Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Prove it!
Unexplained Mysteries Discussion Forums > Unexplained Mysteries > Metaphysics, Psychology & Psychic Phenomena
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4
PsiSeeker
I'm a believer in special abilities, but have come across some people that just won't believe in it, no matter what i say.

Does anyone know how these extra special abilities work scientifically. It will help if you can include one of the body sistems, nervous system, or describe another unknown body system, energy system for instance.
Fluffybunny
QUOTE (PsiSeeker @ Jul 28 2004, 11:59 PM)
I'm a believer in special abilities, but have come across some people that just won't believe in it, no matter what i say.

What you say doesn't help your case. I can say anything I want regardless of how preposterous it may be.

Doing it is another matter.

James Randi offers a one million dollar prize to anyone who can show evidence of their skills

QUOTE
The Foundation is committed to providing reliable information about paranormal claims. It both supports and conducts original research into such claims.
At JREF, we offer a one-million-dollar prize to anyone who can show, under proper observing conditions, evidence of any paranormal, supernatural, or occult power or event. The prize is in the form of negotiable bonds held in a special investment account. The JREF does not involve itself in the testing procedure, other than helping to design the protocol and approving the conditions under which a test will take place. All tests are designed with the participation and approval of the applicant. In most cases, the applicant will be asked to perform a relatively simple preliminary test of the claim, which if successful, will be followed by the formal test. Preliminary tests are usually conducted by associates of the JREF at the site where the applicant lives. Upon success in the preliminary testing process, the "applicant" becomes a "claimant."

To date, no one has ever passed the preliminary tests.


I'll tell you what, go get that one million dollar prize and you will not only shut me up, but you will make me your biggest supporter.

Simple enough isn't it?
Xenojjin
If you want to prove psychic's are real , Go find a creditable scientist and work with him/her Instead of Randi . Randi may be offering a million , but he is also as senile as they come tongue.gif

I have looked into James Randi a bit and have discovered that while he may be somewhat intelligent he is very closed minded ...and if you read the guys notes he has written to others you will find he is very aroggant . lets just say This site has 13 yr olds on here that can show more maturity then this old coot .

Furthermore Randi greatly goes against all things paranormal , if someone successfully completed his challenge he and his entire foundation would look like fools on top of losing one million dollars . I dont think anyone will be winning that million anytime soon rolleyes.gif

So you wanna prove psi ? You can try and be my guest . I personally wouldnt suggest it ( PM me and Ill explain why ) But if you must ---> find a differant way then James Randi .
Fluffybunny
QUOTE (Xenojjin @ Jul 29 2004, 12:31 AM)
If you want to prove psychic's are real , Go find a creditable scientist and work with him/her Instead of Randi . Randi may be offering a million , but he is also as senile as they come tongue.gif

Nice dodge. whew...close call there.

But is doesn't change the fact that no one has ever proven that they have these skills that you folks claim to have. It has never been reproduced in an observable setting.

btw, he doesn't create the tests, it is a mutual agreement. Randi simply wants to make sure that any trickery can be spotted and exposed for what it is.

You don't think that Randi wouldn't ba able to make more than a million off of the proof of paranormal skills? If you think that he wouldn't take advantage of having proof of paranormal skills that you are more senile than you claim he is. I have met the man, he is not senile by any means.

BurnSide
Of course Randi is close-minded. We're talking about Human Powers that are absolutely impossible. I'd trust Randi more than i'd trust one single person who CLAIMS they have super powers.

Everybody just wants to be special. WELL YOU'RE NOT, you're the same as everyone else. You're not super human, no one is. End of story.
Anakim
Burnside-
QUOTE
Everybody just wants to be special. WELL YOU'RE NOT, you're the same as everyone else.


This isnt the first time you've said this! It seems as if you're the only one who belives that others think they're special. Understand that it has nothing to do with being special or being super human! Its about discovering something about yourself that you never knew existed! Nothing more nothing less.
jeceris
i haven't seen or met anyone i would consider having obvious psychic powers, and even that guy who does crossing over is a crock as far as i'm concerned.
however, if you want some evidence of other psychic ability. look up things like, st joseph of copertino.
this monk would go into a religious trance and levitate, finding himself stuck in a tree once when he came out of his trance. the pope and many others witnessed his flying about.
this to me seems plausible, that this person tapped some energy, maybe anti-gravity, how he did it, well i'd love to know.
wish he was around now for randi to watch.
aquatus1
QUOTE
however, if you want some evidence of other psychic ability. look up things like, st joseph of copertino.


I would propose that Moses parting the Red Sea would be a far greater example of telekenesis than anyone else could come up with.

That is ultimate evidence, right? Thousands of witnessess, etc...

Sorry, no.

Randi is arrogant. He is also rude, abrasive, and shows little tolerance for self-deception. He is, however, an methodologist without peer. He and his staff of researchers (no, he does not judge things himself, he has a "jury" of practicing scientists), once they and the testee have agreed upon the parameters of the test, conduct it several dozen times, and record and publish the results. These people are not amateurs. They are so experinced in the field of research that they can easily design a test that will eliminate all variables except the alleged psychic ability. If such an ability exists, then the results of the test will support it.

That is what evidence is: non-subjective, imperical data that has been tested and re-tested several times. Stories of flying monks, or high school students whirling paper squares on pin points isn't going to do it.
BurnSide
QUOTE (Anakim @ Jul 29 2004, 10:00 AM)
Burnside-
QUOTE
Everybody just wants to be special. WELL YOU'RE NOT, you're the same as everyone else.


This isnt the first time you've said this! It seems as if you're the only one who belives that others think they're special. Understand that it has nothing to do with being special or being super human! Its about discovering something about yourself that you never knew existed! Nothing more nothing less.

I don't think so. I personally believe that people like tameer are claiming all these ridiculous things because she wants to be special and important and whatnot.
But it only end up making you look stupid for claiming all these things.
Anakim
QUOTE (BurnSide @ Jul 29 2004, 04:14 PM)
QUOTE (Anakim @ Jul 29 2004, 10:00 AM)
Burnside-
QUOTE
Everybody just wants to be special. WELL YOU'RE NOT, you're the same as everyone else.


This isnt the first time you've said this! It seems as if you're the only one who belives that others think they're special. Understand that it has nothing to do with being special or being super human! Its about discovering something about yourself that you never knew existed! Nothing more nothing less.

I don't think so. I personally believe that people like tameer are claiming all these ridiculous things because she wants to be special and important and whatnot.
But it only end up making you look stupid for claiming all these things.

Why would you think that? Its not like there going around flaunting any abilities or even showing any superiority towards anyone. I'm not trying to start an argument or even a debate on the subject, im just curiouse as to why you feel the way you do.
BurnSide
Because it's what kids do. They seek attention.
They also aren't flaunting their abilities, only the fact that they CAN do these things. If it was me, i'd flaunt them like crazy, considering i'd be able to do something no other human being on the face on this planet has EVER been able to do since humans existed.
tameer
oh okay you want to say something just bring it. I can say alot of things right now but im not going to waste my time, confronting your ass. You see im not CLAIMING anything. The most reason im only really on these forums is to help people out. and ask questions that i need answered. I like helping people. and i like it when they help me. take anakim for example we help each other out all the time. But i say to him how im doing and what im practicing and what i can do. im not claiming anything! And if you have a problem with psychic abilities not being real. then you can just get the hell out of these forums. Because thats what we all believe in psychic ablities.Its the time where we are all interested in them, and practice them. We dont need any normies coming in here acting like we dont know what were doing! Because we know more than any of you kind of people on what were doing.

I never even met the james randi guy anyway. because Xeno had a point. And i have my own. showing off my skills is not needed. instead i try to keep it private. to the people i help on the forums. and websites.

And when you said because i want to be special and importent. Honestly, I think no matter what, we all are. We all are special and important in our own special ways. I dont need a bunch of psychic ablities to prove that to me or not. because truth to be told, you have those psychic abilities too. you just dont want to believe it, for your own reasons, that i right now dont want to get into. So yeah....

BurnSide
Prove it tameer. Prove it or lose it.
Not trying to be mean, but unless you can prove your abilities, you are a fraud. That's just the way it is.
Anakim
QUOTE
*Because it's what kids do. They seek attention.*

Who is seeking this attention that you speek off and how?

QUOTE
*They also aren't flaunting their abilities, only the fact that they CAN do these things.

And the problem with that would be? What would you have them do? Go around claiming to be superman?

QUOTE
If it was me, i'd flaunt them like crazy, considering i'd be able to do something no other human being on the face on this planet has EVER been able to do since humans existed.*

No affence but that sounds like the childish behavior that you claim to dislike about these people! Once again it seems as if you're the only one who belives that these people think they're special.

BTW- Why do you single out Tameer all the time? To me she seems to fit your profile the least. Just curiouse!
BurnSide
Actually, i'm going to set up a debate about it. 1v1 or 2v2, would you like to participate? That way you can try your best to prove the abilities online.

What's a good title, Psychic Abilities: Are They Real? Does that do it justice? Do you call them Psychic Abilities?
Anakim
Like I said before Im not trying to debate the subject. Im just curiouse as to why you feel the way you do! Debating the sub. would benifit noone because in the end you would still feel the same way and visa versa!
tameer
whats the point of proving it? i never care to prove my abilites to anyone... no im not a fruad if i just dont want to show it. Thats a very childish behavior to think like that. i dont care about the debate, i dont care about what you think, except the fact that you should understand that all of science cant explain everything.

What your basically saying is that you may believe in the "big bang" theory. but what if its fake? huh? what if its not real? They could have easily made those pics they showed to the word, confronting the big bang theory. Maybe there was no big bang. But if you believe in the big bang theory you might as well believe in psychic abilities... once again, all of science cant prove everything......
BurnSide
I believe in things that are proven. You can't simply go around boasting that you can do things that are neither proven or accepted by science. These things are not possible. If you don't even want to debate on the subject, well, that doesn't leave you very credible does it.
Xenojjin
They claim it isnt real because basic psychology dictates that anybody who claims something like psychic powers is actually in denial about their own strength and simply wants attention to help them get through life .

Fun thing about psychology is that it can be used to dictate that anyone is insane .

Logically , I dont exist .

tameer
haha. but i dont understand why you wouldint try it out yourself and see if it works for you. trust me i was just where you were once burnside. Though once somebody does prove it to you, i, with my own experience will honestly tell you, that the "proof is all in you"! try it out atleast for a couple of days. would you rather want somebody to prove it to you. Lose your credit. Or prove it to yourself. its more of a miracle in your way.
Anakim
QUOTE (Xenojjin @ Jul 29 2004, 05:18 PM)
They claim it isnt real because basic psychology dictates that anybody who claims something like psychic powers is actually in denial about their own strength and simply wants attention to help them get through life .

Fun thing about psychology is that it can be used to dictate that anyone is insane .

Logically , I dont exist .

Yet he is posting a message on this forum as we speek! Come on Burnside, do you realy belive only what science tells you?
BurnSide
If someone did prove it to me, of course i would become an instant believer. Same with God, or Aliens, or Nessie, or Bob Dole. But that's just it, no one has ever proved anything. Why not? Why not end all the arguing, show that you can do it, etc.

When i was a kid, i did try all this stuff. Obviously, it didn't work.

I'm still going to make a debate on the subject, i feel it would be a good debate. Please answer my question, do you call them Psychic Abilities? Or something else?
BurnSide
QUOTE (Anakim @ Jul 29 2004, 12:22 PM)
Come on Burnside, do you realy belive only what science tells you?

yes.
Fluffybunny
QUOTE (tameer @ Jul 29 2004, 09:10 AM)
i never care to prove my abilites to anyone... no im not a fruad if i just dont want to show it.

How incredibly convenient for you.

QUOTE
They claim it isnt real because basic psychology dictates that anybody who claims something like psychic powers...


No xeno, we don't, but thanks for putting words in our mouth in an attempt to steer the conversation away from the facts of the matter.

No one has ever proven that they have these powers you all claim. Bottom line.

You folks have gyrated around ever reason why you would not want to prove it in order to keep your fantasy world intact, but the bottom line is that you have not proven yourself to have any skills whatsoever. It is a fantasy.

I would love for people to be able to have these powers. I would be the charter member of the xeno and tameer fan club if they were actually to settle the endless debate as to whether these powers exist. I would offer seed money for the foundation to teach people how to generate these skills.

QUOTE
What would you have them do? Go around claiming to be superman?

I would have them go around offering proof of their skills and no more.

The proof would speak for itself. In that regard it is painfully silent here.

Falco Rex
A few posts back Tameer referred to the rest of us as "Normies." This goes against the content of the entire point that was trying to be made about not trying to be special or different. By labeling us apart from you, you've begun to set yourself up in an exclusive little club of your own. This certainly seems to point to tha fact that BurnSide may have a point here..
The longer this goes on and the more I hear, the more it sounds like a live-action role-playing game. If you believe you can do it that's all well and good. We all live our own lives. But my issue was with the original title of the thread. If you can't find a single salient point to back you up, don't call it fact..
BurnSide
THANK YOU gentlemen.
Anakim
How would proving these abilities to somone who doesnt even belive in them benifit someone with these abilities? What would be the point?
BurnSide
They would be BELIEVED.

What, on earth, is the point in having these abilities but NOT proving it to someone who doesn't believe? As fluffy said, it's all a little to convienient that people claim to have and be able to use these abilities, but are not up to proving them.
Anakim
QUOTE
A few posts back Tameer referred to the rest of us as "Normies." This goes against the content of the entire point that was trying to be made about not trying to be special or different. By labeling us apart from you, you've begun to set yourself up in an exclusive little club of your own. This certainly seems to point to tha fact that BurnSide may have a point here.

Damn! You caught that huh! I agree! maybe she could have reworded that phrase a little!
Falco Rex
The point would be that you've just proven the ability. Not just to us but to the whole world. Then nobody would look at people funny or find an excuse to be somewhere else when people began to talk about this. You'd be removing yourselves from the lunatic fringe. You'd gain legitamacy once and for all. Not to mention the money-making opportunities, the benefit to humanity as a whole and the fact that organized science would take a good long look at psychic powers for once..
And there's plenty more reasons and benefits besides..But still, given all that people who claim these powers remain unwilling to even try..
BurnSide
QUOTE (Anakim @ Jul 29 2004, 12:46 PM)
QUOTE
A few posts back Tameer referred to the rest of us as "Normies." This goes against the content of the entire point that was trying to be made about not trying to be special or different. By labeling us apart from you, you've begun to set yourself up in an exclusive little club of your own. This certainly seems to point to tha fact that BurnSide may have a point here.

Damn! You caught that huh! I agree! maybe she could have reworded that phrase a little!

Yeah, maybe, because she completely proved my point.

Just wants to be different. Special.
Xenojjin
QUOTE (BurnSide @ Jul 29 2004, 05:24 PM)
If someone did prove it to me, of course i would become an instant believer. Same with God, or Aliens, or Nessie, or Bob Dole. But that's just it, no one has ever proved anything. Why not? Why not end all the arguing, show that you can do it, etc.

When i was a kid, i did try all this stuff. Obviously, it didn't work.

I'm still going to make a debate on the subject, i feel it would be a good debate. Please answer my question, do you call them Psychic Abilities? Or something else?

Rather then just making it on psychic abilities : why dont you have it cover the basic idea of believing in something VS not believing until scientifically proven .

That way you will cover magic and other such things as well .
Anakim
Thats the the thing. These people aren't trying to make people belive, they are just trying to further their abillities. Proving it wont do that.
BurnSide
QUOTE (Xenojjin @ Jul 29 2004, 12:50 PM)

Rather then just making it on psychic abilities : why dont you have it cover the basic idea of believing in something VS not believing until scientifically proven .

That way you will cover magic and other such things as well .

good idea. That would be a different debate, but i like it.

Blind Belief vs Belief with proof.

I may just start that up.
Anakim
That one kind of has my attention. Ill be looking for it.
tameer
you know burnside. and fluffy if i might add....
Anakim had a very good point. People who, like me, are trying to simply improve there "hidden talants" as i might say, are simply doing so. We dont need for you to come and question us on believing if its true or not. Because we know its true. And thats all thats important. Thats all that matters. If you have a problem in understanding that. then go ahead and all your life think about how many things you didint believe just because you didint want to. and how many things you did. You can right now, make a psi wheel try and spin it. I'm sure if you kept trying you could spin it in no time. The thing is you dont want to.

And I dont care about stopping arguments and earning a million dollars and all that crap. for my own reasons, im sure people like anakim and xeno, have there own reasons too. But it doesnt mean we cant do it just because we keep it private. Not SECRET. but PRIVATE. you wouldint understand why. maybe we wouldint like all the attention. because then only negitive attitudes would be neglected towards it. Its better in ALOT of ways to keep it small, and unwided....
Fluffybunny
QUOTE
We dont need for you to come and question us on believing if its true or not.


We too do not want you to come here and claim your fantasy world as "facts".

If you want to say that you are in some kind of fictional rpg group; knock yourself out. Have fun, claim whatever you wish. You can say that you are hovering 6 inches above your chair while typing as far as I am concerned. You can claim to be able to levitate your parents Buick as far as I care just as long as the claims are made within the scope of fantasy that you are dealing with.

There is a big stretch between your fictional world of magic and feats of amazing ability and the real world of cold hard facts. I don't like when people present their fiction as fact. When I see it here time and time again I speak up to support a more scientific point of view.

It is similar to people selling snake oil; it is not nice when someone takes advantage of another’s lack of knowledge or gullible nature. There are kids here who are not old enough to have done their own research and come to their own conclusions whatever they may be. I am not comfortable letting you have your point of view with free reign. I see what you are claiming as based on untruths. I am going to make sure that people get both points of view. Whatever they decide to believe is up to them. It should be an informed decision though.

We see it here all of the time from folks who claim to have all of these incredible talents, yet never back up their claims with anything of substance. Once again you have squirmed around in every fashion to avoid the bottom line fact that you are not willing to back up your claims with anything of substance.
nate0192
QUOTE (BurnSide @ Jul 29 2004, 04:48 PM)
Because it's what kids do. They seek attention.
They also aren't flaunting their abilities, only the fact that they CAN do these things. If it was me, i'd flaunt them like crazy, considering i'd be able to do something no other human being on the face on this planet has EVER been able to do since humans existed.



the reason we don't show them off is because the part of the brain that is used for psychic abilities doesn't care about showing off. the reason you don't have a psi ability, is because that part of your brain is underactive
BurnSide
ahahahahahaah!!!

oh, sorry, just, ahahah!! The part of the brain doesn't care about showing off. Riigghtt. ahahah.

Again, HOW CONVIENIANT!
gonzowalker
Where were all the psychics a few months ago when I made a topic about using these powers to find a missing boy?

If I had the ability to do so, I most definately would help.

Remember what Uncle Ben said, "with great power comes great responsibility". tongue.gif
Wings of Selkhet
QUOTE
the reason we don't show them off is because the part of the brain that is used for psychic abilities doesn't care about showing off, that's why you don't have a psi ability, that part of your brain is underactive


Nice to know our forum members are just so highly educated in neurology. rolleyes.gif

There is a difference between showing off and proving something. I guess every scientist who has ever proved anything is showing off, eh? That Snell! What an arrogant prick! Oh, and Newton - what a bastard! Who does he think he is, eh? (Sorry; first two scientists I thought of. tongue.gif)

You know, there's a very easy way to stop people from questioning/harassing you. Just prove that you can do the things you claim to, and voila, we'll leave you alone. Incredibly simple, and yet you still refuse. It's the internet - what can we do, come to your house and force you to levitate things for us? All you have to do is show us a video clip. It won't kill you. How can we exploit you - we don't know who you are.

And gonzowalker has a good point. If you really had any of these abilities you claim to, you'd be out helping people instead of posting on a message board about them. After all, you don't care about showing off!
nate0192
QUOTE (Anakim @ Jul 29 2004, 05:02 PM)
QUOTE
*Because it's what kids do. They seek attention.*

Who is seeking this attention that you speek off and how?

QUOTE
*They also aren't flaunting their abilities, only the fact that they CAN do these things.

And the problem with that would be? What would you have them do? Go around claiming to be superman?

QUOTE
If it was me, i'd flaunt them like crazy, considering i'd be able to do something no other human being on the face on this planet has EVER been able to do since humans existed.*

No affence but that sounds like the childish behavior that you claim to dislike about these people! Once again it seems as if you're the only one who belives that these people think they're special.

BTW- Why do you single out Tameer all the time? To me she seems to fit your profile the least. Just curiouse!

the part of the brain that is used for psychic abilities is called the prefrontal cortex. when it is underactive or destroyed the person "retrogresses" which means they act immature for their age (showing off)
Wings of Selkhet
Sorry nate, don't know too much about the human brain, please link me to something that proves that the prefontal cortex is used for psychic abilities. grin2.gif

nate0192
it hasn't been proven
Wings of Selkhet
*dies laughing*

Wow, this thread is so pointless. There will never be any proof, will there?

*wipes tears of laughter from eyes*
nate0192
there haven't been any tests in a lab mesuring the brain activity of psychics
Xenojjin
QUOTE (nate0192 @ Jul 29 2004, 10:06 PM)

the part of the brain that is used for psychic abilities is called the prefrontal cortex. when it is underactive or destroyed the person "retrogresses" which means they act immature for their age (showing off)

huh.gif

erm...no ...

It has more to do with not really caring to show off in general or in my case understanding what that means .
aquatus1
QUOTE
there haven't been any tests in a lab mesuring the brain activity of psychics


Nate...

Look, I respect your beliefs and all, but you really need to do your research before making definitive statements such as these, that can be confirmed or falsified with a few minutes on an internet search engine. It is because of academic laziness such as this that many of the alleged psychics in this forum lose credibility.

The Electroencephalograph (EEG) was invented in 1929 By German psychiatrist Hans Berger for the express purpose of testing to see in telepathy could be explained by brain waves. Since that time, numerous universities have, and still do, continue studying brain activity of psychics.

There have been results, but probably not the ones you want to hear. It has been repeatedly shown that electromagnetic exposure to certain areas of the brain accurately and reliably mimics the exact sensations claimed by people who have undergone paranormal phenomena. That includes everything from telepathy to sensing ghosts. It has also been shown that intense meditative concentration, such as that employed by people entering a psychic trance, seperates a certain portion of the mind (chemically, not physically), and creates a state of extreme suggestability.

You can choose to believe that certain people have powers that defy all explanation, or for that matter, even detection, or you can choose to believe that the effects that we have not only observed, but induced repeatedly and reliably through scientific means are the cause of the phenomena.

Either way, do your research first.
nate0192
do u have any links to sites that have the results of those tests? i've been researching for experiments like that online and i haven't been able to find anything. i was mainly talking about psychokinesis, telepathy, and empathy. and they aren't super human abilities that only a small group of people have. everybody has them but in most people they aren't strong enough to be noticeable
tameer
*sigh*

okay look if you guys really want proof why dont you go to psipog.net
they have video's and pics there in the media section, like us, this is the forum. We dont care to prove it to anyone. Mainly because we dont want to. And you cant make us no matter what you do. So go to psipog.net or telekinesis.mine.nu for example, and see there media sections. there's your proof. i dont know how thats going to change anything because once proof is in front of your eyes, the next thing your going to complain and argue about is that it was on camera. See so whats the point of even proving at all?
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.