Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Why Christianity MUST Change or Die
Unexplained Mysteries Discussion Forums > Unexplained Mysteries > Spirituality vs Skepticism
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
zandore
Hyper I never thought of it put to a poison/serum analog. grin2.gif thumbsup.gif
starlitkate
I've deleted my posts because it's off topic and doesnt go with what is previsouly being discussed on this posts. original.gif
Charlie_0978
QUOTE(etvisitor7 @ Sep 23 2005, 08:17 PM) [snapback]859223[/snapback]

innocent.gif Christianity, as it exists today, must change greatly or risk dying out. This is the conviction of thousands of people today who love the original message of Jesus, but who are repelled by the gross distortions passed off as "the Word of God" by the fundamentalist and narrow-minded churches.
Have any of you heard of John Shelby Spong, the controversial retired Bishop of Newark, New Jersey? If anyone can put HEART back into Christianity, he can! A strong proponent of Christian Reformation, he bravely champions the rights of gays and lesbians, the right of priests to marry if they wish, and the right of women to be priests. His book "Living in Sin" argues convincingly against the absurd fundamentalist belief that sex before marriage is sinful. Also, he totally rejects the doctrine of Original Sin.
According to John S. Spong, "In many of its details, the Bible is simply WRONG!" He says that, throughout history, the Bible has often been used to justify war, slavery, segregation and apartheid. "It defines women as inferior creatures and suggests that homosexual persons be put to death." Spong says the Bible is NOT the literal Word of God. As for me, I would say that it is a mixture of spiritual inspiration and guidance, human opinions (such as St Paul's attitude to women, and his condemnation of homosexuals), mistranslations, misinterpretations, and the history of the chosen people as they slaughtered thousands of men, women and children in the Name of their vengeful God.
John Spong also speaks out against the Church's protection of abusive priests, and against the hypocrisy of the Religious Right in politics. His books on Progressive Christianity (about 15 of them) include "Rescuing the Bible from Fundamentalism", "Liberating the Gospels", "Why Christianity must Change or Die", and "The Sins of Scripture".
Anyone interested in reading more can visit these links:
www.dioceseofnewark.org/jsspong
www.bishopspong.com
.............................................................. Namaste, Mark


who are you to say Christianity must change..people just try to adjust Christianity to their human desires to have sex etc..they want to mold religion to their convinience and that would be to distort the original religion besides if you cant embrace something that has rules thats something but trying to change it into something else just to say you are not doing anything wrong thats sick.


QUOTE(joc @ Sep 23 2005, 08:29 PM) [snapback]859244[/snapback]

I suggest you read the Bible yourself and draw your own conclusions....not adhere blindly to what ANY theologian espouses....they all have their own agendas....and more oft than not, their agenda is not Gods's agenda...



good post..
etvisitor7
QUOTE(stillcrazy @ Sep 24 2005, 04:59 AM) [snapback]859575[/snapback]

That's what I was trying to get at.

Many of these bible thumpers, such as WBC pick and choose scriptures to justify what they teach. Anyone who takes the time to study the bible, or any holy book for that matter, and not just what some guy or gal in a suit says is in the bible, I think there would be a lot less problems with folks faith.

It was asked of joc, but I'll respond to the question as well.

Gay coupling.

I can, condemn the behavior, but cannot condemn the person. This applies to all sins. And must treat the person as I would any other.


Still Crazy, Gay coupling is NOT a sin. It is merely another form of sexual expression, amongst a wide variety of expressions existing today. True love can be expressed through gay sexuality, just as it can through heterosexuality, bisexuality, polygamy, polyfidelity, polyamory, or even group marriage. Love is always love, no matter what form it takes, sexual or otherwise!
Gay coupling is one form of True Love expression; therefore, how can it be a sin? Since God is Love, this means that, whenever a lesbian makes love with another lesbian, God (Love) is expressing through that gay couple! Gay sexual love cannot be a sin because it does not go against God who IS Love! How can love be a sin when that is God's True Nature?
Jesus said, "Judge not, that you be not judged." But so many Christians are passing judgement everytime they condemn gay sexuality and call it a 'sin'. They pass judgement on sex before marriage; they pass judgement on women by saying that they cannot be priests; they even pass judgement on sexuality itself by not allowing priests to marry, because they think that sex prevents them from reaching complete unity with God. Sex is judged as being an obstacle to deep communion with God. innocent.gif
etvisitor7
QUOTE(Sheri berri @ Sep 24 2005, 05:08 AM) [snapback]859589[/snapback]

Joc, Its discrimination no matter how you slice it and thats what the bible stands for , i don't understand why if people want o try anpther way there is so much resistance , Fear is the greatest tool of control man has ever devised and guilt and religion uses them on there followers go ahead beleive what you wish but not everyone is afraid . Namaste Sheri


Yes indeed, Sheri, wisely said! Discrimination by any other name smells just as foul. When will all these judgemental religious people come to realize how much suffering they create with all this talk of gay sex being sinful? Don't they understand that their judgemental behaviour goes against all that Jesus stood for? Jesus said, "Love one another", and "judge not, that you be not judged", but many narrow-minded Christians cannot see that gays ARE loving one another in their sexual couplings. And those very same Christians ARE judging others when they call gay sex a 'sin'. And all this judgement inevitably leads to violence and discrimination against gays and lesbians.
Tangerine Sheri
Mark Very well put and this needs to be said over and over until it is understood, Love is never "Wrong" when it is between two consenting people, I can't really add to your post because you put it so perfectly, Religion has got to grow up and except responsibility that their narrow view of "God " is keeping the world in the state of stagnation and division and I want add that religion is soley responsible for the discrimination and awful treatment towards half the population, the feminine expression,
Tangerine Sheri
QUOTE(Sheri berri @ Sep 24 2005, 04:44 PM) [snapback]860499[/snapback]

I don't know how many ways this can be said the only god there is is the imaginings of mens minds,
PA i was making a blanket staement that the bible is discriminitory across the board, a word on GRACE Pa grace is the beautyy that permeates all of the universe and includes the inhabitants , grace is the feminine essence of the feminine the strength of the masculine, the movement of the waves the vivdness of the sunset, i understand how you are interpreting it and you religous folk think that the bible is the end all philosophy on the universe and its meanings its one philosophy and a very poor one at that , the philosophy in the bible has nothing to do with intuitive understanding its a manual on how to be a martyr IMO Namaste sheri



PA I am very aware of grace, because it doesn't fit the biblical understanding of Grace doesn't mean there are no other possible definitions my understanding of grace is based on personal experience not a text book definition, no one understands grace better than a woman .grace is the inherent quality of any woman PA maybe it is you who does not understand Grace?.Just something to ponder.Namaste sheri
stillcrazy
QUOTE
Still Crazy, Gay coupling is NOT a sin. It is merely another form of sexual expression, amongst a wide variety of expressions existing today. True love can be expressed through gay sexuality, just as it can through heterosexuality, bisexuality, polygamy, polyfidelity, polyamory, or even group marriage. Love is always love, no matter what form it takes, sexual or otherwise!


I will disagree with you on this. For two reasons. Where do you draw the line? Does it make Incest okay when the victim thinks, through convincing of the other party, that sex with a family member is okay. Does it make pedophilia okay because the victim is convinced that the other party is doing it out of love.

I do not have to condone the behavior, but I can not, and will not condemn the person. As that is not my place. I will not dissolve my friendships with people I know who are gay.

Sheri Berri, I will be the first to tell you the Bible is sexist, in a modern way. It places all the responsibility for providing for and teaching the family on the male. It places certain responsibilities of child rearing on the female. It also places sexual responsiblity equally on both.
Tangerine Sheri
QUOTE(stillcrazy @ Sep 25 2005, 05:45 PM) [snapback]861625[/snapback]

I will disagree with you on this. For two reasons. Where do you draw the line? Does it make Incest okay when the victim thinks, through convincing of the other party, that sex with a family member is okay. Does it make pedophilia okay because the victim is convinced that the other party is doing it out of love.

I do not have to condone the behavior, but I can not, and will not condemn the person. As that is not my place. I will not dissolve my friendships with people I know who are gay.

Sheri Berri, I will be the first to tell you the Bible is sexist, in a modern way. It places all the responsibility for providing for and teaching the family on the male. It places certain responsibilities of child rearing on the female. It also places sexual responsiblity equally on both.



Still Crazy
IMO Incest, and sexual deviant behavior does not stem from a healthy understanding and a respect for ones sexual nature , it comes from denying that the sexual nature is natural, IMO we draw the line by teaching that our sexual nature is a gift and beautiful and an expression of love in the Physical. When someone is taught that there sexual nature is "bad" wrong vile vulgar to be denied you can guareentee you are creating a sexual deviancy, unwanted pregnancys , rapists etc. Religion is soley responsible for defining and mandating the way ones sexual nature is to be embraced, If you beleive that the sex act is the most loving beautiful act between two people (consenting) you will act in accordance with it, if you are taught it is wrong and "bad' and something that can get out of control and is evil in intent. you will also embrace behaviors that reflect that. It is often misunderstood by religon that the origins of the problems we have in the crimes of a sexual nature are lack of self control and denial of the sexual nature isn't strong enough but the problem is the beleifs that are taught!f change the beeliefs you change the behavior, you will never change behavior thru the behavior itself, Religon is stagnate in its understanding and denies its responsibility in creating the problems to begin with, It would empower religion to admit that they are wrong in there approach to sexuality, people aspire to be what they are told they are, any parent will tell you that. Namaste Sherii
GIDEON MAGE
i have read the n.t., and conclude that yeshu was simply teaching judiasm. If christians would go back to observing the commandments, and remember that yeshu said they were not to be changed, they can eat kosher food and observe god's sabbath, so i think it would be wonderful if christians would give fundamentalist nonsense and follow Yeshu's teachings. it reminds me of the old rhyme.
"roses are red,
violets are bluish,
if it weren't for Yeshu,
we'd all be jewish."

of course, it was "St.Paul" who really took Yeshu's teachings and first twisted them all around.
Turtle
QUOTE(stillcrazy @ Sep 25 2005, 08:45 PM) [snapback]861625[/snapback]

I do not have to condone the behavior, but I can not, and will not condemn the person. As that is not my place. I will not dissolve my friendships with people I know who are gay.


And how many do you know that are gay that you befriended knowing they were gay?

QUOTE(Sheri berri @ Sep 25 2005, 09:19 PM) [snapback]861651[/snapback]

Still Crazy
IMO Incest, and sexual deviant behavior does not stem from a healthy understanding and a respect for ones sexual nature , it comes from denying that the sexual nature is natural, IMO we draw the line by teaching that our sexual nature is a gift and beautiful and an expression of love in the Physical. When someone is taught that there sexual nature is "bad" wrong vile vulgar to be denied you can guareentee you are creating a sexual deviancy, unwanted pregnancys , rapists etc. Religion is soley responsible for defining and mandating the way ones sexual nature is to be embraced, If you beleive that the sex act is the most loving beautiful act between two people (consenting) you will act in accordance with it, if you are taught it is wrong and "bad' and something that can get out of control and is evil in intent. you will also embrace behaviors that reflect that. It is often misunderstood by religon that the origins of the problems we have in the crimes of a sexual nature are lack of self control and denial of the sexual nature isn't strong enough but the problem is the beleifs that are taught!f change the beeliefs you change the behavior, you will never change behavior thru the behavior itself, Religon is stagnate in its understanding and denies its responsibility in creating the problems to begin with, It would empower religion to admit that they are wrong in there approach to sexuality, people aspire to be what they are told they are, any parent will tell you that. Namaste Sherii


Extremely well said IMLO
Take a bow.
thumbsup.gif
Tangerine Sheri
QUOTE(Turtle @ Sep 25 2005, 06:27 PM) [snapback]861659[/snapback]

Extremely well said IMLO
Take a bow.
thumbsup.gif

Turtle Ah shucks you are making me blush Namaste Sheri
Something Like Laughter
QUOTE(Sheri berri @ Sep 25 2005, 07:10 PM) [snapback]861589[/snapback]

PA I am very aware of grace, because it doesn't fit the biblical understanding of Grace doesn't mean there are no other possible definitions my understanding of grace is based on personal experience not a text book definition, no one understands grace better than a woman .grace is the inherent quality of any woman PA maybe it is you who does not understand Grace?.Just something to ponder.Namaste sheri
i would think that very few people on this board understand what the NT writers ment when they used 'charis' the greek word translated as grace.
stillcrazy
QUOTE
And how many do you know that are gay that you befriended knowing they were gay?


Since this is my last post to the forum I will answer the question.

23 that I know are gay. I knew 15 were gay before becoming friends with them.

You all enjoy.

Peace to you all
Paranoid Android
QUOTE(hyperactive @ Sep 26 2005, 02:19 AM) [snapback]861119[/snapback]

PA and joc:

what you are missing in your claims of grace is the following:

belief structures prior to the abrahamics granted the equivilant of this grace except that there was never a suffering prior to it to be granted grace from! This grace concept is a remolding of ideas lifted from ancient eastern philosophies. Science and christianity don't get along because science requires you cite your sources, for one reason.

the grace granted by the abrahamic god is grace from his own tormenting of you! this is the equivilant to me injecting you with a poison and telling you if you do as i say i will inject you with the cure before it is too late. A prime example of how the abrahamics are all about control and dominance. Many do not need this grace you speak of because we have not been given the poicson it is a cure for.


Obviously you do not know what Grace is either...........
hyperactive
PA, isn't that always the excuse!

So go ahead and do tell what version of grace you claim was not lifted from prior philosophies. please do tell. Put it "in stone" for once. No more wiggle room please.
Paranoid Android
QUOTE(Turtle @ Sep 26 2005, 11:27 AM) [snapback]861659[/snapback]

And how many do you know that are gay that you befriended knowing they were gay?


Not sure off the top of my head, but at least six yes.gif
SilverCougar
QUOTE
And how many do you know that are gay that you befriended knowing they were gay?


I have a harem of gay men... X)
mako
QUOTE
i would think that very few people on this board understand what the NT writers ment when they used 'charis' the greek word translated as grace.

I doubt if any of you realize that the grace of Lord Mithra was first and more encompassing than that of later imitators.
Paranoid Android
QUOTE(mako @ Sep 26 2005, 10:30 PM) [snapback]862111[/snapback]

I doubt if any of you realize that the grace of Lord Mithra was first and more encompassing than that of later imitators.


I tend to disagree. I admit I don't know a huge amount about Mithra, but of what I've found, the concept of Grace is not in Mithraism.

On similar note, a group of atheists trying to disprove Christianity (sorry, can't remember specifics) tried to show that there was nothing different or new to Christianity. They proved that everything in the Bible could be found in other religions...... EXCEPT GRACE!!!!!!!

And I read an official quote (again, sorry I don't have specifics) from a convention of Mithra followers who said that it's obvious CHristianity is NOT based on Mithraism.

Just a thought.

Regards, PA

Mythra
I do not know where you recieved your information, but we who follow the Lord have always maintained that Christianity was a imperfect copy of what the Lord Mithra taught. Only Mithra gives true grace, grace unencumbered by the need to believe in him. He came and died that all mankind would have salvation with no strings attached.
Paranoid Android
Does that mean I'm saved regardless what I do? WOOHOO! I can be a Christian and still be saved by the power of Lord Mithra. Yay! So if I keep believing in Jesus I've got my bases covered. If I'm right - Jesus is my ticket. If you're right, Mithra - I can't lose w00t.gif

Mythra
Did I mention the fire cleansing that a non-beleiver will have to undergo at the end of time? It will smart a bit, but afterward you will be allowed in heaven, but you ticket is paid and you will not spend eternity in Hell (try that with the imitator)
GIDEON MAGE
mythra-were you baptized in an underground chamber with the blood of the bull? just asking.
pa-it's been done to death, but Yeshu is almost 100% carbon copy of Mithra, Krishna, and dozens of other savior figures.

check this out if you haven't already
zandore
QUOTE(GIDEON )
pa-it's been done to death, but Yeshu is almost 100% carbon copy of Mithra, Krishna, and dozens of other savior figures.
I think he has seen the evidence but just does not want to accept.
Mythra
QUOTE
mythra-were you baptized in an underground chamber with the blood of the bull?

Because we are sworn to secrecy when baptisted, all I can answer is - "We follow the old ways". notworthy.gif
Azalin
Issues like same sex marriages, and same sex relationships cannot just be changed in the church because a bunch of gay people want it. Thats directly closing the bibles entire teachings. If the church was to do that, what would be the next to go ?. You could continue to change everything to meet your everyday lifestyle that you want.

The bibles traditions are not very hard to follow, and it's not the bibles fault, or the churches fault that society has twisted the world to the point that it is today. Everyone has their freedom of speech, and their right to freedom and free choices. HOWEVER, a bunch of people "wanting" to change thousands of years of traditions to better meet THEIR lifestyles is not going to happen.

I strongly believe in Pope Benedicts decesions, and believe thats why God appointed him in the position he has today, through the Cardinals.
GIDEON MAGE
QUOTE
The bibles traditions are not very hard to follow, and it's not the bibles fault, or the churches fault that society has twisted the world to the point that it is today. Everyone has their freedom of speech, and their right to freedom and free choices. HOWEVER, a bunch of people "wanting" to change thousands of years of traditions to better meet THEIR lifestyles is not going to happen.



Yep, over a thousand years of celebate priests fellating little boys is a hard tradition to break.
Azalin
QUOTE(GIDEON MAGE @ Sep 26 2005, 06:44 PM) [snapback]862488[/snapback]

Yep, over a thousand years of celebate priests fellating little boys is a hard tradition to break.


That has nothing to do with the religion Gideon, thats the individual. The world is an un-perfect place, and we are all sinners.
mako
QUOTE
That has nothing to do with the religion Gideon, thats the individual

Why is this the stock answer anytime Christians get caught doing something wrong? A tree is know by the fruit it bears, and it seems to be bearing some mighty rotten fruit! yes.gif
Azalin
QUOTE(mako @ Sep 26 2005, 06:53 PM) [snapback]862492[/snapback]

Why is this the stock answer anytime Christians get caught doing something wrong? A tree is know by the fruit it bears, and it seems to be bearing some mighty rotten fruit! yes.gif


One specific organization cannot stop thousands of people from doing something, doesn't matter how hard they try. Every job everyday try to stop people from coming in late, scamming businesses, calling in sick when they are not, and just being all around lazy.

The church does pay large amounts of money to the families of these victims of this case, and to be honest, thats the best they can do. A person that can go to College, and graduate from Bible School is obviously of intellect. How much more can the church do to screen certain people ?. A priest is a difficult job worldwide and it's on a very large decline, because people do not have the Willpower to do it anyone in todays society. Trust me, being a Priest puts a lotta pressure on the individual. Not only are you a front man for an entire religion, your someone that hopefully anyone can trust for advice, a shoulder to cry on, knowledge, and day to day help. This is a large responsibility, to be able to have anyone come up to you, tell you the strangest and darkest sins you may of ever heard, and then be able to bless them, and go to bed at night knowing what you know.

Priests have it hard, and I just hope that some people do that respect for them, instead of always putting them down.
mako
QUOTE
One specific organization cannot stop thousands of people from doing something, doesn't matter how hard they try. Every job everyday try to stop people from coming in late, scamming businesses, calling in sick when they are not, and just being all around lazy.

You are wanting me to believe that an organization, organized along the lines of the Roman Army of the 2nd and 3rd centuries CE, that micromanages the lives of its adherents, that demands complete obedience of its clergy and laity, did not know what was going on nearly nationwide (maybe even world wide). We have evidence that the church was aware of this problem for decades …… and you want us to believe that they couldn’t do anything about the problem? Come on, get real, the priests that weren't daydreaming of little boy’s butts were trying to sweep the problem under the carpet instead of attempting to fix it!
QUOTE
The church does pay large amounts of money to the families of these victims of this case, and to be honest, thats the best they can do.

Now they are paying, but if they had spent half the effort when this problem surfaces decades ago, many of the young children that are being paid, would have been spared the anguish and suffering that they went through.
QUOTE
A person that can go to College, and graduate from Bible School is obviously of intellect. How much more can the church do to screen certain people ?

I don’t know, but it seems to me that the Protestants haven’t had any problem with their preachers lusting after young boys on the scale that the Roman Church has had. Maybe y’all need to ask them how they did it.
QUOTE
A priest is a difficult job worldwide and it's on a very large decline, because people do not have the Willpower to do it anyone in todays society.

The difficulty of a job is no excuse for the sexual molestation of the young. One of the most difficult jobs in the world is the military. I don’t think I have seen many cases of military members molesting young boys either on the installation or in the neighborhood of it. Does this mean that these secular men are more moral than the Church's leaders?
QUOTE
trust me, being a Priest puts a lotta pressure on the individual. Not only are you a front man for an entire religion, your someone that hopefully anyone can trust for advice, a shoulder to cry on, knowledge, and day to day help. This is a large responsibility, to be able to have anyone come up to you, tell you the strangest and darkest sins you may of ever heard, and then be able to bless them, and go to bed at night knowing what you know.

Oh puhleese, spare me the whining….There may have been a time decades ago that people might have looked up to priests, but that time is long gone, thanks mainly to the shenanigans of those “brave” men wearing the reversed collar. The sins they hear about are the reality faced by the Police, Firemen and Military everyday. We manage to sleep and don’t need a warm little boy to take the edge off.
QUOTE
Priests have it hard, and I just hope that some people do that respect for them, instead of always putting them down.

As I said, a tree is known by the fruit it bears and what it has been bearing is turning the people from it. Your Pope is doing too little too late to reverse the trend. yes.gif
Azalin
Personally it seems you have had a personal problem with this mako, you seem to make it out that every priest does this. And Mako, I was a Roman Catholic Priest, and not once did I ever touch a little boy in any perverted way, and neither did any of my hundreds of clergy men. As far as the military being harder, I dont believe so. My oldest brother is a Sargeant in the Army, and other older brother is a Master Corporal, trust me, I know everything they do. They take and give orders, thats exactly the make up of it. I would not go to an army personel, and confess my sins, and ask for forgiveness, or for information on life changing commitments.

Just because you are not a significant part of the Roman Catholic Church, doesn't mean people do not trust and love the Church. There are more then 2 BILLION worshippers of the faith. Go and watch some live footage of when Pope John Pauls funeral was being done. Every Hotel in Rome was booked, every street corner was filled with people giving their prayers and thanks.

Are you implying that the molestation of young boys is some kind of coverup by the church, that they say " oh you can do it, we have done it for hundreds of years, just don't get caught! ". Thats just ridiculous. I personally have met a few priests that were convicted of these crimes. These are decent men, and 3 of them were let off of charges because of no significant evidence, they were just greedy families looking for money from the church. Things like this destroy a priests life, and they know the consequences. Their are bad priests, I stand by that, there are some that follow God and the Church, but only choose bits and pieces that they believe in, and that is somewhat ridiculous as well. But you need to know that that the Roman Catholic Church is not a corrupt establishment, you seem to forget the millions of dollars they have given to third world countries, and towards poverty and the homeless. Of course, none of this is ever in front page news, because journalists and the rest of the world just say " Who cares, this is what the church is suppose to do ", so it never gets covered.

hyperactive
Azlan,

As the world's largest money making institution, what percentage of money is being given by the RC church to all these "Causes" you list?

rolleyes.gif
Azalin
QUOTE(hyperactive @ Sep 26 2005, 08:30 PM) [snapback]862566[/snapback]

Azlan,

As the world's largest money making institution, what percentage of money is being given by the RC church to all these "Causes" you list?

rolleyes.gif


Im not sure of the exact percentage, but if it makes you feel better, the church is BROKE. They are selling cathedrals, paintings and other religious artifacts just to pay the government on their land taxes and bills and utililities of their churches worldwide.

When Pope benedict was elected, one of his main rules was to figure out how to get out of the 2 Billion dollar defeceit the church was in.
zandore
QUOTE(Azalin @ Sep 26 2005, 02:40 PM) [snapback]862486[/snapback]

HOWEVER, a bunch of people "wanting" to change thousands of years of traditions to better meet THEIR lifestyles is not going to happen.

Then there is no hope for the church.
Christianity on the other hand if it will change then it still has a chance.
mako
QUOTE
Personally it seems you have had a personal problem with this mako

No, I just have a problem with someone trying to justify what your church did and the attempt to sweep the whole mess under the carpet.
QUOTE

you seem to make it out that every priest does this. And Mako, I was a Roman Catholic Priest, and not once did I ever touch a little boy in any perverted way, and neither did any of my hundreds of clergy men.

Nope, you and they probably didn’t, you were too busy trying to cover the problem up instead of taking action to stop it and rid yourselves of it!
QUOTE
As far as the military being harder, I dont believe so. My oldest brother is a Sargeant in the Army, and other older brother is a Master Corporal, trust me, I know everything they do.

Knowing and KNOWING are two different things. Have you ever heard the whine of a bullet fired in anger? Have you ever killed another human? Have you ever looked in the eyes of your best friend as he breathed his last breath? Until you can answer yes to every one of those questions, then you have no idea of what they do! Incidentally, thanks to Vietnam, Grenada and Panama, I can answer yes to every one of those questions.
QUOTE
They take and give orders, thats exactly the make up of it. I would not go to an army personel, and confess my sins, and ask for forgiveness, or for information on life changing commitments.

As I said above, they do a helluva lot more than that, especially now with the “War on Terrorism”. You know, we are equal, I ain’t gonna ask no priest to hear my confessions, especially since I am a third generation Deist!
QUOTE
Just because you are not a significant part of the Roman Catholic Church, doesn't mean people do not trust and love the Church. There are more then 2 BILLION worshippers of the faith. Go and watch some live footage of when Pope John Pauls funeral was being done. Every Hotel in Rome was booked, every street corner was filled with people giving their prayers and thanks.

That makes what the Church does right? I don’t think so. Incidentally of the Christians of the world, Catholicism is less than ½ of that population, and is only 16% or less (depending on which website you take your figures from since one of them really agree) of the world population. Of the non-Catholic Christians, I would say almost none love or trust your church and of the non-Christians of the world, I would say that very few love or trust your church. The numbers you quote doesn’t mean much, he was after all the leader of a state and his fellow Catholics would tend to want to be at his funeral. That has nothing to do with the validity of you church.
QUOTE
Are you implying that the molestation of young boys is some kind of coverup by the church, that they say " oh you can do it, we have done it for hundreds of years, just don't get caught! ". Thats just ridiculous. I personally have met a few priests that were convicted of these crimes. These are decent men, and 3 of them were let off of charges because of no significant evidence, they were just greedy families looking for money from the church. Things like this destroy a priests life, and they know the consequences.

Oh Puhleese, you don’t think the world really buys that garbage do you? Too many of your fellow priests have admitted to it and too many have been moved by the church to forestall prosecution.
QUOTE
Their are bad priests, I stand by that, there are some that follow God and the Church, but only choose bits and pieces that they believe in, and that is somewhat ridiculous as well. But you need to know that that the Roman Catholic Church is not a corrupt establishment,

Tell that to the myriad of peoples that the Church has tortured, murdered, enslaved, and in general destroyed over the last 1900 years of so!
QUOTE
you seem to forget the millions of dollars they have given to third world countries, and towards poverty and the homeless. Of course, none of this is ever in front page news, because journalists and the rest of the world just say " Who cares, this is what the church is suppose to do ", so it never gets covered.

That’s right, according to their tenants that what they are supposed to do. However, there is all the money that never made it to where it was supposed to go. What was it Jesus said about wanting recognition for your "holiness" that this will be your reward, not heaven? yes.gif
Azalin
QUOTE(zandore @ Sep 26 2005, 09:26 PM) [snapback]862627[/snapback]

Then there is no hope for the church.
Christianity on the other hand if it will change then it still has a chance.


Then in your assumptions the church will die, but I'd rather them die then to change their teaching. If you can just change religious teachings as you go along, then what are you really following ?, whatever feels good at the time ?. Thats blasphemy to change what's been put in the bible.

We all know instances in the bible may of been changed, or left out, since it has been recorded over hundreds of years, through Greek, and Latin. You just need to believe that it's what god wanted in the end result.
Something Like Laughter
QUOTE(Paranoid Android @ Sep 26 2005, 08:08 AM) [snapback]862134[/snapback]

And I read an official quote (again, sorry I don't have specifics) from a convention of Mithra followers who said that it's obvious CHristianity is NOT based on Mithraism.
"The only domain in which we can ascertain in detail the extent to which Christianity imitated Mithraism is that of art." Is that what you are referring to? If it is its found in Mithraic Studies: Proceedings of the First International Congress of Mithraic Studies

the whole grace thing, from Handbook of Biblical Social Values:
"'grace' (charis) is a shorthand way of referring to the patron-client relationship, to enjoying patronage, while when referring to God, it is his willingness to be patron, to give patronage."
i again highly recommend that book. thumbsup.gif
hyperactive
so changes are what "god wanted". then future changes are what he wants as well by that stance. Which way is it?

Not that it matters, all human creations have a finite life cycle.
Tangerine Sheri
QUOTE(Paranoid Android @ Sep 26 2005, 06:08 AM) [snapback]862134[/snapback]

I tend to disagree. I admit I don't know a huge amount about Mithra, but of what I've found, the concept of Grace is not in Mithraism.

On similar note, a group of atheists trying to disprove Christianity (sorry, can't remember specifics) tried to show that there was nothing different or new to Christianity. They proved that everything in the Bible could be found in other religions...... EXCEPT GRACE!!!!!!!

And I read an official quote (again, sorry I don't have specifics) from a convention of Mithra followers who said that it's obvious CHristianity is NOT based on Mithraism.

Just a thought.

Regards, PA



PA Grace permeates all things is all things , it has nothing to do with religion ! To have a true understanding of grace, it requires you to be in communion with the part of yourself that is divine or universal or part of the system. grace is the awareness of this! god isn't some thing that is outside, brought to you, but is you and many, many philosophys speak of this , God self ! self actualization etc. etc. Grace can also be thought of as a gift ,the gift of life, the reverence for all that is meaning that you get, there, is a unity and synergy that is the system and each has a viable part in it and uses their life as the tool which expresses its understanding and awareness of that which it is. The creator and created are one in the same, By the Grace of God Go I is a metaphor for this understanding. Namaste sheri
zandore
QUOTE(Azalin)
If you can just change religious teachings as you go along, then what are you really following ?, whatever feels good at the time ?. Thats blasphemy to change what's been put in the bible.
Is this not what has been happening for 1900 years? When a Priest looks at a little boys behind is that not a gay pedophile? Then to move the priest to a different church...Is that not helping broaden his horizons?
In my book that is aiding and abetting a felon. How about yours?

QUOTE
We all know instances in the bible may of been changed, or left out, since it has been recorded over hundreds of years, through Greek, and Latin. You just need to believe that it's what god wanted in the end result.
How many versions of the Bible in Greek? Latin? In English there are "OVER 100 VERSIONS" of the Bible. Your God wanted that? You call it blasphemy to change what's been put in the bible? To translate from what Hebrew to what ever language are you not changing the Bible?
Azalin
How can you even compare a religious priest to a military personel. The war on Vietnam was not a good thing, you had I'd say half of America against that war. The war on Terrorism to this day is not going anywhere. Half or more of Americans hate the war and hate Bush for even starting it all.

And to think I was "sweeping" up sexual crimes for the church just shows how delusional you really are. As far the the church destroying their opposition during the Roman and dark ages, what does that matter. Europeans came here and killed thousands of native amercians to call this land their own. Of course, we all say that was just, ya know, exploration of the new world, or slavery of the African Americans, but the church, oh, they were so much worse to do it. The church was persecuted as well. Ever heard of the "Great Persecution " at the hands of Emporer Nero ?. When they fed thousands of Christians to lions in gladiator pits. When they made them drink hot lead, poked out there eyes and cut off their tounges, that went on for a few decades.


zandore
QUOTE(Azalin)
As far the the church destroying their opposition during the Roman and dark ages, what does that matter.
What does it matter? Just think of how much further along we could be in all fields of knowledge. How many people died during those times that might not have if it never happened?

QUOTE
Europeans came here and killed thousands of native amercians to call this land their own. Of course, we all say that was just, ya know, exploration of the new world,
I am Native American. I can not argue with you on this. thumbsup.gif

But this.....
QUOTE
or slavery of the African Americans
How much do you know of the African slave trade? Did you know it was Africans doing the "rounding up" of slaves. Can you say that there was no mention (favorable mention) of owning slaves in the Bible?
Azalin
No one can say where we would be without the Church, we may be better, or we may be worse. All we can really say, is that we would not be here, right now, without it. If your happy with your life, then you should give a bit of appreciation to church to shape the world to what it amounted too today. Although there are a lot of factors, it's a hard issue to debate, cause no one knows.

I know of the slavery, and to be honest, it was a bad example. Slaves were more universal back then, they are considered now with modern technology.
hyperactive
yes, azalin, it is a game of guessing to make alternate timelines for all the "what ifs"

however, just because i am "here, now" does not mean i owe anything to the timeline prior to me, for the alternative would simply be that i never exist. It is not as if the church spent 2000 years raping and torturing my forbearers for the explicit purpose of my being born.

Now, the past is the past. We are at a crossroads now where a critical mass of knowledge is being reached that will see a fundamental shift in people's views and in society overall (structurally). Soon (relative to the length of time man has existed) christianity will be a footnote in history. There is no stopping the evolution of the species.
Azalin
QUOTE(hyperactive @ Sep 26 2005, 10:48 PM) [snapback]862745[/snapback]

yes, azalin, it is a game of guessing to make alternate timelines for all the "what ifs"

however, just because i am "here, now" does not mean i owe anything to the timeline prior to me, for the alternative would simply be that i never exist. It is not as if the church spent 2000 years raping and torturing my forbearers for the explicit purpose of my being born.

Now, the past is the past. We are at a crossroads now where a critical mass of knowledge is being reached that will see a fundamental shift in people's views and in society overall (structurally). Soon (relative to the length of time man has existed) christianity will be a footnote in history. There is no stopping the evolution of the species.


Agreed that science has pushed very far in the last hundred years. However, until they can find a way to theorize the creation of the entire universe, and somehow dis-prove the theory of God, then Christianity will always be here. And like you said with your relative to the time of man, this may still take another 100 to a 1000 years.
hyperactive
not necessarily so. religions run their course, as a part of the societies they serve. christianity could be dead long before the majority of the planet's populace recognizes the lack of any gods. Right now (as in the current years) christianity is shrinking and islam is growing. Islam could very well see a lifespan of 2000 years, where in 100 christianity will be a minority player (if things continue the way they are now).

the proof of "no god" is easier than most realized and has been documented for a while now. it is just a question of it getting out there and people accepting it. (as with so much. even the most basic discovery in science is not valuable to the public unless they accept it.)
GIDEON MAGE
once again may i recommend to all of you to read "the hero with 1000 faces" by Joseph Campbell. if you read the book, you mioght just think more intelligently about mr. Yeshu and all of his look-alike predecessors. and the mithraic art i 've seen doesn't look christian. i don't recall seeing pictures of Yeshu emergong from a rock to be born of the mother gaea, or of yeshu slaying a bull, or challenging the sun. where are these pictures? I'd love to see them, mr. laughter. please at post a link to some of these christian frescoes that portray Yeshu ben Yosef becoming one with Helios, or portrayed with a dog, a raven and a scorpion. are these common motifs in christian art? wow something new to study.thanks. wait-i forget the frescoes of Yeshu bearing the wheel of the zodiac on his shoulders. where is that?
Azalin
QUOTE(hyperactive @ Sep 26 2005, 11:42 PM) [snapback]862798[/snapback]

not necessarily so. religions run their course, as a part of the societies they serve. christianity could be dead long before the majority of the planet's populace recognizes the lack of any gods. Right now (as in the current years) christianity is shrinking and islam is growing. Islam could very well see a lifespan of 2000 years, where in 100 christianity will be a minority player (if things continue the way they are now).

the proof of "no god" is easier than most realized and has been documented for a while now. it is just a question of it getting out there and people accepting it. (as with so much. even the most basic discovery in science is not valuable to the public unless they accept it.)



When I see a religion outclass the Roman Catholic Church I will be surprised, it will not happen in my lifetime. Video Games, Movies, school and education is all mostly done through Roman Catholic Beliefs. The RC church is the leading religion in all of these media's which would all have to change as well. God shows up in your money, in your countrys anthem, in the court of law, all of these things.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.