This is an Urban Legend and a song. I remember it well, as my father used to play his guitar and sing it for me when I was a little girl.
It is has a few variations but, here it is:
LAURIE (STRANGE THINGS HAPPEN)
Written by Milton C. Addington & Cathie Harmon
Recorded by Dickey Lee - 1965
Last night at the dance I met Laurie
So lovely and warm, an angel of a girl
Last night I fell in love with Laurie
Strange things happen in this world
As I walked her home, she said it was her birthday
I pulled her close and said, "Will I see you anymore?"
Then suddenly she asked for my sweater
And said that she was very, very cold
I kissed her goodnight at her door and started home
Then thought about my sweater and went right back instead
I knocked at her door and a man appeared
I told him why I'd come, then he said
"You're wrong, son, you weren't with my daughter
How can you be so cruel to come to me this way?
My Laurie left this world on her birthday
She died a year ago today"
A strange force drew me to the graveyard
I stood in the dark, I saw the shadows wave
And then I looked and saw my sweater
Lyin' there upon her grave
Strange things happen in this world
And a link to the lyrics:
LAURIE (STRANGE THINGS HAPPEN).
We had such great times begging my father to sing this song! It always scared us so much but, we loved it at the same time