Wednesday, January 23, 2019
Contact us    |    Advertise    |   Help    |   Cookie Policy    |   Privacy Policy    RSS icon Twitter icon Facebook icon
    Home  ·  News  ·  Forum  ·  Stories  ·  Image Gallery  ·  Columns  ·  Encyclopedia  ·  Videos
Find: in

New tests cast doubt on 'impossible' EmDrive

Posted on Thursday, 24 May, 2018 | Comment icon 32 comments

EmDrive may not be all it's cracked up to be. Image Credit: NASA
Researchers in Germany may have found an explanation for the thrust produced by the controversial drive.
Despite being branded as 'impossible' by most scientists, NASA's electromagnetic propulsion engine has been attracting a lot of interest in recent years as a possible successor to the chemical engines traditionally used in deep space probes and other spacecraft.

First developed back in 2001 by aerospace engineer Roger Shawyer, EmDrive allegedly works by converting electrical power in to thrust without the need for propellant through a process that scientists argue is in direct violation of the laws of physics.

Test results obtained by NASA's own Eagleworks advanced-propulsion lab have proven encouraging, however the exact mechanism responsible for producing the thrust has proven elusive.

Now though, German scientists who have built and tested their own EmDrive in a vacuum chamber have come to the conclusion that this apparent thrust is actually illusory.

Their analysis has indicated that the readings are most likely the result of 'electromagnetic interaction' between the device's power cable and the Earth's magnetic field.

While their findings don't completely rule out EmDrive as a viable propulsion system, it does cast doubt on whether it is really quite as revolutionary as people have been making out.

Source: | Comments (32)

Tags: EmDrive, NASA

Recent comments on this story
Comment icon #23 Posted by paperdyer on 25 May, 2018, 14:11
Trekkers if you please!
Comment icon #24 Posted by paperdyer on 25 May, 2018, 14:19
I'm not saying the Germans are wrong, but like the Swiss, if it's not invented here, it's wrong! I've had too many of my ideas pooh-poohed over the years only to show as a claim in their patents later.
Comment icon #25 Posted by bison on 25 May, 2018, 17:26
The scientific community in China evidently deemed testing the em drive in space a worthwhile project.
Comment icon #26 Posted by pallidin on 25 May, 2018, 19:15
Now don't get uneccessarilly testy, Waspie... geeze. I know the lab was a controlled environment, but I said a more controlled environment; refining the controls from what was learned or speculated. That's a valid comment. There is nothing wrong with what I had said.
Comment icon #27 Posted by Tom the Photon on 4 June, 2018, 13:10
Much as I hate to agree with Waspie, this time he’s absolutely correct. Some things are potentially possible, which is why the jury’s out on many issues like dark matter, multiverses, God, etc.  There’s no real harm in thinking about such ideas, even if little is to be gained from them. Other things in science are simply not possible.  Perpetual motion machines do not exist.  Stone pyramids do not channel energy from distant stars.  Star patterns in the night sky do not determine our fates.  An EM drive cannot work, as the idea violates conservation of momentum – a fundamental principle of the... [More]
Comment icon #28 Posted by Tom the Photon on 4 June, 2018, 13:20
I totally agree with you: there's a lot of supercilious posting, pseudo-intellectual meanderings and pompous put-downs here.  There are a handful of cabals who cheer each other on, voting up even the most banal messages, revelling in their supposed intelligence and superiority.  I hope I don't come across like that - I always try to explain my contributions as carefully as possible. But this topic isn't unexplained.  It's basic physics which is easy to understand (see my previous post).  Let's save our dreams and imaginations for the huge number of currently unexplainable topics still out ther... [More]
Comment icon #29 Posted by bison on 4 June, 2018, 15:06
It's difficult to know what to make of the EM drive at this point. Even this latest refutation of its working is somewhat tentative. They propose to refine their test apparatus before firmly concluding that there is no unexplained directional force. I agree that the laws of motion are very unlikely to be breakable. It occurs to me, though, that some unconsidered physical mechanism may be at work. Dr. Harold White, at NASA has discerned that a simple electrical charge may be able to warp space slightly. It's not inconceivable that some variant of this proposed electrical interaction with space-... [More]
Comment icon #30 Posted by Tom the Photon on 4 June, 2018, 19:13
Powered, sustained flight doesn't break any laws of physics!  It was just a matter of building engines light and powerful enough to achieve the speed to generate enough lift to overcome the weight of those engines plus wings and a load.    Dr White's work requires the existence of an entirely new form of matter that has never been detected.  This matter must have exactly the right properties to warp space-time around itself, notably it must have negative mass.  (This is totally different to antimatter which has positive mass but opposite charge.)  So much of the research and thinking in this f... [More]
Comment icon #31 Posted by bison on 4 June, 2018, 20:43
Lord Kelvin declared in 1895 that heavier than air flying machines were 'impossible'.  Being a very good physicist, he surely based that pronouncement on the laws of physics, as they were understood at that time. Note that he didn't say they were unworkable given current technical limitations. His statement is an unqualified 'impossible'. Eight years later, the Wright brothers performed the impossible. Dr. White assures us that his test apparatus contains no exotic matter. He has explained why he believes that a simple electrical charge, contained in a ring of capacitors, may be able to warp s... [More]
Comment icon #32 Posted by Tom the Photon on 6 June, 2018, 21:43
Didn't Kelvin also famously state words to the extent that "there is nothing more to be discovered in science" weeks before X-rays and radioactivity were discovered? Thanks for the update on Dr White - I'll make time to read his work in depth and won't comment again unless I think I understand it.

Please Login or Register to post a comment.

  On the forums
Forum posts:
Forum topics:


Black hole radio jet 'pointed directly at Earth'
The supermassive black hole in the center of the Milky Way seems to be pointing a radio jet directly towards us.
Secret Pentagon research projects revealed
A newly declassified list of top secret US government projects reads like something out of an X-Files episode.
Eels 'hyperactive' due to cocaine in the Thames
According to a report, excessive drug use in London may be having an adverse effect on some of the local wildlife.
Steam-powered space probe could work forever
Scientists have developed a prototype for a steam-powered spacecraft that can refuel itself with water.
Featured Videos
Gallery icon 
Round Earth vs flat Earth
Posted 1-18-2019 | 4 comments
Why do some people believe that the Earth is as flat as a pancake?
Which is correct - math or maths ?
Posted 1-10-2019 | 2 comments
For years, there has been some confusion over the shorthand of the word 'mathematics'.
How fast does glass crack ?
Posted 12-31-2018 | 5 comments
The Slo Mo Guys attempt another intriguing slow motion experiment in their back yard.
The most mind-blowing space discoveries
Posted 12-28-2018 | 0 comments
A look back at some of mankind's greatest space-related discoveries.
The origins of Christmas
Posted 12-22-2018 | 0 comments
A look back at the origins of several modern Christmas traditions.
 View: More videos
Stories & Experiences
Johannesburg Men in Black
1-2-2019 | Johannesburg South Africa
Giant flash of light
1-2-2019 | Pomona, California
Terrifying unexplained screams
1-2-2019 | Dorion, Ontario, Canada
My name is whispered
11-9-2018 | Wish not to disclose
Strange numbers on arm
11-9-2018 | Charlotte, NC
Two experiences
10-31-2018 | Pryor, OK
Various experiences
10-31-2018 | Californiia
A transparent figure
10-31-2018 | Nigeria
My childhood haunting
10-29-2018 | Cincinnati, Ohio
Orange, hovering, atom-like figure
10-25-2018 | West kelowna

         More stories | Send us your story
Top   |  Home   |   Forum   |   News   |   Image Gallery   |  Columns   |   Encyclopedia   |   Videos   |   Polls
UM-X 10.712 (c) 2001-2018
Terms   |   Privacy Policy   |   Cookies   |   Advertise   |   Contact   |   Help/FAQ