Monday, January 23, 2017
Contact us    |    Advertise    |   Help   RSS icon Twitter icon Facebook icon
    Home  ·  News  ·  Forum  ·  Stories  ·  Image Gallery  ·  Columns  ·  Encyclopedia  ·  Videos
Find: in

Alien bacteria turns out to be iron deposits


Posted on Monday, 21 March, 2011 | Comment icon 97 comments | News tip by: Kali74


Image credit: NASA

 
What was thought to be fossilised bacteria in a meteorite has turned out to be something more mundane.

The find echoes the alleged discovery of fossilised micro-organisms in a Martian meteorite that turned out not to be. "'It was a good lesson in trusting your data over what you’d been told you should find," said Professor Alison Marshall who was part of the team that re-examined the rock. "At every step of the way, we would do an experiment expecting to find one result and find the complete opposite instead."

"It was a discovery that scientists proclaimed was the oldest evidence of life on our planet."

  View: Full article |  Source: Daily Mail

  Discuss: View comments (97)

   


 
Recent comments on this story
Comment icon #88 Posted by Kali74 on 8 March, 2011, 16:46
Next NASA will say the only position he ever held was a janitor and that the bio on the NASA site was a typo.
Comment icon #89 Posted by DONTEATUS on 9 March, 2011, 4:13
Next NASA will say the only position he ever held was a janitor and that the bio on the NASA site was a typo. I`ll stand behind this man If He can make that worm do a trick! But then again there are lots of brilliant men and women that have no stinkin phd`s! Can anyone say otherwise?
Comment icon #90 Posted by lost_shaman on 9 March, 2011, 5:35
I`ll stand behind this man If He can make that worm do a trick! But then again there are lots of brilliant men and women that have no stinkin phd`s! Can anyone say otherwise? Clearly 'worms' can do some serious 'tricks'. The question is do they need a 'Planet' like the young Earth or does a Comet or pre-cometary matter suffice? If both or just the latter then the Comet's are older. The heavy elements we find on Earth are certainly billions of years older than the solar system itself. The Organic matter must also be very old considering we see it present throughout the Universe.
Comment icon #91 Posted by Paxus on 9 March, 2011, 6:40
Well I think it's exciting! If we can happen upon bacteria from 'off-world' the implication is there that life maybe well be very frequent in the universe.
Comment icon #92 Posted by Karlis on 20 March, 2011, 12:46
Dr. Richard B. Hoover cracked open a CI1 meteorite a carbonaceous chondrite which is one of only nine believed to have ever been found on earth and discovered fossils he claims are of bacteria not found on earth. His research is published in this months (March, 2011) edition of the Journal of Cosmolgy. The journal has invited 100 experts and has issued a general invitation to over 5000 in the scientific community to review the paper. foxnews.com (I know fox news ) It's a really interesting article, scientists are very hesitant to get excited about it, which is understandable we've had similar ... [More]
Comment icon #93 Posted by ShadowSot on 20 March, 2011, 13:10
Whoops! Scientists left red-faced as oldest 'evidence of life' turns out to be iron deposits. Not scientists, technically Dr. Hoover is an engineer. We've already gone through the evidence as related to his research, the faultiness of it and the poor quality of the journal he published in. Edit: Wait, the article doesn't bear much relation to this thread.
Comment icon #94 Posted by Kali74 on 20 March, 2011, 16:09
Not scientists, technically Dr. Hoover is an engineer. We've already gone through the evidence as related to his research, the faultiness of it and the poor quality of the journal he published in. Edit: Wait, the article doesn't bear much relation to this thread. Hey there, I'm still not sure I've seen good support of the claim in faultiness of this research or poor quality of the journal. I realize the journal is a supporter of panspermia therefor bias may come into play but what else is there? Is there something that I have missed? Thanks Edit to add: Also I found it interesting that NASA, l... [More]
Comment icon #95 Posted by ShadowSot on 20 March, 2011, 16:58
Hey there, I'm still not sure I've seen good support of the claim in faultiness of this research or poor quality of the journal. I realize the journal is a supporter of panspermia therefor bias may come into play but what else is there? Is there something that I have missed? Thanks I'd recommend reading the reports I posted. Chiefly, there's a couple of main critiques: The extreme likelihood, even if there is evidence of bacteria, of contamination. Second, the scale we're looking at is much above the level of bacteria, and is instead looking at a level where things like tin whiskers are common... [More]
Comment icon #96 Posted by Kali74 on 20 March, 2011, 17:08
I'd recommend reading the reports I posted. Chiefly, there's a couple of main critiques: The extreme likelihood, even if there is evidence of bacteria, of contamination. Second, the scale we're looking at is much above the level of bacteria, and is instead looking at a level where things like tin whiskers are common. Third, the journal is not under attack because of it's support of panspermia, a theory that still gets tossed around in scientific discourse fairly often, but instead that the journal is the singular work of it's editor, with very poor quality controls for their articles, and outr... [More]
Comment icon #97 Posted by 27vet on 21 March, 2011, 11:47
Maybe they were bionic bacteria?


Please Login or Register to post a comment.


  On the forums
Forum posts:
Forum topics:
Members:

5859159
264660
165164

 
New clue emerges in DB Cooper hijacking case
1-22-2017
An independent investigation in to the long-running mystery has managed to dig up an important new clue.
Did humans wipe out Australia's megafauna ?
1-22-2017
A new study has cast doubt on the idea that climate change wiped out most of Australia's huge beasts.
Some of us are able to 'hear' flashes of light
1-21-2017
Scientists have identified a form of synaesthesia that may affect more than one fifth of the population.
Fresh doubts cast on Tunguska impact theory
1-21-2017
Russian scientists have found evidence to suggest that the impact crater may predate the event itself.
Other news in this category
Dark streaks on Venus could be alien microbes
Posted 1-12-2017 | 29 comments
Scientists are keen to launch a mission to Venus to investigate mysterious dark streaks in its clouds....
 
Telescope upgrade to aid hunt for alien life
Posted 1-11-2017 | 1 comment
The Very Large Telescope (VLT) in Chile will soon be seeking out habitable worlds around Alpha Centauri....
 
Scientists are planning to contact aliens
Posted 12-28-2016 | 95 comments
An organization in San Francisco is planning to send messages out to potentially habitable planets....
 
Could alien life thrive on brown dwarf stars?
Posted 12-4-2016 | 10 comments
Extrasolar planets may not be the only place where it is possible to find signs of extraterrestrial life....
 
Erich Von Daniken predicts 'ET will return'
Posted 11-7-2016 | 84 comments
The controversial author of 'Chariots of the Gods' predicts that aliens will return within 20 years....
 
Color flashing stars could be evidence of ET
Posted 10-31-2016 | 9 comments
Two Canadian astronomers have found possible signs that an alien civilization is trying to communicate....
 
Could aliens have wiped themselves out ?
Posted 10-10-2016 | 141 comments
Professor Brian Cox maintains that advanced extraterrestrial civilizations may inevitably self-destruct....
 
Is there extraterrestrial life on Proxima b ?
Posted 10-8-2016 | 15 comments
Scientists believe that a nearby extrasolar planet is 'likely' to be capable of supporting alien life....
 
Stephen Hawking warns against contacting ET
Posted 9-24-2016 | 152 comments
The world-famous physicist believes that contacting intelligent extraterrestrials is probably a bad idea....
 
SETI is investigating 'interesting' signal
Posted 8-30-2016 | 21 comments
Astronomers are attempting to determine the nature of a strange signal picked up by a Russian telescope....
 
'Alien megastructure' star is still a mystery
Posted 8-8-2016 | 280 comments
Astronomers are no closer to explaining the erratic behavior of this perplexing stellar phenomenon....
 

 View: More news in this category
 
Top   |  Home   |   Forum   |   News   |   Image Gallery   |  Columns   |   Encyclopedia   |   Videos   |   Polls
UM-X 10.7 Unexplained-Mysteries.com © 2001-2017
Privacy Policy and Disclaimer   |   Cookies   |   Advertise   |   Contact   |   Help/FAQ