly.
You say, it will only be one way...the magic.
I say, it could be either.
What's the point in arguing it? We don't have any idea.
Perhaps you simply want to dominate the thread with your opinions, as if they were facts?
...and insert nonsensical comments about my faith in humanity's ability to figure things out.
I generally get involved with such threads to insert a bit of rationality and critical thought processes into the mix.
When it's obvious that someone is making conclusions without any basis in human experience, I generally attempt to show them that they're using faulty logic.
That's why I'm here.
Now, if you wish to dominate here, and say that 50% of the probablilty of what we'll discover if and when we ever encounter an alien craft is in fact 100% fact...well, be my guest.
You're allowed....but try not to demean rationality when someone puts it in your face!
You have no idea what we'll understand, or what we'll be able to determine...IF we ever do get our hands on an alien craft.
You might be right, and you might be wrong, or...you might be half right.
Who knows?
No one.
Why do you bother arguing it. Just say it's your opinion. That'll do. Declaring it as fact is going to get you countered, which it did.