Saturday, May 28, 2016
Contact us    |    Advertise    |   Help   RSS icon Twitter icon Facebook icon
    Home  ·  News  ·  Forum  ·  Stories  ·  Image Gallery  ·  Columns  ·  Encyclopedia  ·  Videos
Find: in

Alien bacteria turns out to be iron deposits

Posted on Monday, 21 March, 2011 | Comment icon 98 comments | News tip by: Kali74

Image credit: NASA

What was thought to be fossilised bacteria in a meteorite has turned out to be something more mundane.

The find echoes the alleged discovery of fossilised micro-organisms in a Martian meteorite that turned out not to be. "'It was a good lesson in trusting your data over what you’d been told you should find," said Professor Alison Marshall who was part of the team that re-examined the rock. "At every step of the way, we would do an experiment expecting to find one result and find the complete opposite instead."

"It was a discovery that scientists proclaimed was the oldest evidence of life on our planet."

  View: Full article |  Source: Daily Mail

  Discuss: View comments (98)


Recent comments on this story
Comment icon #89 Posted by DONTEATUS on 9 March, 2011, 4:13
I`ll stand behind this man If He can make that worm do a trick! But then again there are lots of brilliant men and women that have no stinkin phd`s! Can anyone say otherwise?
Comment icon #90 Posted by lost_shaman on 9 March, 2011, 5:35
Clearly 'worms' can do some serious 'tricks'. The question is do they need a 'Planet' like the young Earth or does a Comet or pre-cometary matter suffice? If both or just the latter then the Comet's are older. The heavy elements we find on Earth are certainly billions of years older than the solar system itself. The Organic matter must also be very old considering we see it present throughout the Universe.
Comment icon #91 Posted by Paxus on 9 March, 2011, 6:40
Well I think it's exciting! If we can happen upon bacteria from 'off-world' the implication is there that life maybe well be very frequent in the universe.
Comment icon #92 Posted by Karlis on 20 March, 2011, 12:46
Whoops! Scientists left red-faced as oldest 'evidence of life' turns out to be iron deposits. It was a discovery that scientists proclaimed was the oldest evidence of life on our planet. But researchers who thought they had found 3.5 billion-year-old bacteria fossils in Australian rock have been left red-faced after U.S geologists debunked their findings. A team from the University of Kansas said the microscopic structures are nothing more than tiny gaps in the rock that are packed with lifeless minerals.
Comment icon #93 Posted by ShadowSot on 20 March, 2011, 13:10
Not scientists, technically Dr. Hoover is an engineer. We've already gone through the evidence as related to his research, the faultiness of it and the poor quality of the journal he published in. Edit: Wait, the article doesn't bear much relation to this thread.
Comment icon #94 Posted by Kali74 on 20 March, 2011, 16:09
Hey there, I'm still not sure I've seen good support of the claim in faultiness of this research or poor quality of the journal. I realize the journal is a supporter of panspermia therefor bias may come into play but what else is there? Is there something that I have missed? Thanks Edit to add: Also I found it interesting that NASA, last week, appointed a "Planetary Protection Officer" who's job it is to ensure that alien microbes do not contaminate earth nor earth microbes contaminate other planets...after firmly dismissing Dr. Hoover's claim.
Comment icon #95 Posted by ShadowSot on 20 March, 2011, 16:58
I'd recommend reading the reports I posted. Chiefly, there's a couple of main critiques: The extreme likelihood, even if there is evidence of bacteria, of contamination. Second, the scale we're looking at is much above the level of bacteria, and is instead looking at a level where things like tin whiskers are common. Third, the journal is not under attack because of it's support of panspermia, a theory that still gets tossed around in scientific discourse fairly often, but instead that the journal is the singular work of it's editor, with very poor quality controls for th... [More]
Comment icon #96 Posted by Kali74 on 20 March, 2011, 17:08
Thanks for the clarification, sometimes thing just need to be said a certain way for light to dawn lol.
Comment icon #97 Posted by 27vet on 21 March, 2011, 11:47
Maybe they were bionic bacteria?

Please Login or Register to post a comment.

  On the forums
Dr Heimlich performs the Heimlich manoeuver
The man who invented the anti-choking technique has for the first time used it himself to save someone.
Government study finds cellphone-cancer link
The findings suggest that exposure to cellphone radiation may cause brain and heart cancers in rats.
Giant squid may grow larger than a school bus
A new study has suggested that giant squid may actually grow to be much larger than previously believed.
Aristotle's lost tomb has finally been found
The long-sought final resting place of the Greek philosopher has been unearthed at a site in Macedonia.
Other news in this category
Are there trillions of alien civilizations ?
Posted 5-22-2016 | 76 comments
A new study has suggested that the universe is likely to be teeming with extraterrestrial life forms....
SETI is seeking ET around red dwarf stars
Posted 4-5-2016 | 25 comments
The SETI Institute is aiming to find evidence of aliens in a place where nobody had thought to look....
Can we mask the Earth from hostile aliens ?
Posted 4-2-2016 | 49 comments
A new study has suggested that it may be possible to stop alien civilizations from discovering us....
Obama: 'no direct contact with aliens yet'
Posted 2-14-2016 | 87 comments
The US President commented on extraterrestrial contact during a television interview with a six-year-old....
Mars 'cauliflower' may hint at microbial life
Posted 2-2-2016 | 39 comments
Mysterious silica formations photographed in a Martian crater could represent evidence of alien life....
Could alien life have already gone extinct ?
Posted 1-21-2016 | 67 comments
Even if we do find a habitable planet, could its indigenous life forms have already died out long ago ?...
Comets can't explain 'alien structure' star
Posted 1-17-2016 | 244 comments
An astronomical anomaly thought by some to be an 'alien megastructure' has continued to defy explanation....
Was 'Wow!' alien signal triggered by comets ?
Posted 1-16-2016 | 23 comments
The famous 'Wow!' signal picked up in 1977 could turn out to have a rather mundane explanation....
NASA head comments on finding alien life
Posted 12-7-2015 | 28 comments
Charles Bolden has commented on what would happen if NASA encountered an extraterrestrial life form....
Was British policeman abducted by aliens ?
Posted 11-26-2015 | 34 comments
Former police officer Alan Godfry had a close encounter with a UFO while on patrol back in November 1980....
'Alien structure' found around distant star?
Posted 10-14-2015 | 244 comments
Astronomers have been left puzzled by a star that appears to have an unexplained mass orbiting around it....

 View: More news in this category
Top   |  Home   |   Forum   |   News   |   Image Gallery   |  Columns   |   Encyclopedia   |   Videos   |   Polls
UM-X 10.7 © 2001-2015
Privacy Policy and Disclaimer   |   Cookies   |   Advertise   |   Contact   |   Help/FAQ