The mysterious cosmic interloper has been captured on camera and NASA insists that it really is just a comet.
At a press conference yesterday, NASA revealed new data and images concerning 3I/ATLAS - an object from a distant solar system that has been careening through our own cosmic neighborhood, culminating in a closest approach in early December.
While most scientists remain adamant that the object is a mere comet, others - such as Harvard's Prof Avi Loeb - have raised the possibility that it could be an intelligently controlled extraterrestrial vehicle.
Several anomalies have been pointed out in recent months, resulting in a great deal of debate over its true nature and whether or not it really is a comet as is generally believed.
During the press conference, NASA furthered the notion that 3I/ATLAS is a mere comet by detailing its behavior and by showing some new pictures, including one captured from Mars by the HiRISE camera onboard the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter (see image above).
"It's natural to wonder what it is," said Nicola Fox, associate administrator of NASA's Science Mission Directorate. "We love that the world wondered along with us."
"We were quick to be able to say: Yup, it definitely behaves like a comet."
"We certainly haven't seen any technosignatures or anything from it that would lead us to believe it was anything other than a comet."
Prof Avi Loeb, however, is not convinced.
In a recent blog posting, he argues that NASA should have discussed all of the things that are unusual about 3I/ATLAS instead of insisting that it is a normal comet.
Given that the object is continuing to get closer to us, we should soon be able to capture more detailed, high-resolution images, thus helping to solve its mysteries once and for all.
Whether everyone will be satisfied with those findings, however, remains to be seen.
That, and a billion other feckin' stupid ideas that are impossible to disprove. And Loeb is trained in scientific fields so he can come across as plausible, "I'm only following the data", but he's just another articulate charlatan, best ignored. In My Humble Opinion.
This is exactly how these rumours start. Sensational claims spread faster than real science because they are novel and emotional, so people repeat them without checking. Algorithms amplify engagement, not accuracy, and repetition creates the illusion of truth. Say something vague enough, echo it a few times, and nothing turns into "common knowledge." This is documented in the MIT study published in Science in 2018 by Vosoughi, Roy, and Aral, which showed false information spreads farther, faster, and more widely than true information. https://politics.media.mit.edu/papers/Vosoughi_Science.p... [More]
I can agree with your assessment, Tom, but I happen to enjoy this man, tho I can't say exactly why. It's obvious that he is just trying to get a name for himself.
Well this is weird. I definitely read about it online, it was on a US newspaper website. Can't remember which one. New York Times maybe? Anyway I've searched and can't find any references to it. It stated that the signal was received within 3 hours of Comet Atlas closest approach to Earth. Either I imagined it or it's a cover up.
It was in the USA Herald. I'm trying to work out how to share the link but I'm not great with this sort of thing. Also have a screenshot but again no idea how to post it.
Classic clickbait BS from USA Herald, which isnt even close to a recognized scientific news outlet. They often mix nonsense with fringe speculation that should not be taken seriously... unless backed by observational data from independent scientific instruments or published research.
Looks to be on a par with GB News and the Sunday Sport Although the latter did have some serious stories in the past like the WW2 bomber found on the Moon! And what did happen to it?
The CIA is playing silly b*****s CIA makes shocking statement about mysterious interstellar visitor that upends NASA's comet story https://share.google/McOWwj8DLDpTKSwCr
Please Login or Register to post a comment.