QUOTE(jpalz @ Nov 10 2006, 03:24 AM) [snapback]1421524[/snapback]
First of all, I'm sorry to hear about your experience in that forum KBA.
Yeah, unfortunately many times people get so rigid with that they believe that it becomes a distortion of what the original belief is, leading to.... yup, you guessed it, bigotry. And I get sick of that as much as you do.
*Silly mode on*
Mmm... I've got an electric guitar here, an Ibanez. I wonder how it would look like on their heads...
*Silly mode off*
Now, regarding your original post, I wanted to comment some parts of it.
Yup, faith has to be questioned, otherwise you would be some kinda mindless drone. I'm not very fond of using Bible verses, just because I'm a lazy-a$$ to look for it on the Net or to get up from the chair I'm writing, walk 10 feet and grab the Bible, but this verse came up to my mind right now. It goes a bit like this:
Now, saying that anyone of right mind would give up their belief is more debatable, but for now let's just stick to the main point here, mmmkay?
Mmm... unfortunately many times people close themselves to other persons because of the rigidness of their own beliefs. I'm not targeting just Christians or Muslim or Wiccans or the followers of the Jack Bauer Church, but also people with no religious belief whatsoever (some of their sites on the Internet are so arrogant and full of bigotry that in the end there's no way you can take them seriously- the comment about the electric guitar is valid on them too

).
So, where am I going? That bigotry is not a problem of the religion itself, because if it were because of that, most religious people would be arrogant, bigot "poo-heads" (you know the real term that would go in here, the one that starts with an sh**) when it's rather a minority of them -Shirley Phelps anyone?- but rather of how people take their beliefs (or lack of).
Well KBA, what do you think about it?
Hullo, nothing too bad about my experience.. not far from what I expected to find.
And I think the people that are like this tend to be the fundamentalist Christians, I know first-hand because of my dad.
QUOTE(IamsSon @ Nov 10 2006, 04:37 AM) [snapback]1421575[/snapback]
I believe that if Jesus were alive today and on the internet, He would more likely be here in UM than on a Christian site because the true Christian understands that eternity in Heaven is not the goal, it is a reward, the goal is a personal relationship with God, and that personal relationship includes completing the work that God prepared you for and prepared for you.
However, I have to wonder if the answers you got would have been different if these people had know you were not what you advertised yourself to be. You see the answers they gave you were correct. From the Christian perspective, no matter how nice someone is, they have sinned at some point in their lives and so, have earned the sentence of eternal separation from God (death, hell). But if they had been aware that you were not a Christian they may have tried to explain this (it's a big IF, I'll admit, but I can always hope they would have done the right thing), and not been so harsh with their answers.
If Jesus were alive today, from what we can draw from the bible, he would be completely disgusted with U-M and any other Christian site, and almost any site on the internet.
The answers they gave were what they believed. If they are looking at it as an argument their answers will change and intolerance will prevent any conversation.
And they don't need to explain it to me, I've been deep into Christianity, I've been brainwashed by its cutesy "Jesus loves you" image. I know how it works, I just want to have someone who currently is Christian say it so it sounds less biased.
If we are all loved by god then why does acknowledging Jesus put us in any better standing? Have you ever been angry at a stuffed animal for something that stuffed animal did? No, because it would be beneath you. Just like any of our sins would be beneath any real God.
QUOTE(SoldierKG @ Nov 10 2006, 06:24 AM) [snapback]1421665[/snapback]
1.Christian chat rooms are not even close to being majorly Christian
2.Why were you looking in a chat room and not a church?
I have been to many chat rooms and as a Christian have been shocked at the fact that those poeple are calling themselves Christian. I have talked to people in Christian chat who have said they don't believe in Jesus yet will still call themselves Christians. Christian Chat is not a reliable source.
Let's establish some stuff.
1.Everyone sins
2.Your friend is a someone so then he to has sinned.
3.You:If God makes us knowing that most of us will not accept him and end up tortured, then does he really love us?
I'm not going to go to a church to get a few posts. And yes, the people were authentic christians

. They went directly with what the Bible says and with what Every other true Christian I know would say.
I know my friend has "sinned" based on the Bible, and that everyone has.. But that's irrelevant. The argument went so far as for them to say he is a bad person and not a good person. That's intolerance and bigotry no matter how you spin it. And it's what the true fundie Christians believe. Remember those "God hates [homosexuals]" protestors everyone so loathed? They were the closest to the bible's teachings, considering the bible wants Gay people murdered. Not forgiven.
QUOTE(SoldierKG @ Nov 10 2006, 06:24 AM) [snapback]1421665[/snapback]
Well God created everyone with a free will. That's like saying if you know your child is going to be born into a world of violence and hatred why not abort it? Then where would we be? And please do not say that my analogy is not the same. If it isn't please show me how it isn't. Also you look at hell like a torure chamber, but when you look into it by denying the existence of God we are asking for it. (I don't mean that how I am pretty sure you think I mean it.)
It isn't the same. A proper analogy would be if you know your child will be tortured and murdered with your approval because they are different than you, and you still have them born while you claim to love them. And when it happens you could stop the torture and murder, but instead you condone and take part in it. Don't try to say THAT isn't a proper analogy, because it is the exact same thing. Although how God could require vengeance on such a puny, inferior, defenseless being is questionable in and of itself. See the teddy bear reference.
By denying the existance of God we are asking for torture? SO since you deny Allah do you think you deserve to be mamed by his followers or Allah himself? What about Budda, should he be the real god and hate you for denying him do you think you deserve his punishment? Krishna? Zeus? Neptune? Vishnu? Etc? If God can not clearly tell us that the word is his own, why the heck would he punish us for uncertainty if it is or not? I am not denying God, I'm denying Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, Paul, David, Job, etc.
QUOTE(SoldierKG @ Nov 10 2006, 06:24 AM) [snapback]1421665[/snapback]
Look at it this way we are spiritually designed for God. Our sole purpose is to serve him (Doesn't that make God conceited?) maybe, but if your perfect you can be.
This is the heart of my post. You can not be conceited and perfect, the 2 are a contradiction. If you are perfect, you have no desire to be conceited. It's a human emotion, because the bible was written by humans. Those of faith will accept pitfalls in their religion because they look past that so they can still believe they have a spot in paradise. If you make billions of people to serve you endlessly, even when they are of no help to you, you are imperfect. Perfection can not co-exist with imperfection, because something that's perfect has no reason to exist in the first place. And if it did exist, it would be the only thing to exist, because it is perfect and needs nothing else. If something has a creator, it is imperfect because something has authority over it. If something does not have a creator, and is perfect, it would not create because it is self sufficient in full. The need for praise is again, a human and imperfect emotion.
Christianity or other such religion is not hard to contradict, but it is hard to remove. Because the heavily faithful will desregard even the most obvious and incriminating contradictions, Progress can only be made in doubt. If people have no doubt, you yourself can not convince them otherwise. They can see your points and create doubt themselves, but only then can religion be given up.
And no, I take no offense in your post, because if I let myself take offense in opinions that are different that mine, then I form assumptions and can't try to understand or debate them at the same time.
------------
I'm going to stem a little off topic here, I will post my experiences with Christianity to possibly give people a small bit of insight into what I am saying here.
So, basically I was raised Christian. Two Christian parents, church every Sunday and Tuesday, can't date until 16, and only people from the church, prayer and quiet time every day, you get the idea. It decided alot of my opinions, politically, spiritually, and socially. I never really questioned it until I was 13. And before that, I sat there just like everyone who I am now arguing against and gave misguided logic as to why God can't be denied etc. etc. I know what it's like to be there and you see everything through a screen that you cannot know about until you've left it behind. So when I was 13 it started to seem wrong to me. The major turning point was when this friend whom I talked about earlier asked me that question.. "Do you think I'm going to hell." I reluctantly told him yes. And it felt wrong, and I knew it was wrong. I basically became aware of being brainwashed. So then I began to read the bible from a skeptic's point of view, and it became quickly obvious how absurd it really was. I gave up Christianity pretty quickly after that, yet still went to church because I didn't know what my parents would do if I told them. But eventually I got tired of agreeing with their stuck-up preachings and proud comments and told them flat out (Just a few months ago, I'm currently 14, about to turn 15.) And I expected it, but because of the intolerance my parents have from Christianity, I became less to them. My dad has since taken up a habit of pointing out each of my mistakes to me, and my mom basically is her same old psychotic (That's not an exaggeration with the things she's done) self but less friendly towards me now. They don't buy me anything but the basic needs for life, while they spoil my baptised sister rotten with a car, $300 blinds, a new $200 bedframe, too many clothing items to count, and so on. I'm not complaining to anyone, I really don't mind because I know that I live very well compared to many in this world, I'm only using that as an example of what it can do to people. They try to get me to come to Church every time they go and yell when I do not oblige (which is always).
So as you can see I'm quite disobedient of my parents, but in my eyes with good reason. Not to sound overly condescending but when your parents are still trapped in a fairy tale reality (and they spend much of their time on it), it's hard to take orders seriously. You begin to question their authority over you because they themselves have such biased and intolerant attitudes. I think most people in my situation would understand. Now I wonder, who here, what Christian here thinks that because I am disobedient to my parents that I should be stoned to death as your Lord demands (Since I "do not accept Jesus' forgiveness")? I would love to see any Christian look me in the eye and tell me they really believe that, and then take them to court and get them locked up.
QUOTE("the bible")
Deut 21:18-21
18 If someone has a stubborn and rebellious son who will not obey his father and mother, who does not heed them when they discipline him, 19then his father and his mother shall take hold of him and bring him out to the elders of his town at the gate of that place. 20They shall say to the elders of his town, ‘This son of ours is stubborn and rebellious. He will not obey us. He is a glutton and a drunkard.’ 21Then all the men of the town shall stone him to death. So you shall purge the evil from your midst; and all Israel will hear, and be afraid.
The bible is a foul and disgusting book..
I would like to end that by saying I am in no way shape or form complaining or whining, I simply look forward to the future and appreciate what I do have now. I'm not asking for pity nor reassurance, I am simply trying to make a point.