Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Altantis
Unexplained Mysteries Discussion Forums > Unexplained Mysteries > Ancient Mysteries & Alternative History
Pages: 1, 2, 3
Discordia
According to the continental drift theory, all the continents fit together, like a jigsaw puzzle. If you look at a map, you will see that the continents really do fit together- with the exception of the USA in North America and Western Europe. Could Atlantis be the missing piece? Source

Many scriptures throught history share the story of the "Great Flood" Could this have resulted in the continental drift? Think about all the lost civilizations discovered already that are under water. I am not sure wether they have discovered anything there yet, but it could be buried underneath the ocean floor.

[attachmentid=14239]
Atlantis's location based on Ignatius Donnelly's book, Atlantis: The Antediluvian World.

So if I am correct, tha'd put it here...(assuming the theory of pangea)
[attachmentid=14240]

So any suggestions or other theories? I know there has been numerous posts on Atlantis before, and if this one has been done before, sorry.

aquatus1
Continental drift is caused by plates of unimaginable mass and size being moved by currents in a lake of molten rock the size of the planet Earth. No great flood is ever going to move one of these babies.

The other problem is that island (not continent) of Atlantis, like all the other land masses, would be, essentially, along for the ride. Even if it did exist once and was inundated, the sea-mount would still be there. If you can find a sea-floor map of the Hawaian Islands region, you can see a series of sea-mounts that used to be the Hawaian Islands stretching back for thousands of miles (and even making a right-angle turn when the continental movement shifted!)
Discordia
aquatus1 your right about the plate movements, The flood wouldn't have caused them. I don't know what possessed me to say that. What I mean is; After the great flood took place, did it bury Atlantis? And if so, with time and the plates shifting, could it be buried deep within the ocean.
Shaftsbury
What you are talking about is called plate tectonics, and if you look at a map of the world as it was during the Permian period (225 million years ago) you will see that the continents fit nicely together into one big supercontinent called Pangaea.


Plate Tectonics - Pangaea Continent Maps
marduk
QUOTE(Shaftsbury @ Apr 29 2005, 04:09 PM)
What you are talking about is called plate tectonics, and if you look at a map of the world as it was during the Permian period (225 million years ago) you will see that the continents fit nicely together into one big supercontinent called Pangaea.


Plate Tectonics - Pangaea Continent Maps
[right][snapback]596696[/snapback][/right]

oh ffs you guys.
even plato said that his story was fictional
there was never an atlantis
it doesn't exist
of course i'm sure you've all seen the hundreds of examples of atlantean art and coinage and thats whats driving this nonsense forwards right ?
speculation is sometimes useful
speculating over something that doesn't nor has ever existed is pointless
Conspiracy
there could be a atlantis, and it does prove there was once civilizations which are now buried underwater, long ago water wasnt as high, so there was alot more land showing, some civilizations were built on those banks and when the water levels rose again 'the great flood' it wiped out those city's/civilizations, theres some going from the carribean to japan to even india and some near europe, so maybe atlantis does exist just its ruins havnt been found under water yet.
marduk
QUOTE(Conspiracy @ Apr 29 2005, 05:31 PM)
there could be a atlantis, and it does prove there was once civilizations which are now buried underwater, long ago water wasnt as high, so there was alot more land showing, some civilizations were built on those banks and when the water levels rose again 'the great flood' it wiped out those city's/civilizations, theres some going from the carribean to japan to even india and some near europe, so maybe atlantis does exist just its ruins havnt been found under water yet.
[right][snapback]596861[/snapback][/right]

or maybe you're just delusional and unsure of your facts ?
shall we vote ?
w00t.gif w00t.gif w00t.gif
one last time then
plato is the only source for the atlantis myth in the history of this planet
plato was a philosopher
philosophers tell stories to teach good behaviour
understand yet ?
The Roswell Man
trust me marduk, this will run and run.
until sum1 says they found 'antlantis' treasure and whereabouts of the place
then u might be screwed
u neva know, stranger things have happened... hmm.gif ohmy.gif
marduk
QUOTE(The Roswell Man @ Apr 29 2005, 05:41 PM)
trust me marduk, this will run and run.
until sum1 says they found 'antlantis' treasure and whereabouts of the place
then u might be screwed
u neva know, stranger things have happened... hmm.gif  ohmy.gif
[right][snapback]596886[/snapback][/right]

"then u might be screwed"
now you're getting me all excited
hehe w00t.gif
Discordia
Well Marduk, the ancient Sumerians was first believed to be a myth until they finally discovered it was real and obviously you know a lot about them considering thats where your name came from. Yes there are a lot of myths out there, but sometimes you have to read between the lines, there are truths to some of them. So I do believe Atlantis exists, even Edgar Casey, a christian prophet believes that it existed. And here we go again! lol We are good at one thing; disagreeing. laugh.gif
marduk
QUOTE(Discordia @ Apr 29 2005, 10:07 PM)
Well Marduk, the ancient Sumerians was first believed to be a myth until they finally discovered it was real and obviously you know a lot about them considering thats where your name came from. Yes there are a lot of myths out there, but sometimes you have to read between the lines, there are truths to some of them. So I do believe Atlantis exists, even Edgar Casey, a christian prophet believes that it existed. And here we go again! lol We are good at one thing; disagreeing.  laugh.gif
[right][snapback]597680[/snapback][/right]

the ancient sumerians were never thought to be mythical
my name is babylonian
plato didnt believe in the existence of atlantis. why do you
edgar cayce stated that atlantis would be uncovered in the 60s
you remember the headline from back then " Atlantis found at last"
no neither do i
you're right we'll probably keep disagreeing for a long time
at least until you actually say something factual
hehehe
w00t.gif thumbsup.gif grin2.gif
Discordia
QUOTE(marduk @ Apr 29 2005, 01:09 PM)
you're right we'll probably keep disagreeing for a long time
at least until you actually say something factual
hehehe
w00t.gif  thumbsup.gif  grin2.gif
[right][snapback]597687[/snapback][/right]



Lol! I will bite my tongue on that comment, cos I am a nice american. original.gif
Anyways, criticism is good as long as it's not insulting, you walk a very thin line on that. laugh.gif

I remember reading something about people believing the sumerians were a myth. thumbsup.gif

marduk
QUOTE(Discordia @ Apr 30 2005, 01:27 AM)
QUOTE(marduk @ Apr 29 2005, 01:09 PM)
you're right we'll probably keep disagreeing for a long time
at least until you actually say something factual
hehehe
w00t.gif  thumbsup.gif  grin2.gif
[right][snapback]597687[/snapback][/right]



Lol! I will bite my tongue on that comment, cos I am a nice american. original.gif
Anyways, criticism is good as long as it's not insulting, you walk a very thin line on that. laugh.gif

I remember reading something about people believing the sumerians were a myth. thumbsup.gif
[right][snapback]598042[/snapback][/right]

you're quite right i walk right on the line
its the best way to make a point when you're talking to someone who's really really wrong in most of their comments
present company excepted
see
easy peasy
w00t.gif thumbsup.gif
Discordia
QUOTE(marduk @ Apr 29 2005, 04:31 PM)
QUOTE(Discordia @ Apr 30 2005, 01:27 AM)
QUOTE(marduk @ Apr 29 2005, 01:09 PM)
you're right we'll probably keep disagreeing for a long time
at least until you actually say something factual
hehehe
w00t.gif  thumbsup.gif  grin2.gif
[right][snapback]597687[/snapback][/right]



Lol! I will bite my tongue on that comment, cos I am a nice american. original.gif
Anyways, criticism is good as long as it's not insulting, you walk a very thin line on that. laugh.gif

I remember reading something about people believing the sumerians were a myth. thumbsup.gif
[right][snapback]598042[/snapback][/right]

you're quite right i walk right on the line
its the best way to make a point when you're talking to someone who's really really wrong in most of their comments
present company excepted
see
easy peasy
w00t.gif thumbsup.gif
[right][snapback]598047[/snapback][/right]


You british people are so mouthy. grin2.gif
Stellar
Maybe theEven if there is no Atlantis, there could still be a sunken civilization who's story resembles Atlantis (at least in the "huge amazing culture who sunk" part)... and thats why I think things like this persist.
marduk
how can a civilisation be huge if its all contained on one island
if america disappeared in a day and a night like atlantis was supposed to then we'd still know it was there because of all the americana around the world
just a little suspicious that nothing has ever been found stamped with "made in atlantis"
you think ??
aquatus1
QUOTE(Discordia @ Apr 29 2005, 03:07 PM)
aquatus1 your right about the plate movements, The flood wouldn't have caused them. I don't know what possessed me to say that. What I mean is; After the great flood took place, did it bury Atlantis? And if so, with time and the plates shifting, could it be buried deep within the ocean.
[right][snapback]596689[/snapback][/right]


Okay, well, making the assumption that two things which have no evidence of having ever occurred or existed (and that have much evidence that they didn't occur) did actually happen, my second point would still apply.

Islands, to say nothing of continents, do not simply disappear. They may sink, the get get covered over with water, they may get washed out, but an island (and a continent) is much, much more, than simply what one sees on the surface. To completely delete the existance of the island of Atlantis, you not only have to destroy the island itself, you also have to destroy the entire volcanic basalt sea-mount, all hundreds of feet of it that went from the bottom of the ocean all the way to the top. If Atlantis did indeed exist, despite Plato's claim that it was fictional, and it was placed before the gates of Herakles, despite many who would ignore that in favor of claiming the math was wrong, we should still be able to find a sea-mount somewhere in that vicinity. Even the real Great Flood, the flooding of the Meditarranean Basin, would not have destroyed a seamount like that.
marduk
QUOTE(aquatus1 @ Apr 30 2005, 04:01 PM)
QUOTE(Discordia @ Apr 29 2005, 03:07 PM)
aquatus1 your right about the plate movements, The flood wouldn't have caused them. I don't know what possessed me to say that. What I mean is; After the great flood took place, did it bury Atlantis? And if so, with time and the plates shifting, could it be buried deep within the ocean.
[right][snapback]596689[/snapback][/right]


Okay, well, making the assumption that two things which have no evidence of having ever occurred or existed (and that have much evidence that they didn't occur) did actually happen, my second point would still apply.

Islands, to say nothing of continents, do not simply disappear. They may sink, the get get covered over with water, they may get washed out, but an island (and a continent) is much, much more, than simply what one sees on the surface. To completely delete the existance of the island of Atlantis, you not only have to destroy the island itself, you also have to destroy the entire volcanic basalt sea-mount, all hundreds of feet of it that went from the bottom of the ocean all the way to the top. If Atlantis did indeed exist, despite Plato's claim that it was fictional, and it was placed before the gates of Herakles, despite many who would ignore that in favor of claiming the math was wrong, we should still be able to find a sea-mount somewhere in that vicinity. Even the real Great Flood, the flooding of the Meditarranean Basin, would not have destroyed a seamount like that.
[right][snapback]598621[/snapback][/right]

you forgot to add that it wasn't just an island.
plato said it was bigger than two continents
libya and asia
baastetnoir
There is another Theory that says Atlantis could have been located somewhere in the Portuguese Azores Island ???

Atlantis in Azores ?

Lost Atlantis

Possible Capital of Atlantis has described by Platos
CApital

taking that Azores is in the Atalntic Ocean, i would agree with the high possibility ...Atlantis/Atlantic ????
marduk
QUOTE(baastetnoir @ Apr 30 2005, 06:36 PM)
There is another Theory that says Atlantis could have been located somewhere in the Portuguese Azores Island ???

Atlantis in Azores ?

Lost Atlantis

Possible Capital of Atlantis has described by Platos
CApital

taking that Azores is in the Atalntic Ocean, i would agree with the high possibility ...Atlantis/Atlantic ????
[right][snapback]598805[/snapback][/right]

shows what you know then don't it
no.gif no.gif no.gif w00t.gif
aquatus1
QUOTE(marduk @ Apr 30 2005, 04:32 PM)
you forgot to add that it wasn't just an island.
plato said it was bigger than two continents
libya and asia
[right][snapback]598738[/snapback][/right]


I didn't forget, I simply don't agree with it. The translation can either be "larger", or "greater" than the rest of the known world, but considering how Atlantis is referred to on several different occasion as being an island in front of the Pillars of Herakles (one of a few actually), and that there simply isn't room for anything of that size there, or anywhere in the Mediterranean ocean, I follow more the theory that by "greater", Plato was referring to power and influence, not physical size.
Undefined_innocence
QUOTE(Discordia @ Apr 29 2005, 07:35 PM)
QUOTE(marduk @ Apr 29 2005, 04:31 PM)
QUOTE(Discordia @ Apr 30 2005, 01:27 AM)
QUOTE(marduk @ Apr 29 2005, 01:09 PM)
you're right we'll probably keep disagreeing for a long time
at least until you actually say something factual
hehehe
w00t.gif  thumbsup.gif  grin2.gif
[right][snapback]597687[/snapback][/right]



Lol! I will bite my tongue on that comment, cos I am a nice american. original.gif
Anyways, criticism is good as long as it's not insulting, you walk a very thin line on that. laugh.gif

I remember reading something about people believing the sumerians were a myth. thumbsup.gif
[right][snapback]598042[/snapback][/right]

you're quite right i walk right on the line
its the best way to make a point when you're talking to someone who's really really wrong in most of their comments
present company excepted
see
easy peasy
w00t.gif thumbsup.gif
[right][snapback]598047[/snapback][/right]


You british people are so mouthy. grin2.gif
[right][snapback]598054[/snapback][/right]


Marduk is always mouthy and rude. And just to place my two cents in.. i believe it existed. Maybe not to the standards that hight that everyones places on it, but that it existed in some way.
Stixxman
QUOTE(marduk @ Apr 30 2005, 02:38 AM)
how can a civilisation be huge if its all contained on one island
if america disappeared in a day and a night like atlantis was supposed to then we'd still know it was there because of all the americana around the world
just a little suspicious that nothing has ever been found stamped with "made in atlantis"
you think ??
[right][snapback]598425[/snapback][/right]

Maybe the theortical Atlantis was a single global civilization that encompassed all the races of man. Maybe the great flood seperated them and what we see today is the remnants that survived..and developed along a different path that emphassied segregation, I dont know. While I am not an Atlantis believer I am a believer in pre-human history. thumbsup.gif
Discordia
QUOTE(Undefined_innocence @ May 2 2005, 12:06 PM)
QUOTE(Discordia @ Apr 29 2005, 07:35 PM)
QUOTE(marduk @ Apr 29 2005, 04:31 PM)
QUOTE(Discordia @ Apr 30 2005, 01:27 AM)
QUOTE(marduk @ Apr 29 2005, 01:09 PM)
you're right we'll probably keep disagreeing for a long time
at least until you actually say something factual
hehehe
w00t.gif  thumbsup.gif  grin2.gif
[right][snapback]597687[/snapback][/right]



Lol! I will bite my tongue on that comment, cos I am a nice american. original.gif
Anyways, criticism is good as long as it's not insulting, you walk a very thin line on that. laugh.gif

I remember reading something about people believing the sumerians were a myth. thumbsup.gif
[right][snapback]598042[/snapback][/right]

you're quite right i walk right on the line
its the best way to make a point when you're talking to someone who's really really wrong in most of their comments
present company excepted
see
easy peasy
w00t.gif thumbsup.gif
[right][snapback]598047[/snapback][/right]


You british people are so mouthy. grin2.gif
[right][snapback]598054[/snapback][/right]


Marduk is always mouthy and rude. And just to place my two cents in.. i believe it existed. Maybe not to the standards that hight that everyones places on it, but that it existed in some way.
[right][snapback]601491[/snapback][/right]


Lol! Someone agrees with me tongue.gif

Also, thanks to everyone who has posted here, there are some interesting theories.
Undefined_innocence
Yah.. i just dont usually point out something like that unless i see need to .. hehe.
I myself like reading new theroys on all kinds of things. I mean.. scientist cant be right all the time.
The Roswell Man
yo we brits betta stick 2gether here grin2.gif tongue.gif laugh.gif
anyho, what intrigues me as marduk said, why is there no evidence of 'made in antlantis' artifacts or buildings that arent jus faked up to look so? huh.gif ohmy.gif
seems strange to me such an advanced civilization wont even bother leave the calling cards that they are around.
after all, wont plato have been given or know of anlantian 'gifts' or objects? hmm.gif disgust.gif yes.gif
Discordia
QUOTE(The Roswell Man @ May 3 2005, 06:34 AM)
yo we brits betta stick 2gether here  grin2.gif  tongue.gif  laugh.gif
anyho, what intrigues me as marduk said, why is there no evidence of 'made in antlantis' artifacts or buildings that arent jus faked up to look so? huh.gif  ohmy.gif
seems strange to me such an advanced civilization wont even bother leave the calling cards that they are around.
after all, wont plato have been given or know of anlantian 'gifts' or objects? hmm.gif  disgust.gif  yes.gif
[right][snapback]602656[/snapback][/right]


Well think about everything we have today and thousands of years later. Do you think the people from the next time will really understand how "advanced" we supposedly are. A lot of things that are made today would be gone with no evidence that they existed. Keep in mind natural disasters that could occur such as floods etc..which would destroy a lot. Also, if Alantis is buried deep beneath the ocean, that would explain why there are no artifacts.
marduk
Yeah i see what you're saying,
so atlantis must have lived on in myths all over the world ?
hang on though seeing as its just plato that actually knew anything about it at all and as he himself said it was a fictional story to teach good behaviour then isn't it about time someone rang the alarm clock
wake up people
the only evidence we have of a civilisation that spanned the globe in 9500bce is one mans word,
everything you have ever heard written on the subject sprang from that.
theres no pottery
no atlantean language or writings
no atlantean art
no evidence of atlantean navigation
etc
etc
Any body know where Utopia is located or is that a silly question ?
w00t.gif w00t.gif w00t.gif
" Marduk is always mouthy and rude"
I see no evidence of that
w00t.gif thumbsup.gif thumbsup.gif grin2.gif
jjtss
[oh ffs you guys.
even plato said that his story was fictional
there was never an atlantis
it doesn't exist
of course i'm sure you've all seen the hundreds of examples of atlantean art and coinage and thats whats driving this nonsense forwards right ?
speculation is sometimes useful
speculating over something that doesn't nor has ever existed is pointless
[right][snapback]596760[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

NO NO NO NO NO no.gif no.gif no.gif no.gif

Plato did not say his story was fictional. He did say that he remembered it exactly as his father told it to him and was now passing it on as accurately as possible to preserve the memory of Atlantis and also to illustrate what happpens to a great nation when it become emeshed in its own greedy ambitions. hmm.gif




jjtss
Has anyone read Clive Cussler's "Atlantis Found"? Its great fiction but the foreword about the 7120BC Comet was fantastic nonfiction. It's a shame that he didn't provide a bibliography for that part. Would love to get some of the reference material. Anyway it is a rational explanation for the disappearance of Atlantis.
Discordia
WAKE UP PEOPLE!! The great Marduk has spoken! haha. Although for some reason this mystery has been around for ages, he obviously knows for sure that it didn't exist.
LucidElement
Yep im taking geology, and plate tectonics deffinitly were involved in the movement of the Earth. I do believe at tone time Atlantis was no doubt peiced together perfectly with the rest of the world, then it driffted apart, and then it sunk! we all need to jump in the water and swim around lol...
Essan
QUOTE(LucidElement @ May 4 2005, 08:53 AM)
Yep im taking geology, and plate tectonics deffinitly were involved in the movement of the Earth. I do believe at tone time Atlantis was no doubt peiced together perfectly with the rest of the world, then it driffted apart, and then it sunk! we all need to jump in the water and swim around lol...
[right][snapback]604086[/snapback][/right]


If you're studying plate tectonics you'll soon realise that's a geological impossibility original.gif

If Atlantis existed in may have been a coastal settlement, or small, low, island, flooded by rising sea levels after the Last Glacial Maximum. But any other idea is pure geological fantasy.

If you want to put a big landmass in the Atlantic you need first to completely re-write geophysics wink2.gif
marduk
QUOTE(Essan @ May 4 2005, 11:22 AM)
QUOTE(LucidElement @ May 4 2005, 08:53 AM)
Yep im taking geology, and plate tectonics deffinitly were involved in the movement of the Earth. I do believe at tone time Atlantis was no doubt peiced together perfectly with the rest of the world, then it driffted apart, and then it sunk! we all need to jump in the water and swim around lol...
[right][snapback]604086[/snapback][/right]


If you're studying plate tectonics you'll soon realise that's a geological impossibility original.gif

If Atlantis existed in may have been a coastal settlement, or small, low, island, flooded by rising sea levels after the Last Glacial Maximum. But any other idea is pure geological fantasy.

If you want to put a big landmass in the Atlantic you need first to completely re-write geophysics wink2.gif
[right][snapback]604139[/snapback][/right]

why not, they've already started rewriting history to fit it in.
why do some people go nuts everytime someone mentions the "A" word.
before you know it andy someones gonna mention hapgood as if he's some kind of holy grail and you know where we go from there,
bloody elephants and einstein again
is it just me or is it getting really samey in here
Essan
QUOTE(jjtss @ May 4 2005, 03:21 AM)
Has anyone read Clive Cussler's "Atlantis Found"?  Its great fiction but the foreword about the 7120BC Comet was fantastic nonfiction.  It's a shame that he didn't provide a bibliography for that part. 
[right][snapback]603875[/snapback][/right]


That's because he made it all up (although to be fair, some 'alternative' writers have also proposed similar, though equally unverifiable, events). As I've not read the book I can only guess he may have used the comet impact theory proposed by Chritopher Knight and Robert Lomas in Uriel's Machine - another book I've not read innocent.gif . Unfortunately the Greenland ice cores make it quite clear that no such impact occured. Leastways, not then.

Essan
QUOTE(marduk @ May 4 2005, 10:26 AM)
QUOTE(Essan @ May 4 2005, 11:22 AM)
QUOTE(LucidElement @ May 4 2005, 08:53 AM)
Yep im taking geology, and plate tectonics deffinitly were involved in the movement of the Earth. I do believe at tone time Atlantis was no doubt peiced together perfectly with the rest of the world, then it driffted apart, and then it sunk! we all need to jump in the water and swim around lol...
[right][snapback]604086[/snapback][/right]


If you're studying plate tectonics you'll soon realise that's a geological impossibility original.gif

If Atlantis existed in may have been a coastal settlement, or small, low, island, flooded by rising sea levels after the Last Glacial Maximum. But any other idea is pure geological fantasy.

If you want to put a big landmass in the Atlantic you need first to completely re-write geophysics wink2.gif
[right][snapback]604139[/snapback][/right]

why not, they've already started rewriting history to fit it in.
why do some people go nuts everytime someone mentions the "A" word.
before you know it andy someones gonna mention hapgood as if he's some kind of holy grail and you know where we go from there,
bloody elephants and einstein again
is it just me or is it getting really samey in here
[right][snapback]604143[/snapback][/right]



One day we'll convince the World that Atlantis was just a story.

But by then what's the betting folk believe that Hogwart's Castle really exists........ w00t.gif
marduk
"One day we'll convince the World that Atlantis was just a story."
nah Plato did that,
"But by then what's the betting folk believe that Hogwart's Castle really exists........ "
i have noticed that you are naturally predisposed to mention childrens books in your postings at this adult forum. lol
did you read any good blyton lately, she rocks
aquatus1
QUOTE(jjtss @ May 4 2005, 03:16 AM)
NO NO NO NO NO no.gif  no.gif  no.gif  no.gif
Plato did not say his story was fictional.  He did say that he remembered it exactly as his father told it to him and was now passing it on as accurately as possible to preserve the memory of Atlantis and also to illustrate what happpens to a great nation when it become emeshed in its own greedy ambitions.    hmm.gif
[right][snapback]603872[/snapback][/right]


You've never read either Timaeus or Criteas, have you?

I encourage you to do it. Timaeus is only half-a-page on Atlantis, and Criteas is only 8 pages long. Really, it isn't a difficult read, and it would certainly clear up a lot of the nonsense one hears about Atlantians being peaceful, global, or even real.

Plato is not the one telling the story of Atlantis. He is hearing it from an Egyptian priest (yes, that is part of the story as well; not the source of the story, just part of the story). And Plato does outright say "The story that you yesterday recounted to us as fiction, today we will impose to reality", meaning that the fictional story of Atlantis was going to be used as a metaphor for Athens.
The Roswell Man
probs is, u can say antlantis isnt real till ur blue in the face, but some ppl will keep believing it regardless none the less..... disgust.gif sad.gif
just matter of the belief system. blink.gif
marduk
QUOTE(The Roswell Man @ May 4 2005, 03:45 PM)
probs is, u can say antlantis isnt real to ur blue in the face, but some ppl will keep believing it regardless none the less..... disgust.gif  sad.gif
just fact of life. blink.gif
[right][snapback]604375[/snapback][/right]

a fact is just about the last thing it is roswell, life or otherwise
w00t.gif w00t.gif
baastetnoir
QUOTE(marduk @ May 3 2005, 07:46 PM)

everything you have ever heard written on the subject sprang from that.
theres no pottery
no atlantean language or writings
no atlantean art
no evidence of atlantean navigation
etc
etc

well if it was destoryed by a volcano it would be very hard if not impossible to find anything

QUOTE
" Marduk is always mouthy and rude"
I see no evidence of that
w00t.gif  thumbsup.gif  thumbsup.gif  grin2.gif
[right][snapback]603522[/snapback][/right]


Marduk isnt rude,... he is just cranky rolleyes.gif tongue.gif wink2.gif
The Roswell Man
when ppl cum up with the same bullcrap stuff theories and such, wont u? tongue.gif grin2.gif
baastetnoir
QUOTE(The Roswell Man @ May 4 2005, 04:21 PM)
when ppl cum up with the same bullcrap stuff theories and such, wont u? tongue.gif  grin2.gif
[right][snapback]604975[/snapback][/right]



lol...probably ... wink2.gif
marduk
QUOTE(baastetnoir @ May 4 2005, 09:37 PM)
QUOTE(The Roswell Man @ May 4 2005, 04:21 PM)
when ppl cum up with the same bullcrap stuff theories and such, wont u? tongue.gif  grin2.gif
[right][snapback]604975[/snapback][/right]



lol...probably ... wink2.gif
[right][snapback]604998[/snapback][/right]

"well if it was destoryed by a volcano it would be very hard if not impossible to find anything "
sigh
if i say one last time once more i'm gonna go green and start splitting things, not neccesarily my trousers
so
one last time
plato described atlantis as a super culture
it was based on an island the size of two continents
it navigated every ocean on earth
it traded with every culture on earth (despite the fact that in 9000bce there weren't any)
modern day america is a good comparison
if america got wiped out overnight there would be masses of evidence that it existed
why isn't there any evidence that atlantis existed except for platos account?
because as even plato said it was FICTION
you can't take just a small part of platos account and then prune away all the bits that don't fit.
Not unless you want me cranky
w00t.gif w00t.gif
baastetnoir
QUOTE(marduk @ May 4 2005, 06:36 PM)
Not unless you want me cranky
w00t.gif  w00t.gif
[right][snapback]605221[/snapback][/right]


Marduk you know you look the best when you're cranky ... The crankier the better !!! w00t.gif kiss.gif

lol
Undefined_innocence
opinion. Opinion. OPINION!!

People are going to think what they want to think.

ALWAYS.

I lean in no direction on this. I think it could be true. Just maybe not to the extent that t was brought forth. But anyhow. Thats me. MY OPINION!
Discordia
QUOTE(Undefined_innocence @ May 4 2005, 06:14 PM)
opinion. Opinion. OPINION!!

People are going to think what they want to think.

ALWAYS.

I lean in no direction on this. I think it could be true. Just maybe not to the extent that t was brought forth. But anyhow. Thats me. MY OPINION!
[right][snapback]605613[/snapback][/right]


I agree, but it is fun to look at different theories and such. So I don't really care what Marduk has to say, I respect his opinion, as well as all others. Even though he probably doesn't respect mine. tongue.gif
jjtss
]

That's because he made it all up (although to be fair, some 'alternative' writers have also proposed similar, though equally unverifiable, events). As I've not read the book I can only guess he may have used the comet impact theory proposed by Chritopher Knight and Robert Lomas in Uriel's Machine - another book I've not read innocent.gif . Unfortunately the Greenland ice cores make it quite clear that no such impact occured. Leastways, not then.
[right][snapback]604148[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

OK!! Thanx!! I'll just stick with the Laurentian Dan meltdown for Catastrophic explanations in prehistory. blush.gif
marduk
QUOTE(Discordia @ May 5 2005, 03:45 AM)
QUOTE(Undefined_innocence @ May 4 2005, 06:14 PM)
opinion. Opinion. OPINION!!

People are going to think what they want to think.

ALWAYS.

I lean in no direction on this. I think it could be true. Just maybe not to the extent that t was brought forth. But anyhow. Thats me. MY OPINION!
[right][snapback]605613[/snapback][/right]


I agree, but it is fun to look at different theories and such. So I don't really care what Marduk has to say, I respect his opinion, as well as all others. Even though he probably doesn't respect mine. tongue.gif
[right][snapback]605658[/snapback][/right]

ooh thats harsh.
i respect everything and everyone, but when people come along with opinions based on complete fallacies what am i supposed to do
what would a friend do if you told her that throwing yourself under the wheels of a bus would make you rich. would she try and talk sense into you.
see i'm just trying to stop your intellect get crushed.
w00t.gif w00t.gif
The Roswell Man
ahhhh, i thought the pressure in my brain was building up too much... w00t.gif w00t.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.