Basically you rate the person above you's signature. You rate them out-of-five on creativity, out-of-five on style, out-of-five on humour, out-of-five on wisdom and out-of-twenty overall. IYW include a reason

Nobody ever reads signatures-- now for once they can get attention!

EXAMPLE FORMAT:

Creativity: 0/5
Style: 0/5
Humour: 0/5
Wisdom: 0/5
Overall: 00/20

Galor, this was a long ongoing topic that was closed not to long ago since it was pretty pointless.
You can see the closed topic here:
http://www.unexplained-mysteries.com/forum...c=14154&st=2280

We don't need a repeat of that topic.