Join the Unexplained Mysteries community today! It's free and setting up an account only takes a moment.
- Sign In or Create Account -
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 3
KBA

Why people are skeptical of psychic claims

172 posts in this topic

Posted (edited)

It seems like a lot of people act surprised or upset when they talk about their "powers" here and are met with skepticism from multiple members of U-M. I frankly have to wonder why people would be surprised at such a thing.

Firstly, we need to understand the way the world works.

The world is full of all different types of people who believe all different types of things and feel all different types of emotions, and so on. Now, there's definitely no shortage of people in the world who would agree that the human mind is capable of doing magical and unexplainable things. However, in the modern era of science and reason, there are an increasing number of people who want evidence before they will believe what you're saying.

Nobody inherently deserves trust.

When someone makes a claim that they have a psychic power, it collides with the reality that most of us have been living in and experiencing. In such a reality, it is impossible for the brain to produce magical effects, such as twirling objects, burning things, or accurately guessing what random peoples' favorite color is. It would be the same if I came up to you and told you that your foot is made of jelly. You wouldn't believe it, because you have always understood that your foot is made of blood, bone, muscle, skin, etc.

And you shouldn't believe it! Your foot is not made of jelly! It's good to be skeptical toward things like that, because you have so much evidence saying what your foot is truly made of, and only one quick claim that your foot is made of jelly. It's only reasonable to stick with the scientific explanation.

Now, imagine the brain is our "foot". Many, many people come here and claim that the brain has the ability to perform magic feats. They say: "your brain can do it too!". When you hear something like this, how is it really any different than them telling you your brain is made of jelly? They are stating that the human brain can perform tasks that it has never been shown to be able to perform, and without an apparent means to perform said feat.

So which way do you expect people to sway? In the direction of the person making one quick claim? Or in the direction of hundreds of years of scientific research and evidence? It makes no sense to believe random claims on an internet forum. It ignores the simple principle that the most evident theory is likely the closest to the truth. This is why people ask for a video, or some sort of proof when you do make these claims.

After all, how many people have come on here and said they could do magical things with their minds? Hundreds? Thousands?

How many of those people likely had video recording equipment? Half of them? All of them?

And how many people have offered a video to prove it? Not a single one.

Imagine that I strolled over to this forum claiming with great confidence to have brown hair. I wanted people to believe that I had brown hair... yet nobody would believe me unless I posted proof. What would I do, then? I'd take a quick picture or video to show that I did, in fact, have brown hair. It's a simple process, and it gives credibility to the claim I'm making. Why is this so hard when it comes to psychic powers?

Well, as us skeptics see it, it's because the powers you claim to have do not exist.

You can change our opinion if you really can do it, you just have to be reasonable about it.

Edited by KBA

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is pretty much what I was saying in the thread I started in here today - well said.

I can't wait to hear the excuses that will inevitably come rolling in.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Imagine that I strolled over to this forum claiming with great confidence to have brown hair. I wanted people to believe that I had brown hair... yet nobody would believe me unless I posted proof. What would I do, then? I'd take a quick picture or video to show that I did, in fact, have brown hair. It's a simple process

And even then, you could of faked the evidence. i.e photo-shop, bad lighting, Hair dye(if you were claiming it was natural).., etc etc. but other than that i totally agree :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Its good to be a skeptic. :tsu: Boo ya.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
You can change our opinion if you really can do it, you just have to be reasonable about it.

I am happy with your opinion and do not wish to see you change it.

There is a saying that beauty is in the eye of the beholder. An experience is kind of like that. It is very subjective.

I would say that some the people who share their experience with the group au U_M are looking for others with similar experiences. Some others are looking for attention. Still others are stretching their minds to reach out for something more than they have been taught is all that is.

I realize that the proof seekers will never find proof because experience with unseen energies is unseeable. The day may well come when someone can change lead into gold and prove to all what they can do. However if they were wise thay would keep that skill a secret.

John

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I am happy with your opinion and do not wish to see you change it.

There is a saying that beauty is in the eye of the beholder. An experience is kind of like that. It is very subjective.

I would say that some the people who share their experience with the group au U_M are looking for others with similar experiences. Some others are looking for attention. Still others are stretching their minds to reach out for something more than they have been taught is all that is.

I realize that the proof seekers will never find proof because experience with unseen energies is unseeable. The day may well come when someone can change lead into gold and prove to all what they can do. However if they were wise thay would keep that skill a secret.

John

If these supposed energies have an effect on the real world, ex: TK, then they should easily be shown to work. Even telepathy would be easily validated. No one wants to step up. Why is that? Because they can't do it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
If these supposed energies have an effect on the real world, ex: TK, then they should easily be shown to work. Even telepathy would be easily validated. No one wants to step up. Why is that? Because they can't do it.

I am currently workin on settin up a telepathy test with eight bit Eric...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

And even then, you could of faked the evidence. i.e photo-shop, bad lighting, Hair dye(if you were claiming it was natural).., etc etc. but other than that i totally agree :P

Well, that's true. However, most of the people here truly believe they have these powers. It's obvious that a quick video can't be taken as absolute proof of a power, but at least as a litmus test regarding who's being even slightly honest. If someone does make a video, it can at least break some ground and show that the person is at all interested in putting their money where their mouth is. And I think if some people actually went and tried to prove it, they would realize that they may be deceiving themselves and can't actually do it. A lot of people do very subjective tests to "prove to themselves" that it's real.

I remember there was one guy who made a few videos a long time ago, I think his name was ASmatt. They were pretty well done, and I'll let the jury stay open on that one. Of course there's a million ways he could have faked it, but I certainly have more respect for him than someone who comes up with excuse after excuse for not being able to do something they regularly do; but in front of their camera. Even if it was faked, it least it was engaging :lol: .

Edited by KBA

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Even if it was faked, it least it was engaging :lol: .

Mmm..Unfortunately, 'Engaging' is about as good as it gets ^_^ , but then again it's probably a good thing, after all...who wants some school kid(full of angst), or even an adult for that matter, going around with the ability to effect change from a distance, and with the power of thought(or the wave of a hand). Not me, thats for sure :unsure2:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

Oh yet another post of this type. I will say, if I had any of this type of powers, I will not show it even if I could. Because the statement, "you are more powerful if others don't know your true power." Is what I think is true. Fame and glory, sometimes have to yield to some secrecy. I myself would like a normal life over a life of a famous person. I have read a lot of things about famous people in life. Actors, scientists, well, Their lives sound glamourous to the observer. But is it? The people involved know better. And I am ready to be sure that most of them want to live a normal lives like the next person.

There is a reason why the fourms is such a haunt for believers. Over the world wide web, you can be anybody. Nobody knows who you are. You can discuss opinions freely without people giving you strange glances. The real life is totally different.

Now on to videos. You can request videos. But that does not mean you will get it. Not everyone has the desire, time or just simply wish to let you see what they do. Its both, the trouble taken to prepare when they can do something better or just lazing around.

Edited by Sporkling

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

It seems like a lot of people act surprised or upset when they talk about their "powers" here and are met with skepticism from multiple members of U-M. I frankly have to wonder why people would be surprised at such a thing.

Firstly, we need to understand the way the world works.

The world is full of all different types of people who believe all different types of things and feel all different types of emotions, and so on. Now, there's definitely no shortage of people in the world who would agree that the human mind is capable of doing magical and unexplainable things. However, in the modern era of science and reason, there are an increasing number of people who want evidence before they will believe what you're saying.

Nobody inherently deserves trust.

When someone makes a claim that they have a psychic power, it collides with the reality that most of us have been living in and experiencing. In such a reality, it is impossible for the brain to produce magical effects, such as twirling objects, burning things, or accurately guessing what random peoples' favorite color is. It would be the same if I came up to you and told you that your foot is made of jelly. You wouldn't believe it, because you have always understood that your foot is made of blood, bone, muscle, skin, etc.

And you shouldn't believe it! Your foot is not made of jelly! It's good to be skeptical toward things like that, because you have so much evidence saying what your foot is truly made of, and only one quick claim that your foot is made of jelly. It's only reasonable to stick with the scientific explanation.

Now, imagine the brain is our "foot". Many, many people come here and claim that the brain has the ability to perform magic feats. They say: "your brain can do it too!". When you hear something like this, how is it really any different than them telling you your brain is made of jelly? They are stating that the human brain can perform tasks that it has never been shown to be able to perform, and without an apparent means to perform said feat.

So which way do you expect people to sway? In the direction of the person making one quick claim? Or in the direction of hundreds of years of scientific research and evidence? It makes no sense to believe random claims on an internet forum. It ignores the simple principle that the most evident theory is likely the closest to the truth. This is why people ask for a video, or some sort of proof when you do make these claims.

After all, how many people have come on here and said they could do magical things with their minds? Hundreds? Thousands?

How many of those people likely had video recording equipment? Half of them? All of them?

And how many people have offered a video to prove it? Not a single one.

Imagine that I strolled over to this forum claiming with great confidence to have brown hair. I wanted people to believe that I had brown hair... yet nobody would believe me unless I posted proof. What would I do, then? I'd take a quick picture or video to show that I did, in fact, have brown hair. It's a simple process, and it gives credibility to the claim I'm making. Why is this so hard when it comes to psychic powers?

Well, as us skeptics see it, it's because the powers you claim to have do not exist.

You can change our opinion if you really can do it, you just have to be reasonable about it.

I have provided video proof, fyi...

And, I'm not suprised at such skeptism. I expect it. I'd be suprised to if someone was to say "I can channel energy through me", believe me, I would...But, I'd also go, and try it myself, to decide whether or not this is real...

Edited by Heartagram3200

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

I have provided video proof, fyi...

That you lost, and wasn't definitive of anything but air currents from what I've heard. A bit of cotton fluff moving on a table, is that the one? You refuse to do the same experiment the right way, under glass. Why is that?

Edited by Moonie2012

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
That you lost, and wasn't definitive of anything but air currents from what I've heard. You refuse to do the same experiment the right way. Why is that?

I refuse to do it...Cause I have better things to do than make vids, that no one will believe...Not even if Albert Einstine came alive and said they were genuine...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

I refuse to do it...Cause I have better things to do than make vids, that no one will believe...Not even if Albert Einstine came alive and said they were genuine...

No, you won't do it because you can't. Admit it. If you could do it, you would show us in a heartbeat.

I'm willing to bet you tried it, and it didn't work. Am I right? Or are you going to claim that you did do it the right way, but just won't film it?

Edited by Moonie2012

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If I did do it...No one would believe it...Everyone knows, that even if the most conclusive evidence for psychic abilites was found...Only about 10% of the skeptics here would ebelieve...Those like Eric, and Black Sabbath, and Mattshark...They would all believe it was fake, or they'd just sya "I'm right, you're wrong" Thats what they always do...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
If these supposed energies have an effect on the real world, ex: TK, then they should easily be shown to work. Even telepathy would be easily validated. No one wants to step up. Why is that? Because they can't do it.

We did have 'some' success with Jbreen's (spelling?) remote viewing test a few months ago....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
If I did do it...No one would believe it...Everyone knows, that even if the most conclusive evidence for psychic abilites was found...Only about 10% of the skeptics here would ebelieve...Those like Eric, and Black Sabbath, and Mattshark...They would all believe it was fake, or they'd just sya "I'm right, you're wrong" Thats what they always do...

So, have you tried it (under glass)? Did it work?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I have provided video proof, fyi...

And, I'm not suprised at such skeptism. I expect it. I'd be suprised to if someone was to say "I can channel energy through me", believe me, I would...But, I'd also go, and try it myself, to decide whether or not this is real...

Your video proof was crap. You did it in a way as to be worthless and I believe you did it that way on purpose. You knew if you did it right that you would be proven wrong. Very sad.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

Your video proof was crap. You did it in a way as to be worthless and I believe you did it that way on purpose. You knew if you did it right that you would be proven wrong. Very sad.

What if he actually did it under glass and it worked? Would you believe it then, or would you automatically call it fake?

You know, if you do it right (i.e. no breaks in film, good close-ups of the equipment and surface used, etc.), an experiment like this would be very hard to fake. No air is going to get under a glass inverted on a table with a tablecloth.

I tried it myself with a psi wheel, I tried everything to get that thing to spin, and the only way it moved was if I banged on the table. If you get one under glass to spin, it would be amazing.

Edited by Moonie2012

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I refuse to do it...Cause I have better things to do than make vids, that no one will believe...Not even if Albert Einstine came alive and said they were genuine...

You refuse because you can't. You are nothing more than a scammer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
What if he actually did it under glass and it worked? Would you believe it then, or would you automatically call it fake?

If he did it properly, then I would be inclined to believe him.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
We did have 'some' success with Jbreen's (spelling?) remote viewing test a few months ago....

There was some findings to suggest further study. :tu:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

If he did it properly, then I would be inclined to believe him.

As would I. Sadly, he persists with the excuses, which only proves he is not being honest.

Nobody that can actually pull it off is going to refuse to do it, especially when they have tried to prove it before.

Edited by Moonie2012

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

Look, many people here believe, that we who belive in TK, and other psychic abilities lie intentionally to get attention. I myself, do not do that. Sure, maybe I'm not doin TK, and maybe the feelings I get from psi are bio-feedback...But, I myself believe I can do TK, and that psi is real. Why, because of all the evidence I've shown myself that supports it, the only real evidence is apparent once you get up and try it yourself. So, I don't lie, the only way I would be lying, would be unintentionally...Maybe this sin't TK, or psi, but...I believe it is, I'm not making things out of the air that I don't believe, any claims I make, I believe thye did happen...And, you guys say I make excuses, but...Whenever we tell the skeptics to tyr it themselves, they make excuses too...They say

"I did it before, didn't work" or "I have a family", Well, isn't that what you accuse us of doing? Of making excuses to get out of doing something? The "I did it before" excuse...Well, try it again! Maybe you'll get new results you didn't expect...I started psi, because I heard about it, and it sounded ridiculous, so I wnated to try it to see how stupid it was...And Oh my gosh, I stuck with it! I honestly didn't believe in it one bit till I tried it myself...And the "I got family" excuse...I use that same exact excuse, and you guys attack and mock me for it...If I can't use that excuse, why should the skeptics be able to?

Edited by Heartagram3200

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

You prove quite a reasonable point, KBA. Most people who do post, exclaiming they have powers, in fact do not. In your thought process , it is truly not comprehendable, I believe, and possibly even folly to the degree of amusement. I could say I do have powers or abilities, does that make it true? No. Well for one, I do, but I really don't have to prove they exist or gain attention to them, as it is a waste of time. Say what you want, you all are entitled to your skeptical opinions.

Edited by Drayno

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 3

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.