Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: God created you just to send you to hell.
Unexplained Mysteries Discussion Forums > Unexplained Mysteries > Spirituality vs Skepticism
Pages: 1, 2, 3
Faeden
HI all

I would like to edit this, and state that I do not believe that god creates us just to send us to hell. I am asking a valid question based on what some people believe, that god would create us knowing most of us might go to hell. Its not an attack on anyone, but me asking a question that I have.

A thought come to me about the idea of eternal burning and damnation.

Extremists, and brainwashed people, and power hungry tyrants all believe that if you do something as minor as get god's name wrong, or do not worship him, you do not get into his loving kingdom, even worse you have to burn in a lake of fire for all eternity. Is this the real image and nature of a being so great and magnificent that created the awe inspiring universe, and life? Or is it a slanderous travesty against our creator ? Is god really so shallow and petty that he/she would punish you for not kissing his/her butt? Is it not a horrible sin to accuse God of being a egotistical power hungry tyrant ?

After thinking about this belief the thought occurred to me, that if god is like this, then being that most people have different religions, or are not religious at all 80% or so must be going to hell to burn. Now if this is true, what on earth is god doing creating human souls, that he knows will most probably end up burning in the worst of annoys for a whole eternity. My question is ‘why would god create us knowing we will most probably have to burn ?’ isn’t this the act of a homicidal, sadistic, maniac? If the laws of the after life are that the "none believers" will burn in hell, then why doesn’t "he" stop creating humans, and put a stop to the continuous creation of souls? Why does he continue to help Satan’s fire burn?

If god knew when he created souls that most of them would burn in hell, why o why did he create them in the first place, all he is doing is fuelling the fires of hell, and giving his enemy Satan more satisfaction, being its god that is making the logs, knowing he is making them for Satan, and to fuel Satan’s fire. If this is so, god and Satan must have some kind of business agreement, and must love each other, as they seem to both complement each other, god gets all the ones that worshipped him, and Satan gets all the ones that worshipped him, by not worshipping god, what a bizarre notion of enemies.

Why cant these religious extremists spot these huge flaws and contradictions ?

And also if this is the nature of the after life, may I ask a question I have asked before 'What if you are a good believing Christian, Muslim, or Catholic ect, and your child that you love and adored, picked the wrong religion, and you went to heaven, but God sent your beloved child into hell, to burn the worst type if agony’s known for all eternity, could you go to heaven knowing that the god you are now with sent your child into hell, could you look that god in the eye?’ I do not know about you, but if god sent my children, that I loved, into hell to burn, I could not be anywhere near him/her.

Please stop slandering Jesus, Allah and the other great religious leaders, as cold tyrants it Pi*ses me off.

All the best
Faeden
Ashley-Star*Child
Hell is not a made up idea. It was seen by the very same prophets who saw Heaven. From Jesus showing a disciple hell, to Enoch seeing Heaven and hell, Moses, Ezra, etc.
theoric
QUOTE(Ashley-Star*Child @ Apr 18 2005, 05:43 AM)
Hell is not a made up idea. It was seen by the very same prophets who saw Heaven. From Jesus showing a disciple hell, to Enoch seeing Heaven and hell, Moses, Ezra, etc.
[right][snapback]576803[/snapback][/right]

historically speaking, hell was created by the church as a tool to prevent people from leaving the church. (scare them into submission, if you will)
Faeden
Ashley I never said hell is made up, i said the idea that god is so cruel that he/she would send poor human souls in to a "fiery hell" is made up. I said the idea that people get sent to hell for not believing in a certain religion is made up.

Ashley I do not know how to brake the news to you, so maybe you might want to take a seat, if you are not all ready seated. Just because it says it in some books, doesn’t make it so, there are a billion and one books in the world, and they all claim different things, it doesn’t make them so either.

I believe in a place one might call "hell" but its not fiery and hot, quite the opposite its dark, cold, and lonely. Hell to me is being void of the god light.

Click HERE to read a mediums descent into the dark realms.

All the best
Faeden
Ashley-Star*Child
No it wasn't. It's in texts as ancient as those that make up the OT.

On top of that, there are as many people who see hell in NDE's as there are tht see 'Heaven', or any white light.

I say 'Heaven' because half the time what they are seeing isn't Heaven at all.

Before anyone goes anywhere, for the first three days you have to watch you entire life, movie like, but in 'time-travel' mode, where you are there, seeing yourself in 3rd person, watching the mistakes of your life. From then, those events are brought forward by the Irin, and the Qaddism, judgement angels, one side for you, the other, accusing angels, against, which bring your case before God. After that it is decided where you go.

When people see hell in an NDE, it's a warning. Then you get sent back. It's just not your time.
LoVer_Of_GoD
u people think that hell is a made up place? hahahaha... well, we will see how made up it is when our life ends, now wont we? well, i wont, i will be in paradise... but someone will, and i hope that that person makes sure to die with a tanning suit, sunblock, and flip flops, cause its gonna get hot... it is rediculous to call God a tyrant and blame Him for sending people to hell when it is THEIR fault they go there... the have the knowledge of hell, they have the way out, but still they choose to go there... OH GOD, OPEN THE EYES OF THE LOST SO THAT THEY MIGHT SEE UR ENDLESS LOVE... OPEN THE EARS OF THE LOST SO THAT THEY MIGHT HEAR UR MIGHTY VOICE... OPEN THE HEARTS OF THE LOST SO THAT THEY SHALL EXPERIENCE TRUE AND TOTAL JOY IN HEAVEN ABOVE..
Ashley-Star*Child
What you're talking about Faeden isn't hell, it's Sheol/pergatory. The middle ground. The place people go to before Heaven and after hell. They are transitional.

Most people end up in Sheol, before ever reaching Heaven.
LoVer_Of_GoD
ashley, just asking but are u a jehovahs witness?
Ashley-Star*Child
You have all the knowledge of it. Wishing it doesn't exist won't make it go away.

If you want to be an athiest, then you believe in nothing, so there's really no say here or there (or, rather, there shouldn't be). But when you actually do believe in God, you have to take the whole territory, both sides of the story, not just pick parts out that you don't like.
Ashley-Star*Child
Hell no, I'm a mixture of RC and Judaism. Technically, no category.
LoVer_Of_GoD
okey dokey... just wonderin...
zandore
QUOTE(Ashley-Star*Child Posted Today @ 10:03 AM )
But when you actually do believe in God, you have to take the whole territory, both sides of the story, not just pick parts out that you don't like.
With respect but isn't this what main stream Christianity doing today, Pieces and parts. hmm.gif
Ashley-Star*Child
Yeah and it's pieces and parts which have screwed it up almost beyond repair. This was anothr rule. You couldn't make a decsion on parts of 'the WORD' unless you read everything relating to it. Do people do that now?
Faeden
LOL did I hit a nerve there LoVer_Of_GoD ?

QUOTE
people think that hell is a made up place?  hahahaha


Do I keep having to repeat my self, I do not think hell is a made up place, I just know its not fire and brimstone.

QUOTE
well, we will see how made up it is when our life ends, now wont we? well, i wont, i will be in paradise... but someone will, and i hope that that person makes sure to die with a tanning suit, sunblock, and flip flops, cause its gonna get hot..


Naughty naughty did you forget the bible, thou shall not judge? Or thou shall not condemn? Tut Tut.

Do you think God will like the fact that you just made fun of people that are burning in hell? If you do, you must think he is a tyrant.

QUOTE
it is rediculous to call God a tyrant and blame Him for sending people to hell when it is THEIR fault they go there...


Sorry you seem to over look my words, I never called god a tyrant, I was annoyed that people think he is a tyrant, like you do.

QUOTE
OH GOD, OPEN THE EYES OF THE LOST SO THAT THEY MIGHT SEE UR ENDLESS LOVE... OPEN THE EARS OF THE LOST SO THAT THEY MIGHT HEAR UR MIGHTY VOICE... OPEN THE HEARTS OF THE LOST SO THAT THEY SHALL EXPERIENCE TRUE AND TOTAL JOY IN HEAVEN ABOVE..


My eyes, ears and mouth are open my friend, and I intend to use them, instead of believing something just because some money hungry angry man on a podium told me to in a church thumbsup.gif I actually study the afterlife, rather than just take a power obsessed mans word for it thumbsup.gif

"LoVer_Of_GoD" I seemed to have angered you, I wonder why that doesn’t surprise me?... Did I make you question something ?

Ashley I have never heard of anyone have a NDE and say they saw fire and brimstone only darkness, but most are positive ones. Didn’t you say a while back you had a NDE, and that it was not of the nicest in nature ?

I think the only people that would have a vision of fire and brimstone in a NDE are religious fundamentalists and extremists, that where obsessed with the idea of a fiery hell…. Ironic that....

Hell to me, is for the ignorant, its your hell you burn in it LOL devil.gif

All the best
Faeden
Irish
Well it’s my personal opinion but here goes.

If He brought you into existence He certainly has every right to take you out of it!

Unless you’re pleading your defense as insanity, you would have to give recognition first to the judge/God(for providing salvation) and jury(The word of God) and your defense council/Jesus.(For actualy going to hell for you).
This recognition is a very small price to pay.

All the Best
Irish
zandore
QUOTE(Ashley-Star*Child Posted Today @ 10:19 AM )
Yeah and it's pieces and parts which have screwed it up almost beyond repair.
This same attitude was in abundance when the bible was edited way back when so it might not be salvageable.
LoVer_Of_GoD
QUOTE(Faeden @ Apr 18 2005, 08:34 AM)
LOL did I hit a nerve there LoVer_Of_GoD ?

QUOTE
people think that hell is a made up place?  hahahaha


Do I keep having to repeat my self, I do not think hell is a made up place, I just know its not fire and brimstone.

QUOTE
well, we will see how made up it is when our life ends, now wont we? well, i wont, i will be in paradise... but someone will, and i hope that that person makes sure to die with a tanning suit, sunblock, and flip flops, cause its gonna get hot..


Naughty naughty did you forget the bible, thou shall not judge? Or thou shall not condemn? Tut Tut.

Do you think God will like the fact that you just made fun of people that are burning in hell? If you do, you must think he is a tyrant.

QUOTE
it is rediculous to call God a tyrant and blame Him for sending people to hell when it is THEIR fault they go there...


Sorry you seem to over look my words, I never called god a tyrant, I was annoyed that people think he is a tyrant, like you do.

QUOTE
OH GOD, OPEN THE EYES OF THE LOST SO THAT THEY MIGHT SEE UR ENDLESS LOVE... OPEN THE EARS OF THE LOST SO THAT THEY MIGHT HEAR UR MIGHTY VOICE... OPEN THE HEARTS OF THE LOST SO THAT THEY SHALL EXPERIENCE TRUE AND TOTAL JOY IN HEAVEN ABOVE..


My eyes, ears and mouth are open my friend, and I intend to use them, instead of believing something just because some money hungry angry man on a podium told me to in a church thumbsup.gif I actually study the afterlife, rather than just take a power obsessed mans word for it thumbsup.gif

"LoVer_Of_GoD" I seemed to have angered you, I wonder why that doesn’t surprise me?... Did I make you question something ?




hit a note? not a chance.. u would have liked if u did though, wouldnt you? and as for the hungry angry man on a podium, i learned nothing from going to church... all i believe and know is from my own study and my own guidance from the Holy Father... angered? i dont get angry... i got kinda excited though.. havent posted for a while... not a fun one anyway... i condemned nobody... i stated that someone going to hell would need those things.. and hell, the LAKE OF FIRE, isnt going to be dark and cold, hence the FIRE part... lets see.... question somethin? naw.. i dont question anything other than how u come up with this stuff.... and about the tyrant thing... arent u the one that said that God sends people to hell? well, u are calling him a tyrant, arent u?
Faeden
Hi "Lover of god"

QUOTE
i condemned nobody...


Keep convincing your self of that, I am sure you can keep pulling the wool over your gods eyes.

QUOTE
and about the tyrant thing... arent u the one that said that God sends people to hell? well, u are calling him a tyrant, arent u?


Come again??? Are you hearing voices, or seeing things ? I have never said that in my entire life, your a strange cookie Ill give you that.

QUOTE
question somethin? naw.. i dont question anything other than how u come up with this stuff....


Isn’t it a while ago you where telling me that I had made you question some things, and that you could feel god telling you that I was telling the truth ? Has that opinion changed ? Maybe you think now that I am actually "Satan" tempting you away from Christ LOL… Do you think I am a demon "Lover of god"? Perhaps I am, and I just do not know it, or maybe I do know it and I am just a good lair. This kind of thinking is spiritual paranoia, and sends people into a vicious circle of fear. Ill say sorry to Jesus for you again next time I see him, so I can apologise to him on your behalf, for thinking he is cruel thumbsup.gif as you know he Is ever forgiving. Well I am off for a brimstone burger (extra hot) enjoy your time in heaven, and ill enjoy my time in hell, while devils poke my butt with pointy pitchforks.

All the best
Faeden
theoric
@lover

i have to agree with faeden. your comments did indeed sound very judgemental (not to mention it sounded like you enjoyed the idea of watching others roast in a fire-pit).

Anyway, why would you so strongly believe that any creature would do such a thing as eternal roasting? Those that say this is true and say their god is all loving are contradicting themselves. Unless of course to love is to torment. innocent.gif
LoVer_Of_GoD
never called u a demon, nor satan, and yah i did say that God was telling me that SOME of what u were saying was true... actually most of it... but some of it still remains off track... and i apologize.. i misread ur opening post...sorry...

and i didnt mean to sound judgmental.. i was actually makin a joke... sorry... and God is all loving... look at all he has done to give us a way out of hell.... adam and eve messed it all up at the beginning, but then God gave us a way out of it then, the people still messed it up, and he sent jesus, giving us an even easier way out of hell... so, whats next? the only thing left is to end it all and start all over again.... hence the end times, but that is a different thread.
theoric
QUOTE(LoVer_Of_GoD @ Apr 18 2005, 07:20 AM)
never called u a demon, nor satan, and yah i did say that God was telling me that SOME of what u were saying was true... actually most of it... but some of it still remains off track... and i apologize.. i misread ur opening post...sorry...

and i didnt mean to sound judgmental.. i was actually makin a joke... sorry... and God is all loving... look at all he has done to give us a way out of hell.... adam and eve messed it all up at the beginning, but then God gave us a way out of it then, the people still messed it up, and he sent jesus, giving us an even easier way out of hell... so, whats next?  the only thing left is to end it all and start all over again.... hence the end times, but that is a different thread.
[right][snapback]576947[/snapback][/right]

historically, what was next was he sent muhammed and gave the world his next message (if you believe in one prophet, you must accept them all - otherwise you are just picking the parts you like thumbsup.gif )
lightbeyondthedark
QUOTE(hyperactive @ Apr 18 2005, 07:50 AM)
historically speaking, hell was created by the church as a tool to prevent people from leaving the church. (scare them into submission, if you will)
[right][snapback]576813[/snapback][/right]
LOL
I was taken by love long before hell entered my mind... Not even worried about it...
Why should I?

QUOTE(Faeden @ Apr 18 2005, 08:34 AM)
I do not think hell is a made up place, I just know its not fire and brimstone.
Hmm... Well I don't think Gods final judgement is fire and such, I have no real idea what hell under lucifer may be like...

QUOTE(Faeden @ Apr 18 2005, 08:34 AM)
QUOTE
well, we will see how made up it is when our life ends, now wont we? well, i wont, i will be in paradise... but someone will, and i hope that that person makes sure to die with a tanning suit, sunblock, and flip flops, cause its gonna get hot..

Naughty naughty did you forget the bible, thou shall not judge? Or thou shall not condemn? Tut Tut.
Judge not, and ye shall not be judged: condemn not, and ye shall not be condemned: forgive, and ye shall be forgiven - Luke 6:37

QUOTE(zandore @ Apr 18 2005, 08:36 AM)
QUOTE(Ashley-Star*Child Posted Today @  10:19 AM )
Yeah and it's pieces and parts which have screwed it up almost beyond repair.
This same attitude was in abundance when the bible was edited way back when so it might not be salvageable.
[right][snapback]576883[/snapback][/right]
Men are flawed, but grace can overcome any flaw...

QUOTE(LoVer_Of_GoD @ Apr 18 2005, 08:48 AM)
[right][snapback]576900[/snapback][/right]

QUOTE(Faeden @ Apr 18 2005, 09:06 AM)
[right][snapback]576925[/snapback][/right]
Come on guys, lets all get along... happy.gif


LBD
~peace
Faeden
Hi lightbeyondthedark

QUOTE
Judge not, and ye shall not be judged: condemn not, and ye shall not be condemned: forgive, and ye shall be forgiven - Luke 6:37


Wise words indeed. What a shame more people do not actually practice it, the world would be a much better place if they did.

"Lover of God" I never said you called me a demon, I asked if you thought I was a demon.

All the best
Faeden
LoVer_Of_GoD
ok... but i really didnt mean to sound judgemental.. i was just trying to make a joke.. apparently im not as funny as i thought...
Faeden
QUOTE(LoVer_Of_GoD @ Apr 18 2005, 04:59 PM)
ok... but i really didnt mean to sound judgemental.. i was just trying to make a joke.. apparently im not as funny as i thought...
[right][snapback]577024[/snapback][/right]


I think you did make a joke yes, but you based it on what you believe. Dont worry bud, I forgive you, its all good thumbsup.gif

All the best
Faeden
lightbeyondthedark
QUOTE(Faeden @ Apr 18 2005, 10:03 AM)
I think you did make a joke yes, but you based it on what you believe. Dont worry bud, I forgive you, its all good  thumbsup.gif
[right][snapback]577033[/snapback][/right]

Your a good man Faeden... thumbsup.gif

LBD
LoVer_Of_GoD
and i apologize for the hostility, if i was showin any... my teacher yelled at me and it put me in a bad mood... sorry eveyone..
theoric
QUOTE(LoVer_Of_GoD @ Apr 18 2005, 08:05 AM)
and i apologize for the hostility, if i was showin any... my teacher yelled at me and it put me in a bad mood... sorry eveyone..
[right][snapback]577040[/snapback][/right]

thumbsup.gif

it doesn't matter. all flows past and is forgotten
LoVer_Of_GoD
i almost was seeming like one of those super extremists... im not... i dont know if i qualify for either classification
zandore
QUOTE(lightbeyondthedark Posted Today @ 11:27 AM )
QUOTE(zandore @ Apr 18 2005 @  08:36 AM)
QUOTE(Ashley-Star*Child Posted Today @  10:19 AM)
Yeah and it's pieces and parts which have screwed it up almost beyond repair.
This same attitude was in abundance when the bible was edited way back when so it might not be salvageable.
Men are flawed, but grace can overcome any flaw...
It was not man that I was talking about.
QUOTE(LoVer_Of_GoD Posted Today @ 11:59 AM )
ok... but i really didnt mean to sound judgemental.. i was just trying to make a joke.. apparently im not as funny as i thought...
Keep practicing PADAWAN! thumbsup.gif
QUOTE(LoVer_Of_GoD Posted Today @ 12:05 PM )
and i apologize for the hostility, if i was showin any...
Beware anger leads to the dark side. devil.gif
QUOTE(LoVer_Of_GoD Posted Today @ 12:12 PM )
i almost was seeming like one of those super extremists...
In truth.....Just someone that might need to learn his Religion a little more my friend. thumbsup.gif Never dought your faith.
LoVer_Of_GoD
i still have a lot to learn, zandore.. i am a padawan, if u wana talk star wars.. and i dont have any master to teach me except for God... so i figure ill be ready in a couple of years.. in that time ill keep posting and learning... i learn stuff everyday here... so it all good
lightbeyondthedark
QUOTE(zandore @ Apr 18 2005, 11:43 AM)
QUOTE(lightbeyondthedark Posted Today @  11:27 AM )
QUOTE(zandore @ Apr 18 2005 @  08:36 AM)
QUOTE(Ashley-Star*Child Posted Today @  10:19 AM)
Yeah and it's pieces and parts which have screwed it up almost beyond repair.
This same attitude was in abundance when the bible was edited way back when so it might not be salvageable.
Men are flawed, but grace can overcome any flaw...
It was not man that I was talking about.
Then who were you talking about?

"This same attitude was in abundance when the bible was edited way back when so it might not be salvageable."


So who was it edited by?

QUOTE(zandore @ Apr 18 2005, 11:43 AM)
QUOTE(LoVer_Of_GoD Posted Today @  11:59 AM )
ok... but i really didnt mean to sound judgemental.. i was just trying to make a joke.. apparently im not as funny as i thought...
Keep practicing PADAWAN! thumbsup.gif
QUOTE(LoVer_Of_GoD Posted Today @ 12:05 PM )
and i apologize for the hostility, if i was showin any...
Beware anger leads to the dark side. devil.gif
Someone isn't excited for episode 3 are they? tongue.gif

QUOTE(zandore @ Apr 18 2005, 11:43 AM)
QUOTE(LoVer_Of_GoD Posted Today @  12:12 PM )
i almost was seeming like one of those super extremists...
In truth.....Just someone that might need to learn his Religion a little more my friend. thumbsup.gif Never dought your faith.
[right][snapback]577213[/snapback][/right]

Very true... Why have faith if your going to doubt it?


LBD
LoVer_Of_GoD
i dont doubt my faith.. my faith is super strong... my knowledge is somewhat lacking in certain areas...
zandore
QUOTE(lightbeyondthedark Posted Today @ 02:00 PM )
So who was it edited by?
Constantine, Nicea, Also wasn't it orally passed down before it was written down? hmm.gif
LoVer_Of_GoD
i know i cant wait till episode 3... ooh yeah.. woo hoo.. cant wait. grin2.gif
lightbeyondthedark
QUOTE(zandore @ Apr 18 2005, 12:07 PM)
QUOTE(lightbeyondthedark Posted Today @  02:00 PM )
So who was it edited by?
Constantine, Nicea, Also wasn't it orally passed down before it was written down? hmm.gif
[right][snapback]577265[/snapback][/right]

Check it

LBD
LoVer_Of_GoD
interesting
lightbeyondthedark
Also check this

LBD
zandore
QUOTE(lightbeyondthedark Posted Today @ 02:12 PM )
Check it
AH *AHEM* Bible.com.....OK does this mean I can start using skeptic links? hmm.gif
QUOTE(Bible.com)
5. Who wrote the Bible?
The Bible was written under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit by over 40 different authors from all walks of life: shepherds, farmers, tent-makers, physicians, fishermen, priests, philosophers and kings. Despite these differences in occupation and the span of years it took to write it, the Bible is an extremely cohesive and unified book
Physicians, priests, philosophers and kings I think would have known how to write but shepherds, farmers, tent-makers and fishermen I don't think so. They would have to have told it to someone and who is to say that they did not do some editing. hmm.gif
As far as being "Cohesive and Unified" grin2.gif Want to have another go at it? grin2.gif
LoVer_Of_GoD
simma down.. jk haha wink2.gif grin2.gif original.gif :9
lightbeyondthedark
QUOTE(zandore @ Apr 18 2005, 12:31 PM)
QUOTE(lightbeyondthedark Posted Today @  02:12 PM )
Check it
AH *AHEM* Bible.com.....OK does this mean I can start using skeptic links? hmm.gif
Whats stopping you... tongue.gif

QUOTE(zandore @ Apr 18 2005, 12:31 PM)
QUOTE
5. Who wrote the Bible?
The Bible was written under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit by over 40 different authors from all walks of life: shepherds, farmers, tent-makers, physicians, fishermen, priests, philosophers and kings. Despite these differences in occupation and the span of years it took to write it, the Bible is an extremely cohesive and unified book
Physicians, priests, philosophers and kings I think would have known how to write but shepherds, farmers, tent-makers and fishermen I don't think so. They would have to have told it to someone and who is to say that they did not do some editing. hmm.gif
As far as being "Cohesive and Unified" grin2.gif Want to have another go at it? grin2.gif
[right][snapback]577317[/snapback][/right]
Who is to say that farmers and shepards couldn't write? couldn't they learn to write?

LBD
JennRose
QUOTE(zandore @ Apr 18 2005, 02:07 PM)
QUOTE(lightbeyondthedark Posted Today @  02:00 PM )
So who was it edited by?
Constantine, Nicea, Also wasn't it orally passed down before it was written down? hmm.gif
[right][snapback]577265[/snapback][/right]


It was indeed passed down orally, especially the first part of the Old Testament. It was a stricly oral history for several hundred years, which is one reason it has so many myths similar to those of other, more ancient, religions.

And the gospels were passed around for a few years before being committed to paper. I believe the earliest wasn't written down until about 60-70 years after Jesus supposedly was killed.
LoVer_Of_GoD
are u sure about that?
zandore
QUOTE(lightbeyondthedark Posted Today @ 02:34 PM )
Whats stopping you... tongue.gif 
Trying to act like a Christian. (Sorry for the low blow tongue.gif )
QUOTE(lightbeyondthedark Posted Today @ 02:34 PM )
Who is to say that farmers and shepards couldn't write? couldn't they learn to write?
Odds are very high that they dod not know how to read and write.
QUOTE(JennRose Posted Today @ 02:38 PM )
It was indeed passed down orally, especially the first part of the Old Testament. It was a stricly oral history for several hundred years, which is one reason it has so many myths similar to those of other, more ancient, religions.

And the gospels were passed around for a few years before being committed to paper. I believe the earliest wasn't written down until about 60-70 years after Jesus supposedly was killed.
You could not have pick a better time for this one Jenn! thumbsup.gif notworthy.gif
zandore
QUOTE(LoVer_Of_GoD @ Apr 18 2005, 02:43 PM)
are u sure about that?
[right][snapback]577347[/snapback][/right]

Yes... She saved me from having to look it up.
lightbeyondthedark
QUOTE(zandore @ Apr 18 2005, 12:44 PM)
QUOTE(lightbeyondthedark Posted Today @  02:34 PM )
Whats stopping you... tongue.gif 
Trying to act like a Christian. (Sorry for the low blow tongue.gif )
Oooo... blink.gif

LOL

QUOTE(zandore @ Apr 18 2005, 12:44 PM)
QUOTE(lightbeyondthedark Posted Today @  02:34 PM )
Who is to say that farmers and shepards couldn't write? couldn't they learn to write?
Odds are very high that they dod not know how to read and write.
I don't want to hear about odds... Theres a chance they could, and theres a chance they couldn't...



LBD
JennRose
QUOTE(zandore @ Apr 18 2005, 02:45 PM)
QUOTE(LoVer_Of_GoD @ Apr 18 2005, 02:43 PM)
are u sure about that?
[right][snapback]577347[/snapback][/right]

Yes... She saved me from having to look it up.
[right][snapback]577352[/snapback][/right]


Yes, I can list a few of the similar myths if you want and some sources for dates of the gospels.

(oh, and just an aside, there were originally over 50 gospels considered for NT, but other years have been whittled down over the years by moinks, scribes and people in power to the 4 currently in the commonly accepted Bible.)
LoVer_Of_GoD
could it possibly be because they said the SAME THING??? what would have been the point in putting books in the bible that said the same thing? i honestly think we needed only one gospel.. it would have had the same meaning.
zandore
QUOTE(lightbeyondthedark Posted Today @ 02:47 PM )
I don't want to hear about odds... Theres a chance they could, and theres a chance they couldn't...
The odds are far far greater that they were illiterate.
LoVer_Of_GoD
maybe.. but they easily could have written and read...
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.