Sunday, September 26, 2021
Contact us    |    Advertise    |   Help    |   Cookie Policy    |   Privacy Policy    RSS icon Twitter icon Facebook icon
    Home  ·  News  ·  Forum  ·  Stories  ·  Image Gallery  ·  Columns  ·  Encyclopedia  ·  Videos
Find: in

Free Guy: are we all characters in a simulation?

Posted on Friday, 20 August, 2021 | Comment icon 22 comments

Just what is reality anyway ? Image Credit: CC BY-SA 3.0 Glogger / Chris Aimone
Ever wondered if you actually exist entirely within the confines of a realistic computer simulation?
Benjamin Curtis - a senior lecturer in philosophy and ethics at Nottingham Trent University - takes a look at the ideas and concepts behind Ryan Reynolds' recent hit movie 'Free Guy'.

Have you ever wondered if you're just a character in some elaborate simulation? You shake the thought off because you're a real person, living a real life, in a concrete reality. But can you be certain that you are? Isn't it at least possible that your body and that the world around you are nothing but illusions?

This is the conundrum that Guy, played by Ryan Reynolds, finds himself in the middle of in the film Free Guy. However, in this case he is, in fact, an NPC (non-player character) in an open-world computer game called Free City. He is a character in a simulation, and this realisation changes his "life" forever.

Many of us have wondered if we, like Guy, are just NPCs in some game. A sceptical hypothesis like this was first raised by the 17th-century French philosopher Rene Descartes. He didn't imagine he might be an NPC, of course. He imagined that an evil demon might be deceiving him into thinking the world around him was real when it was not. But evil demons are considered a bit passe these days.

In 20th-century philosophy, the favoured alternative was to imagine that we might be brains in vats hooked up to electrodes being deceived by nefarious neuroscientists feeding our experiences into us via electrical impulses. This is (more or less) the basic premise of the film The Matrix. But now even brains in vats are old hat.

Contemporary philosophy instead asks us to imagine that we are living in a computer simulation and that our minds themselves are mere emulations that run on computer code. This hypothesis has been taken seriously by many philosophers and scientists, with some arguing that the hypothesis is not only possible but has a good chance of being true. So, the question of whether you are in a situation similar to Guy's is a genuine one worth thinking over.

Do we have free will?

So if we are like Guy and living in a computer simulation, what becomes of our free will?

In the movie, Guy certainly feels like he has free will, but admits that his thoughts and behaviour is down to his programming. And there certainly seems to be something right about this. If our minds were nothing but a computer program running on a server somewhere, then it's hard to see how we could have any real control over what we think and do. Everything would be determined by our programming.

But now we can take this a step further and ask: what is the difference between a mind that runs according to a program in a computer, and one that runs according to biological laws in a brain?
Guy has no free will because his thoughts and actions are the result of electronic operations going on inside a computer that he has no control over. But, our thoughts and actions are the result of biological operations going on inside our brains, and we have no control over those either. So, it seems, whether we are in a computer simulation or the real world matters not. Either way, we lack free will.

There might be some hope for both Guy and us, however. Perhaps Guy's programming and our neurology merely sets certain parameters within which free action is still somehow possible, as some (known as libertarians) think. Or perhaps free will consists in something other than being able to do otherwise than we do, as others (known as compatibilists) think.

Can computer programs be conscious?

A traditional view that was held by Descartes, and is still held by some contemporary philosophers (such as Richard Swinburne), is that consciousness does not spring forth from the operations of our biological brains at all. The mind is on this view entirely distinct from the brain, but the two nevertheless interact. So conscious thoughts occur in a spiritual mind and are then beamed across to the physical brain.

But if like me, you find such a view implausible and think that consciousness arises from the operations of biological material, then it seems one must admit that a genuine conscious mind could arise from the operations of non-biological materials too, like those a computer is made from. And if this is right, given the rapid increase in computing power that we are now seeing, and the development of artificial intelligence, the day when such a mind arises might not be far off.

The consequences of there being conscious computer minds are far-reaching. One such consequence is the question of the moral status of such minds, which is raised in Free Guy. If they can have desires and emotions, be happy or sad, and fall in love, all of which Guy does in the movie, then they certainly seem to warrant as much moral respect as human beings.

But then it would seem to be morally wrong to interfere with their lives, such as resetting their programming, which would be akin to murder. As such, it would seem that the legal frameworks that protect our rights would have to be extended to protect theirs too. How to do this is a complicated issue that philosophers and legal experts are only just beginning to tackle.

Benjamin Curtis, Senior Lecturer in Philosophy and Ethics, Nottingham Trent University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license.

Read the original article. The Conversation

Source: The Conversation | Comments (22)

Tags: Simulation

Recent comments on this story
Comment icon #13 Posted by Abramelin on 23 August, 2021, 10:52
reset start "Bwaaaahhhh!!!" project female gland "Mmmmm...mmmmm... mmmm "
Comment icon #14 Posted by Abramelin on 23 August, 2021, 16:58
The Programmer's ways are mysterious...
Comment icon #15 Posted by lightly on 24 August, 2021, 12:56
A "simulation" of what?   I've never understood the idea.
Comment icon #16 Posted by Will Due on 24 August, 2021, 15:13
  How about the simulation of doing God's will here on earth, as it will be done there in heaven.    
Comment icon #17 Posted by Will Due on 24 August, 2021, 16:19
  Perhaps a life simulator like a flight simulator teaches a person how to fly an airplane.    
Comment icon #18 Posted by lightly on 24 August, 2021, 16:51
basically the word  simulation means , Not Real.. a contrived copy.      And if I am part of this supposed simulation, Then I'm not real either!  As, in, EXISTING as a living ,thinking, emoting, sentient creature.  No matter how complex or advanced AI gets, it will never be truely aware of anything, including it's own existence .   ?  It's still only a    machine.   ??
Comment icon #19 Posted by MysteryMike on 24 August, 2021, 20:23
It's basically what you get when you put The Lego Movie, The Maxtrix, and The Truman Show all into one.
Comment icon #20 Posted by closed for business on 26 August, 2021, 4:31
Hi Will If we are just programs how could one not do god's will if they have none to start with because there is no reality just programs, like say for instance that my programming is to be a pain in your or someone else's imaginary a@@ how would I not be doing god's will if that is how he wrote the ? 
Comment icon #21 Posted by joc on 26 August, 2021, 12:14
I had another dream last nite the dream...I knew it wasn't a dream but I was wishing it was...but I knew it was actually happening...when I woke up I laughed and thought ...that was only a dream...pffft Some people just don't know what reality is.  ...and then again...some of us do!   
Comment icon #22 Posted by llegendary on 26 August, 2021, 13:24
Yes. We are inside the Matrix....except we are characters that don't get out until after someone extracts our code and puts it into a body. Then we become Battlestar Galatica type cylons that are immortal.

Please Login or Register to post a comment.

  On the forums
Forum posts:
Forum topics:


Oldest human footprints in North America found
Archaeologists have identified what are now thought to be the oldest footprints ever found on the continent.
Ghost with a bowler hat said to haunt Heathrow
There have been many sightings of a ghostly figure in and around Heathrow airport over the years.
LIDAR reveals hidden secrets of Teotihuacan
Traces of the ancient South American city can still be found in the roads and structures of modern Mexico.
William Shatner is going to space, aged 90
The legendary Star Trek actor is set to become the oldest person ever to venture into space next month.
Stories & Experiences
Mystery 'troll' captured on camera
4-24-2021 | Marsta, Sweden
My Grandfather's NDE
4-24-2021 | Oakland, California
The voice of something not human
11-17-2020 | Baldwin Hills, Los Angeles
Shadow figure demon ?
11-14-2020 | USA
Ghost following me
9-18-2020 | Iowa
Mysterious glowing cube
8-23-2020 | Alabama
Black blob in my room/bed
7-23-2020 | Powell,TN U.S.
Transparent levitating ball
7-14-2020 | Santa Rosa, California

         More stories | Send us your story
Featured Videos
Gallery icon 
NASA studies underwater 'white smoker' vents
Posted 4-17-2020 | 3 comments
Hydrothermal vents on the ocean floor can teach us about possible habitats on other worlds.
10 strange things about our solar system
Posted 3-17-2020 | 0 comments
A look at some of the most mysterious things about our solar system.
Lizzie - Scotland's other loch monster
Posted 3-8-2020 | 0 comments
Amelia Dimoldenberg investigates the Loch Ness Monster's neighbor.
Adam Savage and Spot
Posted 2-14-2020 | 5 comments
Adam Savage tests out Boston Dynamics' impressive Spot robot.
NASA 2020: Are you ready ?
Posted 1-1-2020 | 3 comments
A look at what's coming up in the world of spaceflight this year.
 View: More videos
Top   |  Home   |   Forum   |   News   |   Image Gallery   |  Columns   |   Encyclopedia   |   Videos   |   Polls
UM-X 10.712 (c) 2001-2021
Terms   |   Privacy Policy   |   Cookies   |   Advertise   |   Contact   |   Help/FAQ