Join the Unexplained Mysteries community today! It's free and setting up an account only takes a moment.
- Sign In or Create Account -
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 5
ali smack

should sex offenders be chemically castrated?

   18 members have voted

  1. 1. should sex offenders be chemically castrated

    • yes. if they are proven
      10
    • no. They shouldn't be.
      4
    • Sometimes.
      3
    • Not bothered either way
      1

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

42 posts in this topic

I am not sure if I have put this in the right or wrong section of this site but wondered, do you believe sex offenders ( Rapists, child molesters, zoophiles, )

should be chemically castrated to prevent them for committing there horrendous crimes again, or not?

I think they should be. But only if it is proven that they are guilty. I think it would help to prevent them hurting anyone else, if these dreadful characters are ever let out of prison again.

But I am interested on hearing people's views on this.I am also interested if anyone has any evidence which disproves my belief that chemical castration is a good idea.

I am also interested in what people's views of how sex offenders, especially and mostly repeat sex offenders punishments should be.

I think they should be given strict jail terms. In some cases. I don't even think they should be let out. I don't believe in killing or torturing them.

Because as much as I can't stand these animals. I don't really see the point in dragging yourself down to there level. Furthermore it isn't in my opinion going to help victims of sexual abuse, rape etc. But would like to hear people's views who believe this to be a good idea.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Does chemically castrating a male sex offender stop him from ever committing a sex related crime? What do we do with women sex offenders?

I think they should all be put to death if proven guilty.

4 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If the rape is against a child then the death penalty needs to apply. Other then that we need to define Rape a little better as theres date rape, I said no rape the next day...I mean theres some ridiculous cases out there. Young teenagers getting accused of it because of a few days age difference then what the laws are. So yeah clarify that then Ill tell what I think.

Serial adult rapists. The death penalty. So the option I would choose was not provided.

Edited by AsteroidX
4 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Time and time again... rape is about control, not sex for the most part. A chemically castrated person can still rape someone with with an object or their hands. Also, a chemically castrated male can actually counteract the drugs with one of many testosterone boosting meds on the market.

Violent or repeat sexual offenders should be removed from the world.

Edited by Purplos
3 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

.I am also interested if anyone has any evidence which disproves my belief that chemical castration is a good idea.

I am also interested in what people's views of how sex offenders, especially and mostly repeat sex offenders punishments should be.

I think they should be given strict jail terms. In some cases. I don't even think they should be let out. I don't believe in killing or torturing them.

previous evidence shows chemicals doesnt always work or sometimes becomes ineffective.

i recall reading the news and case where the defense lawyer got a doctor

to mention to judge 100 percent a chemical drug would work,

only problem once the offender got out he didnt take his medicine and he committed more terrible offensives.

i can imagine the horror and outrage of those families who found out the system failed and mad at the defensive lawyer for not mentioning conditions where it was prone to fail.

clearly him not taking medicine affects how it would affect him,

also if someone got a blood transfusion for some reason,accident,disease,etc, it would probably affect the effectiveness of the medicine..

What do we do with women sex offenders?

I think they should all be put to death if proven guilty.

well if they are sentence to jail, perhaps hook them up with the male sex offenders, perhaps that will ease their sexual frustations lol jk - but who knows they may like that idea

Edited by samspade

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Think of it from a different perspective.....

Imagine you where convited of being a sex offender, but you where really innocent? And thye did this to you? What would your opinion be then? Because people are sometimes convited wrongly. It happens more than you know.

Civilisations are judged by how they treat their animals and their prisoners.....

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with Hasina that if there proven guilty they should just be put to death, No torture needed

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Unfortunately rape is not confined to any one country. Many if not all are experience this scourge on an alarming level.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Think of it from a different perspective.....

Imagine you where convited of being a sex offender, but you where really innocent? And thye did this to you? What would your opinion be then? Because people are sometimes convited wrongly. It happens more than you know.

Civilisations are judged by how they treat their animals and their prisoners.....

The system fails all the time but think about if someone raped someone you know and got out of prison with no consequances whatsoever after there jail sentence. Thats why pedophiles are usually killed in most prisons by the other inmates.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The system fails all the time but think about if someone raped someone you know and got out of prison with no consequances whatsoever after there jail sentence. Thats why pedophiles are usually killed in most prisons by the other inmates.

Yes I know that, but imagine if someone i knew was falsley convicted and sentenced to death.....

To truly understand the situation and consequences you have to view all perspectives.

People lie, I've heard a woman cry rape before with one of my friends. Luckily he never got cconvicted cause of witnesses. But she lied for revenge, it's a very dangerous card woman can use and some nutjob woman will use it.

Same with girls or boys aorund 14/15. They have used molestation to get revenge, heard some right horrible stories about people doing that.

Fact is, innocent people could be killed byt he system, or tortured etc. Once that starts happening, say goodbye to any freedom we have left.

Edited by Coffey
1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In my state we have a man that raped 2 women and killed them in the 1990's. He is due to be released this spring. Justice failed and the death penalty should have been carried out. Hopefully it will be post prison before he kills again.

Edited by AsteroidX
2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Does chemically castrating a male sex offender stop him from ever committing a sex related crime? What do we do with women sex offenders?

I think they should all be put to death if proven guilty.

I agree with this.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you catch someone raping a child yes cut them out or cut it off. Women caught sexually abusing kids should have their ovaries and uterus removed so there is no chance of them having a kid to abuse. I have zero tolerance for pedophiles. I think you should go to jail for having child pornography.

However sometimes women lie about being raped when the parents finds out like when they end up pregnant or to get back at the boyfriend. So I would make very sure we are dealing with a real rapist before we start neutering men and women or putting them to death.

2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Does chemically castrating a male sex offender stop him from ever committing a sex related crime? What do we do with women sex offenders?

I think they should all be put to death if proven guilty.

I use to think that rapist should be executed as well. But then I realized that rapist would have nothing to lose, but all to gain by also killing their victims. Murder wouldn’t increase the consequences it can only inflate the chances of evading execution. The death penalty for rape only encourages the crime to escalate. Although rape is a horrific form of abuse, punishing murder more severely tends to deter rapist from also killing their victims. So by giving rape the death penalty, the rapist loses nothing, but might gain by also committing murder.

Don’t get me wrong I think rapist should die too, but I know that will only cause the crime to escalate. So I would settle for life in prison for rapist and not the outrageously short time they get now.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
So I would settle for life in prison for rapist and not the outrageously short time they get now.

Give them there own prison itleast. There not popular amongst the common thieves and murderers and your old pot growing community. Those criminals that live by a criminal code think rapists need to die as well. Put them in general population is a stab at the common criminal. Just kill em. Many of them do murder there victims and the number of victims each rapist has is usually not reflected in there criminal profile.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Does chemically castrating a male sex offender stop him from ever committing a sex related crime? What do we do with women sex offenders?

I think they should all be put to death if proven guilty.

Not deffending the act but rape is not murder so an eye for an eye does not balance out in the balance of law. The death penalty hasn`t stopped murder 1.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Before anyone goes to far.....

I know of 2 people that are registered " sex offenders ". They are labeled " sex offenders " where they live. They can not find jobs, have trouble renting, etc...

Why are they sex offenders?

One was 18 and had a 16 year old girl friend, and yes, they had sex. The parents were not happy......He is now a registered sex offender.

The other was 20, had a few dates ( more like booty calls ) with a girl who was maddly in love with him. She said she was 19, and she looked it. She even had ID showing this...When she ended up pregnant, the truth came out...Another 16 year old.....Now he is a registered sex offender.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Any rapists or pedophiles reading? Repent! Go get help immediately! It is an internal grief you have against your own self or other deep rooted emotional qualms that has taken control of you. You have added to your own shame making it worste for you. Some say there is no hope for you? Is that true? Repent! Take control of your own life and quit hurting other people. Get the help you need.

I also consider this a form of rape:

A man (in most cases) telling a woman he loves her and that he wants to marry her just so he can sleep with her and then bail out. These lies, emotional and physical penetration are a violation and assault on a womans body.

Edited by SpiritWriter

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Give them there own prison itleast. There not popular amongst the common thieves and murderers and your old pot growing community. Those criminals that live by a criminal code think rapists need to die as well. Put them in general population is a stab at the common criminal. Just kill em. Many of them do murder there victims and the number of victims each rapist has is usually not reflected in there criminal profile.

I`m for a prison system that of Escape from New York.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Before anyone goes to far.....

I know of 2 people that are registered " sex offenders ". They are labeled " sex offenders " where they live. They can not find jobs, have trouble renting, etc...

Why are they sex offenders?

One was 18 and had a 16 year old girl friend, and yes, they had sex. The parents were not happy......He is now a registered sex offender.

The other was 20, had a few dates ( more like booty calls ) with a girl who was maddly in love with him. She said she was 19, and she looked it. She even had ID showing this...When she ended up pregnant, the truth came out...Another 16 year old.....Now he is a registered sex offender.

Very true and sometimes all it takes is pointing a finger. Once the claim is made the guy has very little to fall back on in his deffence.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Before anyone goes to far.....

I know of 2 people that are registered " sex offenders ". They are labeled " sex offenders " where they live. They can not find jobs, have trouble renting, etc...

Why are they sex offenders?

One was 18 and had a 16 year old girl friend, and yes, they had sex. The parents were not happy......He is now a registered sex offender.

The other was 20, had a few dates ( more like booty calls ) with a girl who was maddly in love with him. She said she was 19, and she looked it. She even had ID showing this...When she ended up pregnant, the truth came out...Another 16 year old.....Now he is a registered sex offender.

Very true and sometimes all it takes is pointing a finger. Once the claim is made the guy has very little to fall back on in his deffence.

I agree and pointed that out at the beginning of this thread. We have like so many other things put up a huger smokescreen in what may be considered a petty violation or not a crime at all and a serial rapist/child molester and lumped them into the same stigma. This is completely unfair TBH. But that being said a child has the right to grow up safe and taking that away is worse then murder in most cases.

Edited by AsteroidX

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not deffending the act but rape is not murder so an eye for an eye does not balance out in the balance of law. The death penalty hasn`t stopped murder 1.

I'm not in it for an 'eye for an eye' nor as a deterrent for future rapists, this is obviously a person who can't function in society, a person who can't control sexual urges or violent urges. Stealing is one thing, murder and rape are crimes against a person's a body, completely different then stealing someone's car or ruining their property. Rapists and murderers destroy people, simple.

6 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree and pointed that out at the beginning of this thread. We have like so many other things put up a huger smokescreen in what may be considered a petty violation or not a crime at all and a serial rapist/child molester and lumped them into the same stigma. This is completely unfair TBH. But that being said a child has the right to grow up safe and taking that away is worse then murder in most cases.

Sorry about that, I meant to quote yours, and add my two examples.....Long day I guess....I read yours, and came back later to post....My bad.

Edited by Sakari
1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not in it for an 'eye for an eye' nor as a deterrent for future rapists, this is obviously a person who can't function in society, a person who can't control sexual urges or violent urges. Stealing is one thing, murder and rape are crimes against a person's a body, completely different then stealing someone's car or ruining their property. Rapists and murderers destroy people, simple.

I agree but I will not be a part of any type of murder. Life in prison.

2 people like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree but I will not be a part of any type of murder. Life in prison.

Where resources can be wasted on them to keep them alive. I'd put then to work at the very least. Good, back breaking work with no pay. Doubt that, they'd probably just be locked up for 23 hours a day, then walked for an hour.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 5

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.