QUOTE
March 22, 2007 Books of The Times
The Astronauts Columbia Left Behind
By JANET MASLIN Skip to next paragraph
TOO FAR FROM HOME
A Story of Life and Death in Space
By Chris Jones
While the world grieved for the Columbia crew lost on Feb. 1, 2003, three lonely men in space had a somewhat more complicated reaction. They were the members of Expedition Six, two Americans and a Russian installed at the International Space Station. They had been there since the previous November, and they were getting ready to come home. But the disaster suspended space travel, so no new crew would arrive to relieve them in the foreseeable future. Suddenly they were stuck in a sci-fi limbo.
This crisis became the basis for an Esquire article in which Chris Jones recreated the experience of the three men: Dr. Donald R. Pettit, Capt. Kenneth D. Bowersox and Nikolai M. Budarin. Mr. Jones focused tightly on this story, giving it both intimacy and suspense. Now, one National Magazine Award later (Mr. Jones won for feature writing in 2005), his longer, less assured version of Expedition Six’s perilous journey has been turned into a book.
Like air in a vacuum, the story told in “Too Far From Home” expands to fill the boundaries it has been given. But it has lost its tight focus and some of its verve. Mr. Jones’s efforts to provide context for Expedition Six yield more generic, less compelling historical detail about both the American and Russian space programs, as well as occasionally inflated prose about the lyrical loneliness of an astronaut’s mission.
“Like every astronaut and every cosmonaut, from the first to the last, they were seen as something alien and wonderful, these ordinary assemblies of skin and tissue that had been turned into artifacts by virtue of the places they had been,” he writes about the Expedition Six members, post-expedition. And: “Between expectation and reality, between flying and falling — between earth and space, between home and away — there will forever remain some kind of gap.” Whatever this is, it isn’t the right stuff.
With his book based largely on the astronauts’ recollections (“NASA declined to help me out — for reasons I’ve never been able to fathom,” Mr. Jones writes) and on data that is also well documented on the Web site Space.com, he must bring something unusual to what would otherwise be a relatively routine mix, despite the drama of Expedition Six’s temporary dilemma.
So he concentrates on the you-are-there physical peculiarities of life in space. Oh, wow: Imagine what happens when someone puts Alka-Seltzer in a bubble-sphere of water under zero-gravity conditions. This account is actually at its best with space-trippy images of that kind.
Then there are the diapers. With no inkling about how notorious these would become, Mr. Jones makes diapers part of his detailed examination of how astronauts perform bodily functions in space. No spitting allowed: they have to swallow their toothpaste. Moisture from their sweat will eventually wind up in their tea.
Russian cosmonauts are too tough to wear diapers. Americans do, but the Expedition Six crew declined to use them once it had been determined that they would go home on an outmoded Russian capsule, the Soyuz TMA-1. That trip, which became a nail-biter, was supposed to be relatively brief.
“The American space program has traditionally paid little attention to the psychological health of its astronauts in space,” Mr. Jones notes. But “there is strong evidence that spending a long time in space can make people crackers.” Diapers and all, “Too Far From Home” is certainly prescient this way.
Still, in spite of potentially nerve-wracking claustrophobia and other strains, the Expedition Six team members stayed level-headed and sane.
“Bowersox was the firstborn brother,” Mr. Jones writes. “He was reason and responsibility. Pettit was the wide-eyed kid who loved eating his drinks with chopsticks.” (Dr. Pettit loved experimenting with fluids. His other efforts included that Alka-Seltzer trick.) “Budarin was the weird uncle from Russia.” Although he spends much more time describing each of them, the author doesn’t much deviate from those simple thumbnail descriptions.
Still, Mr. Jones finds ways to overstate each case. “Like Picasso going through his Blue period, Pettit had once been obsessed with clocks,” he says of Dr. Pettit’s ingenious tinkering. Much is also made of Mr. Budarin’s revelation that a breakfast packet of dried strawberries, if soaked in water all day, would make a nice dinnertime dessert. “Another lesson learned, another trick revealed,” Mr. Jones writes of this.
But he makes it clear that the astronaut world has needed to lose its daredevil edge, and that a new breed of calm, stoical, strawberry-soaking astronauts will help give a business-as-usual facade to great space leaps of the future. At Edwards Air Force Base in California, where Tom Wolfe’s test pilots created their legends in “The Right Stuff” and where Captain Bowersox later trained as a test pilot, “the romance has been waived for reason,” the book says. “And at the end of the day, today’s students are far more likely to retire to the in-school lounge with their textbooks and a cup of coffee than to some dusty desert bar with black-and-white photographs of dead pilots on the wall.”
For all the professionalism and sang-froid described in “Too Far From Home,” though, there remains a real, underlying sense of what makes astronauts so far removed from the ordinary. Even when performing routine repairs, an astronaut may gaze at his or her foot and see behind it a similar-sized object that turns out to be Australia.
Emotions in space are no less strange; they bring higher highs and lower lows. And the title “Too Far From Home” hints at the secret ambivalence that goes with this territory. At first glance, to the sentimental reader, the title may signify the loneliness of space travel. But when the men of Expedition Six returned to Earth, they missed their privilege and isolation. They were homesick here too.
The Astronauts Columbia Left Behind
By JANET MASLIN Skip to next paragraph
TOO FAR FROM HOME
A Story of Life and Death in Space
By Chris Jones
While the world grieved for the Columbia crew lost on Feb. 1, 2003, three lonely men in space had a somewhat more complicated reaction. They were the members of Expedition Six, two Americans and a Russian installed at the International Space Station. They had been there since the previous November, and they were getting ready to come home. But the disaster suspended space travel, so no new crew would arrive to relieve them in the foreseeable future. Suddenly they were stuck in a sci-fi limbo.
This crisis became the basis for an Esquire article in which Chris Jones recreated the experience of the three men: Dr. Donald R. Pettit, Capt. Kenneth D. Bowersox and Nikolai M. Budarin. Mr. Jones focused tightly on this story, giving it both intimacy and suspense. Now, one National Magazine Award later (Mr. Jones won for feature writing in 2005), his longer, less assured version of Expedition Six’s perilous journey has been turned into a book.
Like air in a vacuum, the story told in “Too Far From Home” expands to fill the boundaries it has been given. But it has lost its tight focus and some of its verve. Mr. Jones’s efforts to provide context for Expedition Six yield more generic, less compelling historical detail about both the American and Russian space programs, as well as occasionally inflated prose about the lyrical loneliness of an astronaut’s mission.
“Like every astronaut and every cosmonaut, from the first to the last, they were seen as something alien and wonderful, these ordinary assemblies of skin and tissue that had been turned into artifacts by virtue of the places they had been,” he writes about the Expedition Six members, post-expedition. And: “Between expectation and reality, between flying and falling — between earth and space, between home and away — there will forever remain some kind of gap.” Whatever this is, it isn’t the right stuff.
With his book based largely on the astronauts’ recollections (“NASA declined to help me out — for reasons I’ve never been able to fathom,” Mr. Jones writes) and on data that is also well documented on the Web site Space.com, he must bring something unusual to what would otherwise be a relatively routine mix, despite the drama of Expedition Six’s temporary dilemma.
So he concentrates on the you-are-there physical peculiarities of life in space. Oh, wow: Imagine what happens when someone puts Alka-Seltzer in a bubble-sphere of water under zero-gravity conditions. This account is actually at its best with space-trippy images of that kind.
Then there are the diapers. With no inkling about how notorious these would become, Mr. Jones makes diapers part of his detailed examination of how astronauts perform bodily functions in space. No spitting allowed: they have to swallow their toothpaste. Moisture from their sweat will eventually wind up in their tea.
Russian cosmonauts are too tough to wear diapers. Americans do, but the Expedition Six crew declined to use them once it had been determined that they would go home on an outmoded Russian capsule, the Soyuz TMA-1. That trip, which became a nail-biter, was supposed to be relatively brief.
“The American space program has traditionally paid little attention to the psychological health of its astronauts in space,” Mr. Jones notes. But “there is strong evidence that spending a long time in space can make people crackers.” Diapers and all, “Too Far From Home” is certainly prescient this way.
Still, in spite of potentially nerve-wracking claustrophobia and other strains, the Expedition Six team members stayed level-headed and sane.
“Bowersox was the firstborn brother,” Mr. Jones writes. “He was reason and responsibility. Pettit was the wide-eyed kid who loved eating his drinks with chopsticks.” (Dr. Pettit loved experimenting with fluids. His other efforts included that Alka-Seltzer trick.) “Budarin was the weird uncle from Russia.” Although he spends much more time describing each of them, the author doesn’t much deviate from those simple thumbnail descriptions.
Still, Mr. Jones finds ways to overstate each case. “Like Picasso going through his Blue period, Pettit had once been obsessed with clocks,” he says of Dr. Pettit’s ingenious tinkering. Much is also made of Mr. Budarin’s revelation that a breakfast packet of dried strawberries, if soaked in water all day, would make a nice dinnertime dessert. “Another lesson learned, another trick revealed,” Mr. Jones writes of this.
But he makes it clear that the astronaut world has needed to lose its daredevil edge, and that a new breed of calm, stoical, strawberry-soaking astronauts will help give a business-as-usual facade to great space leaps of the future. At Edwards Air Force Base in California, where Tom Wolfe’s test pilots created their legends in “The Right Stuff” and where Captain Bowersox later trained as a test pilot, “the romance has been waived for reason,” the book says. “And at the end of the day, today’s students are far more likely to retire to the in-school lounge with their textbooks and a cup of coffee than to some dusty desert bar with black-and-white photographs of dead pilots on the wall.”
For all the professionalism and sang-froid described in “Too Far From Home,” though, there remains a real, underlying sense of what makes astronauts so far removed from the ordinary. Even when performing routine repairs, an astronaut may gaze at his or her foot and see behind it a similar-sized object that turns out to be Australia.
Emotions in space are no less strange; they bring higher highs and lower lows. And the title “Too Far From Home” hints at the secret ambivalence that goes with this territory. At first glance, to the sentimental reader, the title may signify the loneliness of space travel. But when the men of Expedition Six returned to Earth, they missed their privilege and isolation. They were homesick here too.
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/03/22/books/22...=spaceandcosmos
