QUOTE(rezna @ Feb 27 2007, 02:34 PM) [snapback]1560646[/snapback]
IMHO, I believe that there was a group of people who had a society much older than anything we have in the archaeological records. We see in every single society a creation story. Well, what if they were true? What if some of the stories in the bible were true? THey could have been! Who is to say that just because there isn't evidence of something it didn't happen?
Rezna,
I've said before that the word "evidence" should be used instead of the word "proof" in most posts involving the concept here at U-M. Thanks for using the correct terminology here.
The use of the correct word makes your statement true.
That being said, since you indulged in a "What if...?", then allow me to as well.
Suppose your belief in some much older society were true. Here's
my "What if?" What if this old society had their
own creation myth? Couldn't the "much older" Rezna from that ancient society propose an even older, earlier society from whence came
their creation myths? And what if even that ancient, ancient society had
their own creation myths? Again, couldn't an ancient, ancient Rezna make the same statement? Continua ad absurdum.
That is an example of why it's a waste of time to believe in something for which there's absolutely no evidence whatsoever.
QUOTE(rezna @ Feb 27 2007, 02:34 PM) [snapback]1560646[/snapback]
Now here's a great scenario:
Say global warming does completely screw us over. And lets say it's starts happening in 2012, just for fun! And then it obliterates our society. Volcanos, earthquakes, super storms, galactic debree falling to earth, meteors, etc. It all happens and a lot of us die (could take a lot of time for this to happen, just humor me)...
... Thus, for the rest of time, the greco-roman war is told completely wrong to everyone after that one person screwed it up.
Now, why couldn't this have happened with say, Noah's flood story? I think it did. Or Atlantis? I think it did. Or any of the other myths and stories we here from all kinds of cultures, in all kinds of centuries, etc. Dragons, sea monsters, adam and eve, atlantis, noahs flood or a big flood in general, "a man who came down from the sky", a man who came from across the ocean, there are so many of these stories! DISCUSS!
I'm certain it
did happen with the flood story, though I'd hesitate to call it Noah's. The Biblical flood story comes from Babylonia originally and was misappropriated by the Hebrews in Babylon.
As far as Atlantis goes, I must say that there's just no chance at all that this happened. There is just no traditional "Atlantis story" that is embedded in any Greek mythology or tradition. It's only mentioned in ancient times in two dialogues by Plato. Nothing at all before that. Nobody after that either. None of the Greeks that came right after Plato mention Atlantis at all, except when critiqueing Plato's writings. Atlantis is not really heard from again in any way until Donnalley's book near the end of the 19th century.
Sea monsters, now, that's another story. I'm seriously on the side of many cryptozoologists. Within the last ten years, a new species of
whale was discovered. Now, we've been hunting whales for a long time, long enough to almost wipe them out, but only recently found a new species? Just try to convince me that we know anything at all about what lives down there.
Did you see those pics of the giant squid (the first ever taken of a live one) that Japanese scientist got last year?
Won't catch me in the ocean.
Harte