Tuesday, September 26, 2023
Contact    |    RSS icon Twitter icon Facebook icon  
You are viewing: Home > News > Science & Technology > News story
Welcome Guest ( Login or Register )  
Science & Technology

Traditional folk remedies can fuel misinformation, scientists argue

September 5, 2023 · Comment icon 9 comments



Many traditional remedies can do more harm than good. Image Credit: Pixabay / congerdesign
Folk remedies have been around for as long as human society, but do they still have a place in the 21st-Century ?
When London faced the bubonic plague in 1665, many people desperately sought a way to protect themselves and their loved ones from getting sick. One widely adopted method consisted of mixing two small cloves of garlic in a pint of fresh milk. People believed that drinking this cocktail in the morning, on an empty stomach, would prevent the feared disease.

Like those living through the great plague of London, many people searched for remedies that would keep COVID at bay, which is why claims that garlic could cure or protect people proliferated on social media. The claims prompted an exasperated World Health Organization to post tweets of caution.

Unfortunately, despite laboratory studies showing that garlic does indeed have compounds with anti-microbial properties, the idea of ingesting garlic to prevent becoming infected with any bacteria or virus is mostly folklore.

Folk remedies may sound benign, but they can hurt people. A 72-year-old woman ended up with a chemical burn on her tongue due to her daily use of raw garlic in an attempt to protect herself against the coronavirus, for example.

Medical folk wisdom

The idea of garlic as a blanket cure has its foundation in medical folk wisdom, which is an umbrella term for unproven, widespread beliefs about anything to do with health and disease.

Folk wisdom often has a certain level of seductive intuitiveness and generally originates from cultural beliefs as well as long-held traditions. Folk wisdom can involve herbal remedies, dietary recommendations and advice about following specific behaviours. It is often passed down by word of mouth through generations and may be one of the reasons myths about the causes and cures of diseases persist, despite the progress of medical science.

The unshakeable belief many people hold that eating before you go for a swim is dangerous, for example, has no scientific basis. Even though the logic seems compelling, the idea that eating before swimming causes drowning has been debunked by researchers.

Folk wisdom is complicated because on the one hand it broadly falls under the category of misinformation, but on the other it doesn't quite fit with the usual class of misinformation (such as fake news or misleading advertising). If someone endorses folk wisdom, it is not necessarily a strong indicator they have anti-science beliefs.
People who believe in "starving a fever", for example, can also be pro-vaccines. Likewise, it would not be unusual for a person who follows official health recommendations to also use folk wisdom as an additional safeguard against, for example, the coronavirus.

Don't underestimate it

However, the idea that folk wisdom is predominantly benign might be why experts tend to pay less attention to it. For example, believing that drinking warm milk before bed helps you go to sleep is not going to harm you (even if it's not true). However, other beliefs can be dangerous such as the idea that eating particular foods can bolster your immunity, which can lead people to think they don't need to be vaccinated against the flu or COVID.

Folk wisdom, like other types of misinformation not backed by science, often proliferate on social media, which means it can pose a threat to public health.

For example, in 2020, when the UK went into lockdown, the Burns Centre at Birmingham Children's Hospital saw a 30-fold increase in the number of scald injuries from steam inhalation. This was caused by a folk wisdom on social media that misled parents into believing that inhaling steam could prevent or treat respiratory tract symptoms. This was particularly disheartening because studies published worldwide since 1969 have highlighted the dangers of steam inhalation.

While some examples of folk wisdom have a level of biological plausibility, others do not. For instance, the belief that "an apple a day keeps the doctor away", a medical folk proverb from around 1870, was probably based on the wisdom that apples are full of nutrients. Interestingly, scientists have found that though the vitamin content of apples may not be particularly exceptional, apples are considered a so-called functional food (which must meet a scientific criteria, unlike "superfoods") because of the number of bioactive substances that they have which appear to be health promoting.

Folk wisdom isn't likely to disappear anytime soon. So we need to understand what makes people believe in it and to what extent it challenges beliefs in science. There seems to be a complex relationship between beliefs in folk wisdom and what people actually do to protect their health. Understanding this relationship could be key to preventing its harmful effects. Lives may depend upon it.

Katrine K. Donois, PhD Candidate in Psychology (Science Communication), Anglia Ruskin University and Hassan Vally, Associate Professor, Epidemiology, Deakin University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license.

Read the original article. The Conversation

Source: The Conversation | Comments (9)




Recent comments on this story
Comment icon #1 Posted by quiXilver 26 days ago
No doubt folk notions can lead to misinformation.† However, they can also lead to actual insights as well.† It's not a one way street.† Life is a process that unfolds and evolves and when we are open to explore and learn, we can develop.† So just because it's an old wive's tale, perhaps we shouldn't intrinsically throw the baby out with the bath water.† Nor should we blindly accept anything we hear outright.† Explore, learn and adapt. † I recall reading an instance where a student of latin was interpreting a middle ages text for an assignment.† The manual being translated was describing a proc... [More]
Comment icon #2 Posted by Abramelin 26 days ago
Many people have died or suffered from unexpected 'side effects' after ingesting approved regular medicines.
Comment icon #3 Posted by Nicolette 21 days ago
Wait are we saying garlic doesn't† help immunity? It might not stop the plague but i really don't† think natural remedies are "anti-scientific" if they work. Isn't it a little more anti-scientific to pretend its not valid if they do and that only manufactured remedies are side effect free, despite the fact that they generally aren't? Sounds like big pharma propaganda. I'll take my mythical natural food thank you.
Comment icon #4 Posted by Abramelin 21 days ago
Some claims made by alternative medicine are based on bull. Many others are not.
Comment icon #5 Posted by Liquid Gardens 20 days ago
Sure, the thing with 'folk medicine' or 'traditional medicine' though (not sure about 'alternative' medicine) is that these have been around a long time and many of them, at least the ones that were not bull, are now just called 'medicine' because they have been tested and shown to be effective.† In addition sometimes when submitting the folk medicine to scientific analysis it's discovered that the folk medicine isn't that effective on its own and needs to be refined further.† From†https://www.respectfulinsolence.com/2023/08/28/the-who-endorses-quackery-even-homeopathy/†: †
Comment icon #6 Posted by iAlrakis 20 days ago
There are definitely benefits to using garlic that have been confirmed by research. People are way too fast to dismiss everything based on nature these days. It's been documented many times that even animals specifically go after certain plants to address health issues.
Comment icon #7 Posted by Cho Jinn 20 days ago
"which can lead people to think they donít need to be vaccinated against the flu or COVID." I'd laugh, if it weren't all to tragic.† This article is an excellent example of paint-by-the-numbers, SEO'd alarmist pablum.
Comment icon #8 Posted by quiXilver 19 days ago
† Yea, that about sums it up...
Comment icon #9 Posted by NCC1701 17 days ago
I believe in folk remedies if there is undeniable scientific proof.


Please Login or Register to post a comment.


Our new book is out now!

The Unexplained Mysteries
Book of Weird News

 AVAILABLE NOW 

Take a walk on the weird side with this compilation of some of the weirdest stories ever to grace the pages of a newspaper.

Click here to learn more

We need your help!

Support us on Patreon

 BONUS CONTENT 

For less than the cost of a cup of coffee, you can gain access to a wide range of exclusive perks including our popular 'Lost Ghost Stories' series.

Click here to learn more

 Total Posts: 7,507,171    Topics: 310,841    Members: 200,750

 Not a member yet ? Click here to join - registration is free and only takes a moment!
Recent news and articles