QUOTE(aquatus1 @ Feb 13 2006, 10:56 PM) [snapback]1060243[/snapback]
The thing of it is, though, that neither Einstein, nor DaVinci, made claims that they could not back up. They offered proof, not excuses (or in DaVinci's case, what passed for Theoretical Proof in those days). Sure, their claims where extraordinary, however their evidence and support for those claims where extraordinary as well. These claims of indigo children...they are all the glory and none of the work. No evidence, no support, nothing other than a simple claim made based on something that has never been successfully shown to exist.
At a minimum, is there anyway to distinguish between Indigo and ADD? If there is not, and the only thing that has some sort of supportive evidence for it is ADD, then it is quite likely that what is thought to be Indigo does not exist, and is merely undiagnosed ADD.
Up until recently, ADD did not exist either. These kids were labelled as dumb or naughty.
If you can find the questionaire that you were tested on, I would appreciate it. I have looked at other questionaires, but specifically chose the one I posted as it was the closest I could get to the Indigo Characteristics, although not the same.
Yes, there are vast differences between the two questionaires.
Point 1:
Being inteligent, but not top grades (vs. ) Difficult to read, unless interesting or very easy.
Intelligence is in sharp contrast with very easy reading. For one, if you were inteligent, most reading would be easy.
Point 2:
Very creative and enjoy making things (vs.) Work on more than one project at a time, and fail to finish.
Yet again, working on multiple projects does not imply that you are creative, nor that you are using any kind of creativity to do multiple projects.
Point 3:
Always need to know WHY... (vs.) In conversations, I start to answer questions before the questions have been fully asked.
Not sure if you pasted this one in the correct place.
Point 4:
Disgust and loathing for repetitious work (vs.) I find my mind wandering from tasks that are uninteresting or difficult.
I agree with this.
Point 5:
Were rebellious in school in that they refused to do homework and rejected authority. (vs) My relationships were made difficult by my tendency to talk first and think later.
When you are rebellious, you are the one with the anger. When you talk before thinking...other people are angry with you. Conclusion...This is not related at all.
Point 6:
May have experienced early existential depression. (vs) My moods have highs and lows.
When you suffer from depression, you don't have very many highs. You are on a constant low, unless you take something for it of course. But I will accept.
Point 7:
Difficulty in service-oriented jobs. (vs.) I make quick decisions without thinking enough about their possible bad results.
I am not entirely sure what you meant here. Might have been pasted in wrong place.
Personally, I don't make decisions, without thinking it through at length.
Point 8:
Prefer leadership positions or working alone to team positions. (vs.) In groups, I find it hard to stay focused on what is being said in conversations.
What is meant here has more to do with the Indigo resisting authority than not being able to concentrate.
Point 9:
Have deep empathy for others, yet an intolerance of stupidity. (vs.) I am irritable, and get upset by minor annoyances.
I along with many Indigos I know do not get irritated by little things, but we cannot stand stupidity when the answer blatantly stares the person in the face. This also applies to ourselves. We do not tolerate stupidity in our own lives.
Point 10:
May be extremely emotionally sensitive... (vs.) I say things without thinking, and later regret having said them.
Totally disagree. Firstly, I do not say things without thinking about what I am about to say. If I said something that might have hurt someone, I will apologize, but I will also explain my reasons for saying it, as there was a reason for saying it in the first place.
Point 11:
May have trouble with RAGE. (vs.) I have a quick temper... a short fuse.
The Indigos I know don't lose their tempers very quickly, however when they do lose it all hell breaks loose. They are like a slow boiling kettle and when they reach boiling point, you are gonna get burnt. However, I can't speak for everyone, only the ones I know and myself.
Point 12:
Have trouble with systems they consider broken or ineffective, ie. political. (vs.) In group activities it is hard for me to wait my turn.
Not sure what you implied here. Bad paste, maybe?
Broken or ineffective systems has a lot to do with stupidity and should be corrected.
Point 13:
Alienation from or anger with politics (vs.) My mind gets so cluttered that it is hard for it to function.
I don't see the relation.
Point 14:
Frustration with or rejection of the American dream (vs.) I easily become upset.
This has nothing to do with being upset. This has everything to do with the traditional way of life - get married, buy a house, have children, work 9 - 5 and drive a family car.
Point 15:
Anger at rights being taken away. (vs.) I seem to be thin skinned and many things upset me.
Yet again, this has nothin to do with being upset, but more to do with your rights being taken away. Whether this be privacy, your right to vote or something of that magnitude, and not about things like someone parked in your parking spot, or stole your pencil.
Point 16:
Have a burning desire to do something to change and improve the world. (vs.) Even when sitting quietly, I am usually moving my hands or feet.
How will moving my hands and feet improve the world?
Point 17:
Have psychic or spiritual interest appear fairly young - in or before teen years.
Nothing in the ADD questionaire mentions anything about spirituality. Does this mean ADD people cannot be spiritual? Of course not. Does this mean spiritual people cannot have ADD? Of course not.
Point 18:
Skipped...
Point 19:
Have strong intuition. (vs.) In conversations, I start to answer questions before the questions have been fully asked.
Answering questions before they are fully asked is not a sign of intuition in the context of the ADD questionaire. This relates to the other point in the ADD questionaire about not being able to wait your turn, and not concentrating.
My stepson has ADD...and when answering questions I have not fully asked, he normally gets them wrong...because what he thinks I am asking and what I am really asking is not the same.
Point 20:
Random behavior pattern or mind style. (vs.) I have trouble planning in what order to do a series of tasks.
I agree. You can be Indigo and have ADD, but you do not have to be one, to be the other.
Point 21:
Have had psychic experiences, such as premonitions, seeing angels or ghosts, out of body experiences, hearing voices. (vs.) There is a lot of “static” or “chatter” in my head.
The static referred to here is like the type of static you would get from a detuned radio.
Maybe not quite as dramatic, but the same effect.
Point 22:
May be electrically sensitive such as watches not working. (vs.) No ADD question.
The electrical sensitivity could be a result of the body's bio-electromagnetism acting as electrical magnetic interference (EMI).
Point 23:
May have awareness of other dimensions and parallel realities. (vs.) My thoughts bounce around as if my mind is a pinball machine
This does not mean that you are aware of other dimensions. It means that you find it hard to concentrate on one task at a time. This would also be the reason you cannot complete your assigned tasks. This also relates to daydreaming as daydreaming is one of the major factors that occupy the mind at any given time.
Point 24:
Sexually are very expressive and inventive. (vs.) I almost always am on the go.
Totally unrelated. Being on the go does not make you a good lover. What they are trying to establish here is whether or not you are ADHD as opposed to ADD. The H in ADHD refers to Hyperactivity.
Point 25:
Seek meaning to their life and understanding about the world. (vs.) I am distressed by the disorganized way my brain works.
Finding the meaning of life is not the same as trying to organize your brain. You are searching for answers to questions like: Why are we here? What is my purpose? There is nothing disorganized about questioning the meaning of life.
As you can see from the points I listed, ADD and Indigo are not related. They are not exclusive either. In other words, you can have ADD and be Indigo or vice versa, but ADD is not a prerequisite for being Indigo.
Do you believe that your Astrological starsign can determine the type of person you are to some degree? I am not asking you to believe in the Horoscopes you read, but merely the type of person you are. In other words, Virgos are listed as creative, perfectionists and sometimes critical. Taureans are described as people who have strong will etc etc.
Now imagine Indigo as another starsign for people with similar character traits. Indigos are not X-Men as someone else stated...they are just people who share similar traits. Unfortunately some of these traits do not exactly fall in line with what science tells us, and therefore people tend to persecute Indigos.
Don't think of Indigos as anything other than people. You might know some personally and not be aware of it. They might even be friends of yours.
Point 24: