Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Vegaterians
Unexplained Mysteries Discussion Forums > Science > Natural World
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16
Beckys_Mom
QUOTE(robbieb @ May 24 2006, 12:10 AM) [snapback]1202586[/snapback]

not a problem in all meat, once again u give us nouthing but circumstantial evidence. r stuf was not proof it was ur side of an argument. i want real proof i want to see an article from a real doctor not some baked hippie saying that plant diet is better then a balanced one


OK robbie you want non hippie statements??? REALLY???

Please read EXHIBITS A, B C & D

EXHIBIT A....
ARTICLE
Meat Intake and Risk of Stomach and Esophageal Adenocarcinoma Within the European Prospective Investigation Into Cancer and Nutrition (EPIC)
http://jncicancerspectrum.oxfordjournals.o...t/jnci;98/5/345

EXHIBIT B....
http://www.newstarget.com/000983.html

EXHIBIT C.....
Red Meat cancer clue is found
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/4662934.stm

EXHIBIT D.....
Possible mechanism for the link between red meat and bowel cancerhttp://www.mrc.ac.uk/public-press_31_jan_2006


PROOF????
And what does BM here have??? yup you guessed it...bowel cancer and I am awaiting surgery June 10th.....MY REAL NON HIPPIE DOC TOLD ME SO....
http://www.unexplained-mysteries.com/forum...showtopic=69641

Have a wild guess what i have been eating all my life robbie and still do?? Yup you guessed it MEAT..ALL KINDS OF MEAT...

Do I still like MEAT??...............YES!!! I love meat....but I am cutting down and sticking to whats healthy...I will eat less meat and more healthy food...I will try..and hope to gawd my cancer is gone soon....

and I aint no darn hippieuser posted image


Things I wont eat...Burgers (thats not real meat thats processed garbage)
Fries...screw that...gimme nice sweet potatoes any day
Deep Fried food....Puuulllease...I dont want another freaking stomach ulser!!! blink.gif And I HATE Curry..man that stuff reaks!!!! user posted image

I love fish, Chicken , Turkey, Steak,Lamb chops, potatoes, veg any kind of veg I will eat it........, salads(without nuts lol) Fruit lots of fruit...I drink lots of spring water, love my yogurts...ceeal like Frosties or as you guys call em..frosted flakes LOL

I will cut down on the red meat as much as I can....I value my life...whats left of it happy.gif

Ohh and robbie...if you are still unsure...why not just google it for yourself...type in - Protein in red meat...and take a gander on the many many sites what they say about it...AND...ask your OWN Doctor...(a non hippie one lol)

Have a nice day...user posted image



PS..I still put ham in my sandwiches and at times crispy bacon ph34r.gif
robbieb
i sitll dont find cancer links o be sound yet. i mean all these studies do is look at there meat intake and not anything else there eating. people cna smoke all there life and never get cancer but smoking is linked to cancer but i know a person who worked out in my dojo he was a vegeterian did everything right didnt drink didnt smoke and he got cancer he was studying to become a priest and died from it last summer. and they also taked aobut red meat. there are other types of meat. cancer is a horrible horrible thingg and the worst part about it is u cant tell who will and who wont get it. i have seen enough expirements and taken enough statics classes to know that u can find a link between anytihng and everything if u try hard enough.
skratch
QUOTE(robbieb @ May 24 2006, 07:10 AM) [snapback]1203295[/snapback]

i sitll dont find cancer links o be sound yet. i mean all these studies do is look at there meat intake and not anything else there eating. people cna smoke all there life and never get cancer but smoking is linked to cancer but i know a person who worked out in my dojo he was a vegeterian did everything right didnt drink didnt smoke and he got cancer he was studying to become a priest and died from it last summer. and they also taked aobut red meat. there are other types of meat. cancer is a horrible horrible thingg and the worst part about it is u cant tell who will and who wont get it. i have seen enough expirements and taken enough statics classes to know that u can find a link between anytihng and everything if u try hard enough.


Robbie, how can I say this in a way you will understand, so as not to waste our time...
I feel you keep stating the obvious, so as to credit yourself. Obviously those who take preventative measures not to get cancer can still get it. You claim to be a zoologist, and that's a very admirable career, but at least try and understand what we are telling you. Maybe you could learn something if you bring your head out of the clouds.

I'm not going to say if you smoke you will get cancer, because there is a chance you won't. Just like I am not saying if you eat meat you will get cancer, because there is a good chance you won't.
Those who smoke 1 cigarette per day are less likely to get cancer than those who smoke 1 pack a day. Those who eat 1 burger a day are less likely to get cancer than those who eat 1 bucket of the Colonel's Kentucky Fried Cruelty per day. There will always be those who don't get it who don't try and stay healthy, and those who do, even if they try to prevent getting it. All I am saying, is that those who eat meat regularly are at higher RISK (definition of risk: The possibility of suffering harm or loss; danger. Note: It is a possibility, not a conviction to cancer!) Just because you are a vegetarian does not mean you will not get cancer, but it does help to prevent it. Moreso than chowing down on a chunk-o-meat every meal.
I would like to enlighten you to the fact that you do not have to be fat to have high cholesterol, and you do not have to be fat to have heart problems. If you have a fast metabolism and are in shape, but chow down on KFC and McDicks all the time, you're likely to have a problem internally. We now know what the causes of heart attacks are, and thus we can prevent them. Researchers find that high levels of cholesterol in your blood makes you at higher risk of heart attack. Per 1% increase in the cholesterol found in your blood, there is a 2 % increase in your chance of heart attack. And vice versa, for decreasing your risk. Because of the meat, dairy and egg industries, we still think that all these things are necessary for our health. Did you know that the milk from cows is now being studied for it's effect of INCREASING your risk of developing osteoperosis?? INCREASING!!! Doesn't that drive you mad? The milk industries have been telling us that it makes for strong and healthy bones, and now they're testing it for that? Wow. Sure tells you a lot about these industries, eh?
Anyways, about the cholesterol... I'll rap it up by saying vegans have a 57% reduced risk of death from heart disease... (Info found in the British Medical Journal) Eating meat increased cholesterol. Eating veggies downs it.
Researchers also found that veggies are 25-50% less likely to get from cancer. They also found that people who chow down on bad meat, such as hot dogs, sausages, processed meats, were 70% more likely to get pancreatic cancer. (Found from Xinhua News April 2005.)

Now for this "free range" thing... BE CAREFUL! Free range products are just as stingy if not more that regular products.
The United States Department of Agriculture says animals have to have access to outdoors.
Aaaannnnd that's about it.
There are no rules for how long they are outside, how much space they have. In a report in the Seattle Times, an eyewitness said that a farm that advertised it's hens were raised in a 'natural setting', the birds were actually crammed wall to wall, 6800 chickens, 1 rooster for every 100 hens, and they never set foot outside.
Also, because of genetic manipulation (growth horomones) many of the animals who are described to be free range actually never go outside because it is too much pain and effort to move that far. They are not bred for mobility, they're bred to be shoved down our throats. U.S. regulations for free range products apply only to chickens raised for meat, not eggs. It doesn't matter what the egg carton says, most hens raised for their eggs are subjected to cramped, filthy conditions until their egg production begins to slow, then they are slaughtered. Millions of male chicks are killed (usually in a high-speed grinder called a “macerator”) every year because they are worthless to the egg industry. These places aren't happy go lucky. These animals might be allowed to go outside, but when we pump them full of horomones and antibiotics so they are too heavy and depressed to move, what's the point?
Organic meat must come from animals that are fed no antibiotics or horomones, but it is suspected that LESS than 2% of "organic" animals are raised this way.

*Other Labels Regulated by the USDA*
---“Certified”: Meat that has been stamped with this label has been “evaluated” by the USDA “for class, grade, or other quality characteristics.”
---“Natural”: Use of this label is permitted if the product contains “no artificial ingredient or added color and is only minimally processed.”
---“No Hormones”: This label applies only to beef. Since hormones are not supposed to be given to pigs or chickens, pork and poultry products cannot legally be tagged with this label without the disclaimer, “Federal regulations prohibit the use of hormones.”
---“No Antibiotics”: This label can be used on beef and poultry products, provided that the producer supplies “sufficient documentation … that the animals were raised without antibiotics.”
~~~> Food Safety and Inspection Service, “Meat and Poultry Labeling Terms”, United States Department of Agriculture, Aug. 2003.

No labels address the welfare of the animals during transport on huge, often boiling hot or freezing cold trucks, or in the slaughter house. I can pretty much guarantee you, that whatever you put on your plate, (unless you went out and wrangled yourself a cow to eat from the wild...) it has been abused and mistreated throughout its life.

And robbie, I know what I am talking about. Go talk to a trusted teacher or doctor, and get information from them if you like, but I'm sure they will tell you the same. If the ACS tells you a veggie diet cuts back the risk of cancer, you can assume it's pretty much true...

And here is a reference point for you: (although i've already wrote this before...)
"Studies suggest that people who eat more vegetables and fruits, which are rich food sources of these antioxidants, have a lower risk for some types of cancer."

~http://www.cancer.org/docroot/PED/content/PED_3_2X_Common_Questions_About_Diet_and_Cancer.asp?sitearea=PED
-The American Cancer Society ^^
frogfish
QUOTE
Well, cooking does not kill all parasites

Proper cooking does...

QUOTE
And I HATE Curry..man that stuff reaks!!!!

mad.gif there is no such thing as 'curry'. There is however curry powder used in masalas and kochau.
Tangerine Sheri
Robbie there are some 400 or better posts on this thread with lots of great info from people who take the time to post links and share their awareness, every post you have said the same thing, you eat meat we get that, the brain is large due to meat eating, we get that you beleive that, that becasue chimps eat meat we should too...UNDERSTOOD, you have now added in following with your logic, its not possible to get cancer or any other disease from meat in your opinion based in nothing, after all you eat meat..... nor does it matter becasue you knew someone who did everything "right" and got cancer anyways????Sooo Robbie between you and me are you bored and looking to flame and argue eh robbie wink wink?????? no.gif By the way robbie vegetarians eat dairy which comes from an animal....Vegans eat no animal , Zip, nada......... thumbsup.gif
Raptor
QUOTE(frogfish @ May 24 2006, 08:01 PM) [snapback]1203758[/snapback]

Proper cooking does...


Haha. thumbsup.gif

Awesome post, skratch. I agree wholeheartedly. yes.gif
Beckys_Mom
QUOTE(robbieb @ May 24 2006, 02:10 PM) [snapback]1203295[/snapback]

i sitll dont find cancer links o be sound yet. i mean all these studies do is look at there meat intake and not anything else there eating. people cna smoke all there life and never get cancer but smoking is linked to cancer but i know a person who worked out in my dojo he was a vegeterian did everything right didnt drink didnt smoke and he got cancer he was studying to become a priest and died from it last summer. and they also taked aobut red meat. there are other types of meat. cancer is a horrible horrible thingg and the worst part about it is u cant tell who will and who wont get it. i have seen enough expirements and taken enough statics classes to know that u can find a link between anytihng and everything if u try hard enough.

Robbie a number of things are linked to cancer..but this thread aint about smoking is it??

If you dont want to take the word of anyone here...just ask your own doctor...or look it up yourself

I typed into the Google search bar these words.......red meat gives fiber...look here as to what Google presented to me...

http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en&q=red...le+Search&meta=

plain and simple


I am not telling you to stop eating meat robbie..why would I??? I havent exactly stopped it myself...I should but hopefully will


Ever ask yourself how some die from cancer and they never smoked or drank alchol in their lives???...this is true.................very true...my grandother is proof..she was no smoker or drinker...but loved her meat.........now I am not saying thats what caused it...but it was possible...I aint a scientist robbie..therefore I cant prove it..and neither can you grin2.gif
Beckys_Mom
QUOTE(frogfish @ May 24 2006, 08:01 PM) [snapback]1203758[/snapback]

Proper cooking does...
mad.gif there is no such thing as 'curry'. There is however curry powder used in masalas and kochau.

If I go into a chineese or an indian restraunt..and ask for a chicken curry..id get a freaking chicken curry


WTF is your curry problem??? w00t.gif the darn curry powder makes the curry ...lol



I have never read a chinese menu that said...chicken curry powder with rice w00t.gif or an indian one for that matter...just because you have indian relatives dont give you the right to correct me LOL its CURRY..Curry dishes all over indian restraunts happy.gif
thats what most indian dishes are famous for their curry..and I am not being sarcastic Frogie its true...well over here it is grin2.gif
Something that might intrest you

Fish Curry from Assam (Masor Jhol)
Ingredients:

Fish - 1 lb. cleaned catfish, cut to about 3/4 inch pieces
half tsp. turmeric,
1tsp cumin+corriandar powder
salt
two chopped green chillies
1 chopped onion
minced garlic+ginger
1/4 tsp cumin seeds
1/2 tsp mustard seeds
chopped green corriander
two sliced tomatoes.
Method:

Coat the fish pieces with the spices. In a skillet or wide pan heat 1 tbsp oil and fry the fish pieces for about 2 min on each side. Remove and drain.


In the remainimg oil, sauté cumin+mustard seeds, garlic+ginger and onion, added in that order. Now add sliced tomatoes. Cook for 5 min. Add the fish pieces and simmer for about 10 min.


found on this site ----> http://www.curry-design.com/recipes######/recipes.html

Ohh dear they call it curry ohmy.gif and not curry powder LOL I suggest you look up curry on google and see for yourself

Some say its a good hangover cure..but only an indian curry is..not a chinese curry
Raptor
^ huh.gif
frogfish
QUOTE
just because you have indian relatives dont give you the right to correct me LOL its CURRY..Curry dishes all over indian restraunts

No, the fact that I AM INDIAN has to do with it thumbsup.gif

Curry is not the correct term...stupid Americans abuse it. The correct terms are Kochau, Masala, or Kourma. Which use curry and tamarind powder.

Well, back on topic.
Tangerine Sheri
frog cooking certainly helps but not always, you take your chances when you eat feed lot animals I agreew ith Hyper dairy and meat grown in those circumstances are as deadly as tabacco I will not be shocked if a warning isn't put on meat actually it is read the label about irridatiion.ther are some carcinogens that escape being nuked...............I've only ever called it curry ........and cumin although it says ground.....lol or pepper although it says white or salt even though it says sea.......
frogfish
QUOTE
are some carcinogens that escape being nuked

You just made thatr up, didn't you? Carcinogens in meat? Hahahaha!
Tangerine Sheri
Frog that is why they nuke the meat, its called irridation meat is a lush medium for pathogneic bacteria and germs , it can harbor parasites, toxic chemicals and metal contaminants, turning natural herbivores into cannibals as the meat industry does will bring with it a host of dieease and some are cancer causing (carinogens ) grin2.gif Also the method of air injected stunning used in most US packing plants is said to drive central nervous system tissue from the brain of the animal into its blood stream......yum yum good eh frog.......and it will put hair on your chest lol (wink wink) J/K
frogfish
QUOTE
does will bring with it a host of dieease and some are cancer causing (carinogens )

May I have proof that they actually have carcinogens?
Avinash_Tyagi
QUOTE(frogfish @ May 24 2006, 07:48 PM) [snapback]1204126[/snapback]

May I have proof that they actually have carcinogens?



Heterocyclic amines (HCAs) and benzo(a)pyrene (B(a)P), both cancer-causing compounds, form on the surface of meat during grilling and frying; the levels of these carcinogens on meat depend on the cooking temperature and the degree of doneness.
University Of Minnesota
Beckys_Mom
QUOTE(frogfish @ May 24 2006, 10:07 PM) [snapback]1203931[/snapback]

No, the fact that I AM INDIAN has to do with it thumbsup.gif

Curry is not the correct term...stupid Americans abuse it. The correct terms are Kochau, Masala, or Kourma. Which use curry and tamarind powder.

Well, back on topic.

Well BM here aint what you call a stupid American LOL check the profile LOL rofl.gif

And I aint blind LOL I know you are an indian LOL I have seen a few of your pics LOL

frogfish
QUOTE
Heterocyclic amines (HCAs) and benzo(a)pyrene (B(a)P), both cancer-causing compounds, form on the surface of meat during grilling and frying; the levels of these carcinogens on meat depend on the cooking temperature and the degree of doneness.
University Of Minnesota

Interesting...I wonder how dangerous it is...how risky.

QUOTE
Well BM here aint what you call a stupid American LOL check the profile LOL

And I aint blind LOL I know you are an indian LOL I have seen a few of your pics LOL

Did I say stupid Americans? I meant Stupid America...tongue.gif
Beckys_Mom
QUOTE(frogfish @ May 25 2006, 01:22 AM) [snapback]1204167[/snapback]

Interesting...I wonder how dangerous it is...how risky.
Did I say stupid Americans? I meant Stupid America...tongue.gif

Oppsie LOL well ummm correct me if I am wrong Frog but when you say...stupid America...you are not talking about the land itself LOL you are talking about the people who live there LOL...the land didnt class it as curry laugh.gif
frogfish
Whatever...stupid stereotypes...
skratch
AHH! Good old carcinogens... I forgot to mention that one! Technically that roles right along with the cancer point though, once again (directed to robbie) proving that animal fat is directly linked to cancer. Actually, the USDA released a report stating that cafeterias in schools should change menus so that children wouldn't have a selection of foods that were not animal fat based, thus not forcing them to be exposed to carcinogens at such an early age. Personally I think just educating them, and scaring them away from it is a better tactic.. but that's just me. wink2.gif
Chicken alone contains 3-4 more times the arsenic (yes.. arsenic. Yummyyyy!) than other meats. It also contains dioxin.. Another carcinogen.
80-90% of dietary pesticide intake comes from animal fat.
100% (say it with me now... 1-0-0-%!!!) of dietary hormones and dioxins come from animal fat!
I dare you to tell me once more that meat does not cause cancer.

A couple more things...
Meat from the water, like fish, is (contrary to popular belief) very bad for you as well. It contains high levels of mercury as well as other environmental contaminants.
And finally, once you cook your meat, it develops another array of cancer causing agents.. More specifically called heterocyclic amines. You can look it up. I think I saw it mentioned though.

MAN! As if some of you didn't know that meat, when cooked, is a carcinogen. Cooked properly it is safer, but you can't avoid it entirely on an omnivorous diet.

One day, people will see that vegetarians are healthier.. But I think I'll get sick of explaining all this before then original.gif wink2.gif
I really like this site, there's a good mix of different people on here.. I love the variety.
frogfish
I doubt they (the carcinogens) play a big role...
robbieb
yea well hers what i know a big old steak dripping with ketchup isd a good time a bowl of lettus with a carrot is only good if u chop up some chicken breast and toss that in there with a good dressing.
hyperactive
robbie,

do you enjoy dogmeat as well? how about rat?

taste preferences are a learned behaviour. wink2.gif yes.gif
robbieb
id eat them i mean i have had chinnese before HAHAHA no but seriosuly taste is not regulated by learned behavior ur taste buds change every 7 years about. something u dont like one day can change the next for instancve i used to not liek strawberry whip cream or mintu gun i now like thme all alot. this wasnt a learned behavior grnated some things are considered an aquired taste but for the most part taste is not controled by a learned behavior but a biological occurance.
Tangerine Sheri
QUOTE(robbieb @ May 24 2006, 08:45 PM) [snapback]1204395[/snapback]

id eat them

Robbie yuck.........Why??????

Frog no one is bashing your culture , I for one celebrate and love didffernt cultures and food connects us........

Scratch thanks for the in depth on the carcinogens....

Frog use care eating meat, many won't take the chance, cancer is nothing to play with and its often best to err on the side of caution.........
robbieb
i have never seen a link between eating meat and cancer. that just stupid everyone on earth woudl have died in cancer in the past. maby steriod injected meat might but u dont have to eat that there are alternatives hunting is one or organic meat. i mean someone coudl say eating inorganci plants could cause cancer. it goes both ways u can have the alterd stuff or the real stuff. it all dependso n what u buy.
hyperactive
robbie,

it is not the meat that causes cancer, but what is carried by the meat (both from what the animal ingested and what grows in it while decomposing) and how it is prepared.

and taste preferences are a learned behavior.
robbieb
u do know when u cut a plant down it starts decomposing too right? and by the same things that break down meat

and no there not are u kidding me u mean to say that there is no food ur parent like that u dont like or that u liek that ur parents dont like?
hyperactive
yes, I am well aware of that. wink2.gif
robbieb
o ok so thne thny only cause canser when they break down meat is that what ur saying? cause u know thereo nly producing the same bi product no matter what they are braking down
hyperactive
no,

the decomposition is not the issue with meat. in fact, it is decompostion that gives you b12 in meat. It is the bacteria that can thrive in decomposing meats that are the issue.
robbieb
and the toxic molds and and fungi that liv on decomposing veggis and fruit isnt a problem?
hyperactive
they can be a problem.

the degree of mold risk varies. some foods like peanuts carry a bacteria that can not be irradicated but if your liver is healthy it can process the bacteria without issue.

meat is more suseptable to carrying bacteria than veggies.
Beckys_Mom
QUOTE(robbieb @ May 25 2006, 04:45 AM) [snapback]1204395[/snapback]

id eat them i mean i have had chinnese before HAHAHA

laugh.gif I see what you mean...half the time when you order out of a chinese takeaway...you have asked for a chicken curry with fried rice and when you have tasted the so called chicken you cant help but wonder WTF is it?? But if you have just staggered out of a bar or night club and you head for a chinese takeaway you dont give a toss...you would eat anything w00t.gif


I have been there done it many times ph34r.gif


laugh.gif
Raptor
QUOTE(robbieb @ May 25 2006, 05:16 AM) [snapback]1204425[/snapback]

and the toxic molds and and fungi that liv on decomposing veggis and fruit isnt a problem?


Maybe they are, but whether you're a vegetarian or not, you're going to be eating fruit and vegetables (hopefully, anyway). People that eat meat can potentially be exposed to the carcinogens in the meat as well as the 'toxic molds' in fruit and vegetables. Vegetarians will only be exposed to the molds in fruit and vegetables.
skratch
"i have never seen a link between eating meat and cancer."

Go back and read all the links I have given you, and the posts I have made. Just so that I did not write them for no reason at all. I have provided you with facts, go read them, because at the moment you are only reading what you want to believe...

As for the decomposition thing... Bacteria such as salmonella and e-coli can be found on meat, but rarely on veggies. Meat turns bad MUCH easier than plants, and is harder to tell. With veggies, they go limp, and physically look bad. Bad meat doesn't give many signs.
Also... I prefer to eat fresh fruits and veggies, not moulding ones.
skratch
One more point...
The worst invisible thing you could encounter on plants is probably pesticides, but if you choose organic, it likely wouldn't contain them..
Bloody humans. wink2.gif

Come on now.. I think you are kind of being silly by saying that fruits and veggies contain as much bad bacteria as meat... Meat is flesh.. It rots.. veggies are natural.
Beckys_Mom
QUOTE(robbieb @ May 25 2006, 04:56 AM) [snapback]1204408[/snapback]

i have never seen a link between eating meat and cancer. that just stupid everyone on earth woudl have died in cancer in the past. maby steriod injected meat might but u dont have to eat that there are alternatives hunting is one or organic meat. i mean someone coudl say eating inorganci plants could cause cancer. it goes both ways u can have the alterd stuff or the real stuff. it all dependso n what u buy.

robbie you have a nasty silly habbit of saying it's stupid, thats stupid..the only stupid things I am reading is your lack of knowledge..no offence mate but you sound like someone who hasnt read up any reports...you sound like someone who hasnt bothered to even speak to an expert or a doctor and heck even if you did....you would still say its stupid huh.gif


Tell us this robbie......can you show ANY medical records that prove red meat is not a health risk?? hmm.gif I mean I posted a number of them that say they ARE written by experts, people with the smarts to work it out...........

Since you are so hung up on saying that the early man didnt die of cancer (how on earth you would know that is beyond me)
SOOOOOO FYI I suggest you look up sources on - the early man....and read to where it says...early man the avarage age how long the life span of early man dating way back to the cave man even....cuz I have read up on it and guess what robbie..................the avarage early man only lived to an avarage age of 26.................dont believe me robbie?? Google it yourself and you just might get a lil education on it.... happy.gif remember Google is your friend LOL
robbieb
i understand that life as shorter thne what i meant was cancer was unheard of and there are tribes that eat meat and veggies that have no history of cancer what so ever and sc ientist are studying thme to find out why. so if meat cuases cancewr then they should have cancer. and u can have organic meat too so it goews both wasy with e pesticided on the inoprganci meat and steriods in meat too. i mean a hunter who shotts a deer and eats it wont have to worry aobut if it was begin fed steriods or anything right? and he also wont have to worry aobut it rotting becuase its usualy eaten fast. until somone can explain to me how these tribes that eat meat everyday have no history of cancer but me eating clean non steriod fed cattle and chickens and fish and thel ike will give me cancer i wont belive there is a link between the two. statics can be tweaked my friends. for along time they said cell phones gave u brin tumors because people who had brin tumors ususaly used a cell phone but so did alot of other people and a larger majority dont get brain tumors. then they siad its the side oh the head u use the phone on that determins what side of brain gets the tumor but thre are other possibilitys looking at one aspect of something will never give u a full answer. the truth is its eaing processed foods like twinkies and things liek thaqt with all these chemicals in them that cause the cells to go crazy when exposed to them it was very very very very rare for someone to get cancer back in the day but now look at how many children have cancers. there is a link here and its not meat. some meat that is pumped ewith these steroids and chemicals may add to it but so woudl eating inorgance veggies. theres a bigger picture to look at here. and i feel most of you arentl ooking at it. and belive me if u know anything aobut statics you would know that its all in how you say it that gives it its meaing for instance 4 out of 5 docotrs say triedent is better for your teeth then other gums. ok but who are these doctors and did they ask maby 30 docotrs and only took a fraction of that they wanted ot get this result. i had to do a statics project where we had to do something like that. it realy opened my eyes i dont trust survey liek that anymore.
hyperactive
robbie,

on looking at the whole picture:

you seem to not be interested in seeing how the optimal human diet is animal-free.

Lets see, you are presented with health risks of meats themselves by me and you ignored them.
You diverted to issues of pesticides, herbicides, steriods, bacteria. When presented information on this you diverted to "jungle tribes".
You skipped over the issue of carcinogens pretty much entirely.
You dismissed the factors of environment and genetics.

I won't even get into your "i studied statistics...." claims.

However, all you have constantly done is jump around the fact that meat is not a necessity of the human diet. We can achive all our nutritional needs from plants, and in doing so have a diet that is optimal. A plant based diet not only is complete, it is more efficent, provides more "bang for the buck", and has reduced health risks.

So if you have looked up any studies on health, longevity, etc and diet you will see that vegans are healthier and have longer life expectancy.

Now as to your hunter, he is not going to eat the entire deer at once. He also has to deal with whatever toxins have accumulated in the deer.
Tangerine Sheri
Well said hyper and not to mention Geri just spent her time providing links to help robbie Either robbie is confused or .............????Whats going on robbie....this thread is full of information good sound well researched and many who live the lifestyle some for years....I have no reason to not consume meat other than I don't need too( if i its not nessecary to eat meat and its actually toxic to myself and the enviorment why do it ????) and at this juncture in humanity and industry its simply not safe to do so.....I agree with Hyper scientifically speaking it is logical to not only eat an optimal diet it "lightens my footsteps" I loved that Hyper lol.......Can yu give some insight into how we are socialized what we have a 'taste" for..you are much better than I with the technical stuff thanks Hyper... wub.gif
Beckys_Mom
QUOTE(robbieb @ May 25 2006, 04:32 PM) [snapback]1204871[/snapback]

i understand that life as shorter thne what i meant was cancer was unheard of and there are tribes that eat meat and veggies that have no history of cancer what so ever and sc ientist are studying thme to find out why. so if meat cuases cancewr then they should have cancer. and u can have organic meat too so it goews both wasy with e pesticided on the inoprganci meat and steriods in meat too. i mean a hunter who shotts a deer and eats it wont have to worry aobut if it was begin fed steriods or anything right? and he also wont have to worry aobut it rotting becuase its usualy eaten fast. until somone can explain to me how these tribes that eat meat everyday have no history of cancer but me eating clean non steriod fed cattle and chickens and fish and thel ike will give me cancer i wont belive there is a link between the two. statics can be tweaked my friends. for along time they said cell phones gave u brin tumors because people who had brin tumors ususaly used a cell phone but so did alot of other people and a larger majority dont get brain tumors. then they siad its the side oh the head u use the phone on that determins what side of brain gets the tumor but thre are other possibilitys looking at one aspect of something will never give u a full answer. the truth is its eaing processed foods like twinkies and things liek thaqt with all these chemicals in them that cause the cells to go crazy when exposed to them it was very very very very rare for someone to get cancer back in the day but now look at how many children have cancers. there is a link here and its not meat. some meat that is pumped ewith these steroids and chemicals may add to it but so woudl eating inorgance veggies. theres a bigger picture to look at here. and i feel most of you arentl ooking at it. and belive me if u know anything aobut statics you would know that its all in how you say it that gives it its meaing for instance 4 out of 5 docotrs say triedent is better for your teeth then other gums. ok but who are these doctors and did they ask maby 30 docotrs and only took a fraction of that they wanted ot get this result. i had to do a statics project where we had to do something like that. it realy opened my eyes i dont trust survey liek that anymore.


ALL information no matter what it is...its ALL posted on line...so you dont trust links huh?? even if they are written by experts that are educated on it?? LOL ok then robbie...since you are so blind to that...go ahead ask your doctor....i'll bet you anything you WONT ASK w00t.gif
mklsgl
I didn't know that a valid argument against the benefits of a vegetarian/vegan diet ever existed. And, I can't imagine any logical reasoning to back one.

540+ posts and the "strongest" retorts concerning vegetarianism and/or veganism consist of pure fallacy ("It's natural for humans to eat meat"), denial-blindness-obstinance ("Show me facts/stats and then I'll say that facts/stats can be used to prove or disprove anything, so, therefore, they're worthless"), and genuine ignorance from uncultivated minds ("It's just stupid to think a plant-based diet is healthier for the body and the planet").

****************************************************************************

"Oh, Mama, can this really be the end?/ To be stuck inside a mobile/ With the Memphis Blues again?"
skratch
So... You're for or against vegan/vegetarianism? And why/why not?

Your post confused me... :S
Tangerine Sheri
QUOTE(skratch @ May 25 2006, 12:00 PM) [snapback]1205100[/snapback]

So... You're for or against vegan/vegetarianism? And why/why not?

Your post confused me... :S

Scratch he's for it his parenthsis are quotes that he finds absurd, forgive him he is on cloud nine these days LOL wub.gif
mklsgl
My apologies...

Yes, thank you, Sheri, for the words I somehow failed to write and, more importantly, for interpreting my thoughts, making them clear.

There is no valid argument against the benefits of a vegetarian or vegan diet.

****************************************************************
Praise be to Nero's Neptune/The Titanic sails at dawn/And everybody's shouting/"Which Side Are You On?"...
And Ezra Pound and T. S. Eliot/Fighting in the captain's tower/While calypso singers laugh at them/And fishermen hold flowers...
Between the windows of the sea/Where lovely mermaids flow/And nobody has to think too much/About Desolation Row...
***
Yeah, cloud nine is about right (winky, winky).


hyperactive
QUOTE
Can yu give some insight into how we are socialized what we have a 'taste" for..


there are two basic issues at play: there is our natural/instictual reactions to tastes, and our conditioned responses to tastes (feedback).

At the instictual level, yes, there are tastes that cause a "gag reflex". The body is hard-wired to know certian things are poisonous, for example.

Past that level though, our tastes are developed through exposure and conditioning. We get feedback not just biologically, but socially. We can become desensitized to tastes, and adapted to others. A positive feedback can cause any taste to become sought-after. The "raw" stimulus is connected to a result, which if positive will result in the development of a liking for a taste. Also, exposure allows for desensitizing of a taste, increasing the intensity required for the same effect. This is how people can end up "pouring" salt on their foods, for example. The threshold for "salty" stimulation is shifted by their salt-adding ways. Tastes also work in opposing pairs. This is why to make something seem sweeter, you can add a little salt. So in the salt example, a desensitized salt palate will also have an altered sweet palate. Much like behaviour in general, people build their taste palates through continual habituation.

(It has been some time since i have thought about this so if you see an error, please correct. If this does not sound coherent please ask questions)
Beckys_Mom
If more and more people went off eating meat...the hunters would feel worthless....the butchers would be out of a trade...and then what?? w00t.gif
skratch
QUOTE(Beckys_Mom @ May 25 2006, 08:27 PM) [snapback]1205659[/snapback]

If more and more people went off eating meat...the hunters would feel worthless....the butchers would be out of a trade...and then what?? w00t.gif


Hunters kill for themselves usually. They don't go kill some deer in the wild and then sell it on the market to the public.
As for the butchers, I'm not especially worried. This would be a gradual thing, it's not like it would happen immediately.
The only thing that you could argue would be financially devastated would be the farming industry. And since my original point was that it is cruel and unnecessary to eat animals, I don't really care about them.
Again, it would be a VERY gradual process, and is almost guaranteed not to happen. Humans have developed a taste for meat, and they can come up with the most bizarre reasons for why they eat it. You can't convince someone of a fact if they don't want to believe it, which is clearly evident in this thread.
But as for the factory farming industry - If everyone decided to stop eating meat all at once, I'd be happy to watch them declare bankruptcy, suffer and starve for all the excessive and superfluous pain that they inflicted on their animals. They would get what they deserve, in my opinion.
skratch
I would also quickly like to add, that meat will be around for longer than we are around, and we need not worry about these things. Eating it is a personal decision that you have to make. You can choose to be ignorant to it, and surrender to your taste buds, but I hope you can all taste guilt when you swallow.
You know the animal you are eating led a deprived and painful life, and you know you are putting things into your body that shouldn't be there. You also know you would be healthier without it, and you know the arguments you give to support it are not very defendable. But! It tastes damn good.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.