rezna
Nov 15 2006, 10:52 PM
OMG.
I just read this book. It's incredible! I have an all new theory about what's going on with paranormal incidinces. Everyone, if you are at all into the paranormal, this book is a must read. You can get it for 6 bucks as an e-book, which is what I did. Man, I want to read it again! I just recently started getting back into the paranormal. I've always been a huge X-files fan, and the X-files is just an entertaining way to see paranormal stuff since there isn't anything good on tv about this stuff anymore. I miss Sightings, that was a great show. Anyways, go get this book! Now!
I am thoroughly fascinated now with Utah. I want to go there and look at this farm, just to see it in real life. I don't care about having any experiences, I just want to look at it so the story itsself has more context. It's just amazing to hear these stories. They are profound and happen similarly in other places, too. I refuse to believe that anything paranormal isn't really happening. It cannot be a shared delusion through hundreds of thousands of peoples/experiencers.
We are NOT alone.
Bearly
Nov 16 2006, 04:11 AM
QUOTE(rezna @ Nov 15 2006, 10:52 PM) [snapback]1428408[/snapback]
OMG.
I am thoroughly fascinated now with Utah. I want to go there and look at this farm, just to see it in real life. I don't care about having any experiences, I just want to look at it so the story itsself has more context. It's just amazing to hear these stories. They are profound and happen similarly in other places, too. I refuse to believe that anything paranormal isn't really happening. It cannot be a shared delusion through hundreds of thousands of peoples/experiencers.
We are NOT alone.
I believe in keeping an open mind, but I wouldn't swallow everything regarding the paranormal that you hear. A lot of it is true, but there are some crazy ideas out there. Could you give a brief description of the topics this book covers? Is it supposed to be factual or fiction?
rezna
Nov 16 2006, 05:57 PM
QUOTE(Bearly @ Nov 15 2006, 08:11 PM) [snapback]1428642[/snapback]
I believe in keeping an open mind, but I wouldn't swallow everything regarding the paranormal that you hear. A lot of it is true, but there are some crazy ideas out there. Could you give a brief description of the topics this book covers? Is it supposed to be factual or fiction?
Well, I have an open mind to the paranormal. I believe that Science is the destroyer of an open mind. The more we allow formulas and the scientific method to rule our lives, we'll end up like those people in the latest South Park episode saying things like, "Oh my Science, or Science H Science" Science people are just as zealous as religious people.
Anyways
The book is about a farm in Utah which a family moved to because they wanted to get away from small town gossip. They lived there for around 6 months to a year before anything started to happen. They started experiencing very weird phenomena. The usual stuff though, all in one place. Orbs, Bigfoot appearances, strange other wordly animals, UFO's, etc. The owner got fed up with it after 14 of his prized bulls were mutilated. NIDS, the National Institute for Discovery Science heard about his plight and offered to buy the farm to study it. This is book is the story of the owner of Skinwalker Ranch and his experiences before the NIDS team came on the property, and then the 10 years of research described by two of the NIDS team scientists. Keep in mind that these are Physicists, with PHDs out on this ranch trying to get scientifically proven paranormal evidence. Of course, it didn't really amount to much except this excellent book.
I do not think that eye witnesses make this stuff up, or that they are hallucinating. The end of the book explains their hypothesis of what might be going on at the ranch and it's fascinating. Like I said, I have an all new idea of what paranormal is. We can't look at anything in this world as black and white, it's either real or its not. That is simply not true. What people see is something they see and people like the owners of this ranch had no reason to make any of it up. They were traumatized by it. They lost money from it. THey had to move twice to get away from it.
It's a wonderful read, and just utterly fascinating. There are a lot of websites with snipets of the story, which is how I came upon it. Just do a google for NIDS or Skinwalker Ranch and you'll find all kinds of info about it.
Bearly
Nov 17 2006, 05:41 AM
Thanks for giving more details. It sounds more interesting to me now. I take it now that it is non-fiction, correct me if I'm wrong.
As a scientist who has had paranormal experiences myself and then tried to get other scientists to believe me, I have to agree that dependence on science can lead to a closed mind and it can be as bad as religion. Thanks for posting.
Sweetpumper
Nov 17 2006, 03:52 PM
I'm getting it as a gift for Christmas.
rezna
Nov 17 2006, 07:06 PM
QUOTE(Bearly @ Nov 16 2006, 09:41 PM) [snapback]1429840[/snapback]
Thanks for giving more details. It sounds more interesting to me now. I take it now that it is non-fiction, correct me if I'm wrong.
As a scientist who has had paranormal experiences myself and then tried to get other scientists to believe me, I have to agree that dependence on science can lead to a closed mind and it can be as bad as religion. Thanks for posting.
Your welcome! And what a refreshing post! Someone who applauds me for my opinions, yay! This other message board I was on was horrible. They would tear me down, anything I would say. Good to hear from a scientist who has brains (haha!)
Bearly
Nov 18 2006, 06:21 PM
QUOTE(rezna @ Nov 17 2006, 07:06 PM) [snapback]1430511[/snapback]
Your welcome! And what a refreshing post! Someone who applauds me for my opinions, yay! This other message board I was on was horrible. They would tear me down, anything I would say. Good to hear from a scientist who has brains (haha!)
We have people that will challenge you on this board also, but they have a right to their opinion also. However, a lot of people besides myself have had some kind of paranormal experience and such people are often attracted to this board. So you will find a higher percentage of people with open minds on this board.
IMO a truely good scientist tries to consider all possibilities when seeking the truth and this requires an open mind. Sometimes, some theories can't be tested to everyone's safisfaction, this does not mean that the initial hypothesis is wrong. Unfortunatly, many scientist become biased or only see things through the prism of their field of specialty or there pet theories. This will even affect their interpretation of the results. Even so, as previously stated, I do not believe everything, some things sound more plausible than others, but I try to keep an open mind until firmly proven one way or the other. And sometimes I go out on a limb and believe without proof. I could make a mistake, but so what, that's not a crime. I hope you will continue to enjoy this website and have good experiences. You will learn a lot if you stick around.
boorite
Nov 20 2006, 08:41 AM
This book completely stunned me. It's as if some huge, insane, nonhuman intelligence said "let's dump every crazy paranormal thing in the world into this one family's lap and see what happens." It's not presented as a fictionalization "based on true events." It's supposed to be a sober, straightforward, journalistic account of things that happened to a real family on this particular ranch. It'll change your definition of "weird," that's for sure.
About "science" and what it does to your thinking. Science as a method opens one's mind.
On the other hand, science as an establishment of careerists careering along in their careers can be limiting, I think. For example, there are questions you investigate and questions you simply don't. Not if you want tenure.
And on the third hand is something I'd call scientism. This is a viewpoint that imbues science with all sorts of great properties it doesn't have, like the ability to prove propositions with utter certainty. Often, people who learn a little science are guilty of scientism. They cling to their idea of "science" for pat answers. They are not aware of how much is truly unknown. They tend to dismiss things they can't explain as hallucinations or lies, no matter how implausible that explanation may be.
That ain't science!
Anyway, Hunt for the Skinwalker is indispensible. I hope everyone reads it.
Gatofeo
Nov 26 2006, 03:51 AM
I live in Utah.
I've heard of this farm.
Here, it's known as something of a local urban legend: most of it is fabricated, and what ain't fabricated is made up!
Believe if you must but remember that someone had a book to sell. And your $6 ended up in their pocket.
My understanding is that the family has tried, repeatedly, to play down these rumors but folks won't leave them alone.
I have some experience with being the recipient of hoaxes and local legends. Once reported, it's almost impossible to convince people that it's not true.
No, I haven't read the book. I have no desire to.
boorite
Nov 27 2006, 12:49 AM
For the events in the book to be fabricated, everyone involved, including the authors and their investigative team, would have to conspire in making up the biggest, craziest lie you ever heard and sticking to it all this time. I don't see sufficient reason to come to that conclusion.
The account given in the book cannot be a case of runaway rumors, as the authors had direct access to the experients of these phenomena. Indeed, they worked together closely for an extended period. Some of the events were experienced by the authors themselves and their research team. So a false account couldn't possibly be a result of blowing rumors out of proportion. It would require an airtight conspiracy of big, fat liars.
Gatofeo, you say that your understanding is that the family tried to downplay the events, but folks wouldn't leave them alone. I can agree with this characterization but do not see how it militates against the truth of the account. What exactly do you mean that they have tried to downplay, and how and why? Who hasn't left them alone, and when? How'd you come to this understanding? I am just wondering.
Surely, if rumors about the truth of the reported events can flourish, so can rumors of their falsity. Does anything but rumors suggest that this book represents a conspiracy to defraud the reading public?
uth
Jan 12 2007, 07:56 PM
QUOTE(boorite @ Nov 27 2006, 12:49 AM) [snapback]1439966[/snapback]
For the events in the book to be fabricated, everyone involved, including the authors and their investigative team, would have to conspire in making up the biggest, craziest lie you ever heard and sticking to it all this time. I don't see sufficient reason to come to that conclusion.
The account given in the book cannot be a case of runaway rumors, as the authors had direct access to the experients of these phenomena. Indeed, they worked together closely for an extended period. Some of the events were experienced by the authors themselves and their research team. So a false account couldn't possibly be a result of blowing rumors out of proportion. It would require an airtight conspiracy of big, fat liars.
Gatofeo, you say that your understanding is that the family tried to downplay the events, but folks wouldn't leave them alone. I can agree with this characterization but do not see how it militates against the truth of the account. What exactly do you mean that they have tried to downplay, and how and why? Who hasn't left them alone, and when? How'd you come to this understanding? I am just wondering.
Surely, if rumors about the truth of the reported events can flourish, so can rumors of their falsity. Does anything but rumors suggest that this book represents a conspiracy to defraud the reading public?
I'm reading this book now. I haven't decided yet if I fully believe it, but it is very interesting.
FWIW though, there is a thread on this very board where people posted their own skinwalker encounters:
http://www.unexplained-mysteries.com/forum...p?showtopic=275
Isis2200
Jan 13 2007, 12:02 AM
QUOTE(rezna @ Nov 15 2006, 05:52 PM) [snapback]1428408[/snapback]
OMG.
I just read this book. It's incredible! I have an all new theory about what's going on with paranormal incidinces. Everyone, if you are at all into the paranormal, this book is a must read. You can get it for 6 bucks as an e-book, which is what I did. Man, I want to read it again! I just recently started getting back into the paranormal. I've always been a huge X-files fan, and the X-files is just an entertaining way to see paranormal stuff since there isn't anything good on tv about this stuff anymore. I miss Sightings, that was a great show. Anyways, go get this book! Now!
I am thoroughly fascinated now with Utah. I want to go there and look at this farm, just to see it in real life. I don't care about having any experiences, I just want to look at it so the story itsself has more context. It's just amazing to hear these stories. They are profound and happen similarly in other places, too. I refuse to believe that anything paranormal isn't really happening. It cannot be a shared delusion through hundreds of thousands of peoples/experiencers.
We are NOT alone.
Hi Rezna,
I read the book about a year ago, and I loved it. What do you think is the cause of all the anomalous occurrences on the ranch? military activities or a vortex on the property?
http://ashiana.conforums.com/index.cgi~ Isis
nativechick1989
Jan 16 2007, 07:57 AM
I never heard of that .. I'm gonna have to check out the book, I like reading about stuff like that. Thnx for sharing that info rezna.
Sweetpumper
Jan 16 2007, 03:53 PM
I finally finished Whitley's new one, I'll start this one tonite!
Sweetpumper
Jan 17 2007, 03:30 PM
Got thru about 2 chapters last nite. Wow! If the first 2 are any indication, this is gonna be good. Freaky.
eqgumby
Jan 18 2007, 06:54 PM
QUOTE(rezna @ Nov 16 2006, 05:57 PM) [snapback]1429151[/snapback]
Well, I have an open mind to the paranormal. I believe that Science is the destroyer of an open mind. The more we allow formulas and the scientific method to rule our lives, we'll end up like those people in the latest South Park episode saying things like, "Oh my Science, or Science H Science" Science people are just as zealous as religious people.
Anyways
The book is about a farm in Utah which a family moved to because they wanted to get away from small town gossip. They lived there for around 6 months to a year before anything started to happen. They started experiencing very weird phenomena. The usual stuff though, all in one place. Orbs, Bigfoot appearances, strange other wordly animals, UFO's, etc. The owner got fed up with it after 14 of his prized bulls were mutilated. NIDS, the National Institute for Discovery Science heard about his plight and offered to buy the farm to study it. This is book is the story of the owner of Skinwalker Ranch and his experiences before the NIDS team came on the property, and then the 10 years of research described by two of the NIDS team scientists. Keep in mind that these are Physicists, with PHDs out on this ranch trying to get scientifically proven paranormal evidence. Of course, it didn't really amount to much except this excellent book.
I do not think that eye witnesses make this stuff up, or that they are hallucinating. The end of the book explains their hypothesis of what might be going on at the ranch and it's fascinating. Like I said, I have an all new idea of what paranormal is. We can't look at anything in this world as black and white, it's either real or its not. That is simply not true. What people see is something they see and people like the owners of this ranch had no reason to make any of it up. They were traumatized by it. They lost money from it. THey had to move twice to get away from it.
It's a wonderful read, and just utterly fascinating. There are a lot of websites with snipets of the story, which is how I came upon it. Just do a google for NIDS or Skinwalker Ranch and you'll find all kinds of info about it.
That's sad. Sounds like you just hate logic and reality. I'll have to look into this series of events though.
asc.rudeboy
Jan 18 2007, 08:22 PM
They started experiencing very weird phenomena. The usual stuff though, all in one place. Orbs, Bigfoot appearances, strange other wordly animals, UFO's, etc. The owner got fed up with it after 14 of his prized bulls were mutilated. NIDS, the National Institute for Discovery Science heard about his plight and offered to buy the farm to study it.
how is any of this stuff usual?
any one of these events experienced one way or another are life changing,,,i just have a ahrd time believeing bigfoot and a bunch of ufos and tons of other phenomena happend all at one time in one place,,ok i could possibly concieve a haunted house,maybe a strage animal sighting or even a strange ufo like light you couldnt explain.. but a haunted house with bigfoot and et playing with orbs and carving up cattle all in the same place,im looking for the hidden cameras and wondering what reality tv show im gonna be on.andi hate to say it but the NIDS is a privetly funded organazation so them stretching the truth,or just mkaing things up to sell books is a lot easier to believe then bigfoot,worldy animals,ufos,and orbs.but that dosent mean its not a good read but i dont know if it should shape your outlook on life.
Sweetpumper
Jan 18 2007, 09:04 PM
QUOTE(asc.rudeboy @ Jan 18 2007, 08:22 PM) [snapback]1506826[/snapback]
any one of these events experienced one way or another are life changing,,,i just have a ahrd time believeing bigfoot and a bunch of ufos and tons of other phenomena happend all at one time in one place,,ok i could possibly concieve a haunted house,maybe a strage animal sighting or even a strange ufo like light you couldnt explain.. but a haunted house with bigfoot and et playing with orbs and carving up cattle all in the same place,im looking for the hidden cameras and wondering what reality tv show im gonna be on.andi hate to say it but the NIDS is a privetly funded organazation so them stretching the truth,or just mkaing things up to sell books is a lot easier to believe then bigfoot,worldy animals,ufos,and orbs.but that dosent mean its not a good read but i dont know if it should shape your outlook on life.
Uh, all that's explained in the book.
rezna
Jan 18 2007, 10:29 PM
Yay I'm so glad I could show people a good read
Well, IMHO I believe the authors of this book are not lying. They put their reputation on the line with this book, why would they fabricate all of this to invite their peers to say, "you are a bunch of idiots". I mean why ask for that on purpose? In a situation like this one, it only makes sense for them to come out with the truth about what happened. Isis, I am not sure what was going on there. It's a really good question! After reading the book, I was convinced of the validity of the book. It seems very strange that all of these things would be happening in one place. But maybe that's the answer. Maybe every sighting is just part of all of these things. It just so happens that we got to see all of it in one place. So it could all be happening just like it is in Utah all the time, it's just what we see that gets talked about. Just like how a researcher could easily over look something because they aren't specifically looking for that, they are looking for something else.
It seemed to me that what might be happening is this: Our brains create something called DMT. There are ways to create DMT outside of our bodies as well. I am starting to believe that these phenomena could be from DMT. Maybe there are DMT hot spots in the world. And possibly people who are more susceptable to that. So, if you;ve got all the ingredients which are:
Susceptable person to DMT hot spot + That person in a DMT hot spot = Paranormal phenomena.
Scientists have proven that they can recreate the feeling of "someone watching you" or "a presence in the room". If that is true, than the right conditions could cause this to happen without scientists doing it. Obviously, cause it happens to people all the time.
So maybe Skinwalker Ranch is a heightened DMT producing area of the earth where the magnetism of the core is somehow easier to get through in that particular place, or something like that. And when a person who is susceptable to this (not sure what the parameters of that would be) gets into this area, they start seeing things. DMT causes "hallucinations". That's what scientists categorize something a when 1 person sees something and another person in the same room doesnt see it.
Ok so theres that theory. But I have another theory. I think that DMT could possibly be a travelling agent. Somehow, DMT allows our brain to change its frequencies, to change its "level" and go to a different level of being. A different dimension, or something to that effect. If that is true, and you combine it with the theory I presented before this, then you get:
Susceptable person to DMT hot spot + DMT hot spot + Effects of DMT = Not a paranormal experience, but instead a person changing realities, being able to see another dimension juxtaposed with the one they are currently in.
NOW that is FASCINATING stuff to think about.
battleangel
Feb 2 2007, 08:18 PM
Still haven't had the chance to pick up the book but I did find what seemed to be a decent list of some of what they experienced out there at this site:
http://www.book-of-thoth.com/thebook/index...kinwalker_ranch# Dogs that looked to be deceased, but were animated
# Dog-headed men smoking cigarettes
# Bigfoot-like creatures - the local Ute Indians believe some of these may be actual creatures but consider some of them to be skinwalkers - the Ute often seem to use the term Skinwalker/Sasquatch interchangeably.<ref name="kelleher">Kelleher, Colm & Knapp, George: Hunt for the Skinwalker: Science Confronts the Unexplained at a Remote Ranch in Utah (Paraview Pocket Books, 2005 ISBN 1-4165-0521-0)</ref>
These three things, just based on the brief little descriptions, do sound like skinwalkers. Skinwalkers will use the skin of a dead animal to traipse around in. You can tell it's a dead animal because it's missing the eyes and the skin is kind of rotting. Yuck, lol. They are perfectly capable of blowing whistles, flutes so one smoking a cigarette would not be impossible. "Bigfoot like" creatures also make sense. There was one guy that I ran into whose friend found a really good comparison that my husband (Navajo) just loved and that they can look like they are wearing a gillie suit like a sniper would wear. This definitely give them a "bigfoot-like" appearance.
I'm still really troubled that they went to the Ute or an outsider who heard Ute versions of this kind of thing. It's a Navajo thing. They should have talked to the tribe where it originates from--not the Ute who tend to just be victims of the whole thing. There's a huge difference in knowledge there. Can anybody check to see if they read what Kluckhohn had to say on the subject? His book has been out for decades and is really pretty good. If not, it is this aspect that really makes me worry about their methodology at that ranch (I refuse to call it "skinwalker ranch" because there are probably hundreds of ranches that have skinwalker problems out here--they aren't that special). If they were lucky or thorough, then they would've found out that the appearance of skinwalkers someplace might not indicate anything paranormal really as skinwalkers are pretty much really bad medicine with even worse taste in dress.
So, tiny nod in that they probably did see some skinwalkers but still irked. I will still pick it up to read some century...
Sweetpumper
Feb 3 2007, 07:03 PM
This book is freaky. A lot of info on the Dulce area also, as it seems to mirror a lot of the activities on the ranch. Also native land. This really boggles the mind.
Eric Raven The Skeptic
Feb 3 2007, 07:13 PM
QUOTE(rezna @ Nov 16 2006, 11:57 AM) [snapback]1429151[/snapback]
I believe that Science is the destroyer of an open mind. The more we allow formulas and the scientific method to rule our lives, we'll end up like those people in the latest South Park episode saying things like, "Oh my Science, or Science H Science" Science people are just as zealous as religious people.
Anyways
This is a sad commentary on the state some people.
Sweetpumper
Feb 5 2007, 04:16 AM
I really recommend this for skeptics also. I can't stress the scientific steps taken that leave this team with ONLY "wtf's?"
rezna
Feb 6 2007, 09:00 PM
QUOTE(Sweetpumper @ Feb 4 2007, 08:16 PM) [snapback]1529856[/snapback]
I really recommend this for skeptics also. I can't stress the scientific steps taken that leave this team with ONLY "wtf's?"
that about sums it up
Isis2200
Feb 7 2007, 06:40 PM
QUOTE(rezna @ Jan 18 2007, 05:29 PM) [snapback]1506994[/snapback]
NOW that is FASCINATING stuff to think about.
Wouldn't that be great if they made a movie based on that book? I wonder if they've received any offers. I'll try to find out.
http://ashiana.conforums.com/index.cgi~ Isis2200
The Omega Entity
Feb 7 2007, 10:17 PM
I'm about to read this book but i'm already well aware of the story. For the record, I DO believe in the phenomena but what has always gotten to me in this case and soooo many other single accounts: NO real photo's or video footage seem to surface....??? How can that be on each and every account? I mean, come on,...here we have a paranormal HOT-SPOT that's boasts not only of a high volume of sightings over a relatively short period of time(which would indicate predictability) but also, several variations of phenomena. Yet, not ONE clear picture or footage aside from the standard blurry wierd light, holes in the ground, and mutilated cattle seemed to come from both the original ranch owners or NDIS...? I think anyone even mildly suspicious of strange activity on or near thier home/land would be more prepared. Don't get me wrong, I do consider myself less of a skeptic than a believer but in my A to Z schematic of paranormal consideration, I do need to first clear the 'hurdle' of hard fact.
icdedppul
Feb 7 2007, 11:36 PM
I live in Utah and know several people who have investigated The Ranch. It is all true. Two of my friends have had access to be on the Ranch itself. The other four camped outside the Ranch. They have all experienced unusual things. One got up in the night to relieve himself and something (he couldn't see anything) lifted him up by the neck. The next day he had a bruise on his right neck area. Another one had some unidentifiable "bug" attach itself to his calf. It was about 6 inches in diameter with a hard shell. He got it off and it scurried off but left a nasty mark on his leg. All report a rather "giddy" feeling after being near the Ranch and they feel like falling asleep. Two of my friends had missing time experiences. They also reported seeing a man by a tree just yards from their campsite in a red flannel shirt. This guy has been seen by others.
There is alot going on there and north of the Ranch. The whole area is just plain strange. The locals know about it is not an urban legend. All Indian tribes have accounts of "skinwalkers'; not just the Navajo.
I am going out there when the weather gets warm enough and I'll report what happens to us. We're also investigating the Dry Fork Canyon area. There's alot of high strangeness in Utah. To read more on the Ranch go to a local who has done alot of investigating there at: www.aliendave.com.
rezna
Feb 12 2007, 07:31 PM
QUOTE(icdedppul @ Feb 7 2007, 03:36 PM) [snapback]1533984[/snapback]
I live in Utah and know several people who have investigated The Ranch. It is all true. Two of my friends have had access to be on the Ranch itself. The other four camped outside the Ranch. They have all experienced unusual things. One got up in the night to relieve himself and something (he couldn't see anything) lifted him up by the neck. The next day he had a bruise on his right neck area. Another one had some unidentifiable "bug" attach itself to his calf. It was about 6 inches in diameter with a hard shell. He got it off and it scurried off but left a nasty mark on his leg. All report a rather "giddy" feeling after being near the Ranch and they feel like falling asleep. Two of my friends had missing time experiences. They also reported seeing a man by a tree just yards from their campsite in a red flannel shirt. This guy has been seen by others.
There is alot going on there and north of the Ranch. The whole area is just plain strange. The locals know about it is not an urban legend. All Indian tribes have accounts of "skinwalkers'; not just the Navajo.
I am going out there when the weather gets warm enough and I'll report what happens to us. We're also investigating the Dry Fork Canyon area. There's alot of high strangeness in Utah. To read more on the Ranch go to a local who has done alot of investigating there at: www.aliendave.com.
Excellent post, and very intriguing to hear from someone actually at the site.
In response to the comments about science. You are taking my words too specifically. I don't ever say that all science is hogwash. I definitely think the scientific method is a good one. BUT, I do not like scientism as was described earlier in this thread. When people use science as their religion, things get retarded. And also, science is something we have made up. All the words, the definitions, its all made up. We are merely observing a phenomena and giving it a name. Gravity is a good example. We have merely observed it. Reality didn't actually come out and say, "Gravity exists." We decided that it exists. I'm amazed that scientific people don't see how our human experiences in society shape what we think is weird and whats not. It's difficult for me to articulate what I'm trying to explain. But certain things in our society have already been labelled as "impossible" and those thing will never be accepted by the scientific community as actually worthy of debate. They used to say string theory was retarded, now they accept it as part of the universe model. It just takes time for scientists to allow something to be ok. Its bureaucracy, pure and simple. No scientist is going to say they are looking for a bigfoot creature, their career would be condemned. That is why I say its retarded to worship science as if it's the only way to study something. That is the most close minded avenue in this world. Obviously more is going on than we can explain and worshipping science is exactly the same as worshipping god.
uth
Feb 12 2007, 09:40 PM
QUOTE(rezna @ Feb 12 2007, 07:31 PM) [snapback]1540231[/snapback]
In response to the comments about science. You are taking my words too specifically. I don't ever say that all science is hogwash. I definitely think the scientific method is a good one. BUT, I do not like scientism as was described earlier in this thread. When people use science as their religion, things get retarded. And also, science is something we have made up. All the words, the definitions, its all made up. We are merely observing a phenomena and giving it a name. Gravity is a good example. We have merely observed it. Reality didn't actually come out and say, "Gravity exists." We decided that it exists. I'm amazed that scientific people don't see how our human experiences in society shape what we think is weird and whats not. It's difficult for me to articulate what I'm trying to explain. But certain things in our society have already been labelled as "impossible" and those thing will never be accepted by the scientific community as actually worthy of debate. They used to say string theory was retarded, now they accept it as part of the universe model. It just takes time for scientists to allow something to be ok. Its bureaucracy, pure and simple. No scientist is going to say they are looking for a bigfoot creature, their career would be condemned. That is why I say its retarded to worship science as if it's the only way to study something. That is the most close minded avenue in this world. Obviously more is going on than we can explain and worshipping science is exactly the same as worshipping god.
Science likes to have repeatable data and tends to disregard anomalies as errors when they don't show up in repeated experiments.
When dealing with phenomena that only manifests under certain conditions, or whenever 'it' decides to, does not lend itself to repeated controlled studies. It makes it difficult, if not impossible to have a truly 'scientific' study of it. You can document data about various manifestations of it, but it's still likely to be labeled as 'pseudo science' by those whose worldview doesn't allow for that type of phenomena to exist.
MasterPo
Feb 15 2007, 06:00 AM
Might be a good read. But remember even the Amityville Horror book was finally exposed as a hoax.
uth
Feb 16 2007, 05:00 AM
QUOTE(MasterPo @ Feb 15 2007, 06:00 AM) [snapback]1543883[/snapback]
Might be a good read. But remember even the Amityville Horror book was finally exposed as a hoax.
Yeah, I read this book keeping in mind that it might all be made up, or the man they call Tom Gorman might be fooling them or exagerating- he had the most outlandish experiences, even after NIDS bought the ranch. But as wild as the claims in this book are, they uncovered other cases where identical things were reported. In the end, the writers admit that they considered hoax, delusions, and other things as explanations and they really don't know what is going on.
In the end though, it makes you rethink some ideas you have of certain paranormal phenomenon-- Are Sasquatch really just undiscovered animals, or something else? Are UFOs behind cattle mutalation, or is the explanation even more bizarre? Do UFOs travel from space, or some kind of portal?
boorite
Feb 16 2007, 07:20 PM
I don't think I can convey in a few sentences just how weird the book is. It's as if someone went around the world filling a bag with every paranormal phenomenon there is, and then they emptied the bag over this unsuspecting family.
I'd say that anyone who doesn't go get this book and read it really isn't much interested in the paranormal. Whether or not it's true, it absolutely sets the standard for outlandishness, and that's significant.
icdedppul
Feb 18 2007, 04:16 PM
QUOTE(rezna @ Feb 12 2007, 07:31 PM) [snapback]1540231[/snapback]
Excellent post, and very intriguing to hear from someone actually at the site.
In response to the comments about science. You are taking my words too specifically. I don't ever say that all science is hogwash. I definitely think the scientific method is a good one. BUT, I do not like scientism as was described earlier in this thread. When people use science as their religion, things get retarded. And also, science is something we have made up. All the words, the definitions, its all made up. We are merely observing a phenomena and giving it a name. Gravity is a good example. We have merely observed it. Reality didn't actually come out and say, "Gravity exists." We decided that it exists. I'm amazed that scientific people don't see how our human experiences in society shape what we think is weird and whats not. It's difficult for me to articulate what I'm trying to explain. But certain things in our society have already been labelled as "impossible" and those thing will never be accepted by the scientific community as actually worthy of debate. They used to say string theory was retarded, now they accept it as part of the universe model. It just takes time for scientists to allow something to be ok. Its bureaucracy, pure and simple. No scientist is going to say they are looking for a bigfoot creature, their career would be condemned. That is why I say its retarded to worship science as if it's the only way to study something. That is the most close minded avenue in this world. Obviously more is going on than we can explain and worshipping science is exactly the same as worshipping god.
Rezna, I agree with you completely. Whatever is out at the Ranch is not going to let scientists study it. That has been well established. I belong to the local MUFON group and have met several people that have had experiences out there. There is alot going on even outside of the Ranch property and north of there. The entire area extending to the eastern border nearl Vernal is ripe with weird happenings. My husband was fishing with his BASS club at Dutch John side of Flaming Gorge Reservoir and about 8:00 pm saw several UFO's. His friends also saw them. Strange sightings and experiences have been experienced around Dry Fork Canyon just 6 miles northwest of Vernal, UT as well and my group is also going to investigate this area this summer.
The people I know who have had experiences at the Ranch have had a very difficult time processing what happened to them. It has upset their entire belief system about life as they knew it and they have suffered physical maladies as well. Specifically, gastrointestinal cramping, headaches, nightmares when discussed with others on the same trip are all similar to 2 or 3 others having the same nightmares. Also, for a few days after the visit, some experienced agressive behavior that scared them as it was not their nature to be agressive. They said they have the feeling that whatever is at the Ranch wants them to bring others there, for what purpose, they don't know. These people are all middle-aged professionals who are not crackpots in the least. Some are in the mental health field. 3 of them were hypnotized when they got back to recover possible buried memories of their trip and one drew some fascinating pictures right after hypnosis. There is one photograph someone took from inside their tent upon hearing something outside trying to pull up their tent stakes. I will locate these again and put a link here for all to view.
It looks like Utah will have an early spring so I'm hoping to get to the Ranch sometime in April or May. I will keep posting and report anything new I hear or experience. I have a healthy fear of what's going on there but I am compelled to visit anyway. Some links are found on www.aliendave.com. Dave has also been to the Ranch and he has not updated his site in a long time but there are alot of links and information there on the Ranch.
boorite
Feb 18 2007, 11:55 PM
Thanks, icedppul.
Like I said, a ghost here or a UFO there is one thing, but what's described out at that ranch is a whole new head-changing level of weird. Anyone interested in the paranormal should be hanging on every report coming out of there. I think that it's strong support for John Keel's viewpoint, broadly speaking. I'll be waiting for more reports.
battleangel
Feb 27 2007, 08:49 PM
Hi Icedppul...sorry for the tardy comment.
The reason why I believe that they went to the wrong tribe for information on the skinwalker aspect of it is because skinwalkers most likely originated with the Navajo. There are stories in the Navajo lore that directly point to skinwalkers first existing as a means to improve hunting. If we disregard what they are today and look to the old stories of skinwalkers in Navajo lore, they were clearly an aspect of the hunter-gatherer society. Ute was also hunter-gatherer but other tribes in this area were not. They were agrarian. What a hunting shaman would be doing in an agrarian society is beyond me, lol. All of the tribes out here have had some cultural mixing to some extent so it shouldn't be surprising that there are Hopi skinwalkers and so on. You can ask a member from any tribe out here and the one place that they put warnings on is the Navajo reservation itself. They say "don't drive through it at night" and so on. There is a reason for this.
Do be careful out there. Skinwalkers are heavily armed with poisons...aerial ones.
Finsup22
Apr 22 2008, 04:58 PM
I just finished this last night. I enjoyed it. I recomend it.
Eric Raven The Skeptic
Apr 22 2008, 05:52 PM
QUOTE (Finsup22 @ Apr 22 2008, 11:58 AM)

I just finished this last night. I enjoyed it. I recomend it.
One little sentence to necropost a very old thread. Come on.
Sweetpumper
Apr 22 2008, 06:00 PM
QUOTE (Finsup22 @ Apr 22 2008, 04:58 PM)

I just finished this last night. I enjoyed it. I recomend it.
One of the best paranormal books out there.
Sweetpumper
Apr 22 2008, 06:12 PM
QUOTE (Eric Raven The Skeptic @ Apr 22 2008, 06:52 PM)

One little sentence to necropost a very old thread. Come on.
Books don't die, dude.
Eric Raven The Skeptic
Apr 23 2008, 03:28 PM
QUOTE (Sweetpumper @ Apr 22 2008, 01:12 PM)

Books don't die, dude.
Threads do.
Sweetpumper
Apr 23 2008, 04:19 PM
Not this one, apparently.
Pol_Pot_will_killyou
Apr 23 2008, 06:02 PM
Hunt For The Skinwalker should be made into a movie, it's a great read even if it is fake.
I think Sherman/Bigelow Ranch and the surrounding valley is just a test-site for government-sponsored experiments on crowd control and man-made mass hallucinations.
The part with the "Predator camouflaged" thing screaming in the face of the hippie guy was the best.
-Pol
brahman1888
Apr 26 2008, 09:16 PM
QUOTE (MasterPo @ Feb 15 2007, 02:00 AM)

Might be a good read. But remember even the Amityville Horror book was finally exposed as a hoax.
That's what I was thinking too. Now I'm not at all slamming your views on this topic, as of the moment I know nothing about it other than what has been posted here. I think its cool you're an X-files fan lol. That was and is my favorite show. I just bought the DVD boxed set not too long ago and have been watching all the episodes again, I don't think anything will ever be able to touch how great that show was....and man, I can't wait for the new movie this summer...........
But the Amityville Horror is a perfect example of how people will deliberately hoax paranormal phenomena to achieve fame or money. People believed the Lutz's when this story broke, and this went on for years, until their lawyer finally admitted they made the whole thing up over a few bottles of wine. Sad but true. That stupid book is still categorized as non-fiction too. Maybe you are on to something here, but watch out, people will invent crazy things just to make a buck.
Elite
Apr 26 2008, 09:22 PM
i think that there must have been like some kind of inter-deemensional portal that let all this weird stuff in one place
Eric Raven The Skeptic
Apr 26 2008, 09:38 PM
QUOTE (Elite @ Apr 26 2008, 04:22 PM)

i think that there must have been like some kind of inter-deemensional portal that let all this weird stuff in one place
OR someone with a good imagination.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please
click here.