Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Why is British TV so much better than American?
Unexplained Mysteries Discussion Forums > Other > Movies, Music, Books & Television Shows
Pages: 1, 2
Pale_Horse
I know what y'all will say,
"Pale_Horse, you're an American, you like beer, you smoke, you love American football, you love baseball, you love guns, etc.... Why in the h*ll would a person like you enjoy British TV?"

IMO, British TV has the funniest d*mn shows on the planet. Shows like Black Adder, Father Ted, League of Gentlemen, AYBS, The Young Ones, etc... are immeasurably more witty than mainstream American shows. Why is that? I don't know. Perhaps it is just me that thinks this. I feel that American shows are being "dumbed down" while their British counterparts are not. What are your opinions on the subject? original.gif
lil_kanga77
I used to watch the Young Ones all the time, too.

Don't forget Faulty Towers! (or sometimes known as Farty Towels on the sign out the front ... hehe)

I just think the British are better at comedy - old fashioned, good natured comedy, that is!


thumbsup.gif
Pale_Horse
QUOTE (lil_kanga77 @ Sep 25 2003, 03:48 PM)
I used to watch the Young Ones all the time, too.

Don't forget Faulty Towers! (or sometimes known as Farty Towels on the sign out the front ... hehe)

I just think the British are better at comedy - old fashioned, good natured comedy, that is!


thumbsup.gif

Yes! Loved Fawlty Towers! Classic. Wasn't one of the spellings "Flowery Tw*ts"? Hehe... laugh.gif
lil_kanga77
Oops, Fawlty Towers!

And yes, I believe it was!

laugh.gif
Thistle
Yes I know I'm biased but I have to agree with u lol My only answer would be that in Britain we do not seem to be as afraid to make comedy shows that would be seen as very un-politically correct as elsewhere, take Allo Allo for instance, I cannot imagine any other country making a comedy series based in Nazi occcupied France and rippping the a**e out of the gestapo!!!!!!!!
My all time favourite tho has got to be Only Fools and Horses, don't know if u get that in US but ure missing out if u don't.
But hey, u churn out some good ones as well u know esp the Simpsons lol



grin2.gif grin2.gif
peachykeane
Well we Brits do make great comedy but we still haven't got any drama as 'quality' as the Sopranos or Six Feet Under and while US comedy might not be as off the wall as some of ours there's still some really good stuff.

Best British drama we've had for years was Clocking Off and that's ended! sad.gif
Seraphina
With the exception of Frazier, I havn't seen a single US sitcom that's actually funny (in fairness though, Frazier is genius)...

Father Ted, on the other hand, is the funniest thing I have ever seen grin2.gif

"You mean we put the brick on the accelerator?"
peachykeane
AHHH GO ON, GO ON, GO ON!
sarkypi
I haven't watched British t.v. in awhile, but I noticed that the British spend less on props and more the writing, which is fine by me.
think fast
All I can say is RED DWARF! The best show that ever happened to UK television.
Anyone remeber that one?
kpruitt
QUOTE (thistle1 @ Sep 25 2003, 03:46 PM)
Yes I know I'm biased but I have to agree with u lol  My only answer would be that in Britain we do not seem to be as afraid to make comedy shows that would be seen as very un-politically correct as elsewhere, take Allo Allo for instance, I cannot imagine any other country making a comedy series based in Nazi occcupied France and rippping the a**e out of the gestapo!!!!!!!!
My all time favourite tho has got to be Only Fools and Horses, don't know if u get that in US but ure missing out if u don't.
But hey, u churn out some good ones as well u know esp the Simpsons lol



grin2.gif  grin2.gif

We had a show similar to that... it was called Hogan's Heroes. At the rate that we are stealing show ideas from the U.K. I'd say American television will soon look quite a bit like British television.
Benjo Koolzooie
What UK program ideas have been stolen by America then?
Just wondering.... whistling2.gif
kpruitt
QUOTE (Benjo Koolzooie @ Sep 28 2003, 11:59 PM)
What UK program ideas have been stolen by America then?
Just wondering.... whistling2.gif

Survivor and Trading Spaces are current high-rated shows that originated in the U.K. There are several comedies that were on that were based on U.K. shows, but I can't think of them at the moment.
sarkypi
Who let that slimey American Spielberg get his hands on Doctor Who!!! disgust.gif
Cufflink
QUOTE (sarkypi @ Sep 29 2003, 08:01 AM)
Who let that slimey American Spielberg get his hands on Doctor Who!!! disgust.gif

Great news, Sarkypi! original.gif

Doctor Who is coming back, and it's being made by the BBC! grin2.gif

http://www.bbc.co.uk/cult/doctorwho/
Phantom
And who could forget Bottom? Monty Python's Flying Circus? Men Behaving Badly? The list is endless! laugh.gif
Halo_Jones
One of my fav shows is being remade in America as we speak..The Office....unfortunatly the guy who plays David Brent (Ricky Gervais) is not appearing in it but he is out there now advising the program makers.
Another British classic is ...Absolutley Fabulous.
My fav American Comedy at the mo is..... Malcolm in the middle...the reason I think that it's so popular over here is that it goes against most American Family comedies in the way it has no moral message during each episode. We British hate that!
Benjo Koolzooie
QUOTE (Halo_Jones @ Sep 29 2003, 12:51 PM)

Another British classic is ...Absolutley Fabulous.

My fav American Comedy at the mo is..... Malcolm in the middle...the reason I think that it's so popular over here is that it goes against most American Family comedies in the way it has no moral message during each episode. We British hate that!

Ab fab yep!
Deffinetly no morals there! laugh.gif
Pale_Horse
QUOTE (Benjo Koolzooie @ Sep 29 2003, 01:59 AM)
What UK program ideas have been stolen by America then?
Just wondering.... whistling2.gif

"Coupling" , an American version just debuted here last week.
schadeaux
Benny Hill!!! w00t.gif


And Phantom is right. Monty Python has got to be the best comedy troupe ever!


w00t.gif laugh.gif laugh.gif
Althalus
Brilliant comedy shows, that I like (in no particular order) are:

Blackadder 1 - 4

Red Dwarf

Mr Bean

Only Fools and Horses

Absolutely Fabulous

Men Behaving Badly

Monty Python's Flying Circus

My Family

The American ones I like are:

Friends

Malcolm in the Middle


In the US there were versions of Red Dwarf and Men Behaving Badly, but they did not do as well as the British versions, the reason I think for this is that the British ones are sometimes better scripted, and are also are verbal in gags, were as many US ones are visual.
snuffypuffer
Monty Python is the bomb diggety. Hey, Mr. Show was excellent, so we got some good comedy, just not a lot. Sitcoms over here more or less suck. Haven't seen a lot of British comedy, except for So Graham Norton, I like Graham Norton.
sarkypi
QUOTE (Cufflink @ Sep 29 2003, 10:17 AM)
QUOTE (sarkypi @ Sep 29 2003, 08:01 AM)
Who let that slimey American Spielberg get his hands on Doctor Who!!! disgust.gif

Great news, Sarkypi! original.gif

Doctor Who is coming back, and it's being made by the BBC! grin2.gif

http://www.bbc.co.uk/cult/doctorwho/

Oh, Cuffy wub.gif

That is great news, I so miss this show... original.gif

Thanky for the tip... grin2.gif

Who fans are hard to find here, or slightly more frightnening that Trek fans.
Cufflink
QUOTE (sarkypi @ Sep 30 2003, 01:29 AM)
Who fans are hard to find here, or slightly more frightnening that Trek fans.

laugh.gif

Some of the ones over here are pretty frightening, too. grin2.gif
colorless
Mr. Bean's awesome grin2.gif
One of the best ones is the church one.
Cufflink
QUOTE (siphis @ Sep 30 2003, 02:26 AM)
Mr. Bean's awesome  grin2.gif
One of the best ones is the church one.

I totally agree. Rowan Atkinson is one of Britain's finest comedy actors.
Pale_Horse
QUOTE (Cufflink @ Sep 29 2003, 08:52 PM)
QUOTE (sarkypi @ Sep 30 2003, 01:29 AM)
Who fans are hard to find here, or slightly more frightnening that Trek fans.

laugh.gif

Some of the ones over here are pretty frightening, too. grin2.gif

Soooo.... It's not normal to construct a replica of the TARDIS interior in your bathroom? Not that I have done that or anything..... whistling2.gif

It's not like everytime my wife walks in while I'm taking a shower, I ask her if she wants to see my "sonic screwdriver". wink2.gif
*MoG*
Doctor Who Rocks

I have just been on holiday to Mallorca so I'm not 100% up to date on the latest news, although I do remember my fella reading me a snippit from the paper saying that Doctor Who is going to be made more up to date, and he might be gay (as the new writer is the same guy that wrote Queer as Folk, I can't remember his name).

Actors in the running so far are Alan Davies, Richard E Grant and Stephen Fry.

I'm sure that the article also said that Doctor Who could also be a woman. I'm not too sure I'd like that, Doctor Who has always been a man (yes I know there are female time lords i.e. Rommana, but she was a side kick)

I wonder if they will bring back K9?

P.s. UK Gold is showing repeats of Doctor Who everyday..

clap.gif clap.gif clap.gif clap.gif clap.gif clap.gif clap.gif
Cufflink
QUOTE (Pale_Horse @ Oct 1 2003, 03:21 PM)
Soooo....  It's not normal to construct a replica of the TARDIS interior in your bathroom?  Not that I have done that or anything..... whistling2.gif

It's not like everytime my wife walks in while I'm taking a shower, I ask her if she wants to see my "sonic screwdriver". wink2.gif

So THAT'S who sarkypi is refering to! grin2.gif

Actually, there's no firm news on anything yet, although I can't see them making The Doctor gay, or a woman, because his sexuality is the one constant throughout his generations.

Personally, I hope we see a return of some of the classic monsters.

Any news should reach the BBC's cult TV site first, and that's at:

http://www0.bbc.co.uk/cult/doctorwho/
sarkypi
QUOTE (Pale_Horse @ Oct 1 2003, 03:21 PM)
It's not like everytime my wife walks in while I'm taking a shower, I ask her if she wants to see my "sonic screwdriver". wink2.gif

So, that's what the Doctor was referring to all those times, those english accents get me everytime laugh.gif

Well, I would hate for it to start with a new generation. Doctor number 8 only got that one god awful movie. He deserves to have a few stories. I mean just to start off with another generation is annoying

QUOTE
Actually, there's no firm news on anything yet, although I can't see them making The Doctor gay, or a woman, because his sexuality is the one constant throughout his generations.


Actually how would one go about making the Doctor being gay?! blink.gif

He's flambouyant enough. Can't be done.

I would like him to be more of a player tho, the Spielberg movie gave him a girlfriend disgust.gif

u think after all these years he would have an illegitimate child somewhere. Perhaps a sidekick son? Like "Angel"

I'm gonna have to have someone tape these babies when they come out. I don't think I'll be able stand knowing they're out there while I have to wait for public t.v. to broadcast them

*MoG*
PERHAPS HIS OFFSPRING COULD BE AN INTER-SPECIES MIXED CHILD, PART TIMELORD, PART CYBERMAN?
Agent_21
A CyberLord? I'm sure I once heard him whisper 'Dalek I love you.'
I hear Tom Baker wants to play The Master. He said 'Then The Doctor could say lines to me like: "You look very familiar."'
sarkypi
QUOTE
PERHAPS HIS OFFSPRING COULD BE AN INTER-SPECIES MIXED CHILD


Isn't the Doctor already bi-species? His kid would be tri-species..not a pretty picture
snuffypuffer
Maybe they should make the Doctor a small dog, like a Dachshund or something, umm, please don't throw stuff at me *duck and cover*
sarkypi
QUOTE (snuffypuffer @ Oct 3 2003, 12:45 AM)
Maybe they should make the Doctor a small dog, like a Dachshund or something, umm, please don't throw stuff at me *duck and cover*

oooooh Snuffy,
I won't can't speak for anyone else. I'm sure u sinned against someone. I remember on public television once the fundraiser host said she'd like to see the doctor get younger and younger with every generation until no more. Haven't seen her since.
snuffypuffer
That's scary, I'd better start watching my back for crazy Doctor Who fans. I got a stick, you'se, and I know how to use it laugh.gif
Agent_21
Yeah, you could throw it for the Dogtor to fetch. At least they could save on the budget - give him a timetravelling doghouse instead of the phonebox.
sarkypi
QUOTE (Agent_21 @ Oct 3 2003, 02:15 AM)
Yeah, you could throw it for the Dogtor to fetch. At least they could save on the budget - give him a timetravelling doghouse instead of the phonebox.

That's if the BBC can figure out how to make doggy house out of saran wrap, rice krispy treats, and alumminum foil.
Anirbas
Well I don't watch much British TV other than Keeping up Appearances and I think I am just gonna bust open when I watch it! American TV is trash - I hardly watch TV anymore!
sarkypi
QUOTE (Anirbas @ Oct 3 2003, 05:26 AM)
Well I don't watch much British TV other than Keeping up Appearances and I think I am just gonna bust open when I watch it! American TV is trash - I hardly watch TV anymore!

Well said,

Unless u have cable, it's not worth watching t.v.
I am liking everwood tho' it reminds me of a slightly saner Northern Exposure with love, and Gilmore Girls with the waspy grandparents.
Cufflink
Latest Doctor Who news:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/cult/news/drwho/2003/...0/06/7221.shtml


I had a whinge on this bit, but it's gone now. Sorry folks.
snuffypuffer
Who attacked who?
sarkypi
QUOTE (Cufflink @ Oct 6 2003, 04:14 PM)
Latest Doctor Who news:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/cult/news/drwho/2003/...0/06/7221.shtml


This might be my last post in a while, due to the bitter attack on a dear friend of mine.

I've lost heart in this forum. crying.gif

What?!!!
Who's gonna tape the show for me then?!!! crying.gif
It's is bad enough I'm stuck with American telly and then some yobbo went and gave the rights to Spielberg, but now I am alone all alone crying.gif crying.gif crying.gif
My world is slowly comming to the end.
Tis in Revelations I am sure....
Only the Dr. can save us now...
Or an apology to a dear friend. crying.gif
snuffypuffer
I'll save you Sarky, be your Knight with Shining Shopping Cart.
sarkypi
QUOTE (snuffypuffer @ Oct 7 2003, 09:04 AM)
I'll save you Sarky, be your Knight with Shining Shopping Cart.

aah yes,
the shopping cart the only link to good telly for us americans, but I still need Cuffy to translate for me. Never could understand those english accents.
snuffypuffer
I can speak with a British accent, but as far as translating, I rarely know what I'm talking about, so I prolly can't help there. But I can make you giggle, that's gotta count for something. grin2.gif
sarkypi
QUOTE (snuffypuffer @ Oct 7 2003, 09:21 AM)
I can speak with a British accent, but as far as translating, I rarely know what I'm talking about, so I prolly can't help there. But I can make you giggle, that's gotta count for something. grin2.gif

Maybe if u giggle like a little english boy
snuffypuffer
teee heee heee?
Nintendork
QUOTE (sarkypi @ Oct 7 2003, 09:34 AM)
QUOTE (snuffypuffer @ Oct 7 2003, 09:21 AM)
I can speak with a British accent, but as far as translating, I rarely know what I'm talking about, so I prolly can't help there.  But I can make you giggle, that's gotta count for something. grin2.gif

Maybe if u giggle like a little english boy

i make my teachers laugh hysterically by saying, "look at me! im american! wheres the beef!! toytoytoytoy!" in a british accent
emmy
I prefer the old British sitcoms to the ones that are on now, although My Family is great, Only Fools and Horses, Dads Army, Allo Allo, Porridge, Butterflies, Goodnight Sweetheart, Open All Hours, Blackadder, The Brittas Empire, Absolutely Fabulous, The Young Ones, Bottom, The Detectives, Keeping Up Appearances, The Vicar of Dibley are just a selection of my favourite sitcoms.
I think that the US have some great drama programmes that are better than British ones such as The West wing, The Sopranos, Law and Order and Boomtown, which are all excellent
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.