Wednesday, July 27, 2016
Contact us    |    Advertise    |   Help   RSS icon Twitter icon Facebook icon
    Home  ·  News  ·  Forum  ·  Stories  ·  Image Gallery  ·  Columns  ·  Encyclopedia  ·  Videos
Find: in

Is it ethical to bring back extinct species ?


Posted on Tuesday, 9 April, 2013 | Comment icon 69 comments | News tip by: Render


Image credit: Hobart Zoo

 
Once a species has gone extinct, is it ethically sound to use science to bring it back from oblivion ?

One of the biggest questions raised by the movie blockbuster "Jurassic Park" was that even if we did have the capability to bring extinct species back to life, the question remains whether or not we actually should. With advances in science leading us ever closer to the capacity to resurrect an extinct species, scientists have found themselves pondering the ethical considerations of such an act in addition to the practical possibilities.

One particularly controversial area is in the resurrection of an extinct species of human such as the Neanderthals. If we were able to produce a living Neanderthal, would that person be doomed to a life of scientific experimentation and observation ? Would human rights still apply ?

"Twenty years after the release of Jurassic Park, the dream of bringing back the dinosaurs remains science fiction."

  View: Full article |  Source: Phys.org

  Discuss: View comments (69)

   


 
Recent comments on this story
Comment icon #60 Posted by Myles on 13 April, 2013, 14:36
Unlike an asteroid, humans have the ability to think. It's just unfortunate that a lot of them don't. I agree with that. But it really shouldn't be a factor in bring an animal back.
Comment icon #61 Posted by Hawkin on 13 April, 2013, 20:53
I agree with that. But it really shouldn't be a factor in bring an animal back. I will agree that we are a part of nature since we share this planet with other species. I just feel that since we have the intellect to control our destiny and the destiny of other species, we should repair what we broke.
Comment icon #62 Posted by DieChecker on 14 April, 2013, 2:08
If man had a hand in killing off a species then man should bring it back. It's not the same where dinos became extinct by nature. if humans extinct the creature, then we should be abligated to bring their spicies back as we extincted it What if the species that went extint only lived in one lake, or in one small 1 acre field, and fed off only one kind of plant or flower? Are we going to revive a species that was already 99% extinct? What if the plant or the lake that they depended on no longer exists? That is why I think bring back a species into the world is only a good idea if there is somew... [More]
Comment icon #63 Posted by Hawkin on 14 April, 2013, 3:20
What if the species that went extint only lived in one lake, or in one small 1 acre field, and fed off only one kind of plant or flower? Are we going to revive a species that was already 99% extinct? What if the plant or the lake that they depended on no longer exists? That is why I think bring back a species into the world is only a good idea if there is somewhere for them to live and thrive. Otherwise your good intentions are just creating a second extinction. When I was born, the Earth's population was half of what it is now. I have a feeling that nature will take care of that.
Comment icon #64 Posted by DieChecker on 14 April, 2013, 19:35
When I was born, the Earth's population was half of what it is now. I have a feeling that nature will take care of that. Maybe... Maybe not. Mother Nature is just another god entity that is claimed to have power, but I'd bet she can fade away just as Odin, Jupiter and Zeus have passed away. When humans Create their own environments, we step outside of nature. That is not to say that some plague might not wipe out large numbers of humans, but chiefly what wipes out humans is Other Humans!!
Comment icon #65 Posted by Myles on 16 April, 2013, 22:47
I can certainly understand the arguement that we should only bring back animals who could survive and be prosperous in the wild. Dodo's, Thylacine, passenger pigeon and different deer species would make sense. But I really want both a mastodon and a mammoth to be revived.
Comment icon #66 Posted by markdohle on 19 April, 2013, 14:08
No matter if it is moral to bring back extinct spieces or not... we will do it if we can.
Comment icon #67 Posted by Heaven Is A Halfpipe on 20 April, 2013, 0:50
No it isn't ethical. AKA we'll do it any way until it screws up, then continue to do it. Perhaps if we put a little more effort into looking after the wildlife and animals we already have in the first place then nothing else would be driven to extinction.
Comment icon #68 Posted by Zerocoder on 20 April, 2013, 21:00
No it isn't ethical. AKA we'll do it any way until it screws up, then continue to do it. Perhaps if we put a little more effort into looking after the wildlife and animals we already have in the first place then nothing else would be driven to extinction. most people in the world does not care about the consequenses of their actions, i did not either but now i think twice before i do something No matter if it is moral to bring back extinct spieces or not... we will do it if we can. Agreed, their called animals for a reason and the reason is their not sentient beings that can think and act, the... [More]
Comment icon #69 Posted by DieChecker on 22 April, 2013, 19:20
No it isn't ethical. AKA we'll do it any way until it screws up, then continue to do it. Perhaps if we put a little more effort into looking after the wildlife and animals we already have in the first place then nothing else would be driven to extinction. Compared to most of the world, the US is Mega-Uber-Green. India (overpopulation, disease, industry), China (Farming Nitrites, Industial pollutions), Brazil (Deforestation), Central Africa (burning anything they can find, eating anything they can find, overgrazing, desertification).... are all much worse then the US ecologically. There is more... [More]


Please Login or Register to post a comment.


  On the forums
Forum posts:
Forum topics:
Members:

5731895
260022
161449

 
Philae mission officially comes to a close
7-27-2016
After a year without communication, scientists have finally said goodbye to Philae for the last time.
This year's global warming is off the charts
7-27-2016
Climate scientists have expressed concern over the record-breaking temperatures seen so far this year.
White whale Migaloo spotted near Queensland
7-27-2016
Migaloo, one of only four known white humpbacks in existence, has surfaced once again near Australia.
Mystery surrounds missing craters on Ceres
7-26-2016
Scientists have been attempting to determine why the dwarf planet Ceres has no large craters at all.
Other news in this category
This year's global warming is off the charts
Posted 7-27-2016 | 3 comments
Climate scientists have expressed concern over the record-breaking temperatures seen so far this year....
 
Solar Impulse completes historic global trip
Posted 7-26-2016 | 5 comments
The aircraft, which is powered entirely by the sun, has succeeded in flying around the entire world....
 
New metal is four times tougher than titanium
Posted 7-24-2016 | 16 comments
Scientists have created a brand new type of super-metal by melting together titanium and gold....
 
Defense firm buys out hoverboard company
Posted 7-24-2016 | 5 comments
The jet-powered Flyboard Air hoverboard may soon be seeing use in a range of military applications....
 
Major project fails to detect dark matter
Posted 7-21-2016 | 52 comments
Scientists have shut down their state-of-the-art dark matter detector after it failed to find anything....
 
Meet Graham - a man resistant to car crashes
Posted 7-21-2016 | 17 comments
Road safety authorities have created a model of a human being that has evolved to survive car accidents....
 
Scientists achieve atom-sized data storage
Posted 7-21-2016 | 26 comments
Increasingly sophisticated data storage systems are being built to meet the demands of modern computing....
 
Russian PAK-DA can 'launch nuke from space'
Posted 7-15-2016 | 78 comments
The new strategic bomber, which is currently in development, could be ready for action as early as 2020....
 
Nail-biters may experience fewer allergies
Posted 7-12-2016 | 8 comments
A new study has suggested that children who bite their nails a lot might not develop as many allergies....
 
Mystery still surrounds 1908 Tunguska event
Posted 7-10-2016 | 13 comments
Did an asteroid strike the remote Siberian wilderness over a century ago or did something else happen ?...
 
Bug may invalidate 15 years of brain research
Posted 7-8-2016 | 1 comment
A computer software bug has potentially rendered over a decade's worth of brain studies totally void....
 

 View: More news in this category
 
Top   |  Home   |   Forum   |   News   |   Image Gallery   |  Columns   |   Encyclopedia   |   Videos   |   Polls
UM-X 10.7 Unexplained-Mysteries.com 2001-2015
Privacy Policy and Disclaimer   |   Cookies   |   Advertise   |   Contact   |   Help/FAQ