Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: What evidence do we have?
Unexplained Mysteries Discussion Forums > Unexplained Mysteries > Metaphysics, Psychology & Psychic Phenomena
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
Megalomania
Seriously, when psi is concerned, what evidence do we have?
We have a bunch of teenagers saying that their fingers tingle.
I can make my finders tingle too. It's just blood.

I don't even know why we have a whole forum on this, because it's blatantly obvious we aren't going to find reasonable evidence any time soon. What's even worse is that we have a sub-forum for believers only, where they can brag about their 'abilities'. I don't see the point. They know they are lying, everyone else knows they're lying. It's just pointless.

Okay, enough ranting from me, please stats your opinions. yes.gif
However, if you try to explain your experiences here, without suitable information and fact, you will only be laughed at. hmm.gif
Funi
Searching data...

Videos - none
Photos - none
Ridiculous claims - A LOT!

sleepy.gif
hazzard
You are right of course.
There is absolutely no credible evidence that any of this is real.None.
Tia
The section is for Metaphysics, Astrology and Psychic Phenomena not just kinesis.

It seems that way because a lot of people with interesting points were driven off by rude and ignorant others.

If you don't like the sub-section why bother reading it, free will no one makes you. rolleyes.gif
Bio-Mage
Please do quote one of those "interesting" points. I am dying to to know...
Megalomania
QUOTE(Tia @ Nov 18 2005, 10:45 PM) [snapback]937806[/snapback]

If you don't like the sub-section why bother reading it, free will no one makes you. rolleyes.gif

A lephrechaun does innocent.gif

Nah, I read it because I'm interested in other people's "theories" or as I like to call them, "Blind believing with a hint of 11 different herbs and skeptics"

The skeptics give it the spicy flavour.
Tia
QUOTE(Bio-Mage @ Nov 18 2005, 11:57 AM) [snapback]937814[/snapback]

Please do quote one of those "interesting" points. I am dying to to know...



"Interesting points" are different from person to person, I find some areas of the psychic section interesting others I don't waste my time reading.

An example may be you like football Bio-Mage ( it's an example only), I find it boring and pointless. Do I get on football threads and carry on like an immature brat?
NO, it may be interesting to you but not to me, can you understand that?
Does it make sense to you that football fans wouldn't like me going on their threads being offensive and annoying? There's no difference to psychic threads.

"Blind believing with a hint of 11 different herbs and skeptics" quoted by Replacement.

I find this offensive by calling people blind believers you insinuate that they are stupid and closed minded, living with the fairies. It's a term often used by skeptics when they haven't got anything else to say in their defence, SFS. devil.gif

A question to the skeptics, honestly why do you keep reading this stuff if it obviously upsets your poor little brains? It just doesn't make any sense. rolleyes.gif
Mr Ed
Lol there is absolutely no evidence, at all...but shhhh, you don't want to get flamed.
Tia
Once again, if you believe they have no evidence and you don't like what you read, WHY DO YOU ALL CONTINUE TO POST IN THIS SECTION???????????????????????????????
Mr Ed
No need to shout!
To discuss the views and beliefs of others and each other. To live in harmony on an online community? Hell, I don't know...
Tia
Obviously there was a need to shout, as the harder questions always seem to be ignored.

To live in harmony and discuss the veiws and beliefs of others, don't make me laugh. I can name quite a few people who come to this section purely to get their kicks. They don't contribute anything of intelligence just put-downs.
Mr Ed
I was joking.

Tia, please don't keep going off topic. No one is flaming or getting their kicks here.

The man asked a simple question which demands a simple answer- there is no evidence at all of any of these abilites.

Scientifically they are as real as the tooth fairy.
Tia
"I don't even know why we have a whole forum on this, because it's blatantly obvious we aren't going to find reasonable evidence any time soon. What's even worse is that we have a sub-forum for believers only, where they can brag about their 'abilities'. I don't see the point. They know they are lying, everyone else knows they're lying. It's just pointless."

Ed if you've read all the posts, you'd realise I am on topic and have been mainly talking about this above paragraph.

Replacement asked about psi, and I pointed out this forum isn't just about that. Maybe you should go back and read it all.

Flaming, once again read it all. Some of the terms and wording used are aimed purely at belittling believers..SFS.
Welsh Shaun
QUOTE
The man asked a simple question which demands a simple answer- there is no evidence at all of any of these abilites.

Scientifically they are as real as the tooth fairy.


I keep an open mind about everthing, I believe that it is more healthy to do so, than to totaly deny any posibilities, as you are then denying yourself.
Mr Ed
QUOTE
Replacement asked about psi, and I pointed out this forum isn't just about that. Maybe you should go back and read it all.


No thanks.

QUOTE
I keep an open mind about everthing, I believe that it is more healthy to do so, than to totaly deny any posibilities, as you are then denying yourself.


Lol! Nothing like a bit of early morning philosohpy...
If that works for you then cool. I don't deny everything, I just don't believe anecdotes from unreliable sources.
Welsh Shaun
QUOTE
I don't deny everything, I just don't believe anecdotes from unreliable sources.


Point taken. thumbsup.gif
anomoly
What's truly pathetic is you asking a question which you then answer & then you say if anyone disagrees with you they are to be laughed at. You are the joke who made this laughable thread. stfu, how's that for proof. As if proving anything to anyone in this mostly laughable website is a priority, especially proving something to someone for their entertainment & nothing more.
Mr Ed
QUOTE
You are the joke who made this laughable thread. stfu, how's that for proof.


Lol...thanks for lowering the tone even further. Please don't resort to flaming, it is quite pathetic.
(Hypocrite? Me?)
Stellar
QUOTE

Once again, if you believe they have no evidence and you don't like what you read, WHY DO YOU ALL CONTINUE TO POST IN THIS SECTION???????????????????????????????


Maybe for the same reason that you post in this very topic, even though you believe their posts are useless and shouldnt be in this section.
Milo
QUOTE(Tia @ Nov 19 2005, 06:25 AM) [snapback]939005[/snapback]

Once again, if you believe they have no evidence and you don't like what you read, WHY DO YOU ALL CONTINUE TO POST IN THIS SECTION???????????????????????????????

Good point thumbsup.gif
TeraLink
Yes, you're right. There's absolutely no solid evidence. When we have someone who has proof, we either debunk them into the depths of shame, or we have another Ringu scenario:

{25786}{25856}This is a tape of that day.
{25878}{25925}Correct!
{25946}{25993}Correct!
{26039}{26082}Fraud!
{26086}{26178}It's nothing but a vulgar magic show!
{26183}{26322}Don't be fools! Dr Ikuma! You're being deceived!
{26327}{26377}What's wrong?!
{26561}{26613}She's a freak!

TeraLink Was Here!
sylph
QUOTE(Tia @ Nov 18 2005, 05:45 AM) [snapback]937806[/snapback]

It seems that way because a lot of people with interesting points were driven off by rude and ignorant others.

Tia, there is a way to reclaim what was lost to the race of Man; if you are interested in discussing this, please PM me & we'll chat ~ until then..
Megalomania
QUOTE(Mr Ed @ Nov 19 2005, 11:43 PM) [snapback]939020[/snapback]

No thanks.
Lol! Nothing like a bit of early morning philosohpy...
If that works for you then cool. I don't deny everything, I just don't believe anecdotes from unreliable sources.

Off Topic for a second (sorry), Hehe, Mr. Ed, I'm glad you found my topic tongue.gif You rule! tongue.gif

Now, yeah, sure, this place is about different things, but 90% of things posted here are about Psi. Now, we choose to come here because we want to educate people.... tongue.gif
Chris_com28
From now on I'll waste all my precious time here.
WhiteRaven
It's odd that you're all called skeptics, because I've seen very few real skeptics since I've come, all I see are a bunch of morons telling people off because they believe people can develop skills that other people don't believe in, and saying they are trying to make themselves seem special *snorts* umm this may shock you, but most psychics believe that anyone can learn the skills, which sort of contradicts the thought that it makes us feel "special".

"Scientists" are fools, all they do is a bunch of garbage, with the exceptions of the more intelligent fields of science such as biology, you see it all the time, and it's so stupid.

Mr. proefesser: RRROOAARR, THIS DINO IS 200,000,000 YEARS OLD!!!!

Mr. Squashsniffer: RRRRRROOOOOAAAAARRRRR NO IT'S 300,000,000!!!

WHO CARES???!!!! IF IT'S BEEN DEAD FOR THAT LONG, THEN WHAT DIFFERENCE DOES IT MAKE???????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! WHAT POSSIBLE USE COMES FROM KNOWING HOW LONG AGO AN EXTINCT ANIMAL LIVED?????!!!!!!!! IT'S THE MOST IDIOTIC THING EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!

now then, here's an idea, if you're so sure that psi doesn't exist, then how about you shut up, you're not going to convince us, and we know we're not going to convince you, so your posts are no better than a couple of idiots in lab coats arguing over something that has been dead for millions of years.
angrycrustacean
QUOTE(WhiteRaven @ Nov 19 2005, 06:22 PM) [snapback]939783[/snapback]

It's odd that you're all called skeptics, because I've seen very few real skeptics since I've come, all I see are a bunch of morons telling people off because they believe people can develop skills that other people don't believe in, and saying they are trying to make themselves seem special *snorts* umm this may shock you, but most psychics believe that anyone can learn the skills, which sort of contradicts the thought that it makes us feel "special".

"Scientists" are fools, all they do is a bunch of garbage, with the exceptions of the more intelligent fields of science such as biology, you see it all the time, and it's so stupid.

Mr. proefesser: RRROOAARR, THIS DINO IS 200,000,000 YEARS OLD!!!!

Mr. Squashsniffer: RRRRRROOOOOAAAAARRRRR NO IT'S 300,000,000!!!

WHO CARES???!!!! IF IT'S BEEN DEAD FOR THAT LONG, THEN WHAT DIFFERENCE DOES IT MAKE???????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! WHAT POSSIBLE USE COMES FROM KNOWING HOW LONG AGO AN EXTINCT ANIMAL LIVED?????!!!!!!!! IT'S THE MOST IDIOTIC THING EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!

now then, here's an idea, if you're so sure that psi doesn't exist, then how about you shut up, you're not going to convince us, and we know we're not going to convince you, so your posts are no better than a couple of idiots in lab coats arguing over something that has been dead for millions of years.


Does that ignorance come in a can, or...?
Tia
^^ White Raven lol

Stellar quoted "Maybe for the same reason that you post in this very topic, even though you believe their posts are useless and shouldnt be in this section."

I post in this part of the forum because I have an interest in it. I post in this thread because it's a typical one that wastes space and puts off serious discussion.

Once again the football example could be used...............................
Stellar
QUOTE

It's odd that you're all called skeptics, because I've seen very few real skeptics since I've come, all I see are a bunch of morons telling people off because they believe people can develop skills that other people don't believe in, and saying they are trying to make themselves seem special *snorts* umm this may shock you, but most psychics believe that anyone can learn the skills, which sort of contradicts the thought that it makes us feel "special".

"Scientists" are fools, all they do is a bunch of garbage, with the exceptions of the more intelligent fields of science such as biology, you see it all the time, and it's so stupid.

Mr. proefesser: RRROOAARR, THIS DINO IS 200,000,000 YEARS OLD!!!!

Mr. Squashsniffer: RRRRRROOOOOAAAAARRRRR NO IT'S 300,000,000!!!

WHO CARES???!!!! IF IT'S BEEN DEAD FOR THAT LONG, THEN WHAT DIFFERENCE DOES IT MAKE???????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! WHAT POSSIBLE USE COMES FROM KNOWING HOW LONG AGO AN EXTINCT ANIMAL LIVED?????!!!!!!!! IT'S THE MOST IDIOTIC THING EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Talk about the morons... rolleyes.gif

Knowing our past allows us to better understand the processes behind it, which can directly be translated to processes that are currently occuring.

QUOTE

now then, here's an idea, if you're so sure that psi doesn't exist, then how about you shut up, you're not going to convince us, and we know we're not going to convince you, so your posts are no better than a couple of idiots in lab coats arguing over something that has been dead for millions of years.


Here's another idea. If you're so sure you have any psi ability, go ahead and prove it instead of whining and making excuses, child.

QUOTE

I post in this part of the forum because I have an interest in it. I post in this thread because it's a typical one that wastes space and puts off serious discussion.


Like I said:

QUOTE
Maybe for the same reason that you post in this very topic, even though you believe their posts are useless and shouldnt be in this section.

Travisimo
QUOTE(angrycrustacean @ Nov 20 2005, 01:12 PM) [snapback]939839[/snapback]

Does that ignorance come in a can, or...?

How is he being ignorant?It's his opinion
Tia
Stellar obviously you're not getting the point.

I post in this section because it interests me, that means looking at all the threads in here and replying if needed. I didn't start this thread.

Why do you post in here when it obviously doesn't interest you?
Stellar
QUOTE

How is he being ignorant?It's his opinion


It's an ignorant opinion.

QUOTE

Stellar obviously you're not getting the point.


I am quite getting the point. Question is, are you?
Tia
More then you'll know....SFS. rolleyes.gif
Stellar
QUOTE

I post in this part of the forum because I have an interest in it. I post in this thread because it's a typical one that wastes space and puts off serious discussion.


QUOTE
Like I said:

QUOTE
Maybe for the same reason that you post in this very topic, even though you believe their posts are useless and shouldnt be in this section.


QUOTE

More then you'll know....SFS.


If you had understood the point, you would have realised that I said that we post here for the same reasons!
Turtle
Once in a while I make the journey to find things just don't change here.
Why this section of the forum is not closed and the discussions are moved to the Steel Circle discussion board are beyond me..
I wasted a half hour here looking at the threads, which have all been bogged down by flaming and defensive posts, which have driven off the people whom might want to share something.
Looking at this section, i wouldn't dream of beginning any topic here.
Time to close the whole thing down IMO, or have some moderator control here.
Megalomania
QUOTE(Tia @ Nov 20 2005, 01:13 PM) [snapback]939840[/snapback]

^^ White Raven lol

Stellar quoted "Maybe for the same reason that you post in this very topic, even though you believe their posts are useless and shouldnt be in this section."

I post in this part of the forum because I have an interest in it. I post in this thread because it's a typical one that wastes space and puts off serious discussion.

Once again the football example could be used...............................

We're interested in kinetic ability, not 14 year olds trying to re-enact scenes from Dragon Ball Z
gandalf2013
.
angrycrustacean
QUOTE(gandalf2013 @ Nov 19 2005, 11:09 PM) [snapback]940168[/snapback]

No use trying to get them to understand Tia. They're simply sleepers with a limited mind.


Disagreement doesn't mean we have limited minds. It just means we're not gullible.
gandalf2013
.
Megalomania
QUOTE(gandalf2013 @ Nov 20 2005, 05:16 PM) [snapback]940179[/snapback]

Didn't mention anything regarding disagreements tongue.gif .

In context, you did. hmm.gif
Please... read your implifications before you post something like that w00t.gif
rose_ashes
since when has there been major scientific proof for ANYTHING in this entire forum? if there was such proof, these things wouldn't be UNEXPLAINED, would they?

if you're going to bash one particular part of the forum, you're being completely hypocritical. why is there a section on religion? what proof do we have that any religion is real? i believe there is less proof of religion than there is of psychic abilities. why do we have a section on ghosts? many posts on there involve claims of mediumship, which is also a psychic ability- amazingly, though, i don't see people asking for proof of that. i have yet to see solid proof for anything on this forum, so until you can dig up proof for every other post in every other section, you have no right to harp on this section.

the only way we can have civil conversations on this forum is by respecting eachother's beliefs. i personally believe that religion is full of crap, but i don't sit there and make fun of those who do believe in religion. that's their choice. i challenge it, but i don't stoop so low as to immature jokes and tease them.

perhaps those of you who visit this section and then complain about it need to realize that YOU are the ones that choose to click on the threads. YOU choose to read them. if you want to complain to someone about how this is wasting your time, complain to yourself.

beliefs are different. you have to be fair and respectful of others and their own personal beliefs.

there is a difference between constructive criticism and destructive criticism.
Megalomania
QUOTE(rose_ashes @ Nov 20 2005, 07:51 PM) [snapback]940293[/snapback]

since when has there been major scientific proof for ANYTHING in this entire forum? if there was such proof, these things wouldn't be UNEXPLAINED, would they?

Let's make a foum about the unexplained mystery of my missing socks. That's make a 20x more successful forum than this one.

Tia
Well said rose_ashes. thumbsup.gif

Stellar, you're still missing the point.

I post in this section because it interests me, even threads like this where I'm not going to sit back and watch crap being printed.

You said you posted here for the same reasons, I don't think so. Since when has any of the 'skeptics' come to this section with anything of constructive interest.

" you're all crazy, it's fake" doesn't show an interest in the topic, just a persons narrow minded attitude and immaturity..
Mr Ed
QUOTE
I post in this section because it interests me



So do I my vision embracing friend, but I don't believe a word of it.

QUOTE
Since when has any of the 'skeptics' come to this section with anything of constructive interest.


You bring up a very good point here Tia, but I do completely disagree with the suggestion you are putting foward.
Sometimes, not all the time obviously, but sometimes, telling 13 year olds that these abilities don't exist and then demonstrating why i.e. no proof apart from poorly put together videos on psipog..., sometimes changes their point of view.
No, it doesn't demoralise them or destroy them as people, but it provides another point of view that internet sites on psi or whatever, don't.

Not all people on this forum do this, I don't, but it is constructive to make people look for proof and sense in things rather than just letting people carry on taking the words of a site like psi pog as 'word of God', to to speak.

Tia
I agree to a certain extent about the powers of psi Ed, but this thread was started as a loosely based assumption of the whole psychic section.

rose_ashes
QUOTE(Mr Ed @ Nov 20 2005, 04:11 AM) [snapback]940303[/snapback]

So do I my vision embracing friend, but I don't believe a word of it.
You bring up a very good point here Tia, but I do completely disagree with the suggestion you are putting foward.
Sometimes, not all the time obviously, but sometimes, telling 13 year olds that these abilities don't exist and then demonstrating why i.e. no proof apart from poorly put together videos on psipog..., sometimes changes their point of view.
No, it doesn't demoralise them or destroy them as people, but it provides another point of view that internet sites on psi or whatever, don't.

Not all people on this forum do this, I don't, but it is constructive to make people look for proof and sense in things rather than just letting people carry on taking the words of a site like psi pog as 'word of God', to to speak.



i have no problem whatsoever with people giving alternative explanations and/or debunking theories, but there is absolutely no need to make fun of them. you think kids don't get enough of that at school? when they come online to show someone what they think is really cool, and then get made fun of, it's not going to do much for their self-esteem. a friendly explanation and some constructive criticism will do far more for them than cracking jokes about their age, ignorance, and immaturity will.
Mr Ed
There have also been threads started by believers that consisted of loosely based assumptions of anyone who doesn't believe in or plays devils advocate when talking about psi.
Both sides do it, I vaguely remember a hate thread and a couple of threats as well.
It probably would be best if this kind of fighting stopped, keep it as flame free as possible.
Megalomania
I don't remember where this turned into a thread about believers vs. skeptics...

Oh right.. in my post it kinda says that our pro-psychics are liars... but that's not about all believers...

The main focus of the thread is to explain that we won't get any believable evidence any time soon.
Mr Ed
QUOTE
The main focus of the thread is to explain that we won't get any believable evidence any time soon.


In the words of Katie Melua...

QUOTE
That's a fact,
It's a thing we can't deny
Tia
QUOTE(Replacement100 @ Nov 20 2005, 09:35 AM) [snapback]940315[/snapback]

I don't remember where this turned into a thread about believers vs. skeptics...

Oh right.. in my post it kinda says that our pro-psychics are liars... but that's not about all believers...

The main focus of the thread is to explain that we won't get any believable evidence any time soon.


You kinda just answered for yourself. tongue.gif
Megalomania
QUOTE(Tia @ Nov 20 2005, 08:41 PM) [snapback]940319[/snapback]

You kinda just answered for yourself. tongue.gif

Nah.... yeah... no...... meh... sleepy.gif tongue.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.