Sunday, February 26, 2017
Contact us    |    Advertise    |   Help   RSS icon Twitter icon Facebook icon
    Home  ·  News  ·  Forum  ·  Stories  ·  Image Gallery  ·  Columns  ·  Encyclopedia  ·  Videos
Find: in

Curiosity fails to find methane on Mars


Posted on Wednesday, 25 September, 2013 | Comment icon 14 comments

Curiosity will continue to take readings to monitor for signs of methane. Image Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech
NASA's Mars rover has been unable to find any significant amount of methane in Mars' atmosphere.
The hunt for methane is important because methane is generally considered to be a possible indicator of the presence of life. Recent observations from telescopes on Earth seemed to suggest that there was methane on Mars, but the readings from Curiosity have defused the excitement somewhat.

"Ninety percent of the methane of Earth's atmosphere originate from microbes," said Canadian Astrology chairman Lyle Whyte. "That's why people got excited about methane in Mars' atmosphere."

The original methane readings had been made by NASA planetary scientist Michael Mumma who had used observations from both the Keck Observatory and the Infrared Telescope Facility in Hawaii. "When we saw the methane plumes, we saw values range from 20 to 60 parts per billion," he said. "Curiosity's upper limit is only 1.4 parts per billion."

What does all this mean for the possibility of finding life on Mars ? While we don't necessarily need to find methane for there to be life on Mars, this latest setback makes it less likely that we will find anything living there. "It's not a definitive sign saying that there is no life on Mars, but it's not a good sign," said Whyte.

Source: Yahoo! News | Comments (14)

Tags: Mars, Curiosity


 
Recent comments on this story
Comment icon #5 Posted by Frank Merton on 20 September, 2013, 6:33
Methane is a biological product; I don't know that anything needs it to live, but I'd like to be so informed if I'm wrong. Yes I would say that the business of living can be conducted without producing methane, just not if you are a cow.
Comment icon #6 Posted by Waspie_Dwarf on 20 September, 2013, 11:00
Well I had thought it was clear in context that I was talking about the presence of methane. Your question, given that you had mentioned both methane and the search for life in the previous sentence, was ambiguous. Methane is a biological product It can be, but it can also be produced by non-biological means such as the oxidation of iron. Even if methane had been detected it would not, therefore, have constituted proof of life. The problem for the scientists now is to account for the discrpency in the findings. Positive results were obtained by Earth based telescopes and the European Mars Expr... [More]
Comment icon #7 Posted by Waspie_Dwarf on 20 September, 2013, 11:53
Is there a limit on how much methane there needs to be to support life? Methane is a biological product; I don't know that anything needs it to live, but I'd like to be so informed if I'm wrong. Frank is quite right, methane is a product of life, an indicator that is is there rather than a requirement. It is not a by-product of all life, so not finding methane is not evidence that Mars is devoid of life. Frank's answer got me wondering if there were bacteria which required methane, and it turns out there are, Methanotrophs: Methanotrophs (sometimes called methanophiles) are prokaryotes that ar... [More]
Comment icon #8 Posted by Big Bad Voodoo on 23 September, 2013, 21:10
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/09/130922222800.htm NASA Curiosity Rover Detects No Methane On Mars
Comment icon #9 Posted by The New Richard Nixon on 23 September, 2013, 22:02
cries
Comment icon #10 Posted by Waspie_Dwarf on 23 September, 2013, 22:39
cries I assume you are crying because of the title that Big Bad Voodoo give his thread (which I merged with the pre-existing thread). He called it "No Life On Mars". I shouldn't worry about that too much. The title was deceptive. Lack of methane excludes only the presence of methane producing bacteria. Many bacteria produce no methane, hence this is not evidence of an absence of life on Mars. What it actually is is a failure to find evidence of a particular type of life on Mars.
Comment icon #11 Posted by WelshRed on 25 September, 2013, 11:27
Frank Merton said "Methane is a biological product" Yes but it can also be a geological product so even finding methane would not confirm anything only enhance the "possibility" of life. I want there to life on Mars as much as anyone trust me but this is a blow for sure. Also the rovers location does not matter, if methane was being produced it "should" be detectable anywhere on the planet as it would be carried on the winds all over the planet (just like mars' notorious dust storms).
Comment icon #12 Posted by Waspie_Dwarf on 25 September, 2013, 12:27
I want there to life on Mars as much as anyone trust me but this is a blow for sure. It's a setback but not a catastrophic one. Not all life produces methane so this does not constitutes proof of the absence of life. What it does do is open a whole new can of worms... why was methane detected previously? As is so often the case space missions like this don't answer questions, but they do help us to know which questions to ask. There will be more than one PhD thesis written as a result of these findings.
Comment icon #13 Posted by Asadora on 25 September, 2013, 13:11
I hope we don't find evidence/proof of any life having ever existed on Mars - because that would mean we are still behind the Great Filter. So, personally I'm hoping to find absolutely nothing.
Comment icon #14 Posted by Waspie_Dwarf on 25 September, 2013, 14:01
I hope we don't find evidence/proof of any life having ever existed on Mars - because that would mean we are still behind the Great Filter. So, personally I'm hoping to find absolutely nothing. Discovering life on Mars would not change anything in relation to the Great Filter hypothesis, not least because it has no evidence to support it anyway. It is just one of many arguments against, or attempting to explain, the Fermi Paradox. If there is truth to the Great Filter hypothesis then we are where we are. The discovery (or not) of life on Mars would change nothing.


Please Login or Register to post a comment.


  On the forums
Forum posts:
Forum topics:
Members:

5851931
251315
165770

 
Desert people evolve to drink poisonous water
2-25-2017
The local people of Chile's Atacama desert have developed the ability to drink water laced with arsenic.
Astronauts could fly around the Moon by 2019
2-25-2017
NASA is considering whether to send a crew on its first integrated Orion, SLS flight around the Moon.
Has the Hadron Collider disproven ghosts ?
2-24-2017
According to Professor Brian Cox, if ghosts existed, CERN's atom smasher should have found them by now.
Boy receives 'biggest ever' antivenom dose
2-24-2017
Matthew Mitchell was rushed to hospital after being bitten by a deadly funnel-web spider in Australia.
Featured book
 
By Guy Lyon Playfair
A look at the story of Peggy Hodgson and her four children who, between 1977 and 1979, were at the center of one of the most terrifying poltergeist cases ever documented.
Featured Videos
Gallery icon 
Crushing cans
Posted 2-25-2017 | 3 comments
Muhammad Rashid from Pakistan crushes 77 cans with his elbow within one minute.
 
Is time real ?
Posted 2-24-2017 | 0 comments
Bill Nye talks about the concept of time and how our subjective perceptions of it can change.
 
Is it possible to re-freeze the Arctic ?
Posted 2-23-2017 | 1 comment
Scientists have proposed a rather unorthodox solution to the problems caused by climate change.
 
Giant horse conch
Posted 2-22-2017 | 1 comment
A huge conch makes light work of a tulip snail which fails to make its escape.
 
Water on the Moon
Posted 2-21-2017 | 7 comments
For a long time scientists thought the Moon was bone dry, but as it turns out - it isn't.
 
 View: More videos
Stories & Experiences
Saved by a stranger
2-7-2017 | Green River Wyoming
 
Spooky sense
2-4-2017 | India
 
Ghost car
2-4-2017 | Chicago, IL, USA
 
Mysterious powder
2-4-2017 | USA, North Carolina
 
Puerto Rico UFO sighting
2-4-2017 | Sabana Grande, Puerto Rico
 
Phantom vehicle
1-6-2017 | Ramer, United States
 
True ghost stories
1-6-2017 | Southern California
 
Floating tiles
1-6-2017 | Chewelah, Washington
 
A haunting in Northern California
12-28-2016 | Northern California
 
Strange creature in South Africa
12-28-2016 | South Africa, Hoedspruit.
 

         More stories | Send us your story
 
Top   |  Home   |   Forum   |   News   |   Image Gallery   |  Columns   |   Encyclopedia   |   Videos   |   Polls
UM-X 10.7 Unexplained-Mysteries.com 2001-2017
Privacy Policy and Disclaimer   |   Cookies   |   Advertise   |   Contact   |   Help/FAQ