Sunday, October 17, 2021
Contact    |    RSS icon Twitter icon Facebook icon  
You are viewing: Home > News > Ancient Mysteries > News story
Welcome Guest ( Login or Register )  
Ancient Mysteries

Easter Island collapse theory questioned

January 24, 2014 | Comment icon 51 comments



Easter Island Moai overlooking the Pacific ocean. Image Credit: CC BY-SA 3.0 Gallardoval
Academics have cast doubt on the idea that the inhabitants used up all the island's natural resources.
The enigmatic Pacific island has long held the attention of archaeologists who have struggled to understand exactly what it was that wiped out the people famous for building hundreds of giant stone head statues.

The prevailing theory is that the islanders, known as the Rapa Nui, wiped themselves out over time by using up all of the island's resources in their statue-building endeavors, earning them the accolade of being the best known example of a society that destroyed itself through over-exploitation.
In recent years however this idea has been called in to question, mainly on the basis that the Rapa Nui, far from exhibiting such recklessness, seemed to be masters of agricultural engineering and were more than capable of fertilizing the soil sufficiently to grow the crops needed to feed themselves.

Scientific evidence also seems to suggest that the islanders didn't waste all of their resources, with radiocarbon data indicating that the island was utilized well past the point at which European travelers arrived. There is also evidence to suggest that the removal of the trees happened very gradually over the course of several hundred years.

So if over-exploitation wasn't responsible for the islanders' disappearance, then what was ?

Source: Cosmos Magazine | Comments (51)



Recent comments on this story
Comment icon #42 Posted by jeem 8 years ago
After what they did to their island? Would you take in a family that trashed their own home? I will help people who need help.Think about this
Comment icon #43 Posted by Noteverythingisaconspiracy 8 years ago
How about their gods(ET) take them in their land(planet) Yes that seems so much more likely than the other possibilities PS. I might have use a little bit of sarcasm above
Comment icon #44 Posted by taniwha 8 years ago
I don't understand. I meant North West to New Zealand. ( been having a bit of trouble lately with edit feature sorry ) but im pushed for time right now.
Comment icon #45 Posted by Artaxerxes 8 years ago
Perhaps it has something to do with the human reproductive capacity? Over breeding. Too many people and limited arable land? A female human is capable of giving birth to 15 or so offspring in her lifetime. If half those offspring are female in their lifetime they could have 7.5 X 15 = 112 offspring and then in the next generation it would be 56 X 15 = 840, and so on. With no disease or predators in just a few generations they could easily outstrip the resources of the island and literally "eat the island." At first it would have been paradise but soon it would turn into a trap. Too many people... [More]
Comment icon #46 Posted by Myles 8 years ago
I meant North West to New Zealand. ( been having a bit of trouble lately with edit feature sorry ) but im pushed for time right now. No problem. They certainly came from a population of sea dwellers. You have to wonder if their skills deplinished through the years.
Comment icon #47 Posted by spacecowboy342 8 years ago
Perhaps it has something to do with the human reproductive capacity? Over breeding. Too many people and limited arable land? A female human is capable of giving birth to 15 or so offspring in her lifetime. If half those offspring are female in their lifetime they could have 7.5 X 15 = 112 offspring and then in the next generation it would be 56 X 15 = 840, and so on. With no disease or predators in just a few generations they could easily outstrip the resources of the island and literally "eat the island." At first it would have been paradise but soon it would turn into a trap. Too many people... [More]
Comment icon #48 Posted by taniwha 8 years ago
No problem. They certainly came from a population of sea dwellers. You have to wonder if their skills deplinished through the years. Yes just like the Moai the ancient skills have eroded.
Comment icon #49 Posted by taniwha 8 years ago
Just to add Megalithic heads are not found in NZ. Bird motifs are. The close links that are known is the polynesian language of Rapa nui found its way here or maybe there. Also from what I understand the Antartic realm was known by the South Islands Rapu wai peoples, recounted in genealogical record or myth. There is no reason not to believe the same negative impacts of colonisation on Maori population in NZ also mirror that which was experienced on Rapa nui. Introduced disease and slavery. though doesnt account for deforestation.
Comment icon #50 Posted by aquatus1 8 years ago
I will help people who need help.Think about this Thought about it. Still sounds like a really bad idea.
Comment icon #51 Posted by jeem 8 years ago
Yes that seems so much more likely than the other possibilities PS. I might have use a little bit of sarcasm above I was not serious either


Please Login or Register to post a comment.


Recent news and articles