Sunday, July 23, 2017
Contact us    |    Advertise    |   Help   RSS icon Twitter icon Facebook icon
    Home  ·  News  ·  Forum  ·  Stories  ·  Image Gallery  ·  Columns  ·  Encyclopedia  ·  Videos
Find: in
This news story is archived which means that, while it is still available to view, the information contained within may be outdated and the original source site/link may no longer be viewable.

For the most recent stories, please visit either the site's home page or main news section.

How do we expand the search for alien life ?

Posted on Monday, 28 May, 2012 | Comment icon 24 comments | News tip by: Still Waters


Image credit: NASA

 
In a recent interview cosmologist Charley Lineweaver outlined his views on our efforts to find ET.

Lineweaver argues that searching for life like that found on Earth is the wrong way to go about things. "Imagine if some historian wanted to know about the origin of France," he said. "Most French people now have passports. So imagine the historian went out on an archaeological dig to look for French passports. That would be ridiculous."

The correct way forward, he contends, is to widen the definition of 'life' because we simply don't know what type of living organisms could be out there. "You could say all life today has DNA, but in the past, who knows?" he said.

"What's wrong with the definition of "life"? Almost everything."

  View: Full article

 Source: New Scientist


  Discuss: View comments (24)

   


 
Recent comments on this story
Comment icon #15 Posted by nephilim12 on 30 May, 2012, 6:12
A very healthy discourse and exchange of ideas. I'm loving it Yep, if they wanted to take over, they'd have done it long ago. But as some say, why ET ? Why any particular interest in our world ? Suppose all the UFOs depicted were to have been of earthly origin all along ? Now this is scarier. It means there is another alternative race ( caucasoid, mongoloid or negroid in appearance) having access to superior flight capabilities implying more advanced technology, mingling with us freely while maintaining that distinctive distance and secrecy between themselves. Ahhhh forget it, just wild specul... [More]
Comment icon #16 Posted by psyche101 on 30 May, 2012, 8:14
I am thinking this bloke is after his 15 minutes. I am a bit shocked that a level headed Aussie would take such a new age approach. He is calling hurricanes and stars alive, a star is a chemical reaction isn't it? And a hurricane is a temperature inversion isn't it? And I cannot see that his approach will lead to any discovery, just a great deal of renaming. He just seems to want to get his name into a book, I am a bit bewildered as to what is being accomplished here? What is this all about? Many biologists define life as anything that undergoes Darwinian evolution. We pretend that makes sense... [More]
Comment icon #17 Posted by lost_shaman on 30 May, 2012, 8:26
A Unit? I think this guy is a unit. A gene is a stretch of DNA isn't it? And Isn't DNA something of a Darwinian marker? Gaia? WTF is he on about? Maybe his genius is beyond me, hopefully someone can help me out here, LOL I am looking at you Badeskov my saviour in science! Am I looking at this the wrong way mate? Hey psyche, Couldn't agree more. Darwin's theory of evolution in a nutshell is meant to explain the rise of Species, its absolutely not a TEST for what is or isn't LIFE.
Comment icon #18 Posted by hooko22 on 30 May, 2012, 10:07
Hey psyche, Couldn't agree more. Darwin's theory of evolution in a nutshell is meant to explain the rise of Species, its absolutely not a TEST for what is or isn't LIFE. Nasa did say themselves that life can evolve quite differently. Oh and I think darwin is tied to life as it appears on this planet, but who knows maybe his theory will be sound elsewhere. Can't wait for the day when we might test that! That is if we will be alive!
Comment icon #19 Posted by lost_shaman on 30 May, 2012, 11:36
Nasa did say themselves that life can evolve quite differently. Hey hooko22, I don't mean to be rude when I ask where did NASA say that? I thought it was obvious that all Species have 'evolved' differently than others. Oh and I think darwin is tied to life as it appears on this planet, but who knows maybe his theory will be sound elsewhere. Can't wait for the day when we might test that! That is if we will be alive! Why would it be different?
Comment icon #20 Posted by hooko22 on 30 May, 2012, 11:45
Hey hooko22, I don't mean to be rude when I ask where did NASA say that? I thought it was obvious that all Species have 'evolved' differently than others. Why would it be different? No no I think I might not have voiced it well enough. I meant they did some sort of press release on the fact that life could be made out of some material composition or something like that, that scientists previously had thought was impossible. Please forgive me I'm not exactly a science nerd! Oh and as to why would it be different. Who knows maybe the way of life over there might be all together completely differ... [More]
Comment icon #21 Posted by TheMcGuffin on 30 May, 2012, 14:37
Oh and as to why would it be different. Who knows maybe the way of life over there might be all together completely different, I'm merely voicing my contemplation. Not stating something I think is fact, like I say no one knows and who knows! i suspect that life out there could very well be completely different from anything on earth, or anything we could even imagine as life. I don't see any reason why it would even have to look like us, have cells, DNA or anything like that. It could even be artificial life of some kind.
Comment icon #22 Posted by psyche101 on 31 May, 2012, 0:54
Hey psyche, Couldn't agree more. Darwin's theory of evolution in a nutshell is meant to explain the rise of Species, its absolutely not a TEST for what is or isn't LIFE. Gidday Mate! Been far too long since I have seen you posting I hope all is well with you. This guy seems to be a little all over the place, he is saying Hurricane's should be classified as alive. I am just not understanding what he thinks this will accomplish. Cheers.
Comment icon #23 Posted by psyche101 on 31 May, 2012, 0:55
Nasa did say themselves that life can evolve quite differently. Oh and I think darwin is tied to life as it appears on this planet, but who knows maybe his theory will be sound elsewhere. Can't wait for the day when we might test that! That is if we will be alive! I think with regards to life, Intelligent life and life are quite different in many ways, which would you be referring to? With regards to non-intelligent life, I woud agree, bit with regards to intelligent life, I think there are certain parameters that need to be met.
Comment icon #24 Posted by Occams Razor on 22 September, 2012, 7:32
I saw this chap on an ABC program called 'Big Ideas' here in Australia, he was on a panel with Carol Oliver from SETI and some other chap who's name escapes me. I found it hard to believe this panel was made up of real world-class experts, there seemed to be a lot of nonsense with a few interesting tid-bits thrown in. I thought their ideas regarding intelligent extraterrestrial life were extremely naive. They scoffed at the possibility that any visiting extraterrestrials would be hostile, asking what could they possibly want from us? On the grounds that anything they could get from the Earth t... [More]


Please Login or Register to post a comment.


  On the forums
Forum posts:
Forum topics:
Members:

5948210
256105
168269

 
Robot ventures inside Fukushima reactor 3
7-23-2017
Scientists in Japan have identified what could be fuel debris within the devastated nuclear reactor.
Public names locomotive 'Trainy McTrainface'
7-23-2017
A recent poll in Sweden has shown, once again, why asking the public to name anything is a bad idea.
Did sea creatures push US in to Vietnam War ?
7-22-2017
Back in 1964, the Gulf of Tonkin incident resulted in a renewed commitment to war with Vietnam.
Scientist has 'solved' the Bermuda Triangle
7-22-2017
Dr Karl Kruszelnicki maintains that the answer to the mystery lies in little more than basic human error.
Other news in this category
SETI develops new alien-hunting instrument
Posted 7-18-2017 | 10 comments
Scientists have come up with a way to scan the skies for pulses of light from an alien civilization....
 
NASA denies alien life announcement claim
Posted 6-27-2017 | 54 comments
NASA has played down the suggestion that it is on the verge of announcing the discovery of alien life....
 
Anonymous: 'NASA to announce alien life'
Posted 6-26-2017 | 54 comments
The hacktivist group has suggested that NASA may be on the verge of making a very important announcement....
 
Has the 'Wow!' signal finally been solved ?
Posted 6-11-2017 | 25 comments
Scientists now believe that the mysterious 1977 space signal had actually come from a passing comet....
 
Bigelow: 'aliens are right under our noses'
Posted 5-30-2017 | 89 comments
Aerospace entrepreneur and NASA partner Robert Bigelow believes that ET is already here on Earth....
 
'Alien megastructure' star is dimming again
Posted 5-20-2017 | 338 comments
The mysterious star has been puzzling astronomers for years due to its erratic, inexplicable behavior....
 
Super Earth is 'best chance for finding life'
Posted 4-19-2017 | 10 comments
A large terrestrial planet located 40 light years away could be the perfect place to search for ET....
 
Ireland alien abduction case still intrigues
Posted 4-15-2017 | 6 comments
Numerous sightings of strange objects in the skies above County Derry have been reported over the years....
 
Enceladus could support alien life, says NASA
Posted 4-13-2017 | 15 comments
The space agency has discovered all the crucial ingredients for life in the oceans of Saturn's icy moon....
 
NASA hints at new 'ocean worlds' discovery
Posted 4-11-2017 | 15 comments
The space agency will be holding a press briefing on Thursday about 'the search for life beyond Earth'....
 
Could a lottery help fund the search for ET ?
Posted 4-8-2017 | 29 comments
A new paper has suggested using a lottery and savings bond as a way to fund the search for alien life....
 

 View: More news in this category
 
Top   |  Home   |   Forum   |   News   |   Image Gallery   |  Columns   |   Encyclopedia   |   Videos   |   Polls
UM-X 10.7 Unexplained-Mysteries.com 2001-2017
Privacy Policy and Disclaimer   |   Cookies   |   Advertise   |   Contact   |   Help/FAQ