Jump to content
Join the Unexplained Mysteries community today! It's free and setting up an account only takes a moment.
- Sign In or Create Account -

The Troy Deception


The Troy Deception

Recommended Posts

"The Troy Deception" is a new book by author & historian John Crowe, which documents what is set to become perhaps one of the most significant modern discoveries in ancient history when it goes public next month. John Crowe has uncovered the battlefield of Troy for the first time in modern history & proved his claim beyond reasonable doubt, gaining recognition & support from leading Homeric scholars (including Professor G Nagy & Professor A.M.Snodgrass). For more information & for pre-release copies of the book, please visit the official website http://www.thetroydeception.com

Any question or feedback you may have are very welcome!

TROY-DECEPTION-COVER-197x300.jpg

Author John Crowe uses Homer’s epics about the Trojan War, the Iliad and Odyssey, as the foundation for his research. Composed around 2,700 years ago, these provided the Western world with the foundations of their literature and education. They have had an enormous influence upon western culture. But where is the battlefield of the Trojan War as described in the Iliad? Whether or not Troy existed, the Iliad does exist. And whether or not the Trojan War actually took place, both the battles and the landscape of the battlefield are described in great detail in the Iliad.

Schliemann claimed he found Troy at Hisarlik, and many believed him. More recently others have found Troy near Cambridge in England, in Yugoslavia, and in the Baltic. Yet no-one has managed to find the Homeric Trojan plain. So it is widely believed that it never existed.

John’s approach is different. First, he aims to find the Trojan plain. Once found, it will surely lead us to Homer’s Troy. In Volume 1 he shows, beyond reasonable doubt, that the plain of Troy is now found at Pergamon. It lies in the lower valley of the Bakir Çayi, due east of the island of Lesbos, in a region known to the ancients as Mysia.

It seems a little known fact that Achilles in the Iliad told us that here is exactly where we should expect to find the lands of Troy. And another little known legend tells us that the Achaeans fought in this valley and captured Teuthrania before they went to Troy. So here is the obvious place to start looking for the plain of Troy.

In Volume 2 John will show how the acropolis of Pergamon fits the description of Ilios in the Iliad. It still bears the name which Homer gave to Apollo’s precinct on the highest terrace – Pergamos. The ancient Hittite tablets tell us that Taruisa (Troy) and Wilusa (Ilios) were two separate places, yet there is only one settlement site at Hisarlik. Homer’s descriptions tell us that Troy and Ilios were separate walled cities. Ilios was a ‘holy’ city on the acropolis, and Troy was the lower town on the edge of the plain. We know that Troy had a ‘Dardanian Gate’, which probably opened on to the road which led to Dardania. Close to this gate was a geothermal spring. So we should look for Troy close to the ancient warm spring known today, and to the Romans, as the Asklepion. John explains the Troy deception in more detail.

John’s discoveries add a new and unexpected degree of integrity to Homer’s descriptions of the Trojan landscape. He presents knowledge that has been hidden from the world for over 2,500 years, giving Homeric scholars the opportunity to reappraise the historicity of both the Trojan War and Homer, perhaps the world’s greatest epic poet. John hopes his findings will enhance the credibility of Homer as a witness of ancient history. His studies were inspired by John Lascelles, who first discovered Troy at Bergama and in 2005 wrote ‘Troy: The World Deceived – Homer’s Guide to Pergamum’. The Troy Deception will appeal to all those who are interested in the origins of western culture, and to those who love detective stories.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 12 years later...
 

Why Hisarlik cannot have been Troy.

It has long been known that Hisarlik, unlike Homer’s Ilios, has no natural acropolis. It is much smaller than the Ilios described by Homer. Also the Trojan battlefield below Hisarlik offers a very poor match with Homer’s descriptions of the Trojan plain. Such famous features as the Wall of Herakles and the beautiful hill Kallikolone are absent at Hisarlik. By 1982, soil studies in what was thought of as the plain of Troy showed that, in Trojan times, there was actually a large bay at the mouth of the river Mendere. In Trojan times, some 3,200 years ago, Hisarlik was in reality a coastal fortress. There was no great battlefield here between Troy and the sea, upon which Homer’s heroes fought the Trojan War. If the story is not to be condemned as a fairytale we must try a different approach.

http://thetroydeception.com/supporting-papers/the-troy-deception-explined-for-kldafs-16012014

 

  • Thanks 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted (edited)
On 8/29/2011 at 12:23 AM, The Troy Deception said:

"The Troy Deception" is a new book by author & historian John Crowe, which documents what is set to become perhaps one of the most significant modern discoveries in ancient history when it goes public next month. John Crowe has uncovered the battlefield of Troy for the first time in modern history & proved his claim beyond reasonable doubt, gaining recognition & support from leading Homeric scholars (including Professor G Nagy & Professor A.M.Snodgrass). For more information & for pre-release copies of the book, please visit the official website http://www.thetroydeception.com

Any question or feedback you may have are very welcome!

http://troy.kriskemist.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/TROY-DECEPTION-COVER-197x300.jpg

Author John Crowe uses Homer’s epics about the Trojan War, the Iliad and Odyssey, as the foundation for his research. Composed around 2,700 years ago, these provided the Western world with the foundations of their literature and education. They have had an enormous influence upon western culture. But where is the battlefield of the Trojan War as described in the Iliad? Whether or not Troy existed, the Iliad does exist. And whether or not the Trojan War actually took place, both the battles and the landscape of the battlefield are described in great detail in the Iliad.

Schliemann claimed he found Troy at Hisarlik, and many believed him. More recently others have found Troy near Cambridge in England, in Yugoslavia, and in the Baltic. Yet no-one has managed to find the Homeric Trojan plain. So it is widely believed that it never existed.

John’s approach is different. First, he aims to find the Trojan plain. Once found, it will surely lead us to Homer’s Troy. In Volume 1 he shows, beyond reasonable doubt, that the plain of Troy is now found at Pergamon. It lies in the lower valley of the Bakir Çayi, due east of the island of Lesbos, in a region known to the ancients as Mysia.

It seems a little known fact that Achilles in the Iliad told us that here is exactly where we should expect to find the lands of Troy. And another little known legend tells us that the Achaeans fought in this valley and captured Teuthrania before they went to Troy. So here is the obvious place to start looking for the plain of Troy.

In Volume 2 John will show how the acropolis of Pergamon fits the description of Ilios in the Iliad. It still bears the name which Homer gave to Apollo’s precinct on the highest terrace – Pergamos. The ancient Hittite tablets tell us that Taruisa (Troy) and Wilusa (Ilios) were two separate places, yet there is only one settlement site at Hisarlik. Homer’s descriptions tell us that Troy and Ilios were separate walled cities. Ilios was a ‘holy’ city on the acropolis, and Troy was the lower town on the edge of the plain. We know that Troy had a ‘Dardanian Gate’, which probably opened on to the road which led to Dardania. Close to this gate was a geothermal spring. So we should look for Troy close to the ancient warm spring known today, and to the Romans, as the Asklepion. John explains the Troy deception in more detail.

John’s discoveries add a new and unexpected degree of integrity to Homer’s descriptions of the Trojan landscape. He presents knowledge that has been hidden from the world for over 2,500 years, giving Homeric scholars the opportunity to reappraise the historicity of both the Trojan War and Homer, perhaps the world’s greatest epic poet. John hopes his findings will enhance the credibility of Homer as a witness of ancient history. His studies were inspired by John Lascelles, who first discovered Troy at Bergama and in 2005 wrote ‘Troy: The World Deceived – Homer’s Guide to Pergamum’. The Troy Deception will appeal to all those who are interested in the origins of western culture, and to those who love detective stories.

12 years later…is John even still here…? Pergammon hey?

https://www.amazon.com/Troy-Deception-Finding-Plain/dp/1848765495

Edited by The Puzzler
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, The Puzzler said:

12 years later…is John even still here…? Pergammon hey?

https://www.amazon.com/Troy-Deception-Finding-Plain/dp/1848765495

The guy promoted a/his book, and left.

I don't care.

Apparently no one here has read the book.

Another one on my list to buy and read after I retire.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Abramelin said:

The guy promoted a/his book, and left.

I don't care.

Apparently no one here has read the book.

Another one on my list to buy and read after I retire.

The mention of Pergamon caught my eye, it was one of the great Hellenistic kingdoms. The Attalids had a library excelled only by the one at Alexandria. I’ve never heard it linked to Troy before. Could be interesting, I’ll give it a read.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.