Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Ask a Muslim
Unexplained Mysteries Discussion Forums > Unexplained Mysteries > Spirituality, Religion and Beliefs
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6
muslim
Hey.. Ive met people who dont even know that Muslims believe in God. So I figured Id make this post where you guys can ask me abut Islam, if you like. This post is by no means intended to be a debate. I will not debate anyone. This is intended to be a friendly chit chat and a way of understanding others faiths better thus making us closer. The Quran says that:


"O mankind! We created you from a single (pair) of a male and a female, and made you into nations and tribes, that ye may know each other. Verily the most honoured of you in the sight of Allah is the most righteous of you. And Allah has full knowledge and is well-acquainted.
(The Noble Quran, 49:13)"

note: we is a plural of respect nothing more nothing less.

This is only for people who are interested to learn about Islam not for those who want to debate as I have previosly said. original.gif I am by no means a scholar, so if I cant answer something most likely Ill adress u to somewhere which will have answers. Please, no politics. Strictly religion.
ND-DAVE
one thing that I have allways wondered do followers of Islam consider their one God the same as the Hebrew God of the Christians and Jews. I have heard a few things that say yes and no. Which is it?
EmpressStarXVII
Is it haraam for muslims to be liberal or moderate on social issues like same sex marriage and abortion? Even if you do not agree or practice the above mentioned? For example: You practice and follow the words of Islam, but feel if a woman wants to have an abortion it is up to her, or if two men get married it doesn't directly affect you so you have no say so in the matter?

I hope this isn't a question that will start a firey debate, because it truly is a question that I've been wondering about.

EDIT: spelling
muslim
QUOTE
one thing that I have allways wondered do followers of Islam consider their one God the same as the Hebrew God of the Christians and Jews. I have heard a few things that say yes and no. Which is it?
By no what is meant is that no this is not a trinity God, thats all. So yes Allah is the God of Abraham of Moses of Jesus of Adam and so on. So Yes Muslims consider their God the same as the Christians and Jews in the sence of who He is. In the sence of what He is we differ.
The following is from the Quran and is adressed to Christians and Jews (people of the book, i.e the book God revealed, the Bible)

And dispute ye not with the People of the Book, except with means better (than mere disputation), unless it be with those of them who inflict wrong (and injury): but say, "We believe in the revelation which has come down to us and in that which came down to you; Our Allah and your Allah is one; and it is to Him we surrender." (029.046)


Say: "O People of the Book! come to common terms as between us and you: That we worship none but Allah; that we associate no partners with him; that we erect not, from among ourselves, Lords and patrons other than Allah." If then they turn back, say ye: "Bear witness that we (at least) are Muslims (bowing to Allah's Will). (3.64)

Say ye: "We believe in Allah,
And the revelation given to us,
And to Abraham, Isma'il, Isaac,
Jacob, and the Tribes,
And that given to Moses and Jesus
And that given to (all)
Prophets from their Lord:
We make no difference
Between one and another of them:
And we bow to Allah (in Islam)."


(Holy Qur'an 2:136).

So yeah its the same God original.gif Allah comes from the word Elah which mens "a god". "The God" in Arabic is Allah. So thats all their is to it.

The concept of God in Islam is summarized in this sura (chapter)

In the name of Allah, the Compassionate, the Merciful.
Say: He is Allah, the One and Only;
Allah, the Eternal, Absolute;
He begetteth not, nor is He begotten;
And there is none like unto Him.

(112)

(notice the Say, its because the Quran was a verbal revelation meaning the book was literally authored by God)


QUOTE
Is it haraam for muslims to be liberal or moderate on social issues like same sex marriage and abortion? Even if you do not agree or practice the above mentioned? For example: You practice and follow the words of Islam, but feel if a woman wants to have an abortion it is up to her, or if two men get married it doesn't directly affect you so you have no say so in the matter?


For Muslims to be liberal my answer is the same I would give if a Christian or Jew would be liberal which is that, since you, whatever relegio you follow, believe in this relegion you believe in its scripture. Since that scripture is from God and has laws, shouldnt you follow them? So for a Muslim to be liberal would be sort of disrespectful to God since God gave you these laws who are we humans to say that our laws are better than His. Abortion is only allowed in Islam if the baby was being tormented in her womb for whatever reason and so on that abortion would be the mercifull thing to do. The Muslim perspective is that God sent this relegion to clear the doubts of the ppl of those who were lost as to what to follow and so (Jews and Christians) to guide them and explain everything to them in detail as to what was not explained before. So Islam is a very huge relegion with its laws and so on its very deep its more than a relegion its a way of life, its a social system, a political system, an economic system, its the full deal. So for a Muslim to change in that is very frowned upon because we arent allowed to change anything so that we wont fall in the trap of those before us. Eveything in the Muslim society affects Muslims, we believe we are responsible to make our society a healthy one. We are obligated in Islam to forbid evil and and advise people to do good. So theres no such thing in Islam as to this is none of my bussiness. Every thing a person does, be it in Islam or any other relegion, affects his society, its natural, so we have to forbid all thats wrong (by nice advice of course not by harsh ways). As for moderate, we believe that Islam is a relegion meant for all times and all peoples and all places so it is moderate so u cant be moderate if you arent unoderate. This is the Muslim perspective I know you might have a different opinion thats alright.
GoddessWhispers
I appreciate your offering of this thread muslim. original.gif

With the impression that many are getting now of the whole of Islamic faith, being generated by those that are seeking to martyr themselves, what is the justification in the Quran for their doing so!? If Allah is merciful and good, the Abrahamic god that carries the christian and the jewish gods in it's book, how do Imam's justify inciting followers to kill christians, jews, and others in this terroristic campaign?! Like what you said about the "liberal" philosophy , and following the book, what in the book compels or gives approval for this violence?!

One more question: Would a non-muslim be able to enter a mosque, so as to learn what occurs in worship there!? Is there an etiquette for non-muslims, so as to show proper respect?

Thank you for reading this. original.gif
Nova Scotia
the bible told men of God to cry alloud and spare not ,to show his people their sins .

If you never their blood was on your hands .

If you did and they will not listen ,its on their own hands .


so all a christian has to do is witness and warn . And give the good news of the future Kingdom where Gods laws will lead to a perfect world .


So witness and warn is enough after that its your fault !
Nova Scotia
woops double post
GoddessWhispers
QUOTE(Nova Scotia @ Feb 2 2007, 02:10 AM) [snapback]1525275[/snapback]
the bible told men of God to cry alloud and spare not ,to show his people their sins .

If you never their blood was on your hands .

If you did and they will not listen ,its on their own hands .
so all a christian has to do is witness and warn . And give the good news of the future Kingdom where Gods laws will lead to a perfect world .
So witness and warn is enough after that its your fault !

Pardon me, but is this OT? Or a question about Islam?! Why did you think that statement to be appropriate to the OP of this thread? unsure.gif
muslim
QUOTE
I appreciate your offering of this thread muslim.
I appreciate your participation wink2.gif

QUOTE
With the impression that many are getting now of the whole of Islamic faith, being generated by those that are seeking to martyr themselves, what is the justification in the Quran for their doing so!? If Allah is merciful and good, the Abrahamic god that carries the christian and the jewish gods in it's book, how do Imam's justify inciting followers to kill christians, jews, and others in this terroristic campaign?! Like what you said about the "liberal" philosophy , and following the book, what in the book compels or gives approval for this violence?!


Ill try to answer your question without getting into politics okake wink2.gif
The dillema going on today is a huge dillema. You see, the Quran says allows fighting in self defence. But the Quran doesnt allow you to transgress i.e attack. The Prophet Mohammed also made it very clear that we arent allowed to kill innocent people. He said "{...Do not betray, do not be excessive, do not kill a newborn child.}

this is very clear, extremely clear. He even forbade the killing of plants. These peoples actions, the terrorists think are justified simply because they believe they are defending themselves they forget the rules in Islam for warfare. We arent allowed to kill civilians, old people, woman, plants, children, only those who fght us (the army attacking us) other than that it isnt allowed. So these people theyre going against Islam and Islam has nothing to do with them and Mohammed foretold this he said that therell come a time where a group of people will start to speak about relegion and they know nothing about it and they will kill anyone easier than anything (meaning theyll think killing is allowed and justified just because they think their goals are good).


"And fight in the way of Allah those who fight you. But do not transgress the limits. Truly Allah loves not the transgressors" (Surah Al-Quran 2:190)

So war in self defence is allowed but not 1) transgression and 2) the killing of innocent people. The Quran also says that if you kill an innocent person its as if youve killed the entire world. And if uve saved a person its as if uve said the entire world.

"...If anyone killed a person not in retaliation for murder or to spread mischief in the land, it would be as if he killed the whole of mankind. And (likewise) if anyone saved a life, it would be as if he saved the whole of mankind" (Quran 5:32)

God does not forbid you from showing kindness and dealing justly with those who have not fought you about religion and have not driven you out of your homes. God loves just dealers. (Quran, 60:8)

So as you see, killing innocents isnt allowed. These people are a minority and are not only condemned by Muslims but are also fought by Muslims.
Watch this: http://www.turntoislam.com/forum/showthread.php?t=63

Also, nowadays with the Media bombarding Islam with "Jihad" and so on, as uv said many people have a misconception. Lol go up to anyone in the media and ask them this question "what does the word jihad mean"? Immediately of course theyll shout out holly war !
The word Jihad doesnt even mean holly war did you know that? The word Jihad simply means "struggle". Its a struggle for Gods sake. And as the prophet said: "The best jihad is (by) the one who strives against his own self for Allah, The Mighty and Majestic" (Authentic hadith- Reported by At-Tabaranee) meaning that your struggle against your own evil desires is the greater Jihad i.e struggle for Gods sake. The word Jihad comes also from the word johd which means effort. Anything you do which is good for mankind in Islam is consider a type of jihad i.e struggle for Gods sake. If you go to school if you go to work and so on. The lesser Jihad is the war in self defence and or war to help Christians and or Jews those who are oppressed.

"And what is the matter with you that you do not fight in the cause of Allah and for those weak, ill treated and oppressed among men, women and children whose only cry is; 'Our Lord, rescue us from this town whose people are oppressors and raise for us from you one who will protect and raise for us from you one who will help"
(Quran 4:75)

But the second the oppressor stops we are to stop fighting also. One might say, well, why does a relegion have to have fighting as a part of it? Ill give a short simple answer which is that, no country on earth hasnt ever had in its history a war either it was attacked or it attacked. So if its people are faithfull and their relegion doesnt allow them to fight in self defence you know what would have happened? You would have been speaking German today. If no one stood up against Hitler he would have massacred millions more. And since Islam is also a way of life it allows this because it is a complete relegion i.e has a social system, political system, economical system, and so on.

Hope I gave a good answer? If u want to know more join us at www.turntoislam.com and im sure theyll give u better answers than I did.

QUOTE
One more question: Would a non-muslim be able to enter a mosque, so as to learn what occurs in worship there!? Is there an etiquette for non-muslims, so as to show proper respect?
Yes you're allowed to enter. If ur in USA you can call the nearest mosque to you and ask for an apointment I think. As for the etiquette just dont enter the mosque with your shoes since its a place of worship we take off our shoes. Other than that dont worry about it.

QUOTE
Thank you for reading this.


Please ask more, there are many parts of Islam which are simply beatifull yet most of you dont know about sad.gif Did you know that of the most important things in Islam are ethics? Muslims arent allowed to speak in a language a third person with them doesnt understand. Did you know that a smile in Islam is considered charity? And that the greatest act of charity is when a husband feeds his wife with his hand wink2.gif

Mohammed peace be upon him said "I have been sent to perfect the high moral standards".

Did you know that Muslim woman, at a time where in Europe not only couldnt they own property, but were even considered soulless in europe, in Arabia could own property, vote, had to be educated (it is obligatory in Islam to seek knowledge) and even speak up gainst the Muslim ruler if they want and say their opinion in the mosque without anyone stoping them? Nowadays culture has kicked in and woman have become opressed in some Muslim countries, not because of Islam, but because of the people moving away from islams teachings to culture.
Paranoid Android
QUOTE(GoddessWhispers @ Feb 2 2007, 12:46 AM) [snapback]1525259[/snapback]
One more question: Would a non-muslim be able to enter a mosque, so as to learn what occurs in worship there!? Is there an etiquette for non-muslims, so as to show proper respect?
A very good question, GW. One I am most interested in hearing an answer to edit: it appears it's already been answered - thanks muslim tongue.gif

QUOTE(GoddessWhispers @ Feb 2 2007, 01:21 AM) [snapback]1525284[/snapback]
Pardon me, but is this OT? Or a question about Islam?! Why did you think that statement to be appropriate to the OP of this thread? unsure.gif
Seems a little OT (off topic, that is, if that's what you meant).
Preacherbill
Hey you stole my idea, thats ok cause i stole it from somone else. Really glad to see this kind of disscution going on. The free exchange of ideas and beliefs is what will help lead to a better peace amoungst all people.
Looking forward to reading more when i get the chance.

Now to a question. What is the offical Islamic view on Jesus Christ. Do they belive he was a profit, do they belive he died, I know he is recognized I just would like to know in what form.

Also do you recognize the Jewish OT as holy scripture, being that Islam is an Abrahamic religon, just wondering what the offical view on that Text is.

Thanks
PB
Jack Black
Great thread, ive already learnt things that i was previously unaware of, Thank you
Preacherbill
What is the offical view of islam when you encounter someone who will not convert to your religon. I understand Islam is evangelical in the same way Christianity is in that it wishes to spread its faith.

Also a personal question, do you agree with some of the Muslims in this world who beilve and practice the idea of convert or be killed. As this is a reality in this world today i would be interested to hear your answer.

Also understand that this is just a question, i fully recognize that the Christian faith has done many horrible things to many people in trying to impose its faith on those who did not wish to belive.

Thanks
PB
Nova Scotia
QUOTE(GoddessWhispers @ Feb 1 2007, 02:21 PM) [snapback]1525284[/snapback]
Pardon me, but is this OT? Or a question about Islam?! Why did you think that statement to be appropriate to the OP of this thread? unsure.gif



I WORK UNDER COMPLETE INSPIRATION OF THE HOLY SPIRIT DON"T KNOW WHY I DO WHAT I DO


LOL


I think i had just read Empressstars first question and felt i should give what i veiw as the christion point of veiw .
GoddessWhispers
QUOTE(Paranoid Android @ Feb 2 2007, 02:30 AM) [snapback]1525294[/snapback]
A very good question, GW. One I am most interested in hearing an answer to edit: it appears it's already been answered - thanks muslim tongue.gif

Seems a little OT (off topic, that is, if that's what you meant).
Yes, off topic , was my meaning. original.gif

Thank you Muslim for your answers. It's unfortunate the media promotes the viciousness perpetrated in the name of islam and doesn't allude to the fact that it's contrary to the true teachings of islam. Then again, it doesn't sell well to promote that patriotic spirit that compels people to join the military and fight what's occurring. Or maybe, they figure it doesn't matter that this is contrary to the teachings of Muhammad (Pbuh) and the Quran. A glaring omission, imo, that would to paint the vicious facade of the martyr minded, terrorists, upon all muslims, just by inference. I've been in airports and listened to people murmur about their reticence to board a flight I'm on, when they see what appears to be muslims in the jet way, waiting to board. To which I've walked up to those people and said very politely: What if we were all judged, on sight, for the actions of our predecessors?! Aren't we all children of god, worthy of respect rather than hate because of what we assume about others!? < I say that to the one's wearing religious iconography.

Then I went up and stood right behind the muslims that were standing alone in that line, waiting to board. Sure enough, there I was. Muslims and an atheist, taking the lead. And sure enough, all that murmuring stopped and we all boarded together. wink2.gif Sometimes you just have to set aside the fear, and trust the now.
muslim
QUOTE
Now to a question. What is the offical Islamic view on Jesus Christ. Do they belive he was a profit, do they belive he died, I know he is recognized I just would like to know in what form.
Ok. The official Islamic view of Jesus Christ peace be upon him is:
1) He was the Christ i.e the Messiah that the Jews were waiting for.
2) He was born miraculously without any male intervention
3) He gave life to the dead by Gods permission and did all the miracles he did.
4) He was one of the greatest prophets
5) He wasnt God and or the son of God. Because we believe God is One and absolutely one. We believe God is very exalted above having any partners or associates or equals.

No we do not believe Jesus peace be upon him died. We believe God saved him from the crusifiction and lifted him up into heaven. We dont believe Jesus had to die for anyones sins because the original sin is rejected in Islam. We believe that salvation is achieved by deeds. You do good, you enter heaven God willing. You do bad and repent, God forgives you. You do bad and dont repent, if God wants to forgive you He does and if He doesnt than you have to be responsible for your own actions. We do not believe that sin is inherited or anything like that we believe everyone is born pure and innocent.

Jesus's creation in the Quran:

The similitude of Jesus before Allah is as that of Adam; He created him from dust, then said to him: "Be". And he was. (003.059)


The angels giving Marry glad tidings:

Behold! the angels said: "O Mary! Allah giveth thee glad tidings of a Word from Him: his name will be Christ Jesus, the son of Mary, held in honour in this world and the Hereafter and of (the company of) those nearest to Allah;

He shall speak to the people in childhood and in maturity. And he shall be (of the company) of the righteous."

She said: "O my Lord! How shall I have a son when no man hath touched me?" He said: "Even so: Allah createth what He willeth: When He hath decreed a plan, He but saith to it, 'Be,' and it is!

And Allah will teach him the Book and Wisdom, the Law and the Gospel,

"And (appoint him) a messenger to the Children of Israel, (with this message): "'I have come to you, with a Sign from your Lord, in that I make for you out of clay, as it were, the figure of a bird, and breathe into it, and it becomes a bird by Allah's leave: And I heal those born blind, and the lepers, and I quicken the dead, by Allah's leave; and I declare to you what ye eat, and what ye store in your houses. Surely therein is a Sign for you if ye did believe;

'(I have come to you), to attest the Law which was before me. And to make lawful to you part of what was (Before) forbidden to you; I have come to you with a Sign from your Lord. So fear Allah, and obey me.

(3.45-50)

Jesus's Crusifixion:

That they said (the Jews) (in boast), "We killed Christ Jesus the son of Mary, the Messenger of Allah";- but they killed him not, nor crucified him, but so it was made to appear to them, and those who differ therein are full of doubts, with no (certain) knowledge, but only conjecture to follow, for of a surety they killed him not:- (004.157)


QUOTE
Also do you recognize the Jewish OT as holy scripture, being that Islam is an Abrahamic religon, just wondering what the offical view on that Text is.


We recognize all the scriptures sent by God but we dont follow them because the Quran is the final revelation and in it everything is explained in detail and things which were unclear in the OT were made clearer here etc so we dont follow the OT.


QUOTE
What is the offical view of islam when you encounter someone who will not convert to your religon. I understand Islam is evangelical in the same way Christianity is in that it wishes to spread its faith.


Forced conversion isnt allowed in Islam. The Quran says:

Let there be no compulsion in religion: Truth stands out clear from Error: whoever rejects evil and believes in Allah hath grasped the most trustworthy hand-hold, that never breaks. And Allah heareth and knoweth all things. (002.256)

So we arent allowed to force anyone become a Muslim.

If a person lives in a Muslim country and isnt a Muslim he has to pay a yearly tuotion which is about maybe 100 dollars and in return the governent protects him from anyone who tries to harm him and his religious rights and he can practise his religion as he wills. If he desnt pay than he has to promise that if the country is invaded he will defend it too. This was all done one thousand years ago at a time where the world knew nothing about religiose freedom,many scholars today say that he doesnt even have to pay anything. Non Muslims can live with Muslims freely and practice their relegion freely as they wish. In many cases in Islamic history, when the non Muslims couldnt pay the money because they had problems problems the Muslim government would support them with money too (this was done by Omar ibn il Khattab the second Muslim ruler).
muslim
QUOTE
Great thread, ive already learnt things that i was previously unaware of, Thank you
You're welcome mate =D


QUOTE
Yes, off topic , was my meaning.

Thank you Muslim for your answers. It's unfortunate the media promotes the viciousness perpetrated in the name of islam and doesn't allude to the fact that it's contrary to the true teachings of islam. Then again, it doesn't sell well to promote that patriotic spirit that compels people to join the military and fight what's occurring. Or maybe, they figure it doesn't matter that this is contrary to the teachings of Muhammad (Pbuh) and the Quran. A glaring omission, imo, that would to paint the vicious facade of the martyr minded, terrorists, upon all muslims, just by inference. I've been in airports and listened to people murmur about their reticence to board a flight I'm on, when they see what appears to be muslims in the jet way, waiting to board. To which I've walked up to those people and said very politely: What if we were all judged, on sight, for the actions of our predecessors?! Aren't we all children of god, worthy of respect rather than hate because of what we assume about others!? < I say that to the one's wearing religious iconography.

Then I went up and stood right behind the muslims that were standing alone in that line, waiting to board. Sure enough, there I was. Muslims and an atheist, taking the lead. And sure enough, all that murmuring stopped and we all boarded together. Sometimes you just have to set aside the fear, and trust the now.


Thank you for your kind words, such words come from none other than a pure heart original.gif thank you.
Preacherbill
QUOTE(muslim @ Feb 1 2007, 11:15 AM) [snapback]1525341[/snapback]
Ok. The official Islamic view of Jesus Christ peace be upon him is:
1) He was the Christ i.e the Messiah that the Jews were waiting for.
2) He was born miraculously without any male intervention
3) He gave life to the dead by Gods permission and did all the miracles he did.
4) He was one of the greatest prophets
5) He wasnt God and or the son of God. Because we believe God is One and absolutely one. We believe God is very exalted above having any partners or associates or equals.

No we do not believe Jesus peace be upon him died. We believe God saved him from the crusifiction and lifted him up into heaven. We dont believe Jesus had to die for anyones sins because the original sin is rejected in Islam. We believe that salvation is achieved by deeds. You do good, you enter heaven God willing. You do bad and repent, God forgives you. You do bad and dont repent, if God wants to forgive you He does and if He doesnt than you have to be responsible for your own actions. We do not believe that sin is inherited or anything like that we believe everyone is born pure and innocent.

Jesus's creation in the Quran:

The similitude of Jesus before Allah is as that of Adam; He created him from dust, then said to him: "Be". And he was. (003.059)
The angels giving Marry glad tidings:

Behold! the angels said: "O Mary! Allah giveth thee glad tidings of a Word from Him: his name will be Christ Jesus, the son of Mary, held in honour in this world and the Hereafter and of (the company of) those nearest to Allah;

He shall speak to the people in childhood and in maturity. And he shall be (of the company) of the righteous."

She said: "O my Lord! How shall I have a son when no man hath touched me?" He said: "Even so: Allah createth what He willeth: When He hath decreed a plan, He but saith to it, 'Be,' and it is!

And Allah will teach him the Book and Wisdom, the Law and the Gospel,

"And (appoint him) a messenger to the Children of Israel, (with this message): "'I have come to you, with a Sign from your Lord, in that I make for you out of clay, as it were, the figure of a bird, and breathe into it, and it becomes a bird by Allah's leave: And I heal those born blind, and the lepers, and I quicken the dead, by Allah's leave; and I declare to you what ye eat, and what ye store in your houses. Surely therein is a Sign for you if ye did believe;

'(I have come to you), to attest the Law which was before me. And to make lawful to you part of what was (Before) forbidden to you; I have come to you with a Sign from your Lord. So fear Allah, and obey me.

(3.45-50)

Jesus's Crusifixion:

That they said (the Jews) (in boast), "We killed Christ Jesus the son of Mary, the Messenger of Allah";- but they killed him not, nor crucified him, but so it was made to appear to them, and those who differ therein are full of doubts, with no (certain) knowledge, but only conjecture to follow, for of a surety they killed him not:- (004.157)
We recognize all the scriptures sent by God but we dont follow them because the Quran is the final revelation and in it everything is explained in detail and things which were unclear in the OT were made clearer here etc so we dont follow the OT.
Forced conversion isnt allowed in Islam. The Quran says:

Let there be no compulsion in religion: Truth stands out clear from Error: whoever rejects evil and believes in Allah hath grasped the most trustworthy hand-hold, that never breaks. And Allah heareth and knoweth all things. (002.256)

So we arent allowed to force anyone become a Muslim.

If a person lives in a Muslim country and isnt a Muslim he has to pay a yearly tuotion which is about maybe 100 dollars and in return the governent protects him from anyone who tries to harm him and his religious rights and he can practise his religion as he wills. If he desnt pay than he has to promise that if the country is invaded he will defend it too. This was all done one thousand years ago at a time where the world knew nothing about religiose freedom,many scholars today say that he doesnt even have to pay anything. Non Muslims can live with Muslims freely and practice their relegion freely as they wish. In many cases in Islamic history, when the non Muslims couldnt pay the money because they had problems problems the Muslim government would support them with money too (this was done by Omar ibn il Khattab the second Muslim ruler).

Thanks for the response, It really seams like we should be able to get along and practice our fatih with each other. Some of us may be wrong in our belifs, But we all belive in a merciful god. It is my hope and prayer that we can get beyond the cultural differnces and learn to live together and love one another as children of God. It seams to me as though Islam is going thorugh some of the same growing pains that Jewdism and Christianity did as they evolved and is having to learn how to deal with fanatics in its faith. Thats not to say we still dont have our share of fanatics, we do.
thanks for the answers. It sounds like we can agree do disagree peacefully.
PB
muslim

QUOTE
Thanks for the response, It really seams like we should be able to get along and practice our fatih with each other. Some of us may be wrong in our belifs, But we all belive in a merciful god. It is my hope and prayer that we can get beyond the cultural differnces and learn to live together and love one another as children of God. It seams to me as though Islam is going thorugh some of the same growing pains that Jewdism and Christianity did as they evolved and is having to learn how to deal with fanatics in its faith. Thats not to say we still dont have our share of fanatics, we do.
thanks for the answers. It sounds like we can agree do disagree peacefully.
PB


Thanks, I sure hope we can and God willing we will original.gif And thank you for inspiring me to write this read ;p


Preacherbill
QUOTE(muslim @ Feb 1 2007, 11:26 AM) [snapback]1525357[/snapback]
Thanks, I sure hope we can and God willing we will original.gif And thank you for inspiring me to write this read ;p

I have a question for you, how would your faith communitee, and by that i mean your congregation or whatever term you use, sorry i dont know what the proepr one is, look on having joint services or visitation by christians to a mosque or by musilms to a church. As our society continues to mesh we will have more instances where this happens, i am thinking of weddings, funerals and other such things or possibly even clsoe friendshipw and important evetns i peoples lives, Babtisam, first communion, Barmitsvas, I would include musilm cerimonies but i am sorry to say i dont know of any. Any way just wondering.

PB
muslim

QUOTE
I have a question for you, how would your faith communitee, and by that i mean your congregation or whatever term you use, sorry i dont know what the proepr one is, look on having joint services or visitation by christians to a mosque or by musilms to a church. As our society continues to mesh we will have more instances where this happens, i am thinking of weddings, funerals and other such things or possibly even clsoe friendshipw and important evetns i peoples lives, Babtisam, first communion, Barmitsvas, I would include musilm cerimonies but i am sorry to say i dont know of any. Any way just wondering.

PB


Its allowed of course since all are considered places of worship to the same God. We arent however allowed to participate in anything which contradicts with Islam i.e bowing to a minister etc because we're only allowed to bow to God. Such stuff like that. But generally, yes its allowed. Christians are allowed to visit mosques to ask about Islam and watch the Muslims pray etc.

muslim
I would also like to add to Godesswhispers that even the terrorists who have nothing to do with Islam dont believe in killing all Cristians and Jews. The Quran says you have your religion and I have mine. What they believe in is as follows. Since their country is according them occupied, they are defending themselves by fighting the occupation. So what do innocent Christians and Jews have to do with this? They believe, again, THEY believe that since tens and tens of innocent Muslims are killed by bombings and so on (for ex Iraq which was the strongest bombing a nation took after WW2) that they have the right to kill innocent Christians because innocent Muslims were killed too. Sort of an eye for an eye thing which is very wrong. Two wrongs dont make a right. They know and confess that these Christians are innocent but they say that is fair to kill them. These people are going against Mohammeds teachings who said do not killing innocent people and do not fight exept those who fight you and only those who are actually attacking you i.e the army.
muslim
There is nothing in the Islamic religion which goes against living with non Muslims in a community. It is the first religion which ever practised this too and Muslims and Christians and Jews lived in harmony in the Islamic country long ago. I'll tell you a little story which happened to Mohammed peace be upon him. His neighbor was Jewish, this guy hated Mohammed for claiming to be a prophet and especially since several Jews became Muslim. So what this guy would do was throw his garbage in front of Mohammeds house every day. He would also go to the extent of throwing glass on the ground and nails so that Mohamemd would step on them when he leaves his house. And every day Mohammed would leave his house, clean up the guys garbage and the mess he made and wouldnt even complain and wouldnt even speak to him. Keep in mind Mohammed was the ruler of Madinah the place where they were he could have easily did anything he wanted to this guy yet he didnt. One day Mohammed left his house and to his astonishment, there was no garbage, no nails and no glass. Now if this happened to you, you would have been releaved to say the very least. He went and asked about his neighbor and if anything has happened to him and they told him that he's ill and is in bed. He went and visited him. The guy told him "you do know it is me whos throwing all the garbage in front of your house"?! He said yes but you're my neighbor I have to respect you.

Muslims have no problem with living with Christians in peace original.gif

Nova Scotia
So what did you think of your muslim brother Sadam taking over Kuwait ?

And should the americans of stayed out of it and let him have your country?
muslim
QUOTE
So what did you think of your muslim brother Sadam taking over Kuwait ?

And should the americans of stayed out of it and let him have your country?


I said in the beggening I wont talk about politics.
Nova Scotia
ok no problem but i senced a little anger in you at america in iraq . And my mind keeps Asking where you would Be now if they stayed home .

but any way enough politics
muslim
QUOTE
ok no problem but i senced a little anger in you at america in iraq . And my mind keeps Asking where you would Be now if they stayed home .

but any way enough politics


lol if it makes you happy I believe that no war happens without both sides having to have made a mistake at some point. Its common sence I think, no conflict can arise with just one person being right and one being wrong. I could be wrong of course but thats just my opinion. Their are exeptions of course. Enough politics as u said lol.
Neith
Very good thred muslim. I was very nervous the first time I went to the mosque, every one was so warm and kind I felt at home. I do not pray because I am not a muslim yet.
Irish
Two questions Muslim

How many times a day must a Muslim pray in order to get to heaven?

Does Islam believe in divine justice?
GoddessWhispers
QUOTE(muslim @ Feb 2 2007, 03:49 AM) [snapback]1525399[/snapback]
I would also like to add to Godesswhispers that even the terrorists who have nothing to do with Islam dont believe in killing all Cristians and Jews. The Quran says you have your religion and I have mine....


QUOTE
"We can forgive you for killing our sons. But we will never forgive you for making us kill yours."Golda Meir to Anwar Saddat just before peace talks.


I can understand that. The eye for an eye philosophy appears in the bible and the jewish faith. Though it's implementation would insure a cyclical level of violence that would reverberate through the generations to come, for revenge of what initiated it all in one act, so long ago. Hey, wait a minute.....

wink2.gif

Thanks again Muslim. original.gif
Nova Scotia
What does a muslim beleave the future holds for the country we call isreal ? Or the race we know as jews that live on that land ?
GoddessWhispers
I've heard in other denominational faiths one has to renounce their former faith, if they enter into a new creed of belief. Is there anything of that nature for new muslims?! original.gif
SilverCougar
Moondoggy didn't see the "NO POLOTICS!" part of the post...


Anyways, I applaud you, muslim, for this post. It warms this bitter old heart to see someone taking steps to clearify the views of one's religion. It's not easy... especialy when there are so many misconseptions floating about.

No I don't have a question.. =( Forgive me? (THERE'S ONE! XD)
tuner
I know that you are answering questions her , but I must respon to the statement about no original sin issue.
To answer just one, thought to be error. “Some do not believe there was an original sin”. If not, then why was there a need for a savior? God is way too perfect to make man that is sinful. God said that He made man in His own image and likeness. Is God perfect or not? A God that can make this universe and all that is within, can’t make man perfect and without sin.
There are statements in the Bible that are not only true, but also a principle. Like Jesus when He sent out the disciples said “freely you have received, freely give”. This is a principle. If you don’t have a thing you can’t give it, and if you have it, it is because it was given to you. Right?
Also a principle is found in (Gen 1:11) And God said, Let the earth bring forth grass, the herb yielding seed, and the fruit tree yielding fruit after his kind, whose seed is in itself, upon the earth: and it was so.
(Gen 1:12) And the earth brought forth grass, and herb yielding seed after his kind, and the tree yielding fruit, whose seed was in itself, after his kind: and God saw that it was good.
Well that answers the question, ‘What came first, the chicken or the egg?’ God made the chicken that had the seed within itself to reproduce after it’s own kind. Which brings us to a point that God made man and the seed of man that had seed within himself to reproduce after his own kind. God created man by His seed which is His Word. The nature of a thing is in the seed. So what is the nature of God?
It’s time to point out that I do believe in ONE God. I believe the Bible teaches this not only in the Old Testament but in the new. John 1 says that in the beginning was the Word and the Word was God. In 1st John 5:7 it says that there are 3 that bare witness in heaven, “The Father, the Word and the Spirit.” He didn’t say the Father, Son and the Spirit. There is a reason for this. If you understand that God’s Word is His seed then you will know that God created every thing with His word. Since seed will reproduce after it’s own kind, the we were not created with sin or evil in us or our hearts. Also, Jesus said the God is spirit, so we are first and foremost a spiritual being that has a soul and lives in a body.
We know now in this day that the seed of a thing has a code in it. The genome or DNA that will follow the code to create a man, monkey, or other animal or plant or whatever. 1st John shows us that God is described as having three parts, ONE God with three parts. (Just like man that has three parts, spirit, soul and body). He is Father because all life past present and future has it’s origin in God. Jesus said in John 5:26 “For as the Father hath life Inhimself … showing no life is from any other source. His Word is seed, that is the way He creates and His Spirit is the power or His power. His Word contains the code, if you will when spoken will manifest from the spiritual into the natural. This is backed by Heb. 11:3. Notice it said the Word of His power, not the power of His Word. The Word without the Spirit will lay dormant, but when the Word is spoken in the power of His Spirit it will create.
Now if God create man without sin, then there was a time when Adam allowed sin to enter the human race and corrupted his, (our) seed. Look at 1st Peter 1:23. This came in his disobedience and ate of the tree of knowledge of good and evil. If you want to know just what happened take a look at the story of Abraham with scripture in both the Old and New Testament.
The story of Abram was that he could not have children with Sarai. He was given a promise from God that out of his seed would come a nation and all the earth will be blessed. It was “Unto thy seed”.
Yet the problem was that through Adam all man’s seed is corrupted. We were not there physically, but in seed we were. What mankind needed was one who was a part of the human race, but not a part of the Adamic nature. If man sinned, then a man who know no sin was needed to reverse what Adam did, (redeem). God did formed man out of the dust of the ground, but spoke His word to define man. Without God’s word anything that is created by God through forming, like man and the animals they would have no purpose, reason, meaning or destiny. Because His word is seed the word spoken over a thing defines it and gives it meaning and a reason and destiny. Like when He created the sun. By calling it “sun” it defined it’s purpose and reason for being. The seed that God promised Abram was not only or just a natural seed, but a spiritual seed because it was by faith. Abram was not sterile, but Sarai was barren and could not conceive. I believe God waited on purpose until Sarai was not only barren, but too old to conceive and Abram was impotent. This then was only possible through faith. When you are up against an impossible situation that can not change by any natural means, then when God steps in and makes it possible, this is a result of faith. If man’s seed is corrupted no amount of good works can redeem you. The lesson of Abram was God waited until Abram mimicked in the flesh what we all are in spirit. We are unable to fulfill the word of God because we are uncircumcised in spirit. It was only when Abram circumcised himself that God gave life to that which was dead and Abram was able to plant seed and even though Sarai was barren, which typifies the curse in the earth, Sarai conceived a promise child. When we are circumcised in spirit, we (according to the Bible are dead in sins and trespasses) are given life, the life of God. The only way we can be circumcised in the spirit is because Jesus took the curse for all mankind.
Which brings us to who was Jesus? Since Adam sinned and brought mankind into a sin nature, (in spirit) and his seed was corrupted the only way for a man to be borne into this life without sin was for God to speak His word into a woman, (virgin) and she conceived a child that was a part of the human race, but not a part of the Adamic nature. This is why He is called the Son of God. God’s word is not corruptible so the man that was conceived in Mary was without sin. He is the son of man and the Son of God.
Do a study on the veil that is typified by Abram’s uncircumcision. The veil over the Holy of Holies in the tabernacle and in the New Testament, (11Cor. 3:14-4:7). This is a long and in-depth study, but this it in a nutshell. Jesus went to the cross after living a life without sin and took man’s sin nature and went to hell and paid for man’s sin completely, rose from the dead and anyone who believes this and accepts Him as Lord will be born again and circumcised in the spirit cutting away the veil that was the body of sins. This was like a parasite that when removed will free us from the nature that controlled us and had dominion over us.
JMPD1
Muslim, let me say that this thread has been very informative, both for your answers and sadly, for the ignorance and rudeness of a few christians here who cannot seem to grasp the concept that you are teaching about your religion and trying to avoid politics.

Just as they claim "they aren't responsible for masscres casused by christians", they seem to feel the need to pin the woes of the Islamic world on you.

Too bad the mods don't see fit to notify the offenders to watch their step.

EmpressStarXVII
QUOTE(JMPD1 @ Feb 1 2007, 08:50 PM) [snapback]1526133[/snapback]
Muslim, let me say that this thread has been very informative, both for your answers and sadly, for the ignorance and rudeness of a few christians here who cannot seem to grasp the concept that you are teaching about your religion and trying to avoid politics.

Just as they claim "they aren't responsible for masscres casused by christians", they seem to feel the need to pin the woes of the Islamic world on you.

Too bad the mods don't see fit to notify the offenders to watch their step.


Thank you for pointing this out. I think this is a great thread for us to grow and learn in knowledge even if we aren't considering becoming a muslim, at least we have more insight as to what the religion is really about and not how the media portrays it.
Preacherbill
This is a good thread, it is informative and encoraging to see. if someone posts something rude or abusive report it to one of the mods. They have been very good about removing such matierial from my Ask me what its like to be a Pastor thread. Ususally the offencive mateiral is down within a few minutes.
JMPD1
you are a fair minded individual PreacherBill, tell me your thoughts on post # 38.

post # 33
post # 35
post # 6

Are they appropriate to the discussion?
muslim
QUOTE
How many times a day must a Muslim pray in order to get to heaven?
Hey Irish how are you? Im glad you visited my thread. Muslims pray 5 times a day. Each prayer takes about maybe 5-10 minutes. There are other prayers which arent obligatory but u can pray them if u like. Muslims believes salvation comes through deeds, and part of your deeds of course are your prayer so it isnt just prayer. Muslims believe that from ever prayer till the next if u pray them good your sins will be forgiven. So by the end of the end ull barely have any sins. The only sins which arent forgiven simply by praying are what we call the big ones which are 1) killing 2) drinking alcohol or intoxicants 3) adultry 4) worshiping someone other than God or associating any partners with Him.


QUOTE
Does Islam believe in divine justice?


Very much yes.



QUOTE
I can understand that. The eye for an eye philosophy appears in the bible and the jewish faith. Though it's implementation would insure a cyclical level of violence that would reverberate through the generations to come, for revenge of what initiated it all in one act, so long ago. Hey, wait a minute.....

Thanks again Muslim.


As Gandi said an eye for an eye only leaves the world blind.

Paranoid Android
Just a quick note to remind all people that this thread is about Islam, and a most excellent thread so far. Let's not take it off topic with unnecessary preaching. Thanks
muslim
QUOTE
I've heard in other denominational faiths one has to renounce their former faith, if they enter into a new creed of belief. Is there anything of that nature for new muslims?!
First, a new Muslim isnt even considred a convert but a revert. Because the word Muslim means one who surrenders his or her will to God all praise is to Him. So by definition, you were born a Muslim, I was born a Muslim and everyone was born a Muslim. So when one becomes a Muslim he would be considered a revert. Lastly, no, one wouldnt have to renounce their former faith if you mean as in to say that they no longer are part of that faith in public or something like that? If so, no they don have to. Islam is a continuation and a completon of Judaism and Christianity and there is no point of saying im no longer a Christian because that would be kind of disrespectful to Christianity and so on.


Tuner, if you read my posts you would have realized that Muslims dont believe in a "savior" as in someone dying for anyones sins. Muslims believe the savior is God. He saves you by forgiving your sins if you repent. By forgiving you if He wants even if you dont repent. The only way Jesus Christ peace be upon him was a savior in Islam is that he was sent by God to guide the people from falsehood to truth and therefore in that essence all prophets and messengers were saviors to the people. We believe your true savior is God and secondly your own actions. You save yourself by doing good and being a good king person who obeys his God's comandments. No disrespect, thats just the Muslim view point of it and salvation. As I said previosly, we dont believe sin is inherited. Muslims believe salvation is by your deeds. So they have to strive to by good people and bennefit their society so as a result of their belief, naturally, the world would be a better place.
“The best of people are those that bring most benefit to the rest of mankind.” Mohammed peace be upon him. He also said:

“The best of people are those who live longest and excel in their deeds, whereas the worst of people are those who live longest and corrupt their deeds.”


QUOTE
Ok, may i ask....why do muslim terrorist like to cut off heads.


I dont know. Why dont you ask them? Mohammed said:

“Do not say, that if the people do good to us, we will do good to them; and if the people oppress us, we will oppress them; but determine that if people do you good, you will do good to them; and if they oppress you, you will not oppress them”

So I dont know. They have nothing to do wth Islam so please stop.
*-Aldy-*
Hi, thank you for opening up this topic. I have a question or two, I mean no offence by asking them. original.gif

I would like to know, why do Muslim extremists still stone women to death, and what is the Muslim community doing to make this stop? (Like I said, I know this is not the norm in most Muslim communities, I would presume it is only in more rural areas).

God bless you.
*-Aldy-*
One more question, is a Muslim allowed to change his or her faith? Would the family accept them, or disown them, or does it vary by laws, and mind sets?

(Again no offence, I know many other religions, who would shun anyone who changed their faith).
EmpressStarXVII
In christianity there are different sects. Baptist, Church of God, Nazerine...etc.

Is there more sects in Islam than Shi'ia and Sunni? And if it isn't too complex an answer, what is the difference between the two, and how does one determine they follow Shi'ia or Sunni?

Also. If makeup is forbidden (which I guess I could be wrong, I am just assuming because I have heard many muslims say you are not to draw attention to your beauty) why is it that Kohl is in markets for muslimahs?
muslim
QUOTE
Hi, thank you for opening up this topic. I have a question or two, I mean no offence by asking them.
Its ok original.gif

QUOTE
I would like to know, why do Muslim extremists still stone women to death, and what is the Muslim community doing to make this stop? (Like I said, I know this is not the norm in most Muslim communities, I would presume it is only in more rural areas).


Thank you for asking this question. First, this punishment isnt just subject to woman that would be unfair. Second, Ive never in my entire life herd of someone being stoned, thats how rare it is. Stoning is a punishment for if a married man or a married woman were to betray his or her wife. But, what most people do not know, that this punishment is impossible to be implemented, it literally is impossible. Why? Because as you know adultry isnt allowed in Islam. And if that person commits it he is than subject to the law. But how and what are the sircumstances of one to get stoned? First, their would have to be four witnesses. These four witnesses would have to have watched the entire thing i.e them having sex and these four witnesses cant be a relative. This is impossible to hapen. So the law is their to scare the husband or wife to not do it, but it is impossible to be implemented because naturally when two people commit adultry they dnt do it in a public place so where on earth are four witnesses going to come from? In the entire history of Islam you can actually count the number of people who have been stonned and these people werent trialed for adultry but they themselves handed themselves to the authorities out of guilt. Even at the time of Mohammed, it never happened that anyone was founf guilty of this. A man once came to him and told him that he commited adultry (i.e punish me) and Mohammed told him, maybe you didnt? He said no I did. Then Mohammed said maybe you just hugged her? He said no I did. Than Mohammed walked away from him. The next time the man saw Mohammed told him "punish me" he said "good deeds wipe out bad deeds. Repent to God". So I dont know where these woman are that you're talking about. Maybe in Afghanistan by Taliban and Talibans laws were mostly cultural (they said they rule with Islamic law) but actually the majority of what they did wasnt. Islamic law says that you have to educate your daughter. Woman in Afghanistan as you know werent allowed too. Islamic law says woman are allowed to enter the parlament, woman in Afghanistan and even Saudia Arabia arent allowed too. So you have to be able to differ between culture and Islam, most of what happens to woman today is because of culture not because of Islam. Even the greatest cleric in Saudia Arabia said that woman should have many more rights than what we give the here but unfortanetly this is because culture has kicked in, not Islam. So in conclusion, the laws are their, but its impossible to implement them. Mohammed used to cry when anyone was punished, he would always advise them not too and that they should just repent but they said that the guilt was too great and so on. So in conclusion, stoning is impossible. Its just their to scare that person but its impossible to be implemented. As I said ive never herd of anyone stoned. Ive read about this hapening in Afghanistan and as I said what they do is mostly cultural.

QUOTE
God bless you.


You too original.gif

muslim
QUOTE
Is there more sects in Islam than Shi'ia and Sunni? And if it isn't too complex an answer, what is the difference between the two, and how does one determine they follow Shi'ia or Sunni?
It is a complex answer so ill just make it simple. The majority of the Muslims are Sunni, 85% are Sunni. Less than 10% are Shia and the other 5% are others. Shias practises have nothing to do with Islam , meaning they add things to the relegion which werent their at the time of Mohammed peace be upon him. So you can sort of say Sunni is orthodox and Shia is unorthodox. Shia are so different that they even are considered to have a different relegion. They mostly aee in Iraq and Iran. Thats where they came from in the begeniing. When Islam spread into Iraq and Iran long ago, the people of Iraq and Iran had a relegion which I dont know what you call in English but basically they woshipped fire. After they became Muslims culture kicked in and they started changing the relegion and adding stuff to it and so on. Shias claim that they follow the prophet and his family only. Sunnis follow the prophet, his family and his companions. Shias are a vast minority but are a majority in Iraq and Iran, the rest of the Muslim world mostly is Sunni. The 5% others are several but most of their beliefs even contradict the Quran so I dont know how they consider themselves Muslims if they simple read the Quran theyll see that theyre wrong. For example one guy came and started a new sect and claimed he was the Messiah, the Christ that the jews were waiting for! Any person who was anything about what the Quran says about Jesus will know that the Quran says that Jesus was the Messiah. So how can this guy be the Messiah! So the other are really little with its followers decieved by guys like this one.


Mohammed prophesized this and said that at some point ull be almost 70 sects. So just follow the Quran and my Sunna (sunna is whatever he did, and said, basically his teachings). Muslims believe in a guy who will come and will unite them and there sects. He is called The Mahdi (meaning the guided one). After the Mahdi will come the Anti Christ and after the Anti Christ will come the true Christ (Jesus, from heaven will come down to earth) and defeat the anti Christ and unite the world.


QUOTE
Also. If makeup is forbidden (which I guess I could be wrong, I am just assuming because I have heard many muslims say you are not to draw attention to your beauty) why is it that Kohl is in markets for muslimahs?


Hmm, I'm a male so I dont know much about this. But Ill give a general answer. In Islam, Muslims are supposed to dress modestly and be modest and guard their chastity. Woman are supposed to cover there hair with the scarf and on the other hand men are supposed to grow there beards. Islam focuses on the inner beauty instead of the physical outter beauty of one. The beauty of the heart is what matters most so we dress modestly. Of course lookng good is allowed its not as if you should try and be ugly, but within modest limits. I think that Kihl is allowed since it is something modest and most Muslim woman do wear kihl. It is 1000% allowed for a woman to wear it infront of her husband of course. Lol you'd have to check on that if you become a Muslim someday tongue.gif but most likely I think ts allowed because as our Prophet said peace be upon him "God is beautiful and loves beauty"
(but the most important thing in Islam is the inner beauty not the physical, the beauty of the heart not the body).
muslim
This is very nice Id really like you to watch it.

http://www.turntoislam.com/forum/showthread.php?t=51
EmpressStarXVII
QUOTE(muslim @ Feb 2 2007, 12:43 AM) [snapback]1526412[/snapback]
This is very nice Id really like you to watch it.

http://www.turntoislam.com/forum/showthread.php?t=51



Thank you for that video original.gif, he has a wonderful story.
muslim

QUOTE
Thank you for that video , he has a wonderful story.


Im glad you liked it original.gif
muslim
This is also nice. (I wont be posing links since I think its off topic but this is good)
its Cat Stevens the pop star , now known as Yusuf Islam (he converted) talking about Mohammed (he's recorded Mohammeds biography on CDs and its coming out soon God willing)

http://www.turntoislam.com/forum/showthread.php?t=6310
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.