With the live Halloween special of Most Haunted scheduled for next week and with it getting a lot of negative press over the past few years for my first post I would like to put forward my support to the crew involved in creating the Most Haunted TV show...
I have been a fan of Most Haunted since it's very first episode when I accidentaly came across it while flicking channels on my TV. I was immediately drawn into its Blair Witch similarities, new night vision techniques and my general interest in the paranormal. Since then I have attended a couple of the live shows and spoken to some of the people involved.
In the beginning Most Haunted was a small 1/2 hour show watched by a tiny fraction of Living TV viewers where investigations involved 1 nightvision camera, 1 parasychologist in Jason Karl and 1 'medium' Derek Acorah.
To watch the first series now is like watching a completely different programme. Yvette proves to be a very inexperienced ghost hunter who jumps at every single sound, screams all the time, thinks irrationally and hides behind anyone she can (she has definitely improved). The use of the camera and sound equipment is average at best and you can tell that noone on the show including the experts have any idea what to do and how to report what is going on.
The first series is much more raw than anything since because this was the time Most Haunted was still a small experimental show. A time when the production company and crew had very little money and knowledge of what to do and expect. That is why the footage discovered during its first run is much stronger than anything found at later stages simply because they wouldn't have had the time, funding or creativity to fake any of it convincingly.
Unfortunately as is usually the case as Most Haunted became a bigger success, so it's critics became louder.
As a fan of the show I am obviously open to criticism myself but when I managed to speak to both Karl and Yvette before a live show at Beaulieu Abbey they both spoke of a genuine interest in parapsychology and the search for truth. When I questioned them about visual effects and hoaxing Karl simply replied. That if they where to fake anything they would only manage to undermine themselves, parapsychologists and any genuine footage they actually catch. It was only a few minutes but during that time I didn't see any reason to question their integrity.
That said of course they are in the entertainment business but then if everything about the show was fixed wouldn't every episode look like the BBC's Ghost Watch? Another show that attempted to hoax the nation in the 90's? Plus people who have genuinely experienced paranormal activity will already know that you don't have to fake anything, if you are patient enough things that can't be exlained will just happen.
I also think that Living TV and Antix are well within their rights to make as much money as they can from a show they created, as are people who create and run great websites like Unexplained Mysteries are too.
Over the past few years Most Haunted deserves credit for listening to its critics. Firstly by getting rid of the shows biggest liability, the always theatrical Derek Acorah. Derek was the main reason I felt Most Haunted was getting the abuse it did and although a popular part of the show ( He annoyed the hell out of me, but my mum loved him) by releasing him they did the right thing. Now with David Wells as the main psychic the shows have been much better to watch and some of the footage captured has been excellent.
Another masterstroke was managing to persuade Ciaran O'Keefe who was the shows most publicly outspoken critic to come back on board, according to his website he has been entirely happy with everything in the programme since his return and is therefore happy to continue his relationship with them.
Of course you can argue about Most Haunted until you're blue in the face but what can't be argued is that Most Haunted was a brilliant idea, made a great television show and created a phenomenon.
What possibly annoys it's critics more than anything is probably the fact that they didn't think of the idea first.