Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Egypt demands return of Rosetta Stone
Unexplained Mysteries Discussion Forums > News, Media & World Events > Back Page News
Starlyte
user posted imageEgypt is demanding that the 2000-year-old Rosetta Stone be returned to Cairo and has threatened to pursue its claim "aggressively" if the British Museum does not agree to give it back. The stone, which became the key to deciphering Egyptian hieroglyphics, was found by Napoleon's army in 1799 in the Nile delta, but has been in Britain for 200 years. "If the British want to be remembered, if they want to restore their reputation, they should volunteer to return the Rosetta Stone because it is the icon of our Egyptian identity," said Zahi Hawass, director of the Supreme Council of Antiquities in Cairo. He has begun negotiations with the museum.

"Otherwise I will have to approach them using a different strategy . . . the artefacts stolen from Egypt must come back." Dr Hawass said he had been discussing a three-month loan to the Cairo Museum, before the stone's permanent return to Egypt. The Rosetta Stone, which dates from 196 BC, was discovered in 1799 in the western delta of the Nile. The stone provided a key to understanding hieroglyphic text because it was accompanied by a Greek translation. The French ceded it to Britain under the Treaty of Alexandria in 1801 and it has been exhibited in the British Museum since 1802.

user posted image View: Full Article | Source: smh.com.au
Bizarro
hmm. don't know how i feel about this one. seems like the British earned it from the French in a treaty. i know its originally from Egypt, but maybe they should have held onto it from the beginning. if we give back the artifacts taken through questionable means, we should just give them all back. kind of like sour grapes to whine about it now.
snuffypuffer
QUOTE (DSchwartz @ Jul 22 2003, 03:25 PM)
hmm. don't know how i feel about this one. seems like the British earned it from the French in a treaty. i know its originally from Egypt, but maybe they should have held onto it from the beginning. if we give back the artifacts taken through questionable means, we should just give them all back. kind of like sour grapes to whine about it now.

exactly, why bring it up now, after 200 years?
Sukato-San
Hell, if they start here, then pretty much everything of Egyptian origin will have to go back. The Rosetta stone isn't worth anything, not like the treasures that the Brits and the Americans have from Egypt, it seems odd that Egypt would want that back and not King Tut's sar... sarcoguh... you know what I mean. wacko.gif

Of course, don't think I'm taking anything away from the huge importance of the Rosetta stone in the historical sense... wink2.gif
Aslan
QUOTE
Hell, if they start here, then pretty much everything of Egyptian origin will have to go back.


This is true. The British Museum for one is just packed to the rafters with important artefacts that were stolen in an imperial-age thievery drive - countless Egyptian treaures, the Elgin Marbles (a fair chunk of the parthenon, actually), the Rosetta Stone itself, the Ishtar Gate...it's an unbelievable testament to the nineteenth century's philosophy of we're-more-powerful-than-you-so-we're-having-this.

I'm kind of in two minds about it. On the one hand I appreciate that it's part of Egypt's cultural heritage; but on the other hand I think it's better off where it is. The British Museum is one of the world's best, and people visit it (for free) to experience a vast array of world history, interestingly arranged, well preserved, and informatively labelled. There are very few places where you can see so many famous artefacts from so many different cultures all in one location.

Plus which it was a couple of centuries ago. Time makes a difference to everything. Two hundred years is maybe a bit late to start bothering about something to the point where you want it back.

I'm biased though. I once spent seven hours in the British museum looking for three lost students, and it was the best day I'd had all year.

This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.