Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Theory of Vision by George Berkeley 1709
Unexplained Mysteries Discussion Forums > Unexplained Mysteries > Extraterrestrial Life & The UFO Phenomenon
SEI 312
According to George Berkeley's "Essay towards a New Theory of Vision" (1709), he states that there can be no "sound, or figure, or motion, or color, to exist without the mind." He was an immaterialist: matter does not exist. He accepts the position that ordinary objects are composed soley of ideas.

That being said, basically we interpret objects as whatever our brain wants to interpret them as, and every human is different. What I see as a bird, your brain may see a spinning disc...
Teufelhund
Very creative theory, but a bit far-fetched to me...
SEI 312
QUOTE(Teufelhund @ Jul 7 2007, 04:22 PM) *
Very creative theory, but a bit far-fetched to me...


More far fetched that Aliens from a different planet visiting Earth?

Not to mention coming all this way and not even saying "What's Up Earthlings"

Seriously?
Teufelhund
I didn't say I believe in that theory, did I? wink2.gif original.gif
jaylemurph
Last time I checked, most of Bishop Berkeley's philosophical ideas had passed out of currency;
"Esse est percepi" depends wholly on someone observing the universe in toto constantly and can't hold up if you can't prove a god (which nobody ever has, conclusively).

--Jaylemurph
Mclane
QUOTE(SEI 312 @ Jul 7 2007, 10:09 PM) *
According to George Berkeley's "Essay towards a New Theory of Vision" (1709), he states that there can be no "sound, or figure, or motion, or color, to exist without the mind." He was an immaterialist: matter does not exist. He accepts the position that ordinary objects are composed soley of ideas.

That being said, basically we interpret objects as whatever our brain wants to interpret them as, and every human is different. What I see as a bird, your brain may see a spinning disc...

That idea only works if the item is unrecognisable to begin with, 99% of humans with a normal perceived set of life experience would all recognise what an item is or have a pretty good 'guess' at it, for others the brain creates what it wants it to see as the person overrides the obvious recognition sets.

ie, there are people who so badly want to see a ufo etc that they brainwash themselves..

Personally I think his theory 'blows chunks' to use a US term...
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2008 Invision Power Services, Inc.