Saturday, April 13, 2024
Contact    |    RSS icon Twitter icon Facebook icon  
Unexplained Mysteries
You are viewing: Home > News > Palaeontology > News story
Welcome Guest ( Login or Register )  
All ▾
Search Submit


What was it that gave modern humans the edge over the Neanderthals ?

April 2, 2024 · Comment icon 16 comments
Neanderthals at sunrise.
The Neanderthals are gone, but we are still here. Why is that ? Image Credit: Bing AI / Dall-E 3
Today, we are the only human species left on the planet - but what was it that made us so special ?
Why did humans take over the world while our closest relatives, the Neanderthals, became extinct? It's possible we were just smarter, but there's surprisingly little evidence that's true.

Neanderthals had big brains, language and sophisticated tools. They made art and jewellery. They were smart, suggesting a curious possibility. Maybe the crucial differences weren't at the individual level, but in our societies.

Two hundred and fifty thousand years ago, Europe and western Asia were Neanderthal lands. Homo sapiens inhabited southern Africa. Estimates vary but perhaps 100,000 years ago, modern humans migrated out of Africa.

Forty thousand years ago Neanderthals disappeared from Asia and Europe, replaced by humans. Their slow, inevitable replacement suggests humans had some advantage, but not what it was.

Anthropologists once saw Neanderthals as dull-witted brutes. But recent archaeological finds show they rivalled us in intelligence.

Neanderthals mastered fire before we did. They were deadly hunters, taking big game like mammoths and woolly rhinos, and small animals like rabbits and birds.

They gathered plants, seeds and shellfish. Hunting and foraging all those species demanded deep understanding of nature.

Neanderthals also had a sense of beauty, making beads and cave paintings. They were spiritual people, burying their dead with flowers.

Stone circles found inside caves may be Neanderthal shrines. Like modern hunter-gatherers, Neanderthal lives were probably steeped in superstition and magic; their skies full of gods, the caves inhabited by ancestor-spirits.

Then there's the fact Homo sapiens and Neanderthals had children together. We weren't that different. But we met Neanderthals many times, over many millennia, always with the same result. They disappeared. We remained.

The hunter-gatherer society

It may be that the key differences were less at the individual level than at the societal level. It's impossible to understand humans in isolation, any more than you can understand a honeybee without considering its colony. We prize our individuality, but our survival is tied to larger social groups, like a bee's fate depends on the colony's survival.

Modern hunter-gatherers provide our best guess at how early humans and Neanderthals lived. People like the Namibia's Khoisan and Tanzania's Hadzabe gather families into wandering bands of ten to 60 people. The bands combine into a loosely organised tribe of a thousand people or more.

These tribes lack hierachical structures, but they're linked by shared language and religion, marriages, kinships and friendships. Neanderthal societies may have been similar but with one crucial difference: smaller social groups.

Tight-knit tribes

What points to this is evidence that Neanderthals had lower genetic diversity.

In small populations, genes are easily lost. If one person in ten carries a gene for curly hair, then in a ten-person band, one death could remove the gene from the population. In a band of fifty, five people would carry the gene - multiple backup copies. So over time, small groups tend to lose genetic variation, ending up with fewer genes.

In 2022, DNA was recovered from bones and teeth of 11 Neanderthals found in a cave in the Altai Mountains of Siberia. Several individuals were related, including a father and a daughter - they were from a single band. And they showed low genetic diversity.
Because we inherit two sets of chromosomes - one from our mother, one from our father - we carry two copies of each gene. Often, we have two different versions of a gene. You might get a gene for blue eyes from your mother, and one for brown eyes from your father.

But the Altai Neanderthals often had one version of each gene. As the study reports, that low diversity suggests they lived in small bands - probably averaging just 20 people.

It's possible Neanderthal anatomy favoured small groups. Being robust and muscular, Neanderthals were heavier than us. So each Neanderthal needed more food, meaning the land could support fewer Neanderthals than Homo sapiens.

And Neanderthals may have mainly eaten meat. Meat-eaters would get fewer calories from the land than people who ate meat and plants, again leading to smaller populations.

Group size matters

If humans lived in bigger groups than Neanderthals it could have given us advantages.

Neanderthals, strong and skilled with spears were likely good fighters. Lightly built humans probably countered by using bows to attack at range.

But even if Neanderthals and humans were equally dangerous in battle, if humans also had a numeric advantage they could bring more fighters and absorb more losses.

Big societies have other, subtler advantages. Larger bands have more brains. More brains to solve problems, remember lore about animals and plants, and techniques for crafting tools and sewing clothing. Just as big groups have higher genetic diversity, they'll have higher diversity of ideas.

And more people means more connections. Network connections increase exponentially with network size, following Metcalfe's Law. A 20-person band has 190 possible connections between members, while 60 people have 1770 possible connections.

Information flows through these connections: news about people and movements of animals; toolmaking techniques; and words, songs and myths. Plus the group's behaviour becomes increasingly complex.

Consider ants. Individually, ants aren't smart. But interactions between millions of ants lets colonies make elaborate nests, forage for food and kill animals many times an ant's size. Likewise, human groups do things no one person can - design buildings and cars, write elaborate computer programmes, fight wars, run companies and countries.

Humans aren't unique in having big brains (whales and elephants have these) or in having huge social groups (zebras and wildebeest form huge herds). But we're unique in combining them.

To paraphrase poet John Dunne, no man - and no Neanderthal - is an island. We're all part of something larger. And throughout history, humans formed larger and larger social groups: bands, tribes, cities, nation states, international alliances.

It may be then that an ability to build large social structures gave Homo sapiens the edge, against nature, and other hominin species.

Nicholas R. Longrich, Senior Lecturer in Paleontology and Evolutionary Biology, Life Sciences at the University of Bath.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license.

Read the original article. The Conversation

Source: The Conversation | Comments (16)

Other news and articles
Recent comments on this story
Comment icon #7 Posted by Piney 10 days ago
If you keep talking about Atlantis in Florida your going call him and nobody will be happy with you.?
Comment icon #8 Posted by Myles 10 days ago
As were Neanderthals.  
Comment icon #9 Posted by Abramelin 10 days ago
I think the Neanderthals died out because of their protruding eyebrows. Stupid idea, you say? Well, I offered just one of many other stupid ideas why Neanderthals died out. They were as intelligent as our ancestors. They were strong, they lived in the cold for millennia. They adapted. My idea: they died out because of a couple of reasons: 1. The eruption of Campo Phlegri, 39,000 years ago. 2. Disease brought in by our ancestors. Disease they had no immunity against. I don't think they were less intelligent than our ancestors were. That's just something modern people love to believe.
Comment icon #10 Posted by Piney 10 days ago
I always believed tropical diseases contributed too but I didn't connect the Phlegraean Fields until you mentioned it.  Good lookin out. ?
Comment icon #11 Posted by C L Palmer 9 days ago
There is some evidence pointing to them living in areas with low access to iodine in the surroundings. This might have contributed to some intellectual deficiencies and put them at a disadvantage as well. If the Cro-Magnon humans had access to a more varied diet, they might have been able to overcome this problem by sourcing their food differently. I also have a question: Are Neanderthals considered a different subspecies? And to add to that question, what is the difference in real terms between a subspecies, a race, or a breed? We may just be talking about a racial group (using lay terminolog... [More]
Comment icon #12 Posted by Abramelin 9 days ago
They inhabited an area stretching from England to the Ural Mountains, and from Northern Europe to the Levant. Where exactly was this shortage of iodine?
Comment icon #13 Posted by Tatetopa 9 days ago
There is also evidence of coastal communities with a heavy fish and shellfish component in their diets. There is a lot of evidence to suggest the typical Neanderthal diet was meat heavy.  Meat and eggs are pretty good sources of iodine.
Comment icon #14 Posted by Tatetopa 9 days ago
Could be geographic barriers, climate change, any number of factors.  It could be the most  successful survivors of either species were those bands with a mix of human and Neanderthal genes.  Hybrid vigor.
Comment icon #15 Posted by George Ford 6 days ago
Switching to a meat based diet.
Comment icon #16 Posted by Grim Reaper 6 6 days ago
That certainly plays apart, but I think that the major difference is that we could to changes and the Neanderthals could for whatever reason. Peace

Please Login or Register to post a comment.

Our new book is out now!
Book cover

The Unexplained Mysteries
Book of Weird News


Take a walk on the weird side with this compilation of some of the weirdest stories ever to grace the pages of a newspaper.

Click here to learn more

We need your help!
Patreon logo

Support us on Patreon


For less than the cost of a cup of coffee, you can gain access to a wide range of exclusive perks including our popular 'Lost Ghost Stories' series.

Click here to learn more

Top 10 trending mysteries
Recent news and articles